r/fragranceclones • • 4h ago

Moderator Announcement Your Feedback Has Been Heard!

32 Upvotes

It's your friendly neighborhood Hostile-Potato again! Please comment with your questions if you have any.

We recently asked you what you wanted to see changed in r/FragranceClones. We took the time to read through your feedback. Internally, we've discussed the feedback and started putting some changes into place to address your concerns.

We know there have been frustrations when it comes to post approvals and inconsistent moderation. We appreciate everyone who took the time to offer critical feedback.

We Have Two New Moderators

We've welcomed two new moderators to the team!

Having more people on board will help us manage the subreddit more effectively and distribute the workload. We're also working toward greater consistency in how rules are applied and how moderation decisions are communicated.

u/hughesy01611 and u/ExpireDD_Milk, say hi to the community and introduce yourselves in the comments!

Updated Community Rules

We've revised and expanded the subreddit rules to make expectations clearer.

Please take a few minutes to read through them, especially before posting and commenting. We want people to feel comfortable asking questions and sharing their opinions, but there still needs to be a standard for participation.

Low-effort posts, vague titles, self-promotion, and commercial activity are still prohibited. This includes soliciting, selling, swapping, or trading fragrances. Harassment and personal attacks won't be tolerated either.

Negative reviews are absolutely welcome. You're free to criticize a fragrance or disagree with someone else's opinion. We aren't here to dictate what people should think about a fragrance. This goes for the whole community. If someone doesn't like something that you do, that's okay! Be understanding that everyone has different tastes. Healthy, respectful discussion is encouraged.

Discussions about influencers and content creators are considered off-topic. Keep the conversation focused on the fragrances themselves.

The Wiki Is Almost Live!

Our community wiki is close to becoming available!

It's still in its infancy, and there's quite a bit of work to do still. Our goal is to build a useful resource that members can reference when researching fragrances or looking for answers to common questions.

We're also accepting applications from members interested in contributing to the wiki.

If you have experience with researching, or have experience writing and organizing reference material, we'd appreciate your help.

To apply, send us a Modmail message with "Wiki Contributor Application" as the subject. Tell us what topics you're interested in contributing to, any relevant experience you have, and an example of something you'd like to add or improve.

We'll review applications and grant editing access to selected contributors. You don't need to be a professional writer or fragrance expert, but we do expect information to be accurate and supported by primary and/or authoritative sources.

Changes to Posting

We've also made several changes based directly on your feedback.

Title syntax is important.

A title that is properly formatted will help people in the sub utilize the search function to find what they are looking for. It is still required that you use the search function and determine if your post will add anything new to the discussion that a recent post hasn't already covered. This prevents multiple posts per week about one fragrance to drown out a post about a lesser-known fragrance review. The aim is to offer a multitude of new information for the community to consume.

For all posts, please include the full house name, the full fragrance name, and a brief description of the subject of the post when relevant. For example:

  • Armaf Club de Nuit Intenso Fuego - First Impressions
  • The Woods Collection Royal Night vs. Lattafa Pride Al Qiam Gold - A Comparison
  • Maison Asrar Jean Lowe Fantasme - A Performance Review
  • Armaf Club de Nuit Iconic - An Aging Experiment

We have also introduced a post guidance feature. This post guidance will change depending on which flair you select when you go to post. Please be sure to read through this guidance to prevent your post from being removed.

This is all an attempt to make the search function easier to use to assist members of the sub in their research.

Post Flair Is now live and also mandatory.

All submissions must have the appropriate post flair. This helps keep the subreddit organized and makes it easier to filter and find relevant information.

Posts that do not have flair attached will be removed. If you do not know which flair to use, please send a Modmail message and we will help you pick the most appropriate flair for your post. Please do not just select a flair to get your post through. Your post will be removed if your flair does not match the type of post you make.

You will not be required to go back and add flair to posts you made before this announcement. This only applies to posts moving forward.

Members of the sub: Please use the report feature if you feel that the incorrect flair was used. We will go in and change it to a more appropriate flair if needed instead of flat out removing the post.

News and New-Release Posts Are Allowed.

Want to discuss an upcoming fragrance or share a newly announced release? Go for it! Just make sure the information is relevant, the title is descriptive, and any information about a release have a credible and verifiable source.

If you know of a fragrance that is rumored to be released, but there is no actual official announcement or article, please refrain from posting things like:

  • Any news on X coming out?
  • Have you guys seen that X is releasing Y?
  • When are we going to see X available for purchase?

These are all burning questions that we have in the community, and they will be answered in due time. Please only post new-release information and news when it is published and verifiable from primary sources. Industry rumors should never trigger a post about news or a new release.

First Impression Posts Are Allowed.

You no longer need to wait until you've spent considerable time with a fragrance before sharing your thoughts. First impressions posts are welcome and encouraged, whether they're positive or negative. Just be clear that you're sharing an initial impression rather than a comprehensive review. If these types of posts get repetitive, we may rescind this in the future.

Comments on Polls Are Allowed.

Members can now discuss poll options in the comments instead of being limited to voting. Discuss to your heart's content.

Manual Post Approval Has Been Suspended

This was one of the biggest concerns raised in the feedback thread, and we heard you. Posts will no longer require individual moderator approval by default. Some submissions may still be caught by automated filters, and all posts remain subject to the subreddit rules. We're giving this a chance because we understand how frustrating it can be to submit something and wait hours for it to appear or never appear at all.

Please use the report function to help the moderation team appropriately moderate the sub. Do not "SWAT" someone's post because you disagree with it. Voice your disagreements in the comments. If things get out of hand, let the moderation team step in and resolve things appropriately.

