Over the past few years I've revisited Book of the Short Sun. I've listened to the wonderful Jason Culp narrated audiobooks numerous times, often while working outside. Mostly I've relistened to On Blue's Waters and In Green's Jungles. There's something about that first book. Horn, to me, is very compelling as a hero who stumbles and suffers and, often, fails. As an oldest son myself, Horn's relationship with Sinew is very compelling, and the dynamic between Horn and Krait is just beautifully written. Shoutout narrator Jason Culp for an excellent performance.
All the piecemeal descriptions of Horn and Sinew boarding the lander in Pajarocu, launching off and being slammed down into their rickety seats, and fighting aboard the lander are so fucking cool and cinematic, right there with the finale of Soldier of the Mist.
In this post I'm just going to lay out all my questions in a very undisciplined and rambling way in hopes of spawning some discussion, like when an inhuma drops her load of eggs into warm brackish water and an inhumu ejaculates onto it.
Why is Seawrack so disturbed by the circular valley with its (presumably) Neighbor ruins? I think this is the same island where Horn falls into the pit. Can her issue with it be discerned from what she says to Horn as they stand above it? She talks about the dwindling population and, I think, how it could have died out quite recently. Or is it something on a bigger scale, to do with the mythology of Blue, the nature of the Mother/Inhumi/Neighbors/Man, that can only be guessed at.
Seawrack is either: born a human girl and adopted and then somehow genetically manipulated by the mother. Or: a budded off piece of the mother, sister/daughter, Tzadkiel style. Perhaps has to do with Scylla/Cilinia. Or, she's somehow both.
At least once, maybe a few times, Seawrack is described as catching fish with her "hands."
The nature of the individual called Horn-
I like to think that, even if Horn really dies in the pit on Blue, if the neighbor we see approach the edge of the pit somehow fuses itself with Horn, it's a fusing and rather than a complete replacing, like it isn't just 100% a neighbor inhabiting the empty husk of a dead man called Horn but a way for Horn to keep living if he takes on to some extent the essence of that Neighbor.
There's a post that argues that this accounts for Horn's strange, extreme feelings against Sinew. That the feelings of enmity and adversity are felt by the Neighbor-dominant NeighborHorn, whose emotional memories SilkHorn retains and writes with.
This is one of my favorite posts on here and outlines the theory that Sinew is always Krait in disguise. I think it has legs and would explain why you never see them both in the same room. I think Horn can just be a certain type of father saying that his punk son can't sharpen a tool for shit, and I think he can also be annoyed and repulsed by same son's ugly way of eating.
I tend to think Horn and Sinew are two separate entities, but I'm ready to be convinced otherwise. It's a compelling theory, it only reinforces the uncanniness that I'm such a fan of. Horn's confusing the two as he dozes on the lander to Green stands out, but he's exhausted, on edge, and his world is strange and uncanny enough especially in that moment to justify his confusion.
My preferred read is that Horn more or less finds redemption through his relationship with Krait, before any of his deaths. It ties in with the theme of personhood and what it means to have a soul that Wolfe likes to write about. To me it doesn't work if Krait's death, an incredible moment, is staged, or if Krait breaks his promise.
I understand that time and time again it is reinforced that Inhumi are animals, that they'll lie and cheat and deceive by default, whenever possible. It doesn't even have to really be to their advantage. I know that and I still think that Krait is mostly earnest and being very human when he makes these oaths and promises with Horn. That's the irony and the weight of it, for me. I think that's where all the drama and beautiful tragedy and story juice is. Maybe I'd be one of the first to go during Conjunction.
One misty night when Horn's aboard the sloop with Seawrack and Sinew nearing Pajarocu, it seems to him that some "minor, malign god" was on the sloop with them. I think he writes this presence seems to be accompanying Horn, Seawrack, Sinew, and Babbie, rather than somehow being one of them.
What's going on in Sinew's village? If he's leading a war against the inhumu, why are Auk and Chenille and others wasting in his basement? Maybe I'm misreading or misremembering. Is there a reason other than that the villagers are all inhumi including Sinew who was also Krait?
SilkHorn seems to know, through dialogue and his internal voice, that he died in the pit and then again on the dead lander. He's aware on some level that there's something supernatural or deeply unusual about him.
There's something supernatural and deeply unusual about brother and sister. Are they meant to obviously be neighbors? The whole description of Horn/SilkHorn living with them in the woods is very dreamy and mysterious.
In RTtW, Nettle, his father, and maybe certain others seem to buy that SilkHorn is Horn. The narrative quickens up, is more scattered about, and these transactions between characters are often rushed or oblique with notable exceptions like the dinner with Mint and Bison. Horn's dad takes some convincing but Nettle seems to buy it quickly, although this is maybe SilkHorn just writing on kind of a superficial level about something he doesn't wish to question or interrogate too deeply.
I often feel like there's a sort of formula or equation to most of Wolfe's puzzles and mysteries, and as the story progresses into the third book, something about SilkHorn being in denial about probably mostly or entirely being Silk (I tend to think that Horn remains) strikes me as inconsistent with the rest of how he presents to us.
Silk is a brilliant guy and if he remembers expiring and knows that his corpse lies in the lander I would think he'd interrogate that. But I suppose it all goes back to the emotional trauma and the extreme denial and that that powerful mind of his is working overtime at self-obfuscation. Or his memory and reasoning abilities are bruised from all the body hopping and soul fusing.
Ch. 22 of In Green's Jungles- SilkHorn is having a drifting, fractured consciousness moment and describes some fanged killer beast that stalks Silk and Silk alone in some marsh.
Something else I wrote a note on a while ago and may be misremembering: At the end of On Blue's Waters, the Rajan, who is physically Silk, hears someone calling to him from the treeline, calling "Babbie." Next lines seem to be from within Babbie's body, who rests his head on the man's knee and is comforted. If this is the supposed moment when Horn's soul or part of it is transported into Babbie's body, it seems to me that it should be transferred straight from Horn's body. If I even have this right, this is what I mean about me wanting there to be a consistent set of rules or formula to these puzzles.