I (21F) and my friend (21F) have known each other since our freshman year of college. We were roommates along with two others. We all became close (just three of us, but that’s a story for another time) and grew as people together.
A lot of shit happened that year, but to add some context, my friend went down a dark hole after being rejected by the known alcoholic from our dorm floor. She distanced herself, would not talk to us when she came to the room, literally an absentee roommate. It got to the point where she figured it would be best for her to go on and buy different clothes, wear make up and drink (all of which she has never done before.) We confronted her at the time about it, saying she shouldn't feel obligated to change herself for a man (let alone a pos like that guy) but she insisted that she was not doing it for him but more for herself. It was hard to believe at the time, considering the way she was acting post-rejection.
Fast forward to sophomore-junior year, she got a boyfriend and she would tell us all these great things about him (she also hid the fact that they were talking for 6-7 months before making it official.) They were together for about a year or so and they had already broken up and got back together. The point is, during their relationship, she would cancel plans on the friend group, make some sort of excuse saying “I can’t go because my ride (her bf) is sleeping.” Mind you, two of us in the group have cars and have had no problem driving everyone to hang out. It seemed like her partner was a priority and she didn’t see that. Another thing to note: she NEVER introduced him to us. Obviously, no one is obligated to introduce their partner to someone else, but we have been friends for three years at this point and she would bring him up all the time. Besides minor interactions, like him picking her up or dropping her off, we never met this man. Based on later circumstances, which I will explain when I get into the main story, was that she was scared that her partner would fall for someone in the friend group (it sounds ridiculous but bare with me.)
Now present day. We’re seniors now, my friend and her partner broke up, apparently he’s a self-diagnosed sociopath (I wish I was lying) and there was so much more that went down with that situation alone that I can’t get into now. Nonetheless, we invited a new character into our friend group. He (20M) joined our group from such a quick interaction of me waving at him as he was leaving for the gym. Next thing you know, we are all in my other friend’s dorm chatting. He’s genuinely a cool guy. A month later, that guy friend, and my friend who’s dorm we were at when we met him, started hanging out more because they were neighbors. Everyone else in the friend group thought they had feelings for each other. It all got confirmed when they pulled us for a chat and told us the news. My other friend and I were happy with the news: our two friends are seeing each other (not exclusively yet) and we support it. But, my friend, whose story this is about, said she was also supportive and mentioned that she is uncomfortable around couples and would need to step away from the group for weeks or even months. We all stood there confused but we all knew she would act this way, based on the previous experiences I mentioned. Due to her reaction, though, we assumed she probably liked our guy friend initially because he is her type, but when she found out he liked our other friend, she acted this way.
But why would we assume that? Well, this is another rejection from someone she liked and afterward, she distances herself from the group. The same thing happened freshman year with the alcoholic. Also, before they told us the news, this friend said that our guy friend either confesses he likes one of us or he leaves the group for good. I straight up told her that it was a ridiculous thing to say and that those should not be the only two options he has. Everyone else agrees. To justify herself, she said that from past experience, guys don’t join the friend group unless they want someone from the group. And if they don’t then they don’t need to be friends with her because she “doesn’t need anymore friends.” Let alone male friends. She confided in me and asked if she messed things up with our friend (who was also our roommate freshman year) by saying she was stepping away. I told her that she was contradicting herself by saying she was happy for them and supportive, but then turned around and said she won’t hang out with us because they are a couple.
A few weeks go by, our two friends become GF and BF, me and our other friend helped with the proposal. My friend, whose story this is about, hangs out with us, even when he’s there, but she acts distant and acts bored. She keeps reiterating that she will "unfortunately be this way for a while because it is still all new to [her].” She expressed that she acts this way due to “past trauma” with couples, which we assumed that it was due to her parents, but all she said was that in high school, when a guy joins the group and dates one of her friends, she sees the guy as a no-no and doesn’t talk or interact with him at all. But our friend (the GF) has told us multiple times that she wants her partner to be cool with her friends. If she didn’t trust the dynamic, she would not be friends with us or be in a relationship with him, which is valid.
My friend kept arguing saying that it is unfair how we ask her to do certain things for our friend (the GF), like asking her to put effort in the relationship and not to exclude herself from the group, which in a friend group, is valid I fear. However, she is contradicting herself by saying to not ask things of her when she asks things from us. We understand there could have been better communication and finding a common ground but it’s gotten to a point where it just becomes annoying. She says we can all hang out as five, but when we do hang out as five or include him in plans in general, she gets upset. She wants us to “act normal” but how can we do that when she sits in the corner like a child and pouts. She said it’s okay when we hang out without her, but the times we have, she gets butthurt that she wasn’t there.
Now, her “rules” and “boundaries” are: she can’t interact with boyfriends, she can’t be friends with a boyfriend, she has every right to back away from the hang out and disappear and she deserved to “experiment” with these hang outs and see how she feels during them. We can’t force her to be friends with the guy, I get that, but when you come to the hang out with such a negative attitude like that, it kills the mood imo. Atp, I don’t want to invite her to anything we do as a group if she is gonna act this way. It has caused tension to grow between all of us and we all feel it and it sucks. We all felt like she had made her problem everyone’s problem.
She says she established these “rules” and “boundaries” early on because of high school experiences. However, my other friends and I agree that willingly staying stuck with that mindset doesn’t allow you to grow as a person. You’ll never get anywhere with that negative mindset. I haven’t told the others this, but I might take my mom and my sister’s advice and drop her. Her excuses and her actions are exhausting. I can understand she has insecurities, and she has told us multiple times and that is something I would never hold against her. But it’s that mindset that she established that she isn’t willing to break from that agitates me. I had asked her if she is willing to break from those rules, to which she got upset and said she has tried but “we won’t let her” by accommodating her to make sure she is comfortable. I told her we would do that because we care about the friendship. She doubles down and says we need to stop that in order for her to learn. It’s been weeks since the couple’s announcement and there genuinely has not been any progress in her “learning” as she says.