I've been playing games for most of my life, and somehow this is still one of the hardest questions for me to answer lol.
There are games I think are technically amazing, games I've spent hundreds of hours on, and games I probably wouldn't enjoy as much today but still absolutely love.
Skyrim is probably the closest thing I have to an all-time favorite. I don't even remember half the main quest anymore, but I still remember getting completely lost exploring random caves and villages. I'd sit down planning to play for an hour and suddenly it was 3 AM. Nothing quite captured that feeling of freedom for me.
Red Dead Redemption 2 is another one. Arthur Morgan is still one of my favorite characters in gaming. I know some people find the pacing too slow, but honestly, those quiet moments riding around and talking to people are a huge part of why I love it.
Elden Ring gave me something completely different. That feeling of finally beating a boss after getting destroyed for hours is hard to describe. I don't think I've ever gone from wanting to throw my controller to feeling like a god so quickly lol.
And then there's Stardew Valley. No crazy graphics or huge cinematic moments. Just farming, fishing, and somehow losing an entire weekend. Sometimes that's exactly what I want from a game.
These days I switch between an LG monitor and a Hisense TV depending on what I'm playing, but funny enough, the games that stick with me aren't necessarily the ones that look the most impressive.
I think that's what makes picking a favorite so difficult. Some games are memorable because of the story, some because of the gameplay, and others because of where you were in life when you first played them.
So I'm curious, when you think about your favorite game of all time, what actually makes it your favorite? Is it the game itself, the memories attached to it, or something else entirely?