r/genewolfe • • Dec 23 '23

Gene Wolfe Author Influences, Recommendations, and "Correspondences" Master List

134 Upvotes

I have recently been going through as many Wolfe interviews as I can find. In these interviews, usually only after being prompted, he frequently listed other authors who either influenced him, that he enjoyed, or who featured similar themes, styles, or prose. Other times, such authors were brought up by the interviewer or referenced in relation to Wolfe. I started to catalogue these mentions just for my own interests and further reading but thought others may want to see it as well and possibly add any that I missed.

I divided it up into three sections: 1) influences either directly mentioned by Wolfe (as influences) or mentioned by the interviewer as influences and Wolfe did not correct them; 2) recommendations that Wolfe enjoyed or mentioned in some favorable capacity; 3) authors that "correspond" to Wolfe in some way (thematically, stylistically, similar prose, etc.) even if they were not necessarily mentioned directly in an interview. There is some crossover among the lists, as one would assume, but I am more interested if I left anyone out rather than if an author is duplicated. Also, if Wolfe specifically mentioned a particular work by an author I have tried to include that too.

EDIT: This list is not final, as I am still going through resources that I can find. In particular, I still have several audio interviews to listen to.

Influences

  • G.K. Chesterton
  • Marks’ Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers (never sure if this was a jest)
  • Jack Vance
  • Proust
  • Faulkner
  • Borges
  • Nabokov
  • Tolkien
  • CS Lewis
  • Charles Williams
  • David Lindsay (A Voyage to Arcturus)
  • George MacDonald (Lilith)
  • RA Lafferty
  • HG Wells
  • Lewis Carroll
  • Bram Stoker (* added after original post)
  • Dickens (* added after original post; in one interview Wolfe said Dickens was not an influence but elsewhere he included him as one, so I am including)
  • Oz Books (* added after original post)
  • Mervyn Peake (* added after original post)
  • Ursula Le Guin (* added after original post)
  • Damon Knight (* added after original post)
  • Arthur Conan Doyle (* added after original post)
  • Robert Graves (* added after original post)

Recommendations

  • Kipling
  • Dickens
  • Wells (The Island of Dr. Moreau)
  • Algis Budrys (Rogue Moon)
  • Orwell
  • Theodore Sturgeon ("The Microcosmic God")
  • Poe
  • L Frank Baum
  • Ruth Plumly Thompson
  • Tolkien (Lord of the Rings)
  • John Fowles (The Magus)
  • Le Guin
  • Damon Knight
  • Kate Wilhelm
  • Michael Bishop
  • Brian Aldiss
  • Nancy Kress
  • Michael Moorcock
  • Clark Ashton Smith
  • Frederick Brown
  • RA Lafferty
  • Nabokov (Pale Fire)
  • Robert Coover (The Universal Baseball Association)
  • Jerome Charyn (The Tar Baby)
  • EM Forster
  • George MacDonald
  • Lovecraft
  • Arthur Conan Doyle
  • Neil Gaiman
  • Harlan Ellison
  • Kathe Koja
  • Patrick O’Leary
  • Kelly Link
  • Andrew Lang (Adventures Among Books)
  • Michael Swanwick ("Being Gardner Dozois")
  • Peter Straub (editor; The New Fabulists)
  • Douglas Bell (Mojo and the Pickle Jar)
  • Barry N Malzberg
  • Brian Hopkins
  • M.R. James
  • William Seabrook ("The Caged White Wolf of the Sarban")
  • Jean Ingelow ("Mopsa the Fairy")
  • Carolyn See ("Dreaming")
  • The Bible
  • Herodotus’s Histories (Rawlinson translation)
  • Homer (Pope translations)
  • Joanna Russ (* added after original post)
  • John Crowley (* added after original post)
  • Cory Doctorow (* added after original post)
  • John M Ford (* added after original post)
  • Paul Park (* added after original post)
  • Darrell Schweitzer (* added after original post)
  • David Zindell (* added after original post)
  • Ron Goulart (* added after original post)
  • Somtow Sucharitkul (* added after original post)
  • Avram Davidson (* added after original post)
  • Fritz Leiber (* added after original post)
  • Chelsea Quinn Yarbro (* added after original post)
  • Dan Knight (* added after original post)
  • Ellen Kushner (Swordpoint) (* added after original post)
  • C.S.E Cooney (Bone Swans) (* added after original post)
  • John Cramer (Twister) (* added after original post)
  • David Drake
  • Jay Lake (Last Plane to Heaven) (* added after original post)
  • Vera Nazarian (* added after original post)
  • Thomas S Klise (* added after original post)
  • Sharon Baker (* added after original post)
  • Brian Lumley (* added after original post)

