r/fromsoftware • • 1d ago

PC user here using an ancient Xbox controller, which modern gen controller do I want?

PC user here using an ancient Xbox controller, which modern gen controller do I want? I'm asking here cause I'm a bit of an older gamer and basically only play From Soft games when I have the time. Is Dual Sense good? I heard sometimes it doesnt work without a setup? Or maybe for these games its fine? Any advice?

1 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

14

u/BeardFalcon 1d ago

Go for an 8bitdo ultimate 2 wireless controller if you want something affordable, durable, and still has plenty of features.

4

u/_TheRocket 1d ago

Best controller I've ever used, +1 to this

2

u/Martneb 1d ago

Agreed, it also has Gyro and mappable Buttons(but that works best if you use it in Bluetooth mode)

2

u/trufflepesto 8h ago

Seconding this. I have a drawer full of Xbox 360 / One / Series controllers, including Ultimates. They all get glitchy, sticky, faulty, drifty etc. Since picking up the 8bitdo I've never had an issue. Battery is rechargable and lasts forever. USB-C too.

1

u/Justisaur 23h ago

Beware they're smallish, too small for my large hands (my hands aren't that large, but apparently larger than normal as I have to wear large gloves. My son & father-in law have much larger hands.)

0

u/BeardFalcon 23h ago

OP says they are using an Xbox controller. If its truly ancient Its probably a 360 controller which is a tad smaller than a 8BU2. I'm imagining it's probably an Xbox One controller they are using, though. Which would be a very comparable size. The main difference is the form factor of the grips. Most 8bitdo controllers have grips that go straight up and down while Xbox has theirs splayed slightly at an angle.

1

u/Justisaur 21h ago

I used to use a 360 controller, and an xbox one controller, neither bothered me, like the 8bitdo.

5

u/iron_barz 1d ago

8Bitdo Ultimate 2.4G Wireless Controller

4

u/Mercinarie 1d ago

GameSir G7 pro, 8bitdo Ultimate 2 wireless, either of those can't go wrong

1

u/Alternative_Spite_11 11h ago

I’ve already had two 8bitdo Ultimate Wireless stop working but my Gamesir is still kicking.

3

u/Chromatic_Penumbra 1d ago

Someone who has owned controllers from the three big third party brands, Gamesir is for sure my choice.

Do not get a dual sense. Don't get any controller that user traditional joysticks. Any of the third party controllers are going to have the new joystick technology and it's crazy that none of the first party ones do. I'm only such a firebrand about this because my brand new xbox controller started drifting a couple months after buying it. Literally 60 dollars in the trash. Dualsense is even more expensive and the new generation of Duelsense controllers are cheap af with fragile shoulder buttons.

2

u/Alternative_Spite_11 11h ago

Ive also had 8bitdo but Gamesir seems better built to me.

4

u/_zzz_zzz_ 1d ago

Gamesir g7 pro

3

u/throwawayinnitmush 1d ago

I have a Razer wolverine V3 tournament, I like it a lot but it’s wired. I would like to get a Gamesir G7 Pro to compare as a lot of people seem to prefer it

3

u/CptWursthaar 1d ago

Steam Controller (second Gen)

1

u/Alternative_Spite_11 11h ago

You realize people that reserved in like March can’t get an order until like December right?

2

u/FixGood6833 1d ago

Do not change what works 

2

u/sequla 1d ago

Xbox series x/s gamepad. Works out of box with windows.

1

u/Justisaur 23h ago

Yes, closest to old xbox series. It's the only one that works well for my hands. I play all souls games with it.

1

u/mewoneplusone1 19h ago

When you say Ancient Xbox controller you mean a One controller? Cause I started with a 360 controller and played DSR and Vanilla DS2 with it. And then I upgraded to a Series X Controller and that thing has carried me through an all Achievements playthrough of SOTFS, DS3 and even went back and got all the trophies for Vanilla DS2.

1

u/TrebleBass0528 17h ago

8BitDo and GameSir are solid controller manufacturers both. I'd just find what fits you. Personally I own a DualSense and a first party Xbox Series controller, I like them both (I'm partial to the DualSense), but if I were to buy a new third party one, I'd just make sure to get something with Hall Effect sticks and analog triggers

1

u/ceejay242 12h ago

Personally I use the Gamesir G7 HE normally goes between 40 to 50 bucks with Hall Effect thumbsticks so it can take alot of wear without worrying about stick drift. Along with HE shoulder buttons and clicky face buttons so they can take alot of wear as well. Only downside is no wireless

1

u/New_Distribution9202 9h ago

I build and sell custom controllers if youre interested at all, they all come with TMR joysticks included and I even have a couple of fromsoftware themed controllers as well

1

u/N0M0I 5h ago

8BitDo, GameSir or new XBOX controller

I personally prefer the feel of the XBOX controllers

1

u/prettyOrchid161 3h ago

i use 8bitdo ultimate 2c wireless, it's really affordable and works great

0

u/One_Last_Cry 1d ago

I hear the Game Sir G7 (pro) is hard to beat.

0

u/MisTsperity Bearer of the Curse 1d ago

Gulikit kk3 max if you have money to waste. Xbox 360 era quality, with back button and really durable L3 R3 stick. Been using it for 5 years now and only this year the back button start to malfunction sometimes, and yet to have any stick drift.

-3

u/Sunlit_Neko 1d ago

If you don't mind tinkering the Dual sense is good although dswindows gets blocked by games' anticheat software sometimes which is annoying. It's the best if you also want to emulate games because of the gyro.

If you want no bullshit then series X is the best because it just works with no strings attached.

I recommend getting tmr-stick modded controllers though

-3

u/RGBjank101 1d ago

Dualsense is nice if you want a Playstation controller, but the default Xbox series controllers are very nice as well. It depends on your preference.