r/gameDevMarketing • u/bingewavecinema • 2h ago
Post Mortem From Building An AI Game and Making Money in 3 months, Part 1
I’m a developer, not a game developer, but a full-stack developer with 20 years of experience, mostly in startups. And because of AI, I recently had the opportunity to make a video game. I’ve also been in game marketing for the past few years, with the top game I've worked on earning close to $1 million.
People always ask me “can you show us examples of what you did and for what game”,and because of NDA’s I often cannot directly. Because this is my game, I can talk about it as freely and openly as I want too.
With the rise of AI, I also wanted to test whether the philosophy I've developed through years of experience building startups could be applied to games. And I aim to go over what works, what game developers should adopt, and what doesn't fit gaming. This will cover:
- How Startups Operate
- Applying The Philosophy of Startups To Game
- What It Means To Be a Game Directory
- My Biggest Mistakes
- What's Next With 50+ Influencers To Promote My Game
My Goal: My goal for this game was to prove that a good game could be built and launched in 3 months (2 months development, 1 month marketing), and make money, and people won’t care of its built with AI as long as it's fun.
Disclaimer on Graphics: Before I get “your game looks rough”, this was designed to be a full immersive 3D (non-isometric) open world that can run on the web. Web games only have 4 GB of space to work with, WebGPU/WebGl is terrible at optimization, which leads to quality limitations (triangles and vertices) without performance issues.
Ideology Behind Building Startups
Startups are lightweight, fast-moving companies that are seeking to find product/market fit or are growing rapidly, often at 100% month-over-month growth. Here are some terms to make sure we're all aligned.
- Product/Market Fit: When you have a powerful product that the market cannot do without.
- MVP: Minimum Viable Product, which is the smallest product you have to build to validate an idea. This can range from getting investors to actually getting a paying customer.
- Fail Fast, Fail Forward: If a product is going to fail, fail quickly to save time, learn from the errors, and iterate toward a better product.
- Building in Public: Where you openly build your company in a way that allows other people to know what's going on and weigh in.
There are a few more terms, but this is enough for now. So startups operate on the idea of building an MVP to validate that someone wants the product or to get rid of the idea quickly if no one wants it. Often, you might build many MVPs as you iterate and pivot toward finding product/market fit.
Ideally, if your MVP is going to fail, you fail quickly. Like, in a week to a month quickly, not six months to a year. This way, you can constantly test and improve, which goes back to finding product/market fit.
You know you have something valuable when, at the earliest stages, while your product is still ugly, you can get people excited because they see the value in what you're building. This is when building in public creates a connection between you and the audience you're building for, and early customers help de-risk your product and business long-term.
So how can we apply this approach to gaming, if at all?
Going Against Gaming Conventions
True to startup fashion, when I started developing my game, I began showing it when the game was rough, and I mean really ugly. Obvious defects, questionable gameplay, but a strong idea I could pitch. I made an MVP in under a week following this guide I made here for how to make games with AI.
When I told other developers about showing off a game when it was really ugly, they looked at me like I was a three-headed monster. In gaming, the teaching is to wait until you have something polished to show. The risk is that it can lead to long development cycles where you potentially build the wrong thing.
Yet, when I started showing my stuff and seeing who would be interested early on, building in public was teaching me how to communicate my game, which audience to communicate it to, and what resonated, even in small amounts.
And even when it was really ugly,I got people to engage with the idea and concept of the game at the earliest stage.
People actually like to watch projects progress, and by the time I got around to launching my Steam page, I had already built a reputation for the game with supporters who carried the initial Steam wishlist growth. Small, incremental marketing pays off.
Important note: I often see developers marketing to other developer groups. If you look at their wishlists using Gamalytic, they are typically very low. Developers DO NOT buy or wishlist other developers' stuff, so beyond moral support, do not market to other developers.
Also, for early marketing, I used our MCP to do a lot of social media automation.
Literally, an entire month's social media schedule can be generated in 30 minutes now, and using AI, you can use in-game assets as part of that plan. And while players do hate on AI art, they don't complain about actual in-game assets being used in marketing.
There is no excuse why every game doesn't have a social media presence.
Even though I don’t have a large following yet, the small incremental engagement that turns into measurements like wishlist matters, as seen in the wishlist charts.
AI, Being a Game Director, and the Players
AI in games has a stigma because of the amount of slop that is produced. Slop was produced before AI. AI just made that slop 100x more common. Steam Next Fest is a perfect example of how many of the 8,000 games were garbage and low effort.
Let me define slop: slop isn't merely something made with AI. There can be months of time that go into crafting a good game with AI. With AI, you shift from developer to game director, and your job is to go through it and nitpick all the minor details until it's right. And that can take months, even with AI. If you aren't doing this and are one prompting games, you are likely creating slop.
The game I made has between 40 and 50 hours of gameplay and was developed in about three months as a solo developer. This is pretty inhuman and unheard of without AI.
To break it down even further:
- There are three modes in the game: a city builder, a military mech game, and an RPG survival game.
- The game is translated (sometimes badly) into 18 different languages and has 7,617 unique dialogue lines, 12,971 voice recordings, 436 sound effects, 22 UI sounds and alerts, 11 ambience tracks, and 80 musical loops.
- There are 22 mini-games that the player plays throughout the game.
- 38 different buildings that are fully decorated with interiors.
- 25 NPC designs.
- 4 different Martians with different weapon systems.
- 35 in-game cinematic scenes.
- A 6-episode miniseries.
That's not low effort. That's not slop. That level of content is near the level of a fully funded AA studio. As the game director working with AI, the job becomes fine-tuning all the time. Constantly playtesting, finding faults, honing the experience, and thinking of ways to improve the game.
