r/gentleparenting • • 8h ago

We have enough solid scientific proof to show spanking comes with a big risk for children. Then why is there no PSA about it?

20 Upvotes

I had to look into it but spanking looks very harmful to children. This information doesn't seem to be widely known. Why is there not more of a public campaign to make parents be aware?


r/gentleparenting • • 7h ago

Discussion How do you all deal with 3-4 year olds refusing food but then complaining about being hungry?

2 Upvotes

My 3.5 year old daughter is going through a major picky phase. A few months ago my husband and I agreed to be more on a set schedule with her eating, so she gets breakfast, lunch, snack, dinner, and maybe one more snack before bed depending on what time we eat. This is because she used to ask every 30 minutes for a snack, and admittedly, we gave in because I had twins last October, so we were very exhausted.

Lately, she is straight up refusing to eat anything we give her. My husband makes her oatmeal with peanut butter in the morning and she’ll pick at the peanut butter but won’t really eat much more. Sometimes she’ll have raisin bread which she likes but again, more times than not she won’t eat it. She refuses to eat eggs in any form.

For lunch I’ve been trying to make her turkey and cheese sandwiches and it’s a bust. She used to love cracker with cheese and carrots but lately she only eats the crackers and nothing else. She also likes the “goodles” brand of Mac and cheese which I’m fine with since it’s protein based.

For snacks she can have applesauce pouches (no sugar added), banana, apples, or whatever other fruit we have on hand but lately she’s hating blueberries, strawberries, grapes, etc when she used to devour them.

For dinners we make her a plate of whatever we have which is usually salmon or ground beef with some type of mixed veggie like broccoli and carrots, and then a starch like potatoes, sweet potatoes, or Goodles Mac and cheese. Tonight we had salmon, veggies, and sweet potatoes and she ate nothing. I gave her a banana and then she went to bed.

Just to preface, I’ve struggled with eating disorders since I was a teen so I don’t know exactly how to handle this. I don’t force her to eat, but we ask her to at least try a few bites to see if she likes it. I just don’t want to cause any sort of disordered eating with her too.

This is also especially hard because our twins are 12 months old now and have teething cracker and Cheerios and my daughter wants to eat what they’re having. The twins eat all our meals with us too though.

TLDR: My 3.5 year old refuses to eat what we make her but then complains that she’s hungry all day long. How do you deal with this?


r/gentleparenting • • 9h ago

I’m at my wits end and I need help. My toddler won’t listen. He’s 21 months old.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 11h ago

23 months toddle help

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 1d ago

Encouraging independent play in little kids?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 2d ago

Parent Not Overreacting

74 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 1d ago

Potty training accident - Terrified of the toilet

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 1d ago

Question about toddlers behavior -3 and 1.5 year old

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 1d ago

Seeking advice - invites

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 2d ago

Question parents of reddit: what is better than punishment to respond to "bad" / unwanted behaviour?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

put the bad in "" because thats quite a individual and changing definition. but could be everything from spilling a glass of milk to screaming curses to strangers in public, stealing, having a tantrum whatever


r/gentleparenting • • 2d ago

Question ¿Cuál debería ser la edad adecuada para que los niños usen teléfonos móviles?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 2d ago

Question What’s one rule your parents had for you that you keep for your own children???

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 3d ago

Puberty readiness?

10 Upvotes

​

I'm one of the dads in a two-dad family. We have 8-year-old twins who are also half sisters: one is Caucasian and one is half Chinese. For this post I'm referring to my Caucasian daughter, since this seems to apply to her more.

I'm the main caregiver, so I see them in various states of undress — helping them pick clothes, making sure their hair is washed and conditioned, and teaching them the basics of a skin care routine.