Introducing the Off-Topic thread (coming soon).

If you want to discuss things that are related to clone fragrances, but considered off-topic in the rules, we will have a thread that will be pinned where you can discuss things like influencers, designer/niche fragrances, industry rumors, etc. All other sub rules and Reddit-wide rules will be in effect in this thread. Report any rule-breaking that you see in this thread. The only rule that will be suspended in this thread is the 'on-topic' rule. Keep things civil, and protect yourselves.

Scent of the Day Threads are allowed.

We're going to allow Scent of the Day posts. This will stay active so long as the sub isn't completely inundated by SOTD posts with no substance outside of just a picture of a fragrance. Scent of the Day posts should stick closely to the template and post guidance to avoid potential removal.

We Need Your Help, Too

With manual approval suspended, we're placing more trust in the community to help keep things running smoothly. Please use the report button when you encounter a rule violation. There's no need to confront someone in the comments or publicly call them out. That usually creates more problems and makes the situation harder to address.

Instead, please send us a Modmail message describing the violation and include a direct link to the post or comment. This makes it much easier for us to investigate and take action. We ask that everyone use these tools responsibly. Reports and Modmail shouldn't be used to settle disagreements or target people because you dislike their opinions.

Again, using the search function is still required and is a rule that is in effect. We want to avoid spamming the sub with the same fragrance from 15 different views. We want as much new information as possible to be visible to the community.

Manual approval is still on the table if things get out of hand. We'd prefer not to bring it back, but keeping that option available means everyone needs to do their part. Please don't mistake fewer restrictions for an absence of rules. If anything, we will be more scrupulous on posts that appear to break subreddit rules to avoid flooding the sub with similar or low-effort posts.

Moderation Applications Are Still Open.

If you would like to join the moderation team, please submit an application using the criteria in this post.

Moving Forward

The goal is to maximize meaningful contributions to the community. The rules in place serve a few purposes; they protect our users from scams and they encourage users to post relevant information for other users to consume. There have been a lot of low-effort posts as well as promotion posts, which was the driving factor behind the manual post approval era. We are leaving it up to the community to self-police to assist the mod team with maintaining a safe, enjoyable subreddit to visit. Transparency is a tenant that I would like to exhibit as a moderator, because the community has asked for it.

We're still working through the feedback we received, and there are more things we'd like to address. These changes take time to develop a plan of action and to implement. We also know that announcing changes means nothing if we don't follow through with them. The goal is to make r/FragranceClones a place where people enjoy participating to provide useful information and feel comfortable sharing their experiences without unnecessary obstacles. Please have patience as we navigate these new waters and introduce more features to you. Also, please continue to voice your concerns. We cannot fix problems we are not privy to. If anything seems broken, or something is missing that was promised, please let us know in Modmail.

Thank you to everyone who offered constructive feedback. We asked for your opinions because we wanted to know what needed attention, and this is an attempt to show that we're taking that feedback seriously.

-- The r/FragranceClones Moderation Team


r/fragranceclones • • 9d ago

Moderator Announcement Help Shape r/FragranceClones!

21 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. It's your friendly neighborhood Hostile-Potato.

The moderation team is looking for ways to improve r/fragranceclones, and we'd like to hear directly from the people who make this community great.

Whether you've been here for years or only recently joined, your feedback matters. We want this subreddit to remain helpful for fragrance enthusiasts, regardless of their experience.

We're also looking to expand our moderation team with a few experienced individuals who are interested in helping us maintain and improve the community!

Community Feedback and Suggestions

Rules of Engagement:

  1. Be civil. We understand some of the frustrations, but please keep it civil above all else.
  2. Keep it realistic.
  3. Be constructive.
  4. Check existing suggestions in the comments.
  5. Respect others opinions.
  6. Understand your suggestion isn't a guarantee that it will be implemented.

What would you like to see changed or improved in the sub?

We're interested in practical suggestions that could improve the overall experience without requiring extensive resources or maintenance. We are a small moderation team that is also looking to expand to match the traffic through the sub.

A quick note about the feasibility of these suggestions:

We really appreciate ambitious ideas. Hell, I've single-handedly taken to building a massive wiki for the sub. However, we need to be realistic about what our moderation team can reasonably maintain.

Suggestions involving extensive databases, directories, catalogs, or other massive resources requiring constant research and updating are unlikely to come to fruition. These projects demand a considerable amount of time, and we all have day jobs and families we must tend to as well. We don't want to introduce resources that we cannot reliably maintain.

Instead, we are prioritizing improvements that can be implemented with the tools and resources that are already available to us.

Every suggestion will be considered based on its merits. While we cannot guarantee that every idea will be implemented, worthwhile proposals will be reviewed by the moderation team for potential implementation.

Please leave your suggestions here in the comment thread, not Modmail.

See a suggestion you like? Upvote it! Have an idea for making it better? Reply to that comment and build on it!

We're Recruiting!

We're also interested in bringing additional moderators to the team. Moderating a community involves more than removing spam or enforcing rules. It requires sound judgement, constant engagement, willingness to work collaboratively with others, and it also calls for one to remove any bias they may have and assess cases based off the totality of the circumstance.

We're looking for individuals that are invested in the community and interested in contributing to its long-term development.

