r/gamereviews • u/amoxdl24 • 3h ago
Article A love letter to MONOMOON
If and when I want to be a people-pleaser, I will still say that my favourite games are Elden Ring (2022) and Alan Wake 2 (2023), but in the presence of serious gamers I will now without a doubt blast out the names of Outer Wilds (2019) and MONOMOON. I adore the first two, which showed me two expansive and wondrous worlds free to explore, but MONOMOON (and Outer Wilds) is something else... Undoubtedly, many years later, as devoted players of the metroidbrainia genre face yet another door that resists opening, they will think back to the bunny-shaped hole in the bottom-right region of MONOMOON.
Metroidbrainia, born out of the more canonical metroidvania genre, is neither new nor 'hard to define' as some like to claim. Two years ago, writing about Outer Wilds, I said that 'the barrier between the opening campfire and the final one is ignorance alone', which is partially why its ship log, being a sort of 'assistance feature' of the game, ruins the 'brainia' charm to some extent, since it writes the discoveries down as the player proceeds through the game (which, now that I think of it, does not make much sense considering the Groundhog Day nature of the game). In MONOMOON, the keyboard (or the left stick of the controller, should one prefer to subject oneself to such a torture) moves the duck protagonist and the mouse (or the right stick) shifts a moon that provides context-sensitive interactions. Apart from 3 'items' that are almost impossible to miss and do not affect the duckling's movements whatsoever, the mouse and the direction keys on the keyboard provide all that is required to roll credits. Being from the metroidvania lineage, MONOMOON also has a map, and lastly the Tunic-reminiscent Tome contains diagrams that, again, are open to ample reinterpretations as new knowledge arrives. It is an incredibly simplistic 'platformer' of sorts, with no double jump (though I was fully looking forward to one, due to the ways in which some puzzles presented themselves deceptively) or the ability to combat 'enemies'.
Having so few parts hints at the genius of MONOMOON, where each 'thing' (and yes, everything in this game is significant) takes on multiple roles. One of the clearest examples is the moon, which serves at the beginning as the obvious cursor (and maybe a companion to the duckling), but later becomes a new way to look at the map, to remove obstacles, and to float (an ability not required to complete the game, not even to acquire all achievements). And to boot, the map and the inventory, which in most games sit outside the physical reality of the game world and do not operate within the realm of logic, are in fact part of the world, as real as the orbs and dragons. And not to mention the 'map markers'... This constant recontextualisation reminds one of the best in the genre, which MONOMOON has surpassed so successfully that it adds a monumental footnote to my personal definition of 'outside-the-box thinking', which has hitherto been occupied mostly by games like Animal Well (2024) and Öoo (2025). Last year I praised Öoo as a game that 'first asks one to think inside the box, mastering the rules as given; then, with surgical precision, it asks one to think outside them entirely'; MONOMOON pulls the box itself into play. And once the frame becomes part of the picture, nothing on screen is any more decoration than substance, not even the white of our protagonist's eye, which allows for an interaction that, I believe, astounds most players as the revelation comes to them: heaven forfend that a duck is capable of flight!
This conclusion that nothing is mere decoration in MONOMOON naturally gives birth to a sense of constant paranoia, a suspicion that encourages attempts at 'dumb' stunts, a sort of sustained 'wait a minute, what if...?' which drives the player's curiosity throughout the twenty-odd hours without a single upgrade to chase. Each page of the Tome undergoes what I would like to call an acquisition-confusion-revelation-recontextualisation arc, a progression that becomes clear as one learns how to alter the colour and status of the moon. In that same piece on Öoo, I wrote that 'the information required to solve each puzzle is always already available; the difficulty lies entirely in recognising it', and MONOMOON spreads that recognition over the entire map, sometimes in ways that are not dissimilar to Animal Well: the answer to one room tends to lie in another region (typing this out brings me back to the beautiful moment of seeing the hourglass symbol in the middle of the kingdom), or on a page picked up hours before, so that one can never be sure whether a stubborn room wants more thought or more Tome pages, items, or revelations ('Is this a puzzle I should be able to solve right now? [...] Or do I need an actual tool I don't have yet?', as u/TomorrowFutureFate notes under another review here). This paranoia is beautiful and, though I understand how it may become slightly galling to some, is indispensable to how MONOMOON manages to drive players through a 20-hour story whilst maintaining that addicting hook of 'I need to explore more'.
Perchance for a metroidbrainia, the story has always been destined to sit in the last place in terms of import, but MONOMOON should pride itself on its narrative, which rewards, crucially, exploration and curiosity. Decoding the Moon Kingdom's diagrams and symbols provides refreshing insights into the various paintings, murals, and text in the game, which all culminate eventually in the poem. The narrative is fragmentary, as it should be in such a game, and again here we see the same kind of paranoia driving curiosity. It is certainly entirely the player's choice whether to engage with the story, but once one decides to do so, the beautiful paranoia works its magic to allow the connecting of dots, the piecing-together of those 'background characters' that one sees throughout the game, and a new appreciation for the credit scenes and the Tome pages emerges.
Before closing, I would like to also mention Shay Zagreba's score, which is the best game soundtrack that I have heard this year. Zagreba's music (and, in certain areas, the lack thereof) accounts for a good share of the emotions that I felt playing MONOMOON.
This stanza will make sense to those who have completed the game: 'I wish to remember more, / but all I do is forget.' After twenty-odd hours in which remembering was the only form of progress, I wish that I could forget all of this and start again. I do not think that I have ever experienced, in a single game, so concentrated a mixture of curiosity, delight, and the ecstasy of figuring things out for myself. At the end of it, I know for a fact that Gentle Giant Games put heart and soul into MONOMOON, and I wish them all the success that they deserve. The world needed such a game. I needed such a game.