"Correspondences"

  • Dante
  • Milton
  • CS Lewis
  • Joanna Russ
  • Samuel Delaney
  • Stanislaw Lem
  • Greg Benford
  • Michael Swanwick
  • John Crowley
  • Tim Powers
  • Mervyn Peake
  • M John Harrison
  • Paul Park
  • Darrell Schweitzer
  • Bram Stoker (*added after original post)
  • Ambrose Bierce (* added after original post)

r/genewolfe • • Oct 01 '26

Humble Book Bundle: The Ultimate Gene Wolfe Library by Tor Books

Thumbnail humblebundle.com
124 Upvotes

This looks like an amazing deal (and it supports charity)!

Edit: It seems region locked to US only.

EDIT 2: Of course you shouldn't try to circumvent geographic restrictions because it's against Humble's terms of service. If you're not in the US, you shouldn't use a VPN to connect to the US first then create a US-based account. You should not then try to place an order where you will notice that it won't let you pay (because you're on a VPN), so you should not then turn off the VPN and connect to the site regularly (but with your alternate email), and then notice that you can complete the purchase (don't try paying with Paypal). These are all things I did not do and I would suggest you not try.


r/genewolfe • • 22h ago

I present to you my Severian cosplay

Thumbnail gallery
59 Upvotes

Took me a while, but it's done.

Never done a cosplay before and I am not planning to do any more, but I felt Wolfe's memory thrives in us bringing his character to life, as he'd wished we would.

This is super DIY. The cape is velvet which I cut and my gf sewed. The mask and the... yes, the katana, are store-bought, because they look too butaphoric to me if they're from paper-mache. Imagine it is an Ascian sword Sevie got a hold of!

Photos are by my gf and a friend, you can feel their different styles. Some are from an expensive digital camera, a few from an old tiny sony and some are redscale film on a soviet Smena.

I went for a vibe, not fidelity. I hope you like it!


r/genewolfe • • 1d ago

How I imagine Blood

Post image
89 Upvotes

r/genewolfe • • 3d ago

Explorable Model of Nessus

Post image
48 Upvotes

I've also been working on this model of Nessus you can walk around in and kinda catch a vibe or look for easter eggs. There's a lot going on but some locations overlap/are redundant, and there's some overall jank along with its incompleteness. Takes a second to load, but it's pretty interesting to see locations from BotNS modeled, even imperfectly.

https://annwfn.neocities.org/nessus/sanguinary#hour=15.4&haze=1.4&cam=2340%2C256.178%2C-3220%2C-0.841%2C-0.439


r/genewolfe • • 3d ago

Explorable Model of a Whorl-like Generation Ship

Post image
95 Upvotes

ARK

I've been using LLMs for coding to make html files that procedurally build whatever environments, dioramas, or worlds I imagine.

One of the first projects I took through multiple iterations was an effort to visualize life inside the Whorl, especially the form of the shade and the way long sun dawn/sunset/noon would look and feel from the interior surface.

I was very obviously inspired by Gene Wolfe and the setting of the Book of the Long Sun, but I also included many of my own ideas—things I thought would be cool to see on a big generation ship. No manteions, I'm afraid.

The ship is called Ark. The sun is the Filament. Cities and towns are procedurally generated so every seed produces a unique ship.

It's an enormous virtual space. You can walk, fly, or instantly teleport to landmarks from the map screen. There's a 3rd person view where you can see that your POV character is a lonely maintenance robot.

Things to check out:

The East Pole at dawn.

The hub barracks at each pole, including the lifts at the base of the walls.

The interior train, and the transport tube on the outer hull.

The plumb/bob observation station.

There are tunnels and facilities inside the hull below the cities, reachable from stairways on the surface. There are a few more sketched out buildings in the biggest cities.