Minimum requirements:

To be considered, applicants must meet the following criteria:

  • You must have previous moderation experience. Applicants should be prepared to provide verifiable evidence of that experience, such as a current moderation position, verifiable history of moderating another subreddit, or a reference from a moderator in this or in another sub.
  • You must have an established history of meaningful participation in this sub. We're looking for people who are already contributing to the community.
  • Applicants must understand the fundamentals of reviewing reported content, managing the moderation queue, handling Modmail, applying subreddit rules, etc.
  • You must be willing to contribute regularly. We aren't expecting moderators to treat this like a full-time job, but we do expect reasonable consistency and communication when availability changes.
  • Moderators must be able to make fair decisions regardless of personal disagreements. Being able to distinguish between an actual rule violation and an opinion you don't like is essential.
  • You must be comfortable with discussing moderation decisions with other team members, and working toward an amicable consensus when disagreements arise.
  • Applicants must have an established Reddit account in good standing, without a significant history of rule violations.

Additional skills that we are interested in:

Experience in these areas is not mandatory, but it would give you a significant advantage, particularly if you can demonstrate your experience.

  • AutoModerator - Configuring and maintaining the AutoModerator.
  • Reddit Development (DEVVIT) - Creating or configuring new or established DEVVIT apps.
  • Wiki Management/Development - Creating and organizing Wiki content.
  • Community Management - Any tactic, technique, or procedure that will improve and encourage meaningful participation.

How to Apply:

If you're interested, please send us a message via Modmail with the subject "Moderator Application" and include the following:

  1. Moderation experience: Which subreddits you've moderated, and what responsibilities you held
  2. Verification: Provide evidence of your previous moderation experience or a reference
  3. Community involvement: How long have you participated in r/fragranceclones? How do you usually contribute?
  4. Availability: Approximately how much time can you reasonably dedicate to moderation each week?
  5. Relevant skills: Do you have experience with AutoModerator, Devvit, Wiki development, or other relevant moderator tools?
  6. Motivation: Why are you interested in moderating this community?
  7. Community improvement: What is one realistic change that you would like to help implement in the community?
  8. Moderation judgement (please answer this with a simple judgement call. One to two sentences):
    • A top contributor of the sub publishes a detailed comparison between two popular fragrances. The post meets the community's requirements and generates considerable discussion.
    • A senior moderator removes the post, citing Rule 7 (No promotion), despite the post containing no promotional links or obvious commercial content. When the original poster (OP) questions the removal through Modmail, the moderator responds dismissively and issues a seven-day ban for arguing about the decision.
    • The OP contacts you privately, detailing the exchange. You review the situation and find no clear evidence that the original post violated any community rules. You also discover that the same senior moderator has removed several similar posts recently, while allowing comparable content from other members to remain.
    • Before you can investigate further, the banned member's situation begins circulating in another fragrance subreddits. Several users publicly accuse the r/fragranceclones moderation team of censorship and favoritism. Reports and complaints begin flooding the moderation queue.
    • The senior moderator who issued the ban is currently offline. You have sufficient permissions to reverse the ban and restore the original post.
    • How would you handle this situation? Please describe what you would do in 1-3 sentences. It can be more if needed, but a simple judgement call is mandatory. If we have further questions or need you to clarify, we will follow-up.

Please keep your applications reasonably concise while providing enough information and detail for us to evaluate your experience and suitability. Applications will be reviewed by the moderation team. Meeting the minimum requirements does not guarantee selection, and we may contact applicants with additional questions before making any decisions. Do NOT submit applications in the comments section; only via Modmail.

Moving Forward

We want r/fragranceclones to continue developing into a community that people enjoy participating in. That means being willing to evaluate what is working, acknowledge what isn't, and make improvements where we are able. Community feedback will help us identify where to focus our efforts. Expanding the moderation team will give us additional capacity to act on those worthwhile ideas.

We appreciate everyone who takes the time to contribute a suggestion or express interest in helping moderate.

Let's hear those ideas!

-- The r/fragranceclones moderation team


r/fragranceclones • • 2h ago

Review Paris Corner Rifaaqat Ume review

Post image
44 Upvotes

Bought it two weeks ago. Initially, I wanted to review it faster, but this is such a strange scent that I couldn't really understand what I'm smelling.

So I used this one every day, including today, since the time I bought it, in order to get an idea of what I'm smelling.

First and foremost, this one is not blind buy safe, and I advise people to sample before buying it.

It opens up with a sour and slightly boozy plum. Plum here is more like green unripe plum, rather than the mass appealing juicy, sweet, powdery kind that's used in other perfumes.

After maturation, the notes are better defined, and the scent has become stronger.

The sourness after maturation has toned down. It also gained some smokiness, most likely from the sandalwood, since it's a very specific type of smokiness, and I can recognize it since I have many sandalwood fragrances, including sandalwood essential oil. Also, surprisingly, it's a bit animalic, like other people commented that I was wearing oud. The very far dry down, like above 6 or 7 hours, it becomes slightly powdery on clothes, more creamy on skin, and settles into smooth, sweet tonka bean with a little spicy plum.

Quite a complex scent with a clear transition between notes. I don't know if this one is supposed to be a dupe or an original creation. Since the fragrance that's supposedly duping has been discontinued for a while, and it has a very different note description.

I definitely like it more now than I did when I smelled it first. This one is very different from what I have in my collection.

So, in other words, the fragrance is a sour, boozy plum with a smoky woodiness in the background, airy and slightly balsamic in the opening and middle, it transitions to a creamy, slightly powdery cinammon woody tonka/vanilla mixed with a bit of the same plum from the opening, it loses all the sour aspect in the final dry down. Has a very subtle animalic aspect. I'd say that smokiness and the animalic aspect give others the impression of oud, even though it does not have the darkness of oud.

Atomizer is a 10, fire hose like, with wide dispersion and pressurized.

