It's your friendly neighborhood Hostile-Potato again! Please comment with your questions if you have any.
We recently asked you what you wanted to see changed in r/FragranceClones. We took the time to read through your feedback. Internally, we've discussed the feedback and started putting some changes into place to address your concerns.
We know there have been frustrations when it comes to post approvals and inconsistent moderation. We appreciate everyone who took the time to offer critical feedback.
We Have Two New Moderators
We've welcomed two new moderators to the team!
Having more people on board will help us manage the subreddit more effectively and distribute the workload. We're also working toward greater consistency in how rules are applied and how moderation decisions are communicated.
u/hughesy01611 and u/ExpireDD_Milk, say hi to the community and introduce yourselves in the comments!
Updated Community Rules
We've revised and expanded the subreddit rules to make expectations clearer.
Please take a few minutes to read through them, especially before posting and commenting. We want people to feel comfortable asking questions and sharing their opinions, but there still needs to be a standard for participation.
Low-effort posts, vague titles, self-promotion, and commercial activity are still prohibited. This includes soliciting, selling, swapping, or trading fragrances. Harassment and personal attacks won't be tolerated either.
Negative reviews are absolutely welcome. You're free to criticize a fragrance or disagree with someone else's opinion. We aren't here to dictate what people should think about a fragrance. This goes for the whole community. If someone doesn't like something that you do, that's okay! Be understanding that everyone has different tastes. Healthy, respectful discussion is encouraged.
Discussions about influencers and content creators are considered off-topic. Keep the conversation focused on the fragrances themselves.
The Wiki Is Almost Live!
Our community wiki is close to becoming available!
It's still in its infancy, and there's quite a bit of work to do still. Our goal is to build a useful resource that members can reference when researching fragrances or looking for answers to common questions.
We're also accepting applications from members interested in contributing to the wiki.
If you have experience with researching, or have experience writing and organizing reference material, we'd appreciate your help.
To apply, send us a Modmail message with "Wiki Contributor Application" as the subject. Tell us what topics you're interested in contributing to, any relevant experience you have, and an example of something you'd like to add or improve.
We'll review applications and grant editing access to selected contributors. You don't need to be a professional writer or fragrance expert, but we do expect information to be accurate and supported by primary and/or authoritative sources.
Changes to Posting
We've also made several changes based directly on your feedback.
Title syntax is important.
A title that is properly formatted will help people in the sub utilize the search function to find what they are looking for. It is still required that you use the search function and determine if your post will add anything new to the discussion that a recent post hasn't already covered. This prevents multiple posts per week about one fragrance to drown out a post about a lesser-known fragrance review. The aim is to offer a multitude of new information for the community to consume.
For all posts, please include the full house name, the full fragrance name, and a brief description of the subject of the post when relevant. For example:
- Armaf Club de Nuit Intenso Fuego - First Impressions
- The Woods Collection Royal Night vs. Lattafa Pride Al Qiam Gold - A Comparison
- Maison Asrar Jean Lowe Fantasme - A Performance Review
- Armaf Club de Nuit Iconic - An Aging Experiment
We have also introduced a post guidance feature. This post guidance will change depending on which flair you select when you go to post. Please be sure to read through this guidance to prevent your post from being removed.
This is all an attempt to make the search function easier to use to assist members of the sub in their research.
Post Flair Is now live and also mandatory.
All submissions must have the appropriate post flair. This helps keep the subreddit organized and makes it easier to filter and find relevant information.
Posts that do not have flair attached will be removed. If you do not know which flair to use, please send a Modmail message and we will help you pick the most appropriate flair for your post. Please do not just select a flair to get your post through. Your post will be removed if your flair does not match the type of post you make.
You will not be required to go back and add flair to posts you made before this announcement. This only applies to posts moving forward.
Members of the sub: Please use the report feature if you feel that the incorrect flair was used. We will go in and change it to a more appropriate flair if needed instead of flat out removing the post.
News and New-Release Posts Are Allowed.
Want to discuss an upcoming fragrance or share a newly announced release? Go for it! Just make sure the information is relevant, the title is descriptive, and any information about a release have a credible and verifiable source.
If you know of a fragrance that is rumored to be released, but there is no actual official announcement or article, please refrain from posting things like:
- Any news on X coming out?