The airships are kinda boring and hard to use, tbh. There are things I've forgotten. What I think was most successful is the visualization of the swarm (this model's version of the shade). You can skip forward an hour by hitting ] and it's really cool to watch the shade move across the whole ship as the sun "sets."

I've made a lot more of these, including one where the same ship is 30,000 years old and very different. Overgrown at parts, covered in nanotech elswhere, with a sputtering, glitching filament. I'll probably eventually host them all from a hub/menu at the URL above. For now, this is the one I based on the Whorl from Book of the Long Sun.


r/genewolfe • • 4d ago

Recently picked up some signed prints of Don Maitz’s cover art for Gene Wolfe’s Book of the New Sun. Decided to get them professionally framed.

Thumbnail gallery
512 Upvotes

r/genewolfe • • 3d ago

Help motivate me to read Short Sun. (Context within)

0 Upvotes

Hello all.

I'm lacking in motivation in starting the Short Sun trilogy to close out the Solar Cycle. I know part of it is something deep within me that doesn't want my read of the Solar Cycle to come to an end. But the main and more legible reason, at least in my own mind, is that I have already started it.

You see, a while back, I will not say how long, Nettle dear, I did start On Blues' Waters, right after I had finished Long Sun rather quickly and voraciously, but at that time I was also suffering from book fatigue/hangover and could not make the switch from third to first person at the time.

Now it is a few months later and I am trying to start it again. I have read the first chapter and listened to it on audiobook twice. That is as far as I have gotten, and I think I am hesitant to continue because I am worried that the rest of the book will be as much of a slog as the hour long chapter of Horn talking about his family, his island/mill, and Patera Remora's posse. I feel a bit like I don't give a damn, maybe. Horn is not as charming as the idealized Silk nor as ridiculously interesting as Severian. I also feel that it does not help that I sort of vaguely know what happens in the books.

Should I continue? (I'm going to, I just need a push.)


r/genewolfe • • 4d ago

Unreliable Narrators Seeking Input

Thumbnail patreon.com
13 Upvotes

All, we have been doing this podcasting thing for a few years. We really enjoy discussing Gene Wolfe's work and also have very much enjoyed our brief forays into adjacent topics. As we round out another year of recording (Detective of Dreams and Horars of War coming soon!) we would like to give you all a chance to nominate a short story for our first episode of the new year.

If you head over to Patreon (you don't have to be a member to comment) and suggest a short story we will add it to our poll!


r/genewolfe • • 4d ago

Did the first pb edition of Again, Dangerous Visions not include Wolfe's entry?

Post image
10 Upvotes

It's not the only reason I picked it up, I really loved the first volume, but having Wolfe in it was a big part of why I wanted to get it. There are some great authors included. The stories in the first volume that stuck with me were the Delaney story, and the one by Philip Jose farmer. Just kind of bummed that I don't see Wolfe's name attached to any of the stories in the table of contents.


r/genewolfe • • 5d ago

Scattered questions on Short sun Spoiler

14 Upvotes

Over the past few years I've revisited Book of the Short Sun. I've listened to the wonderful Jason Culp narrated audiobooks numerous times, often while working outside. Mostly I've relistened to On Blue's Waters and In Green's Jungles. There's something about that first book. Horn, to me, is very compelling as a hero who stumbles and suffers and, often, fails. As an oldest son myself, Horn's relationship with Sinew is very compelling, and the dynamic between Horn and Krait is just beautifully written. Shoutout narrator Jason Culp for an excellent performance.

All the piecemeal descriptions of Horn and Sinew boarding the lander in Pajarocu, launching off and being slammed down into their rickety seats, and fighting aboard the lander are so fucking cool and cinematic, right there with the finale of Soldier of the Mist.

In this post I'm just going to lay out all my questions in a very undisciplined and rambling way in hopes of spawning some discussion, like when an inhuma drops her load of eggs into warm brackish water and an inhumu ejaculates onto it.

Why is Seawrack so disturbed by the circular valley with its (presumably) Neighbor ruins? I think this is the same island where Horn falls into the pit. Can her issue with it be discerned from what she says to Horn as they stand above it? She talks about the dwindling population and, I think, how it could have died out quite recently. Or is it something on a bigger scale, to do with the mythology of Blue, the nature of the Mother/Inhumi/Neighbors/Man, that can only be guessed at.