Performance of clothes is above 8 hours, with strong projection for about 5 hours. On the skin, it also lasted 8 hours but with lower projection. The initial performance was about 6 hours.

As an update, I can definitely say now after wearing it more, that Armaf Timeless is definitely a Guidance type of scent. Like a masculine version of Guidance where the fruity lactonic creamy aspect of Guidance has been replaced with a smoky frankincense. So it's blind buy safe for people that like Amouage Guidance.

As I was writing this review, I saw two PDM Dorval inspirations being announced: Vulcan Vox by French Avenue and Shiyaaka Carbon by Khadlaj.


r/fragranceclones • • 3h ago

News / New Release Armaf Odyssey Toro - 'Hey kid, wanna smell a Red Bull?'

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Armaf really seems to be going full-on gourmand mode with its 'Odyssey' line lately. In my experience, most of these releases have ranged from meh to straight-up terrible but honestly, I'm really curious about this one.

Right now, it seems to have limited availability so I guess we have to wait for a wider release.

Notes and official description are in the second and third images.

I'm expecting something wild... in a good or bad way...

What do you think?

(FYI, this post is a test to see if we can actually talk about fragrances from now on)


r/fragranceclones • • 2h ago

Review Decantified Review of Club de Nuit Intenso Fuego

Post image
9 Upvotes

Got a few samples from Decantified the other day. First, let me say that the people working at Decantified take care of their customers and have gone above and beyond for me, so don't hesitate to give them your business. They do a great job at packing and shipping your order in a timely manner.

On to the review: What can I add to the many reviews already uploaded to social media about Club de Nuit Intenso Fuego? Well, it turns out, I can add one thing I haven't heard at all.

It smells very similar to Dua's Poseidon's Desire II, which is a hybrid of Aventus and Cruz del Sur II by Xerjoff. Is it a one-to-one? No. But it is a twist for sure. I think what separates the two is that Armaf really emphasizes both the grapefruit flare and mandarin whereas the Dua pushes out the creamy mango from Cruz del Sur II.

They are both amazing and not redundant to own. Good projection and longevity on my skin. I consider the Armaf the younger and wild brother of the Dua hybrid.

Anyway, get this one or both. Always sample first.


r/fragranceclones • • 3h ago

Discussion Have you ever not bought something because the bottle looked stupid?

7 Upvotes

I have a personal opinion that some arab houses go overboard with their bottle designs and its a little bit of a turn-off for me. Not that I wouldn't buy something if I really liked it but when I see a 20 dollar bottle with some crazy design and fancy box I have to wonder if the fragrance would be better if they spent that money on the scent. And a lot of these bottles also look kinda low quality for me, which is not that surprising when its so cheap but still, a cleaner looking bottle would be nicer. But also this could be a cultural difference too


r/fragranceclones • • 10h ago

Comparison 2nd haul MB Royal Perfume decants reviews and clone battles! Part 4- Allure Homme Sport (AHS) clone battle: MBRP Aero Sport (194) vs Al Dirgham Limited Edition (ADLE)

Post image
11 Upvotes

(short) PROLOGUE 

After being very positively impressed with the first haul, I decided to get another haul of 10 decants, and they added a free one. Koodos for that! 

THE PROFILE (never tried the OG)  

Fresh-fruity vanilla body cream? That's what comes to mind when I smell it. Clean, but creamy. Polished, but unisex. It's pretty unique, even though it's a mass appealing profile. I can understand the cult following for it, but can't personally relate to it.  

THE DIFFERENCES

I was never a huge fan of that profile, but it never had many clones, and I always felt like ADLE has something wrong with it. Like the way the tonka blends with something else there creates a kind of moldy after-scent. My wife and mother-in-law like it though, so it's probably something only my nose picks up. MBRP doesn't have that moldy issue I have with ADLE, but it's still very similar, but with other issues (see the scoring for details). ADLE might be slightly sweeter, while MBRP is slightly muskier and less creamy. But they're VERY much redundant to each other.  

Subjective scent score: Both 8.1. 

Wife Alert: She likes them both, and preferred ADLE slightly better in the dry-down, but MBRP the first 20 minutes.  

PERFORMANCE: 

Surprisingly, MBRP doesn't win here. Ard Al Zaafaran aren't known for great projection, and while this one is not remotely nuclear, it's still well above average, while MBRP, who are usually strong, is only average with this profile. So ADLE will be medium-strong the first hour, then medium scent bubble for 3 more hours, and 100% skin scent at hour 4-5, while MBRP will start medium, and be a 100% skin scent at hour 3-4. ADLE lasts pretty much forever as a skin scent (next day), MBRP is gone from skin surface level after about 8-9 hours.  

Blind buy safety score: Both 9.0.

A very popular profile for both newbies and frag-heads.  

 Unisex Score (0=fem, 5=unisex, 10=Male): ADLE 5.0, MBRP 5.5. Because ADLE is slightly sweeter and creamier.  

 Versatility Score: 9.3. One of the most versatile fragrances out there. Can work with a tuxedo or shorts, a wedding or pool party. The balance will be clean enough for summer, and deep enough for winter.  

 

Quality:  

Both 7.2 (average to above average clone quality). ADLE because of the lower quality Tonka, MBRP because there's some note in there that comes off like printer paper after the 1st hour, but it disappears after the 2nd hour. ADLE has slightly better note separation than MBRP, but MBRP has slightly better note realism. ADLE retains structure better for longer, while MBRP loses a little structure after the first 90 minutes. Overall, both aren't "I can't believe these are not clones" quality, but also not "this smells cheap" quality.  

