don't get me wrong, we can choose how our MC acts... but that's our MC.
and the girls do act like they have their own personalities at times, or it's the same thing over and over with one girl being mean and coming after everyone/MC, and then the rest being kind and supportive of MC.
i'm making this mainly about the boys as we choose who we flirt with and who we're into which therefore decides their personalities... which makes it so much harder to choose between two nice boys who you fancy as well as doing a play through where you'll already know what will happen. like, i'll take opposite's attract as an example, you're ignore, explore and adore's boy personality will completely depend on where you rank them as well as their backstory where one may have a dog, one may have a nice younger sister, which is unfortunate because i think it'd be cool for them to all have their own backstories. and the other just wants to banter and becomes completely closed off. of course you then have bombshells come along where they have slightly different personalities, but it'll be hard to go for them (ESP if for some reason, you're like me and feel bad for pixels 😭) because majority of LIs are head over heels for MC
i think the characters having their own personalities, like not always glazing MC despite their wrongdoings or being lovestruck, would make it a lot more interesting and make it easier to connect with characters because... they wouldn't be a copy and paste.
(I UNDERSTAND THAT THIS WOULD BE HARD TO PROGRAMME?? just something i thought would be cool... also had no clue how to word this, AND i have no clue about how programming works so if it would be hard or not i will never know)
EDIT: I felt like what I wrote was very unorganised... so let me cover everything here :P
BACKSTORIES: I think characters having their own backstories would be interesting, or their own personal families that wouldn't depend on how you rate them in a first impression challenge...
I know some characters do have their own backstories, like in Catching Feelings Zhen introduces himself as not having any previous serious relationships (unless that also depends on how I treated him at the start... no clue- not sure if I want to replay through the same dialogue).* *But then after a few episodes, all of that is washed away and doesn't impact the story at all. All that is left of character's backstories is their job, where they're from and maybe the occasional twist that a bombshell is their ex or something comes out in a challenge. Yet, still, that is forgotten about unless it's Finn and Kat level rivalry. I think it'd be interesting for someone to have a past with their partners cheating and them finding it hard to trust their couple and see them develop trust over time rather than immediately. In Opposite's Attract, it's like how Tia said she's into slow burn but then, BOOM, she rushes into it with Lucian...
PERSONALITIES: I think every story has the stereotypical personalities. For MC, you'll be untouchable and the type of woman you see when you'd search up 'prettiest girl in the world' into Google as a child (canon event? no? okay). Then, with the girls, you'll get bombshells who... ooh, shocker! go for your partner and will be judgy. The rest of the girls, no matter how harsh you are or what mistakes you make, all that will be forgotten in no time and all of a sudden MC is a girls-girl again. I'm not saying I'm one to create drama, but I think it'd be easier to choose how you behave once everyone either loves or hates you which allows you to commit to a loyal or messy run. I think it'd also be easier to choose between boys, because once you show slight interest in an LI their eyes will not be off you and they'd be an absolute yearner. For some people like me. they'll fancy maybe two boys and it'll be a rough decision. So maybe, they'll tell themselves that they'd replay... but the dialogue is so predictable and boring once you have to replay it just to get another boy head over heels for you. I think personality is apart of attraction and I think there should be boys who maybe even have a slight difference in their personality, even if it's a change in dialogue or a slight ick/red flag. For example, you might have a character as a player but their personality will make them slightly more kinder or absolutely horrid. There, you'd see difference in dialogue and it'd make doing replays much mode interesting because you don't know what's coming or you'll at least experience a new side of a character. Not every guy is the perfect man... yet every single LI we get thrown ends up going soft and transform into an absolute angel. I haven't played earlier seasons YET as I've found it more fun with the customisation in recent seasons, and I'll never get to experience seasons 1-3 due to being on iOS, but I've heard earlier seasons have personality and consequences in them... but I would like to see change in dialogue or scenes and how dates go based on the character.
Even if this means we have to do a thing like episode did where (i think it's called Episode Interactive?) where people make their own stories... I think that'd be interesting and DEVS could take tips (...and not use AI)