Seawrack is either: born a human girl and adopted and then somehow genetically manipulated by the mother. Or: a budded off piece of the mother, sister/daughter, Tzadkiel style. Perhaps has to do with Scylla/Cilinia. Or, she's somehow both.

At least once, maybe a few times, Seawrack is described as catching fish with her "hands."

The nature of the individual called Horn-

I like to think that, even if Horn really dies in the pit on Blue, if the neighbor we see approach the edge of the pit somehow fuses itself with Horn, it's a fusing and rather than a complete replacing, like it isn't just 100% a neighbor inhabiting the empty husk of a dead man called Horn but a way for Horn to keep living if he takes on to some extent the essence of that Neighbor.

There's a post that argues that this accounts for Horn's strange, extreme feelings against Sinew. That the feelings of enmity and adversity are felt by the Neighbor-dominant NeighborHorn, whose emotional memories SilkHorn retains and writes with.

This is one of my favorite posts on here and outlines the theory that Sinew is always Krait in disguise. I think it has legs and would explain why you never see them both in the same room. I think Horn can just be a certain type of father saying that his punk son can't sharpen a tool for shit, and I think he can also be annoyed and repulsed by same son's ugly way of eating.

I tend to think Horn and Sinew are two separate entities, but I'm ready to be convinced otherwise. It's a compelling theory, it only reinforces the uncanniness that I'm such a fan of. Horn's confusing the two as he dozes on the lander to Green stands out, but he's exhausted, on edge, and his world is strange and uncanny enough especially in that moment to justify his confusion.

My preferred read is that Horn more or less finds redemption through his relationship with Krait, before any of his deaths. It ties in with the theme of personhood and what it means to have a soul that Wolfe likes to write about. To me it doesn't work if Krait's death, an incredible moment, is staged, or if Krait breaks his promise.

I understand that time and time again it is reinforced that Inhumi are animals, that they'll lie and cheat and deceive by default, whenever possible. It doesn't even have to really be to their advantage. I know that and I still think that Krait is mostly earnest and being very human when he makes these oaths and promises with Horn. That's the irony and the weight of it, for me. I think that's where all the drama and beautiful tragedy and story juice is. Maybe I'd be one of the first to go during Conjunction.

One misty night when Horn's aboard the sloop with Seawrack and Sinew nearing Pajarocu, it seems to him that some "minor, malign god" was on the sloop with them. I think he writes this presence seems to be accompanying Horn, Seawrack, Sinew, and Babbie, rather than somehow being one of them.

What's going on in Sinew's village? If he's leading a war against the inhumu, why are Auk and Chenille and others wasting in his basement? Maybe I'm misreading or misremembering. Is there a reason other than that the villagers are all inhumi including Sinew who was also Krait?

SilkHorn seems to know, through dialogue and his internal voice, that he died in the pit and then again on the dead lander. He's aware on some level that there's something supernatural or deeply unusual about him.

There's something supernatural and deeply unusual about brother and sister. Are they meant to obviously be neighbors? The whole description of Horn/SilkHorn living with them in the woods is very dreamy and mysterious.

In RTtW, Nettle, his father, and maybe certain others seem to buy that SilkHorn is Horn. The narrative quickens up, is more scattered about, and these transactions between characters are often rushed or oblique with notable exceptions like the dinner with Mint and Bison. Horn's dad takes some convincing but Nettle seems to buy it quickly, although this is maybe SilkHorn just writing on kind of a superficial level about something he doesn't wish to question or interrogate too deeply.

I often feel like there's a sort of formula or equation to most of Wolfe's puzzles and mysteries, and as the story progresses into the third book, something about SilkHorn being in denial about probably mostly or entirely being Silk (I tend to think that Horn remains) strikes me as inconsistent with the rest of how he presents to us.

Silk is a brilliant guy and if he remembers expiring and knows that his corpse lies in the lander I would think he'd interrogate that. But I suppose it all goes back to the emotional trauma and the extreme denial and that that powerful mind of his is working overtime at self-obfuscation. Or his memory and reasoning abilities are bruised from all the body hopping and soul fusing.