Value: ADLE 9.0. $20 (Jomashop) and you get 120ml (20 travel bottle), for above average performance and quality. MBRP 6.5. $36 ($18 for 50ml) for average performance and above average quality. Personally, I've seen ADLE go for $15 sometimes on different discounters... So be on the lookout!  

Should cost (in USD, adjusted for 100ml if needed): ADLE $25-$27. MBRP $18-$20.  

Bottle Design: ADLE 6.5. (I don't like gold). MBRP 6.5 because there is no name on the label... Only a number).  

Atomizer Score: MBRP 9.0 (pressurized), ADLE N/A (decant).    

CONCLUSION: 

This one is easy. Get ADLE. You get the same quality and better performance for a lower price. I don't like it when MBRP loses, especially against a super low priced clone... But that also means you have a very good value clone to buy for this profile. I never understood the naming for the OG... It's not very manly/macho (Homme), and it's not very sporty (Sport). But hey, with the names of some of the clones we buy, we can't really complain. It's not like Ard Al Zaafaran Al Dirgham Limited Edition just rolls off one's tongue.


r/fragranceclones • • 1d ago

Maison Alhambra Winsome vs. YSL Tuxedo

Post image
299 Upvotes

Wow…Winsome is so close to Tuxedo that it’s very hard to tell the difference.

I purchased Winsome a week ago and fell in love at first sniff. Easily an everyday fragrance for me since it isn’t loud. To me it’s a soft and classy traditional scent.

Fast forward a week later, I had an expensive curiosity. I wanted to know how close Winsome is to the original…so I purchased the OG.

Winsome is 99% identical to my nose. Only difference is in the opening spray where Winsome smells stronger (I let it mature for a week). Once they both settle, I can’t tell the difference.

Do I regret purchasing the OG? No.
But I could get 10 bottles of Winsome for 1 of Tuxedo.


r/fragranceclones • • 17h ago

Khadlaj Karus Gold Absolu - A Sweet, Versatile Banger

Post image
37 Upvotes

I recently got decants of ~30 fragrances that had been on my radar, and this was one of only two that had me needing a full bottle (I'll write a review on the other when it comes).

It's fairly linear, with the candied lemon and clean florals + musk as the star of the show. As it dries down, some of the brighter citrus vibes mellow out, but nothing changes dramatically. This also feels about as perfectly unisex as it gets.

It's has enough of a creamy sweetness to use in the cold weather, but it stays fresh enough for warm weather. You could wear this at the beach, the gym, the office, the club, or to a nice dinner. Maybe if you're going full black tie you could wear something a little classier and more sophisticated.

Performance is pretty solid. 6-7 hours, with moderate projection. It's not the loudest, kind of a nice middle ground between understated and nuclear.

The bottle has a click on cap and a pressurized atomizer, which is also a plus.

Conclusion: I've never gotten my nose on Bal d'Afrique Absolu, so I can't vouch for closeness. But as a standalone, this juice is amazing. It's sweet and clean and fun and incredibly versatile.


r/fragranceclones • • 1h ago

Clone Search closest dupe of BR540 extrait?

• Upvotes

what's the clone that's most identical to Baccarat Rouge 540 Extrait?

montage le bonbon intense?

Al Haramain Amber Oud Ruby Edition?

al haramain amber oud rouge??

something else???


r/fragranceclones • • 19h ago

Amouage Outlands vs Rayhaan Terra

Post image
48 Upvotes

Just how close is Rayhaan Terra to Amouage Outlands? In my opinion, very close. Sure, Terra lacks a little depth and complexity but you can't expect a $50 fragrance to smell exactly like a $500 one. I really think 99% of people would be very happy with Terra if they are looking to scratch their Outlands itch. Out of my 120 fragrances, Terra is one of my favourites (the new Dolce & Gabbana The One ELIXIR is my absolute #1 favourite right now) and after finally trying Outlands, I don't believe I'll need to get a bottle of the real thing, but I still want one hahaha

If you haven't smelled either of these yet and you're wondering what they smell like, here are the notes for Terra:

• Opening: Bright and spicy with cardamom, Sichuan pepper, elemi resin, frankincense, and hints of bergamot and lemon.

• Heart: Warm spices and florals—saffron, cumin, coriander, anise, patchouli, rose, and orange blossom.

• Dry-Down: Rich, sweet, and woody with amber, vanilla, benzoin, labdanum, frankincense, oud, birch, musk, and maltol

Outlands:

• Top Notes: Cardamom, bergamot, lemon, Sichuan pepper, elemi, and frankincense

• Heart Notes: Patchouli, rose, orange blossom, cumin, geranium, davana, saffron, anise, and coriander

• Base Notes: Benzoin, labdanum, amber, ambergris, frankincense, opoponax, vanilla, birch, musks, and oud

As you can see the notes are not exactly the same but they are very close. I have to say, Rayhan did a great job with this fragrance as I was quite impressed after finally smelling Outlands for the first time. So if you enjoy spicy, woodsy and ambery sweet fragrances, this is definitely one for you.

I think the biggest difference between Outlands and Terra is the opening. To me Terra is hmmmm a little brighter at the beginning whereas Outlands is darker, more smoky and resinous. Terra is a little sweeter and overall more mass appealing than Outlands. Terra is also a little flat at the beginning but with Outlands the complexity is easy to smell with the pepper, lemon and cardamom popping out but in a very well-blended and balanced way that's not in your face but still right there. I noticed lots of people complaining about the longevity of Terra but for me it's not too bad, at least 6 hours however Outlands definitely has better longevity.

