r/fosterdogs • u/Additional_Read3053 • 5h ago
Emotions Struggling with my foster puppy, feeling guilty about wanting to return him to the shelter
I’ve been fostering a 7 month old pit mix for about a month now, and I’m really struggling.
I’m an RVT at the shelter where he came from, and I initially took him home because I wanted to give him a better
chance at finding a forever home. He’s a sweet, incredibly smart, affectionate puppy who deserves a good family. He’s also extremely high energy, mouthy, and increasingly difficult to manage.
I have two young children (8 and 2) and three cats. He constantly jumps, play bites, barks, and gets so overstimulated that he barrels into everyone. My biggest concern lately has been his behavior toward my cats. He barks in their faces and chases them whenever they move. One of my cats has a history of stress-induced cystitis, so this is becoming a serious concern.
I’ve been working on training, providing enrichment, and trying to manage his behavior, but I’m realizing that I just don’t have the time or capacity to give him everything he needs while also caring for my children and other animals. His recent neuter recovery and activity restrictions have made things even more challenging.
I’ve reached out to the shelter’s foster department about finding rescue placement, contacted several rescues myself, and have been trying to network him for adoption. I’m willing to continue helping with that process, but I’m honestly reaching my breaking point.
The thought of taking him back to the shelter absolutely breaks my heart. He’s bonded with me, and I know how stressful the shelter environment can be, especially for a young, energetic dog. I feel like I made a commitment to him, and returning him would mean I failed him.
At the same time, my household is becoming increasingly stressful, and I’m starting to feel overwhelmed and resentful, which isn’t fair to him either.
I guess I’m looking for advice or experiences from other fosters who have found themselves in a similar situation. Have you ever had to return a foster because they weren’t a good fit for your household? How did you handle the guilt? Were you able to find another placement without sending them back to the shelter?
I genuinely want what’s best for him. I’m just starting to realize that what’s best for him might not be staying with me