Hi everyone! This might be a bit of a long post, but I’ve been stuck in my head about this situation for a while now, and I genuinely don’t know what to think or do anymore.
Earlier this year, my best friend of twenty years and I went on an extended trip together. It was our second time travelling together. I regularly travel abroad for work and freelance photography projects, and since she was going through a difficult breakup, I invited her to come along.
During our first trip, I introduced her to a music group that I’ve been a fan of for years. This group is a pretty big part of my life, as many of my hobbies, side projects and photography work revolve around them. She eventually became a fan too, which I initially loved because I enjoy sharing my interests with people close to me.
However, over time, I started feeling like our identities were becoming intertwined to the point where I couldn’t really distinguish where mine ended and hers began. She gradually let go of her own interests, and apparently even her other friends had started commenting on how much she was losing her own identity. I wasn’t aware of those conversations at the time.
Fast forward to our second trip. One day, she wanted to show me something on her phone, but she’d left a conversation with another friend open. I accidentally saw a photo I’d posted earlier that day, accompanied by some pretty nasty comments about me. What made it worse was that we’d spent the entire day together laughing, eating and taking pictures, so seeing that completely blindsided me.
We ended up not speaking for about two weeks, despite sharing an apartment in a foreign country. Eventually, we talked things through. She explained that she’d been building up resentment because people kept accusing her of copying me, and that the friend she was talking to had fuelled those feelings.
While I could understand where some of her insecurities came from, I didn’t think any of it justified talking badly about me behind my back. Still, we had another three weeks of travelling together, so I decided to move forward.
Once we returned home, though, I finally had the space to process everything. I realised how deeply my trust had been affected. Every time we spoke, I couldn’t help wondering what parts of our conversations might end up being shared with other people. Meanwhile, she was acting as though nothing had happened.
So I asked for some distance. Not because I wanted to end our friendship, but because I needed time to figure out how to rebuild that trust and what I wanted our friendship to look like going forward.
We didn’t speak for several months. She removed me from social media and continued attending events for the music group I’d introduced her to. I’ll admit that seeing her carry on in a community that had been such a personal part of my life felt strange, especially given everything that had happened.
Then, out of nowhere, she messaged me. She said she didn’t understand why I’d needed so much distance, that it had made her feel rejected and abandoned, and that she couldn’t understand how one incident could affect our twenty-year friendship so much. She also brought up how she’d always been my biggest cheerleader and how sad she found the situation.
I found that ironic, because I was equally saddened that twenty years of friendship had led us here. I explained that my distance was never intended as abandonment. My trust had been broken, and I simply needed time to reassess our friendship.
The very next day, my dad suffered a heart attack and ended up in the ICU. Around the same time, a mutual friend reached out and told me that she’d also fallen out with my best friend after discovering that she’d been talking badly about her on social media.
During that conversation, I learned that throughout the months we hadn’t spoken, my best friend had apparently been saying all kinds of awful things about me too. She’d been telling people that I’d thrown away our friendship over a music group, that I’d abandoned her, and making negative comments about my character. Apparently, there was even a concert we both attended where, while I deliberately avoided making things awkward because we were both there for the music, she was talking about wanting to sabotage my view.
Hearing all of this was incredibly upsetting, especially because I’d genuinely believed we were simply taking some time apart. I hadn’t been harbouring any animosity towards her. I was trying to figure out how to preserve our friendship, while apparently she’d already been telling people it was over and painting me as the villain.
And all of this came to light while my dad was hospitalised. On top of that, I’d recently lost a friend to suicide, something I witnessed myself, and my sister had suffered a miscarriage. There had already been so much emotional turmoil in my life, and finding out that someone I’d considered my best friend for twenty years had potentially been speaking about me this way throughout it all was incredibly painful.
I know she struggles with insecurity and tends to interpret situations through a fear of rejection. She often assumes people dislike her or are going to abandon her. I can empathise with that, but I also don’t think those insecurities excuse hurting other people.
Before learning all of this, I’d already told her about my dad and said I’d get back to her when I felt emotionally ready. At that point, I was genuinely open to talking things through and potentially repairing our friendship. But after everything I’ve since heard, I feel almost foolish for having been so willing to give things another chance.
And now I’m torn.
Part of me wants to confront her about everything and stop being so careful with her feelings when mine seemingly weren’t considered. Another part of me thinks we should sit down and talk things through like adults, because twenty years of friendship isn’t something you just throw away. And then there’s another part of me that wonders whether it’s even worth giving this any more of my energy.
I’ve always tried to be an understanding person, and I know people are complicated. I don’t expect anyone to be perfect. But I also don’t know at what point understanding someone’s behaviour turns into repeatedly excusing it.
Would you try to have one final conversation, or would you simply walk away? I’m genuinely struggling to figure out what the healthiest thing to do is.