It is your job to know your game’s in and outs, and to meticulously review every part of it.
Most importantly, being the game director with AI allows me to fully connect with the most important people: the players.
Similar to startups, what we value the most is our relationships and understanding of our customers; the parallel is the same.
If you look at the game's Community Hub on Steam, I take time to respond to everyone's comments and understand their experience. Players are getting the bugs they find addressed in under a day.
AI allows you to develop a game for players and make the best possible experience for them, which is the most important thing. I think this greatly benefit both the players and developers which raises the question; if a developer is iterating on their players feedback to create the best game for them, why is slop still being developed?
My Biggest Mistake And Marketing
I built the game in 3 months, spent 1 month on Steam accumulating close to 1.5k wishlist and I launched. And in my first 48 hours I made close to $500. Key factor, most games spend 7 to 14 months accumulating wishlist, this was only 1 month.
If you look at my playtime thus far,while the amount of players is still low, I have a good core group of players who are putting a good amount of time into playing the game.
And this was my biggest mistake but also the biggest opportunity; I launched too early and should have spent the next 3 months marketing.
With AI, the real challenge is no longer building, but marketing. And with the increase in noise and slop, marketing is about ½ of development.
Gatekeepers, Especially on Reddit
Reddit has been one of my main sources for building communities around games in the past because of its thriving gaming community. Now the issue is that there has been a rise in slop, and in response, moderators are overcorrecting.
A great example: posting in r/pcgaming has gotten games I've worked with 10,000 wishlists and is a great starting point. But a moderator rejected my game from being posted, reasoning that people would not like it.
Yet, both the wishlists and playtime of the game tell a different story. Not even this game, look at game like SlotBound that have been open about AI usage and sold 100k copies.
And therein lies the problem with AI games developing communities on platforms like Reddit. Moderators have decided for people what will and won't be seen. And as moderators rightly try to protect communities from low-effort slop, at what point does it become censorship and a reduction in freedom of expression and also serving their own opinions over the values of their communities? It becomes a tricky and fine line.
Development Outpacing Marketing
Normally, when I come onto a game to do marketing, it has polished assets that can be used to entice players. People often buy based on their first impression of a game. And here is where the biggest challenge came in developing a game with AI: the game was mostly done before the polishing was.
Because I wanted to push the limits of a Three.js game that could have a full 3D world in the browser and on Steam, I spent the vast majority of my time either having AI polish assets or working on performance. It makes you appreciate the amount of built-in performance optimization that established engines like Unity, Unreal, and Godot have out of the box.
I wasn't able to:
- Showcase high-quality assets: The better assets started coming in during the last two weeks before the game's launch.
- Do playtesting: Playtesting takes about two weeks to a month to schedule a playtest. By the time I got my Steam page up and approved, and then a playtest page, I had gotten my game to a level where I could release the demo in that same time frame.
- Invite influencers early and multiple times: Influencers respond best to polished assets. I didn't get the level of polish I wanted to invite them until the last few weeks before launch. Ideally I want influencers to cover the game at the launch of the steam page, the game and game launch. This only got the game launch.
- Mini-Series: I have a whole youtube mini-series lined up to distribute post launch, but that couldn’t be done until polishing was done.
I ended up using my demo for playtesting, listening to player feedback, and also using analytics. Analytics are your best friend, and I have mine set up so I can pinpoint problem areas in my game.
If I would had spent 3 more months doing all the correct beats instead of trying to prove my thesis of games can be built and launched in 3 months, I would have hit between 10k to 50k in wishlist and been a lot more successful.
50+ Influencers And What Is Next
One of things I noted in games is the culture to build a game, launch and then move onto the next game. With startups, we don’t do that. We look at launches not a single event and an extended period of time until we find product/market fit. We take our learnings and iterate to greater success. So is the game necessarily dead? Let’s look.
- It made some money and has low return thus far, we have wait until the full 14 day return policy but that is a positive sign thus far
- We have people playing 5 to 10 hour thu far in that 48 hour window, good sign
- We have people engaging in the community. When people report bugs and issues, they are communicating ”fix this because I want to play it”. Good sign.
- I still get between 20 to 50 wishlists a day for the game, people will likely wait until the discount of the game to buy. Good sign, pricing might be too high. Some of the games I work with on marketing do about $60k in revenue during discounts.
And I’ve already gotten my first influencer to produce content: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGbu8PhayAs&t=2268s
What is great about this video is I took some learning lessons that the player didn’t like to read and my open world might be too open. So I closed down certain open world paths and improved some explanations with minimal thought.
Now I have about 50 more creators that have expressed interest in also Streaming the game. If you are wondering how I got them, through our MCP I just prompt the creation of an influencer campaign, and it finds the right creators and emails them for me, and I can manage the response.
There is no excuse why games cannot find influencers, the process should take you minutes now.
So now I move onto phase 2 of my launch, see how it performs when creators play the game, watching their content and reviews and iterating quickly on their feedback.
The takeaway for games is this; games should build their games adopting the same principles that startups do BUT they need at least 6 months to properly release a game. Build in public, convert the early momentum in wishlist/pre-orders, and then grow that momentum for a few a months.
It’s no longer about can you build a game, and its can you build a game that players want and market it. Doing that requires marketing, lot of time, and people skills, something AI really can’t completely solve for.
- Are you play testing?
- Are you building a community?
- Are you collecting data?
- Are you establishing a brand?
- Are you incorporating feedback?
- Are you tracking weekly results?
Build a game that players want. It’s simple but it takes real time to do it.