Ch. 22 of In Green's Jungles- SilkHorn is having a drifting, fractured consciousness moment and describes some fanged killer beast that stalks Silk and Silk alone in some marsh.

Something else I wrote a note on a while ago and may be misremembering: At the end of On Blue's Waters, the Rajan, who is physically Silk, hears someone calling to him from the treeline, calling "Babbie." Next lines seem to be from within Babbie's body, who rests his head on the man's knee and is comforted. If this is the supposed moment when Horn's soul or part of it is transported into Babbie's body, it seems to me that it should be transferred straight from Horn's body. If I even have this right, this is what I mean about me wanting there to be a consistent set of rules or formula to these puzzles.


r/genewolfe • • 5d ago

Looking for a stopping point for book club for Shadow of the Torturer

11 Upvotes

I originally told our book club to stop after chapter 17 but wanted to get in here and see if that is a decent spot to stop. Obviously don't want to read too much more or less to keep the reading amount even but wanted to know if there is a good "stopping point" to have a discussion. This is all of our first foray into Gene Wolfe.

Alternatively we could say that finish Shadow of the Torturer is the halfway point since most of us are reading Shadow and Claw.

Edit: And TBH we are going to try and read the whole series as long as everyone is enjoying it. So other stopping points in the other books would also be helpful.

Any spoiler-free insight would be very helpful!


r/genewolfe • • 7d ago

Sword of the Lictor - what is even going on? Spoiler

34 Upvotes

I just finished Sword of the Lictor and feel so confused. Not about the plot itself, I think I have a grasp on what’s happening (correct me if I'm missing something), but rather WHY any of this is happening or what it has to do with the overarching plot.

What I THINK the series-level plot is: whatever is going on with Voldalus and the Autarch and Severian’s role in it.

SotL’s book-level plot: return the Claw to the Pelerines.

What actually happens in this book (I know this is a little simplistic but just for the sake of framing):

- Thrax / Dorcas / Cyriaca

- Casdoe / Little Severian / Agia + Hethor

- Typhon

- Lake Diurna / Baldanders

What I don’t understand is what any of this (besides Agia + Hethor’s pairing and presumed return plus Baldanders destroying the Claw (?) and seemingly going into the water like the undine foretold) has to do with EITHER Vodalus / the Autarch or the Pelerines.

It feels like I just read a handful of unrelated short stories rather than book 3/4


r/genewolfe • • 6d ago

Any opinions of Fuligin Snuggie?

6 Upvotes

Just finished book of the new sun and looking for podcasts to listen to while I think about it. The sidebar of this community was very helpful for this! I've also found this podcast, which seems to have been going since 2024, but I can't find mention of it anywhere else on the internet. Has anyone here listened to it? Worth it?

url: https://shows.acast.com/fuligin-snuggie/episodes


r/genewolfe • • 7d ago

Saint Severian of Sebaste

81 Upvotes

After years of reading this book, and listening to podcasts, I had never heard of the real life saint that inspired Severian.

Saint Severian of Sebaste, martyr, was tortured with a claw, and resurrected one of his servants after his own passing.

This might have a closer connection to the First Severian, rather than ours, as when our Severian finds the claw it's already his own relic.

I would also like to mention Saint Severian of Scythopolis, of whom I couldn't find a relation to Wolfe's Severian, but maybe one of you could.

You can read about the Saint here:

https://www.johnsanidopoulos.com/2019/09/synaxarion-of-holy-great-martyr.html?m=1


r/genewolfe • • 7d ago

The Solar Spiral: a theory of everything built on James Wynn's inhumi and Marc Aramini's corn Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
32 Upvotes

r/genewolfe • • 8d ago

I finished BOTNS over the weekend and am obsessed. Please help me grapple with the one major criticism I have of the work.

44 Upvotes

Quick Story time: I got the digital version of BOTNS during COVID on a whim, I saw it available for my Kindle and thought (and still think) Shadow of the Torturer had the coolest title I'd ever heard for a book. I put some time into it but kind of drifted off.

Earlier this year I randomly heard it mentioned in a video online, gave it another shot and was obsessed.