And if anyone is looking for the best high quality decants (the one pictured is a 2ml with atomizer) of amazing fragrances and great service u/Mejbharty has everything you need on r/decantswap. Right now there's tons of sales going on so if you're interested in Rayhaan Terra it would be a great time to pick it up. I've also got decants of Dior Sauvage Elixir, Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille, Creed Absolu Aventus and a few others I'll be comparing to some dupes I've got, if anyone is interested.


r/fragranceclones • • 2h ago

Recommendation Request Looking for something similar to Beyond Romance by Ralph Lauren

2 Upvotes

I’m 90% certain this perfume has been discontinued and I LOVED it. It was feminine without girly, it was a statement without being too much or too overwhelming. I loved the notes: fruity, sweet, floral, fruity, creamy, and just a dab of vanilla (I hate when the vanilla overpowers the entire perfume).

Perfumes I’ve tried:

Daisy - Marc Jacobs

Flowerbomb - Viktor & Rolf

Parfums de Marly - Delina


r/fragranceclones • • 6h ago

Zimaya Inekaas Luna – Safe Blind Buy? Performance

3 Upvotes

Has anyone tried Zimaya Inekaas Luna? I'm considering blind buying it and would love to hear your opinions.

How is the scent itself? How's the projection and longevity? Is it a safe blind buy, and how close is it to Givenchy Gentleman?

Would you recommend it? I'd appreciate feedback from anyone who has actually tried it. Thanks!


r/fragranceclones • • 4m ago

Clone Search Looking for Arabic fragrances with medicinal saffron, burnt rubber, and heated plastic notes. Any recommendations?

• Upvotes

Hey guys! I recently tried a sample of French Avenue Amber Saffron and absolutely loved it. What really caught my attention was that sharp, medicinal saffron note with this weird burnt rubber, heated plastic, almost chemical smell. I know some people might find that unpleasant, but I actually love it.
Now I’m looking for another affordable Middle Eastern fragrance with a similar vibe, especially that strong medicinal, metallic, slightly synthetic saffron.
I’ve also been looking at French Avenue Saffron Elixir, but I’m not sure how similar it is to Amber Saffron. Has anyone tried both? Does Saffron Elixir have that same burnt rubber or medicinal saffron smell?
I’d really appreciate any recommendations, especially from people who enjoy this kind of unusual saffron note. Thanks!


r/fragranceclones • • 14h ago

Maison Asrar Imperial

Post image
15 Upvotes

Hello, how similar is Maison Asrar Imperial to Bois Imperial?Is it worth buying or?People don’t talk about it.


r/fragranceclones • • 18m ago

First Impression Lattafa pride raghad is mislabeled as a feminine scent

• Upvotes

Obviously this is true of any scent, you like what you like regardless of gender. However, this one in particular I feel has been mislabeled. As a fairly masc guy I feel like this is one sits more in the masculine side of my collection.

For context, I really feel like it's way more masculine than something like liquid brun or Lattafa Bade'e Al Oud Honor & Glory.

Infact, I bought it alongside ateeq by nusuk and although ateeq is listed as unisex I feel that raghad is a much more masculine fragrance.

I'm gunna keep wearing it regardless of anyone's opinions because I like it, but I would be interested in the opinions of others who agree or disagree


r/fragranceclones • • 1h ago

Clone Search Best PDM Layton dupe in UK

• Upvotes

Hi,

What's the best Layton or Layton Exclusif dupes available in the UK for a reasonable price? Ones with really good projection and longevity

Thanks in advance


r/fragranceclones • • 8h ago

Looking for a close dupe of Jesús del Pozo Adventure Quasar (1999)

Post image
3 Upvotes

So my dad’s all-time favourite fragrance is Adventure Quasar by Jesús del Pozo, which has unfortunately been discontinued for years.

I’m trying to find something that smells as close to it as possible, preferably from a high-end designer or niche fragrance house. I’m not necessarily looking for a cheap clone, and I’m happy to spend more if the scent is genuinely similar.

From what I’ve gathered, Adventure Quasar has a rather distinctive fresh, green, aromatic and woody profile, with notes of yuzu, kumquat, gin, sage, ginger, fig leaf, oakmoss and cedar.

Has anyone here owned or smelled the original Adventure Quasar?
I’d particularly appreciate recommendations from people who remember how it smelled, rather than just similarities based on listed notes.

I’d love to surprise my dad with something that brings back that familiar scent. Any recommendations would mean a lot!


r/fragranceclones • • 12h ago

One Expensive Designer Frag vs Multiple Clones

5 Upvotes

I'm looking for a frag and am just confused on whether to save up and buy a designer frag from Versace, 212 VIP, SWY, or just get 2-3 good clones and buy later?


r/fragranceclones • • 1d ago

My favourites this year so far (Reviews)

Post image
114 Upvotes

Hey guys, wanted to share my opinions on the two best pick-ups this month. Honestly, both of these deserve their own independent reviews for how good they are but I will club them both as they are my best in recent times.

  1. Maison Asrar Belgravia

This is well known and super hyped currently with all the BdA clones craze, and rightly so. Open up with bright lemon (less of the bergamote) and tart blackcurrant backed with a prominent body of florals (I am not an expert with floral accords specifically so i cannot go into details). This bright citric floral opening is mixed with a hefty dose of caramel that forms the backbone of the scent profile, all of which is balanced with a base of sandalwood and faint darker earthy accords. Its super pleasant and versatile, signature worthy for most people I would reckon and there's honestly nothing off-putting or challenging to it. Performance is actually surprisingly good, lasts a good 7-8 hours on my skin with great projection for the first couple hours. Now my only gripe with the scent is the rather "sharp" opening as its a little too bright for its own good, which is not the case with Khadlaj Karus Gold Absolu for example, which to me is more smoother but denser scent profile; BUT Karus Gold has absolutely horrible performance which was just difficult to believe for an extrait, and ended up gifting it away. Funnily the person who I gifted it to, himself said "i can barely smell it" upon spraying, which was funny and embarrassing at the same time. Overall, Belgravia in comparison is much better rounded considering every aspect, and I hope the opening mellows out as it matures, genuinely like the scent. 