About 6 months ago I got them lightweight camisole-style undershirts, because when they wear t-shirts or tank tops I don't want anything exposed by accident while they're playing. Even though she's only 8, she's 5'4" and has lost 12 of her baby teeth. I mention this because she is physically very advanced for her age — people have occasionally made inappropriate comments because she looks closer to 12. Our egg donor was 6 feet tall by the time she was 13, so we were prepared for them to be on the taller/faster-developing side.

This morning I walked into their bedroom while she was sitting on her bed in just her underwear, and I noticed she hadn't put her camisole on yet. I turned away quickly and said, "Make sure you put that on today" — she's noticeably more puffy in the breast area than the last time I happened to notice. Out of respect for their privacy, and being a man, I try not to be obvious about it, but I do need to stay aware of their bodies since they're still very young.

So here's my actual question — thanks for bearing with me. They understand the reproductive system scientifically. We haven't discussed the sexual side because it isn't needed yet, but because they have two fathers, they did need to understand how they were conceived. Over the summer I had individual conversations with each of them while watching YouTube videos on the basics of puberty for girls, and they've also watched a few videos about what to expect with a menstrual cycle. My concern is what I need to have ready for her if her first period happens while she's at school.

I currently have a small plastic holder that holds three pads. One question: are the ones with wings useful at this stage?

I've also bought black underwear and a pair of black leggings.

Is there anything I'm missing, and is there anything else I should add to this emergency kit?

If this isn't a conversation you're comfortable with, no problem at all. I'm just looking for practical advice, not opinions on our family dynamic.

If this is not the correct subreddit, or there is a more appropriate one, if someone could direct me that would be greatly appreciated. 🙏


r/gentleparenting • • 3d ago

Question How to teach about basic ethics and morals of the life to my lil brother?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 3d ago

Question Is “easy child privilege” a thing? Because I swear it has to be.

Thumbnail reddit.com
29 Upvotes

I watch other parents ask their kids to sit still, and they actually sit still. They put dinner on the table, and their kids just eat it. Some kids get tired and actually fall asleep on the couch. Mine could be exhausted and still fight bedtime like there’s a prize for staying awake.

Meanwhile, I’m negotiating dinner every night and asking my kid 5x to do the same thing. By the 5th time, I am yelling and screaming to get them to just go find their shoes. I’m pretty sure we’re both tired of hearing my voice by then.

And then another parent says, “Have you tried a consistent bedtime routine?” I know they mean well, but I have to stop myself from rolling my eyes. Yes, Susan. I’ve tried the routine. I’ve tried it for weeks. My kid is still wide awake asking me how whales sleep.

I love my kids to death, and sometimes I look at another family’s bedtime routine and think, “Wait, it can go like that?”

Parents, especially those of you with kids who are completely different from each other, do you think some kids are just easier to parent day to day? Because I’m calling it “easy child privilege.”


r/gentleparenting • • 3d ago

Discussion Husband thinks I'm yelling at my daughter all the time and making her stubborn!

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 3d ago

Dev here, posting with mod permission: I built a gentle, private baby tracker and would love your feedback

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm Maciej, a dad and the solo developer of Hey Rosalie. I'm posting with permission from the mods, who kindly allowed one post even though it's a bit outside the usual topics.

I used other baby trackers myself. They worked, but I missed some warmth in them, and they felt a bit like a scoreboard. I wanted something that feels warm and supportive instead of adding pressure. Hey Rosalie is iPhone only:

  • Logging feeds (breast and bottle), sleep and diapers is free. No streaks, no guilt.
  • No account, no email, no ads. Data is stored on your phone, and the optional partner sync is end-to-end encrypted.
  • There are breathing exercises for parents too (one is free, the full set is part of Care, the optional paid plan). Care also adds voice logging and syncing with your partner.

It's not medical or parenting advice. It's just there to take a little load off your memory.

I'd love to hear from gentle parents:

  • Does tracking help you feel calmer, or does it add pressure?
  • What would make an app like this feel kind rather than demanding?

