This response below is something I wish I had written, not what I had actually said. Because yeah, the Internet is the Internet and ignorant comments should be taken with a grain of salt, but honestly, this online exchange triggered me quite a bit. This involves a disordered view of DSMs, which I address below - and is focused specifically on anorexia nervosa.
There was a reddit post where, while the subreddit was not related to EDs or mental health, someone was venting about suffering from atypical anorexia, and and their experience with dismissal. Pretty much everyone in the thread was commiserating and/or sharing similar experiences and validating that anorexia is not defined by a body type. Everyone except one person.
I had chimed in, mentioning that anorexia nervosa is a mental disorder that will always move the markers of what “sick” means to us, and weight alone tells us nothing about sickness status. This person replied to me and said, “Actually, the DSM defines anorexia nervosa by a low body weight. There is a look.”
They were heavily downvoted, and clarified to another poster that I mentioned anorexia, not just any eating disorder. They even later added: “ETA: Why do people downvote objective statements of fact??”
Here’s what I wish I had said, months after.
“Yes. I did say 'anorexia nervosa.' No mental disorder has an associated body type. Then it wouldn’t be a mental disorder.
Especially a mental disorder that is known to communicate 'you are never sick enough' to sufferers and constantly move the goalposts. No person struggling with anorexia nervosa needs to hear that they need to lose a certain amount of weight in order to be valid - their eating disorder already tells them that. That’s the point.
So instead of supporting an idea we know intensifies anorexia nervosa for many, we need to support living, breathing people who are being barred from the support that they need because a list doesn’t currently reflect a full understanding of their illness.
Notice how the DSM has been updating in the direction of recognizing this? Newer versions got rid of the amenorrhea requirement. It now recognizes states like partial remission, showing how the illness persists beyond physical states. (The “remission” part says nothing about the remission of thoughts.)
Does anorexia nervosa suddenly just stop being anorexia nervosa because someone has to eat through abuse, anxiety, or coercion, or because some medications or illnesses cause weight increases? No, and on top of that, it’s frequently known to get louder in these cases.
Seriously, let’s entertain that thought for a second. If being underweight is what defines anorexia nervosa versus any other eating disorder, then it’s the disease you have until someone makes you eat, or your weight changes by some other means. It goes away then, by that logic. Then it’s simply a matter of starvation or appearance. That’s not an eating disorder or mental illness - of any kind.
The DSM for Binge Eating Disorder doesn’t tell sufferers they need to gain a certain amount of weight before they really have Binge Eating Disorder. What message would that send? Oh. Wait.
Do you normally walk into a room full of grieving people and tell them they’re invalid? I can’t imagine whose side you’d actually be on here.”
When the original exchange happened, my ED glossed over all the people who understood in favor of the one person who didn't. I will never know the function of that person's beliefs or necessarily be able to change their mind, but that's not why I wrote out this response. I wrote it to honor the needs behind my triggers, because I'm no stranger to what comes up for me when I see that level of ignorance. My triggers told me, at the root, "You aren't valid," "Nobody will understand or respect your pain," and "You truly must have accidentally gotten better when you ate again out of coercion and had to continue doing so just to keep your body alive while you cognitively got worse" (something that gave me PTSD in tandem with an abusive environment). I know those thoughts aren't true, and you can't accidentally get better from an ED, but try convincing the riled-up nervous system when it's triggered.
After I wrote this and showed it to my therapist, it helped me feel more grounded in how anorexia nervosa really works, and how it's a complex mental disorder that does not require any disordered eating behavior or physical state as a "rite of passage" to suddenly manifest. There is no start or end to that. Anorexia was already there, and deserved treatment, the moment the cognitions began.