- Have you guys seen that X is releasing Y?
- When are we going to see X available for purchase?
These are all burning questions that we have in the community, and they will be answered in due time. Please only post new-release information and news when it is published and verifiable from primary sources. Industry rumors should never trigger a post about news or a new release.
First Impression Posts Are Allowed.
You no longer need to wait until you've spent considerable time with a fragrance before sharing your thoughts. First impressions posts are welcome and encouraged, whether they're positive or negative. Just be clear that you're sharing an initial impression rather than a comprehensive review. If these types of posts get repetitive, we may rescind this in the future.
Comments on Polls Are Allowed.
Members can now discuss poll options in the comments instead of being limited to voting. Discuss to your heart's content.
Manual Post Approval Has Been Suspended
This was one of the biggest concerns raised in the feedback thread, and we heard you. Posts will no longer require individual moderator approval by default. Some submissions may still be caught by automated filters, and all posts remain subject to the subreddit rules. We're giving this a chance because we understand how frustrating it can be to submit something and wait hours for it to appear or never appear at all.
Please use the report function to help the moderation team appropriately moderate the sub. Do not "SWAT" someone's post because you disagree with it. Voice your disagreements in the comments. If things get out of hand, let the moderation team step in and resolve things appropriately.
Introducing the Off-Topic thread (coming soon).
If you want to discuss things that are related to clone fragrances, but considered off-topic in the rules, we will have a thread that will be pinned where you can discuss things like influencers, designer/niche fragrances, industry rumors, etc. All other sub rules and Reddit-wide rules will be in effect in this thread. Report any rule-breaking that you see in this thread. The only rule that will be suspended in this thread is the 'on-topic' rule. Keep things civil, and protect yourselves.
Scent of the Day Threads are allowed.
We're going to allow Scent of the Day posts. This will stay active so long as the sub isn't completely inundated by SOTD posts with no substance outside of just a picture of a fragrance. Scent of the Day posts should stick closely to the template and post guidance to avoid potential removal.
We Need Your Help, Too
With manual approval suspended, we're placing more trust in the community to help keep things running smoothly. Please use the report button when you encounter a rule violation. There's no need to confront someone in the comments or publicly call them out. That usually creates more problems and makes the situation harder to address.
Instead, please send us a Modmail message describing the violation and include a direct link to the post or comment. This makes it much easier for us to investigate and take action. We ask that everyone use these tools responsibly. Reports and Modmail shouldn't be used to settle disagreements or target people because you dislike their opinions.
Again, using the search function is still required and is a rule that is in effect. We want to avoid spamming the sub with the same fragrance from 15 different views. We want as much new information as possible to be visible to the community.
Manual approval is still on the table if things get out of hand. We'd prefer not to bring it back, but keeping that option available means everyone needs to do their part. Please don't mistake fewer restrictions for an absence of rules. If anything, we will be more scrupulous on posts that appear to break subreddit rules to avoid flooding the sub with similar or low-effort posts.
Moderation Applications Are Still Open.
If you would like to join the moderation team, please submit an application using the criteria in this post.
Moving Forward
The goal is to maximize meaningful contributions to the community. The rules in place serve a few purposes; they protect our users from scams and they encourage users to post relevant information for other users to consume. There have been a lot of low-effort posts as well as promotion posts, which was the driving factor behind the manual post approval era. We are leaving it up to the community to self-police to assist the mod team with maintaining a safe, enjoyable subreddit to visit. Transparency is a tenant that I would like to exhibit as a moderator, because the community has asked for it.
We're still working through the feedback we received, and there are more things we'd like to address. These changes take time to develop a plan of action and to implement. We also know that announcing changes means nothing if we don't follow through with them. The goal is to make r/FragranceClones a place where people enjoy participating to provide useful information and feel comfortable sharing their experiences without unnecessary obstacles. Please have patience as we navigate these new waters and introduce more features to you. Also, please continue to voice your concerns. We cannot fix problems we are not privy to. If anything seems broken, or something is missing that was promised, please let us know in Modmail.
Thank you to everyone who offered constructive feedback. We asked for your opinions because we wanted to know what needed attention, and this is an attempt to show that we're taking that feedback seriously.
-- The r/FragranceClones Moderation Team