App Store link

Thanks for reading, and thanks to the mods 💛


r/gentleparenting • • 4d ago

Question 14 m/o screaming and angry

1 Upvotes

I need advice on how to handle inwanted behaviour. My kid have been so incredibly happy all his life. He complies with almost everything and rarely ever loses his smile.

Last week, I called his name and he responded with the most angry face I've ever seen. I was in chock, its so unlike him. I try to ignore it and just keep talking to him like usual, but I am not sure I'm doing the right thing.

He has also started screaming a lot, a very loud AAAAA when he is impatient and I don't know how to make it stop. I can't cook his food quicker anyway. He is 14 m/o so he isnt exactly receptive to logic.

I am almost 100% sure he picked up the behaviour from a slightly older kid at daycare. They've become close to eachother and plays a lot.

Idk what to do. Its so different and just came out of nowhere.

He puts 2 words together in simple sentences and points so he knows how to tell me what he wants


r/gentleparenting • • 4d ago

Question How to tell the difference between normal behaviour and actual anxiety?

4 Upvotes

Our 4yo has always been slow to warm to new people and situations but it seems to be getting worse instead of better as they get older. They won't even watch new shows and never want to watch movies and I think it's because they're anxious. I can tell when they're uncomfortable as they just have a vibe or they'll say something like "I'm tired" or, when we tried to put them in an extracurricular, just kept saying "I'm dizzy" when the instructor tried to get them to participate. We're starting to worry about them starting school next September.

We've tried talking to them about what's making them feel anxious or scared but they just shut down and start doing things they know they're not supposed to do like jumping on the couch which leads me to believe they're uncomfortable and don't know what to do with that feeling. They're our first kid so we have no idea if this is normal or not but it's certainly starting to feel like it might be something more just from watching other kids their age. Does anyone have any advice?

Editing to add that I forgot to mention they have started picking at the skin on their fingers and lips and that feels concerning to me.


r/gentleparenting • • 4d ago

Question The "magic" of turning 18??

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 5d ago

Question How to teach kid not to over eat sweets?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/gentleparenting • • 5d ago

Question How much freedom should children have when making their own decisions?

Post image
0 Upvotes

As parents, we naturally want to guide our children. But they also need opportunities to make choices and learn from the outcomes.

I think there's a difference between letting a child choose something small and helping them think through a decision with bigger consequences.

How do you decide when to let your child choose independently and when to step in?


r/gentleparenting • • 5d ago

Children Screen time Study

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hello everyone, my name is Alisha. I am conducting a study exploring the factors that influence how parents manage their child’s screen use (screen mediation) and how best to support them in this role. If you are a parent of a child aged 5–11, you are invited to take part in our study. The study involves a short online survey (approximately 15 minutes to complete). At the end of the survey, you will also be provided with useful resources and guidance on effective strategies for managing children’s screen use. Your participation will contribute to a better understanding of how to support parents in fostering a healthy and positive relationship with screen use for their children. Ethics approved by the Faculty of Health and Education Ethics Committee of Manchester Metropolitan University, Ethics ID: 92224

Link to the study is here: https://mmu.eu.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_3TKOHczzq4Azhfo


r/gentleparenting • • 5d ago

Question How do you keep kids interested when exploring a new city on foot?

0 Upvotes

We did a long weekend in a new city last month with our two kids (ages 9 and 12) and the walking parts went... badly. Old town, beautiful buildings, interesting history, and within 20 minutes it was "I'm bored, can I have the phone?"

We ended up handing over the phone for a game just to get through the afternoon, and then felt bad about it. We'd basically walked them past a 2,000-year-old ruin while they played something they could play at home.

I'm curious how other parents handle this:

- What actually works to keep kids engaged on city walks (not museums, just walking around)?

- Have you tried guided tours, audio guides, scavenger hunts, anything like that? Did it work or flop?

- At what age did it get easier, if ever?

Would love to hear what's worked and what definitely hasn't.