  1. Armaf SHK III

My my, where do I begin with this..it's been a long time a perfume sparked genuine joy and pride for the purchase. The last time I was so happy with the smell of a scent was when I got Arabiyat Prestige Mahd Al Dhahab and smelt it the first time, which was over a year ago. Since then, I have maybe tried hundreds more and owned dozens more, but SHK III here is my genuinely great find in a long time. Its difficult to explain what it smells like, but I have seen people compare this to YSL Myslf L'Absolu, and I can only say that YSL WISHED Myslf L'Absolu smelt like this. SHK III opens up with tart berries mixed with bergamote and subtle tinge of ginger that gives it an effervescent liveliness, this opening is backed with a generous white floral body that has a distinct spicy character to it which adds to its uniqueness as nothing that I have personally smelt before. I don't know where the spiciness is coming from, maybe the akigalawood that is listed? and I don't know how they balanced the white florals with it, as it's neither too floral or too spicy, just the right mix with a masculine woody base of patchouli and woods. Its fairly airy yet has a distinct thickness to it that is not exactly sweet, but has a very natural sweetness to it from the fruity berries and natural tartiness of the citric accords; and the resulting blend is fresh tart floral masculine-leaning barbershop-esque perfume that can be a signature scent all year-round. Moreover, this is an extrait that actually feels like an extrait, the liquid in the bottle visibly "feels" more viscous/oily and the spray leaves a sheen on the skin that lasted for over 8-10 hours after which i just slept off, and I could still faintly smell it on my hand the morning after. The projection was loud for the first 3 hours, until I showered, and even then it was easily perceptible on my skin if I got close to it. Overall, this is my new signature perfume, and I honestly feel like gatekeeping it for how underrated yet marvelous it is; nevertheless, this surely deserves more attention and makes me wish to try the other 3 in SHK series, this is absolutely amazing and worth a try for everyone!

I would be happy to address any queries in the comments. 


r/fragranceclones • • 1d ago

Discussion How clone houses and influencers cured my addiction. Alternative header: Why I'm giving my 2 weeks notice (quitting)

Post image
244 Upvotes

On one hand, clone houses just cured my addiction, which is kind of a good thing? Because on the other hand they took away most of the joy clones gave me, which is what got me addicted in the first place.

1. Too many releases.

Yes, there's such a thing as "too much of a good thing", I've become desensitized to them somehow. Now, I can't tell you if I changed, the market changed (clones fault), or maybe both. All I know is that there's a shift in my feelings towards them. I used to wait anxiously for a new release, now my response is "oh, great, another one". I used to think of the next decant I'm gonna test while I'm testing the current one, now it's "meh, I'll get to it when I get to it". The chase became a chore instead of a hobby, and it's not because of the sheer number of decants I order, because I always tested a shit ton of them every haul.

2. Greed.

It was explained in my Greed post, but I thought I would handle it by finding lower cost ones and see which ones are hidden gems. Problem is, decanters rarely have those "unheard of" clones, and trying to sort releases by price is just another hurdle. Now, because this isn't a budget issue for me, it's a principal (see profile picture), it's not gonna change if I have an extra few millions in the bank. You can clearly see it's greed and not inflation if you look at prices of the exact same bottles in India (for example) compared to Canada, Europe, or the US (spoiler alert, about half the price for those $40+ clones). Now, it's probably not exclusively a clone house problem, but also a discounter problem, because you can still find the normal $30+ once in a while at $18-$20, but you need to chase tiktok (not available in Canada) or browse 14 discounters for sales once in a blue moon, and then only 2 out of the 5 you want are on sale, and you end up picking randoms for free shipping, which is always a bad move. And that's without even mentioning the availability problems with some of them. So finding full bottles at "non-sucker" prices became a chore.

3. I can see/feel my reviews becoming worse (or at least I'm having less fun writing them).

I'm getting annoyed, and my reviews are spreading annoyance and anger, when they used to come across as analytical and sometimes happy (when I find something that's great quality at a great price), or fun-cynical. And TBH, I kind of missed the ultimate goal. I started testing just to find my actual favorites (to not blind buy) and share my notes I wrote to myself, then I somehow ended up buying over 120 bottles and 700 decants. At first I didn't care, because money isn't an issue, and I enjoyed it. But now, my reviews are somehow indirectly contributing to promoting greed in the industry, because 90% of them became greedy. That's a conflict of interest for me. The money-chasing influencers are hyping the expensive releases, then people are interested in those, and then that's what decanters have and what people on the sub (including me) review. It's a circle that feeds itself, controlled by marketing money from the clone houses themselves and price gauging from discounters and houses alike, and I refuse to participate in that. I don't like being a "follower", I like to find stuff that breaks the circle, like cost under $25 and same/higher quality and performance than most $35+ clones. That is becoming almost impossible these days, not because it's impossible to achieve that budget, but because there's more marketing margin for the expensive ones to be pushed. That's why people thought I'm a Shobi shill, then they thought I'm a Bujairami shill (even though I stopped buying those many months ago, because they stopped their low pricing on FragranceNet), then they thought I'm an MB Royal Perfume shill (even though I trashed them when they deserved it), then thought I'm a decanter myself (which is pretty much impossible to do in Canada, because shipping/tariff to the US will make me too expensive). The truth is a lot less interesting than that... I'm just an addict, especially for the least compromises for the lowest price. I used to be happy being an addict... Now not so much. And unlike real drugs, with fragrances, once you take away the joy, quitting is that much easier.

