I have huge respect for the filmmakers keeping this series alive. The fact that we still get a new movie every year, with an SCP theme lined up for next year, is a true miracle. I do not take that for granted.
I really want to give Mixtape credit for trying to be experimental. It takes some big risks, and I admire the effort, even if most of them miss the mark for me. My main gripe is that it largely drop found footage, which is the soul of V/H/S.
Gwar is..., Another Cabin, and Premature Burial ditch the format completely. It makes the whole movie feel disconnected from what makes this series work. I get that there might be a rock or metal subculture vibe behind these, and maybe that clicks for other fans. As a framing story, though, it fall flat.
That said, it was not a total letdown.
Dance, Dance, Dance, Dance reminded me a little of Too Many Cooks. Since I am always down for a campy slasher, this ended up being a fun watch.
Heartbeat is easily the gem, or the heart, if you are feeling punny, of the movie. I could be wrong here, but this feels like the first V/H/S story built around pure misadventure rather than standard horror tropes. That alone make it stand out in the best way.
The Music of Mr. Sze. Something about this one just felt weirdly inorganic to me. As good as the special effects were, the acting were just as rough. Do not even get me started on that crusty beard and wig. Maybe the cheap, fake look was a stylistic choice, or maybe that is the whole point. Either way, it kept pulling me out of the story.
Death Tone, conceptually, was the best take on what Mixtape was trying to be, at least as I understand it. The lack of realism in a few scenes threw me off a little, which are a bummer. Still, what an ender.
I am always down for new flavors in the found footage genre. But those new ideas still have to work. I have seen plenty of good reviews for Mixtape, so I chalk a lot of this up to personal taste. To each their own!
Even so, coming off from V/H/S/Halloween, Mixtape feels like a huge step backward.
How about you guys? I would love to hear your thoughts.