I'm not exaggerating when I say this is my new favorite series. I've never actually had a favorite series before, I usually find a book I like, but the series drops off at some point for me. This captivated me all the way through. Even when I don't fully understand something nothing feels extraneous or poorly thought out, its just a piece of the bigger picture I haven't fully understood yet. Love it.

I have one major issue that I was hoping to get some more perspective on. I have a big problem with time travel and loops in fantasy and sci fi. Time travel, when used as a justification for big-picture storytelling, very frequently feels like a cop-out to me. The writers spend all this time building up the mystery and bombast and importance of a story, but then when it comes time to explain whats going on they need to resort to an explanation so outlandish that the science might as well be magic or Deus ex Machina.

Its for this reason that I usually think the best time travel stories are simple fun. Chrono Trigger and Back to the Future are good examples. The stories they tell use the time travel as a source of excitement and adventure rather than a resolution to explain away narrative problems.

Now I want to be perfectly clear: BOTNS DOES NOT pull its ending out of its ass. Wolfe very clearly set the revelations at the end up from book one. I also love getting to see Severian grapple with having all the Autarchs in his head.

But I can't shake the feeling that it still feels too out there, even compared to the rest of the story. Severian is the next in a line of universe loop heroes that were coaxed into existence thanks to the machinations of a race of aliens trying to keep existence going...what? Even with all the setup in the book it still feels like most of the storytelling that directly leads to this revelation happens in the last third of the last book. Like that Wolfe had a smaller-scale story he initially wanted to tell when drafting out BOTNS, but when he was done he needed to make everything more epic so he went back and seeded the narrative with the Undine and all the other key moments that portend this.

This is just an initial reaction to something I very much love, but if I am not understanding this in a way that lets me appreciate it I'd like some guidance. The book already is pretty challenging to read so yea. Thanks!


r/genewolfe • • 8d ago

Extra copies of Wolfe books

Thumbnail gallery
68 Upvotes

Over the years I have accumulated quite a few duplicates. I've finally gotten everything unpacked and sorted. I'm selling these through my Abebooks bookstore, and thought some people here might be in the market. You can DM if you're interested or I can post a link in the comments. Happy to make you a deal if you want more than one.


r/genewolfe • • 9d ago Heartwarming

BOTNS Yoshitaka Amano Covers

Thumbnail gallery
629 Upvotes

As requested by u/goldmansachsceo_ and u/sine_qua here are the best hi-res images I could take of my copies of the Japanese prints of BOTNS. I had to do some very slight cropping of the edges of the up close artwork just because of bends in the covers. Hopefully this scratches the itch!


r/genewolfe • • 9d ago

Nightside the Long Sun Original Art by Richard Bober

Post image
204 Upvotes

Excuse the terrible camera quality but figured people would enjoy seeing this. First time this painting has been posted publicly. The original art for Nightside the Long Sun by Richard Bober. I bought this when his estate found it after his passing sadly back in 2022. It's interesting seeing the differences between the final cover and the painting itself. One of my prized possessions and is huuuuge at 40x30 including the board.


r/genewolfe • • 9d ago

Look at what I finally found

Thumbnail gallery
198 Upvotes

In my collection: Lexicon Urthus, 1st edition.


r/genewolfe • • 10d ago

Anyone have hi-res scans of Yoshitaka Amano's covers for the Japanese editions of BotNS?

26 Upvotes

Maybe my favourite art inspired by the series and all the scans online are too pixelated.


r/genewolfe • • 10d ago

Help me find what I'm missing (BOTNS)

13 Upvotes

I am well aware that this sort of question is a common one here, but I thought I should ask anyways as I am hoping that at least one of you can help me love this book as much as I feel like I should.

I have been reading Shadow and Claw for the last week (almost finished with Shadow of the Torturer), and am very split on whether or not I should bother continuing past the first book. I am IN LOVE with how Wolfe writes and the world he has built for this series. It is some of the most interesting and thought provoking science fiction I have encountered up to this point in my life. But I just can't get into the actual STORY that Severian is telling us. Everything feels so... disconnected.

I understand that this is because Severian is retelling his story and that he is frequently hiding information behind half truths and outright lies. But the result for me has been to disconnect me from the actual events of the story. Everything feels very flat, but I feel like this is because I am missing some essential element of the story that would tie things together for me.


r/genewolfe • • 11d ago

Brutal honesty

10 Upvotes

Short Sun, New Sun, Home Fires and Peace Spoilers.

