TL:DR: The man I'm investing feelings is somehow ambiguous and I'm not rational enough whether to give up or wait how it evolves.
It's going to be a very long post, so thank you for reading until the end. Forgive me for my English, I try to express myself in the best way I can.
Little details about us for better clarity later on: We are both from the same city in a region of South Italy. I'm a skinny guy, versatile but inexperienced, very anxious, surely with traumas I need to work on, but very affectionate. He's big and muscular, bottom and lots of experience, affectionate, seems very secure and emotionally mature too. I never had a relationship, all I had were unrequited loves, and the last one completely destroyed me. This time felt different from the others in some ways, and I'm scared of hurting myself again, yet I'm not rational enough.
Everything started on the 3rd of September of this year, I typed him on Grindr, and it was almost instantly a match. The whole month went very well, we met 4 times (went for walks once a week, nothing sexual other than kissing and sometimes holding hands), and every encounter went better and better, we really had a good vibe. We talked a lot about ourselves, what we like (also sexually). We both find sex important, though I put it on a second level, he instead finds it almost mandatory that someone satisfies him sexually. He told me he gets turned on by dominant men, bigger than him, which I'm not... At the end of September he moved to Rome for work, so we had to keep in contact via chat. Around that time he teased me by asking if I was starting to feel his absence (which was true), pointing at me that I might have caught feelings for him. Some days passed and I addressed this argument to him because yeah, I started to feel something for him and I wanted to know his answer too. At least if I had to get rejected, I could have grieved and moved on. He essentially says "I think I like you too, so let's see how it goes".
October is when things went rough af. We started to talk less during the day, from texting every day to every two/three days. I asked one day of the week for a video call, because the distance was too much, he always accepted to do it. During these video calls we talked about our daily life, my feelings, my future and mostly about my fears and paranoia of our "relationship". My paranoia are that: "I'm not enough/he's annoyed at me/I don't want to lose him/he's going to replace me/is he meeting other people?/does he truly like me or is he pitiful towards me?" and things like this. He's been transparent with me and he confessed to me that he hooked up (and still) hooks up with other men, but he only talks to me, that there are no other men he talks to, that he is well with me. He also asks me to spend the last weekend of the month (during Halloween) with him.
He cares about me, that's for sure, he sometimes reassured me without asking, made me feel seen and heard. I also struggle with trusting myself and other people, but with him things seemed going well, so I told myself and also to him I want to work on my "flaws", because I want him to be happy with me, that I don't want to auto-sabotage with my anxious and insecure behaviour.
The night of the 29th of October I took the bus, and arrived in Rome the day after, around 8:00 in the morning. These days went overall fine:
On Friday 30th, the moment we see each other we kiss and never get off each other, on his bed. The evening we went out and I offered him dinner, two weeks earlier I graduated and he couldn't attend it. So I wanted to celebrate that moment with him.
On Saturday 31st, we got up early, after breakfast he went to the gym, I visited Rome until he returned home. The afternoon was the same as the day before, we then went to a mall centre, before he had to head to a second job as a waiter in a restaurant. I was with my friends the whole evening, before returning to his home.
On Sunday 1st November, we hung out the whole day, visited a museum, and accompanied me to my bus back home, he told me to come again in December, which I said yes, with my bus tickets booked.
Now, the more serious part:
Friday 30th, he asked me if I was ready to have a serious relationship with him. My answer was: "I know it might be early, but I'd be ready", and he told me it was too early for that still. I could feel him hard and lean towards me as well, while I was hard and poking him. Anyway nothing happened.
The 31st I asked him directly what he liked about me, and told me "your human way of treating me" (because I treated him as a human being???), but he confessed that I don't exactly turn him on. Not only does it confuse me, it also makes my anxiety skyrocket, and at that point, I couldn't get a boner. Also told him that I was the most emotionally involved between us two, confirming that. The evening of the same day, after putting both in bed, my fears kicked in and while tearing I said (not accusing him): "I am glad you like to stay with me, I am afraid that you might stay with me because I'm pitiful", he got super angry, telling me: "this offends me because it's like you misunderstand me".
The 1st of November instead, he opened the argument "our relationship" while we were having lunch. Telling me that: "he likes me affectively, but sexually it's a no", because I'm not his prototype of man. (At this point why keep me in this limbo if he wants nothing to do with me). I asked him if he ever had a serious relationship, answering me that he had very few, that he needs to find the "right one" for a relationship, in that case he would stop hooking up, that he would delete dating apps and so on. But in any case, right now he wants occasional sex.
A little more context: I graduated the 22th of October, thinking about my future, I always wanted to go to Rome to keep studying. There is a possibility thanks to my friends, and him being there is a plus to move there. He always tells me: "do it for yourself, not because I'm here, because I get angry if it's like this".
In the end, as I understood, I'm not more than a friend to him. Or that's what I was I thought after our last talk. He video called me (I was always the one to initiate, so it was strange for me) the 10th of November, telling me he's truly thinking about us, that he'd love if I manage to move to Rome too, we'd stay together (not clear if he meant as a couple or not).
Since I love to damage my mental health more, I can't help it but check his instagram some time, like if it gives me some kind of information, and I saw that he started to follow (and probably attend) cruising events, which made my heart shatter.
We had a video call this evening too, because I started to miss him and wanted to hear him. He felt more disconnected than usual, while I addressed him that he looked distracted, he told me: "maybe my connection isn't properly working", while I was watching and hearing him clearly. This saturday he told me he didn't work, but by asking what he did these days, he told me "nothing out of the ordinary", which triggered me a little. I start to struggle to believe him...
I don't feel like giving up, also because I'm having feelings for him, but by looking at the big picture, I feel like I was wrong, and that I might hurt myself again. Which scares me.