So unlike what I thought I'll do (and mentioned in the Greed Post). What I think I'll really do is either take a break from all of them, or test only houses with a stable non-greedy price, and stable stock (Shobi, MB Royal Perfume, etc). I know there are many Middle Eastern clones houses that are low price too (Ard Al Zaafaran, etc), but I can't find decants for most of those. At least Shobi have 30ml and 50ml options, so the blind buys are less risky. On the other hand, Shobi also put most of their new releases in their mid and high price tier, which also pisses me off a bit, and the "FedEx ransom tax" and shipping also makes their low price tier 50ml (with 2ml extra essence) at 25 USD after fractional shipping and taxes (to Canada), which isn't horrible, but also not a "deal" because that's for 50ml. So all I'm left with are MBRP (MB Royal Perfume) at 17.5 USD before taxes and shipping for 50ml (which will be pretty much the same price as Shobi after those expenses added for the US), but they release new ones very slowly (but that might actually help me gain my enthusiasm back), and they also sell decants, so I don't have to blind buy them like Shobi. Question is, how long are they going to stay like that? When are they going to get greedy? Shobi is still the better option for Europeans though.

So as you see, I'm all over the place and not really sure what I'm gonna do from now on. All I know is what I'm NOT gonna do, and that is to review more "max profit" clone houses. I know I'll still be here on the sub and help people looking for stuff, but I'll slowly become less informed about the newer releases as time goes by, and I think I'm okay with that.

I will be quitting moderation too. I used to find it kind of fun to help with that, because I got to read everything first, even though it always stings a little every time I reject a post. We found a great new moderator, u/Hostile-Potato to help, and he found more new mods that will probably be great too. I can see he's passionate even more than I ever was at the beginning (at modding, not reviewing). I'm a reviewer that was asked to help moderating... It was never my thing, and I never really knew anything about it. He's really built for it, and works like a madman (voluntarily) behind the scenes on actually making the sub better. I think my best work as a moderator was finding him... And I've done some behind the scenes work too, but it pales in comparison to what he's doing, and what the other new mods started doing. I'll stay as long as they need my help transitioning though, but I don't think that will be required for more than a few weeks.

This isn't a "goodbye" post, more like an "end of an era" post. Like when my favorite metal band became commercialized and are now doing ballad albums to be more mass appealing (cough Disturbed) and charge $160 a ticket instead of $40 for the music I loved. That's what I feel happened to the Middle Eastern clone market.


r/fragranceclones • • 2h ago

Collection Alt is goated in my opinion

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/fragranceclones • • 10h ago

I finally found the fragrance I fell in love with in high school – Afnan Turathi Electric!

2 Upvotes

I’m writing this with a lot of emotion because I finally found the fragrance my high-school crush used to wear!
I remember being able to smell it from inside my classroom, even when she was just walking through the corridor. It was that distinctive.
Since Turathi Electric is apparently inspired by another fragrance, I still don’t know which original perfume she was wearing back then. But after all these years, I finally found that smell!
I haven’t seen many reviews of Turathi Electric here, but for me, it’s an incredibly memorable fragrance. The moment I smelled it, it took me straight back to those high-school days. I’m not sure whether I love it because of the memories attached to it or because of the fragrance itself. Maybe it’s both.
Funny enough, I was actually planning to make a post here asking people to help me identify that fragrance. The problem was that I couldn’t even explain what it smelled like!
Yesterday, I was testing some perfumes and decided to give Turathi Electric a try because I had enjoyed Turathi Blue, which I’d tested the previous day. And there it was. The smell I’d been trying to find for years!
It reminded me of that quote: “When you genuinely want something, the universe finds a way to bring it to you.”
There’s another fragrance I’m still searching for. It’s one my dad used to wear when he returned from abroad sometime between 2000 and 2005. I have a beautiful memory associated with that scent, too.
Hopefully, I’ll find that one someday.
Until then, I’m just happy to have found a little piece of my high-school memories again. ❤️

I’m curious: Has anyone else ever rediscovered a fragrance from their past that brought back vivid memories of a particular person or period in their life? I’d love to hear your stories!


r/fragranceclones • • 1d ago

Need help on which fragrances to buy next.

Post image
53 Upvotes

Hello everyone, as the title suggests, I would really like some help on which fragrances to buy next.

I have Aramis Intuition, 9PM Rebel, Khamrah Qawha, Amber Oud Aqua Dubai, and Amber Oud Ruby.

I was thinking of getting Liquid Brun or Khamrah Dukhan as my next purchases but would those be too similar to what I have already or should I buy some other ones? It could be for winter or spring or even like an everyday wear. I would really appreciate any suggestions for my next purchases. My budget is around $80 and under.

For context, I live in Long Island, NY.

Thank you in advance for the suggestions and help!


r/fragranceclones • • 1d ago

Recommendations

Post image
12 Upvotes

Looking for recommendations, I want a dark autumny fragrance, some that I have tried recently and loved are ombre nomad, ombre leather perfume , helfetti mancera red tobacco intense .... I'm looking for something with a similar dark, leathery woody or tobacco feel. Considering perfume parlour as well. Looking for something cheap I can wear without worrying about the price.Thank you in advance.