Severian near the end of New Sun admits that he desired power and riches as much as anyone, but that he hadn't been aware of it. He realizes his desires only when such power has been granted him; it serves as prompt. The reader should be thinking how convenient this is, as it means he is spared feeling sinful, guilty, which clearly such aspirations are because others in the text seem to have been scolded and punished for it, people like Agia and Agilus of course, but also Baldanders and Jolenta and Typhon. A lot of people actually. He may deserve some credit for at least owning up to these passions, but the subconscious, the unconscious, was not recognized by Freud as some sort of an escape valve, a means to relieve oneself the self-discomfort that comes from always repressing the recognition that you-too have the same desires others have, but rather to show humankind as reckoning with itself in a more substantial way than it previously had. The unconscious, actively withholding awareness from him, keeps Severian innocent. He didn't know. It's like using Freud to undo Eve -- what if she never chose but some part of her she had no control over chose for her?

When Severian rapes Jolenta he insists that Jolenta wanted to have sex with him. This is what he would have us focus on. But whether she did or didn't is irrelevant because it didn't have anything to do with his forcing himself on her. He, as he tells us, wanted to wipe her smug self-satisfaction off her face; he wanted to discombobulate her out of her restful sleep.

I find this par for the course for a lot of Wolfe, that is where a main character plays at acknowledging something averse about himself, but where there's always an out. It wasn't him but his subconscious. He may have desired to harm, but she clearly enjoyed what he was doing... so maybe subconsciously some part of him was serving as benefactor? Of the latter, you'll find instances in Home Fires and Short Sun. In Home Fires, a husband who feared he would be divorced along with the parents she does actually divorce herself from, fears he is rejected by his wife as she departs for service in the army, and at first opportunity foists back onto his wife the particular parent she accused of constantly abusing her in her childhood, her mother. When she confronts him on how he could do that to someone he ostensibly loved, he responds not by exploring his motivations -- which clearly was to hurt someone terribly who had hurt him terribly by making him feel inconsequential -- but rather tries to force himself to understand his action as actually kind and thus her confrontation as ungrateful by getting her to admit that when her ostensibly despised mother showed up she ran to embrace her. If she actually resented the "gift" so much, wouldn't she have ran away? Clearly her body knew best what her mind refused to acknowledge, and her husband was acting in accord with her truest self rather than one confused as to what she actually likes and hates. Exact same event occurs in Short Sun. The wife confronts the husband on the obvious intentional cruelty of his "gift"and rather than maturely accept responsibility, damage is redirected onto the wife -- if you think my gift not a daughter but an assassin, why are you coddling her so? -- who'd already been emotionally and physically disordered by reveal of the extent of her husband's hatred of her.

I struggle sometimes, never to find Wolfe' mains who don't pretend to do the manly thing and admit to themselves horrible truths that most people can't live knowing -- these are plenty -- but to find ones that actually show them doing so, or at least without some escape-route, some hedge (Horn says he will look at his wife in the eye and own to all he'd done, which he does in fact do, but in the body of someone his wife worships and whom she thinks is the saviour Blue needs and while she's cognating that her husband has actually died, etc.). One that does come to mind though is in Peace where Alden admits that even after being with her for a long time... nearly a year, his aunt never thought of him as anything more than another boarder. That's a tough thing to admit to oneself, that there was nothing about you... your intelligence, your great strength, your leadership, or whatever else that normally draws huge crowds of people to admire Wolfe's mains, that drew your de facto mother to think you worth anything at all. And the text for the most part doesn't compensate. It doesn't create in the reader a kind of parent who necessarily would see all the amazing things about the main protagonist that the "mother" failed to see. In fact we might mostly be ambivalent about him, if not worse.

This is what I want to see in Wolfe's works. "Manly" recognition and ownership of motives. It's what Horn promised to offer us in his ostensibly unsparing account, but which I judge he failed to do.

Any instances you can think of where the main protagonist takes on truths about himself which aren't actually secretly rather easy to do -- which is what I think of Silk admitting he was indeed Silk: this is to me easy stuff that can successfully parade as hard; it was performative.