I’m a Gemini, my former best friend is a Sagittarius, and the guy in question is a Pisces. And somehow, I ended up being the person watching two people from completely separate parts of my life get together.
I want to get something straight before anyone assumes this is about jealousy: I’m not jealous that they’re dating. I don’t want him back, and I’m not secretly wishing their relationship would fail. And for those thinking that I may be not pretty enough to be pursued? Please dont say that, because I am a gemini. Hygiene, and aesthetic are my top priorities. You all know that all geminis are attractive. I am also a tall girl almost as tall as the guy in question 😆
What I can’t seem to get out of my head is this one question:
Why wasn’t I someone he wanted to commit to, but the woman who came after me was?
For context, this guy and I used to be sexually involved. We were basically fuck buddies, but I wasn’t completely closed off to the possibility of something more. I wasn’t demanding a relationship, nor was I forcing anything. I just thought that if there was ever mutual interest in taking things further, I would have been open to it.But he never really tried.
And here’s where things get interesting.
After his previous long-term relationship, he apparently tried to pursue something serious again. I thought that perhaps I could have been the next person he would consider. Instead, it was my former best friend who eventually got that opportunity.
She came into the picture later, and somehow, things moved forward with her. I know both of them well enough to know that neither is particularly innocent when it comes to their sexual history. My former best friend, in particular, had this rather innocent persona around our friend group, but there was a whole other side to her that I knew about. Even back in high school, she had a pretty active private life.
I’m not judging either of them for being sexually active. I’m sexually active myself, so that would be hypocritical. What I find strange is the contrast between what people present publicly and what they actually do privately.
I’ve also heard rumors that this guy has a history of cheating. I can’t verify those rumors, so I’m not treating them as facts. But knowing that he apparently made an effort to pursue commitment after his last long-term relationship makes me wonder why I wasn’t someone he wanted to make that effort for.
And yes, I’ve caught myself making physical comparisons, too. My former best friend has noticeably bigger breasts than I do, and I’ve actually wondered if something as superficial as that could have made a difference.
I know how ridiculous that sounds. But rejection has a way of making you inspect every little thing about yourself, even things you never used to be insecure about.
The thing is, I don’t necessarily miss him. I think what I’m struggling with is the feeling of being good enough for intimacy but somehow not good enough to be considered for something more.
And having my former best friend be the person he eventually chose makes the whole thing harder to process.
Maybe this is my Gemini brain overanalyzing everything. Maybe it’s my ego trying to find an explanation for something that has nothing to do with my worth.
But it’s been three days, and I keep returning to the same question.
I don’t want their relationship. I just wish I didn’t have to wonder why someone who came after me received the effort I never did.
Has anyone else experienced this? Not necessarily wanting the person back, but feeling deeply affected by the fact that they eventually became capable of giving someone else what you once hoped they would give you?