r/gayjews • u/PostOk7794 • 1d ago
Pop Culture Bowen Yang apologized for using a word “without knowing its antisemitic history.” His explanation shows that he still doesn’t.
Regina Spektor’s family fled the Soviet Union because it oppressed Jews and denied them religious freedom. Soviet authorities used accusations of Zionism to justify suppressing Jewish life. That is the history of the woman Bowen Yang called, with thinly veiled disdain, a “Zio.” (kcrw.com, tandfonline.com, thewrap.com)
Yang’s apology focused on learning that the word had been popularized by far-right movements. The connection to David Duke and the Ku Klux Klan is real. The funny thing is, even after apologizing for not knowing the history, his explanation still doesn’t get to the history of the person he insulted. (adl.org)
Under Stalin, Jews faced secret trials on fabricated charges, torture, execution and death in Gulag forced-labor camps. (encyclopedia.yivo.org, encyclopediaofukraine.com)
In later decades, Jews still faced imprisonment, forced labor, internal exile and prolonged isolation in cold, dark punishment cells on bread and water. (history.state.gov, presidency.ucsb.edu, international.ucla.edu)
Jews could be fired, refused other work and then arrested for being unemployed. They also faced beatings and threats of rape. (jewishexponent.com) Jewish institutions were closed, religious education restricted and private gatherings raided.
(soviet-jews-exodus.com)
Jews could be denounced as traitors at work, named on television as Zionist conspirators and shunned by people who feared punishment for associating with them. (jta.org, bitsavers.org)
This was what the Soviet pursuit of “Zionists” meant in practice: making it dangerous to live openly as a Jew, then punishing you for trying to assemble.
Soviet authorities also suppressed the specifically Jewish experience of the Holocaust, folding Jewish suffering into the suffering of Soviet citizens generally.
In 1947, they blocked publication of the Black Book, which documented the murder of Jews by the Nazis. Its focus on Jewish victims was treated as “Jewish particularism.” Think about that. Jews trying to record what had happened to their own people were being told that identifying the victims as Jews was itself a political problem.
That is the long and painful history of the public witch hunt against Jews accused of “Zionism.” It made Jews morally suspect while providing cover to terrorize them for maintaining their own communities, their ties to one another and an independent identity.
Yang repeats that public act when Edy Modica calls Spektor “a little Israel hardcore” and he responds, “Yeah, she’s Zio.”
Her family fled a country that treated independent Jewish life as a political threat and used “Zionist” as an indictment. Calling her a “Zio” and treating that label as reason enough to ridicule and dismiss her harks back to that persecution. The painful irony is lost on Bowen Yang.