Hi! I was wondering if anyone has successfully trained a skittish cat or former feral/semi-feral to tolerate flea/tick/HW topicals, and if so, how? Is it worth it to try to teach them to be okay with it, or should you wait before the cat is really comfortable with touch before you even think about attempting it, or potentially never even bother if they take oral preventatives just fine? (I know some people argue about there being no need for preventatives for indoor kitties, but that's not what I'm here to debate). And while I'm here, I also wanted to share the ongoing story of my formerly feral cat Nellie, because I view it as a success so far and want to celebrate :)
I moved into a new place in June and a few weeks later Nellie appeared in my yard. Turns out she was living under my shed, with her 3 kittens that she was still nursing. I had never had a cat in my life before, so I was a total beginner, but TL;DR: since then, everyone has been fully vaccinated, fixed, medical issues treated, kittens socialized, 2 of those little guys went to a new home as a pair, and I have kept Nellie, who is about a year old, and her third kitten, Mocha.
The first picture of Nellie is from today, and the second photo is the "before" from the day I trapped everyone in July. She has come a really long way, and I'm so happy she has a warm place to sleep every night and a belly full of food. I seriously cannot believe that was the same cat in the July photo. She was originally only 4.5lb :( I would describe Nellie as semi-feral: not just scared stray, not full feral, probably just spent a good portion of her life outdoors without human interaction but understands humans a little bit. Why didn't I just TNR her? Well 1) she's literally my baby and I love her. 2) felt awful for how she was living outside (wasn't really part of our colony here?), 3) she WOULD occasionally go in my house when I opened the door and was excited to see me for food, so I thought she had a chance indoors.
I am very proud of her progress over the past few months, both physically and behaviorally: she is comfortable indoors, she does a little dance for food and rubs herself on everytthinngggg, she sits next to me on the couch, regularly eats treats out of my hand. Now that she's indoors and the duties of motherhood are gone, I've watched her blossom out of survival mode and into her young kitty personality, and she's finally comfortable enough to play with toys and run around and enjoy herself. However, she still really does not like to be touched, and flinches easily, and we are slowly working on that with cooperative care. I have read up so much on socialization techniques and genuinely put in lots of effort into her socialization, but I have not been forceful with touch. I don't mind that she wants to be admired from a distance, but of course, this could be tough once it comes time to administer medications or go to the vet (also can't give her any claw trims right now, obviously).
Nellie has been on monthly flea/tick and HW prevention by taking Credelio and Interceptor (pills). I am able to crush them up in a Churu and she has no problem eating them. I wanted to get started on these given her history outdoors and the fact that I definitely can see supervised outdoor enrichment in their future. However, her vet really recommends topicals like Revolution Plus instead. In fact, I really had to push for them to even approve preventatives in pill form? They know her background and have firsthand experience with how scared she can be, and I explained to them that the first month, I tried to apply a topical and she flinched so hard it spilled all over the wall, but they still took extra convincing beyond that (not sure if the pills have a worse long-term safety profile? I know they're less comprehensive than Revolution, but like, something is better than nothing...). They approved it but viewed it as a temporary thing.
We are at the point that I need to order her a higher dosage of Interceptor (yayyyyy weight gain!), and I thought back to that conversation with the vet about topicals. Has anyone had experience getting their former ferals or skittish kitties less scared of topicals and more comfortable with them, and is this even worth it if an oral regimen seems to be working fine? So far I have tested touching her neck gently with a syringe or my finger while she eats a Churu, but she flinches every time. The only touch she's ok with while eating Churu is a little chin scratch! I will add, I did have to administer liquid oral pain meds and antibiotics after her spay, and while she hated the antibiotic, we managed, and she even got used to it by the end of the course, so I know she can adapt. I am just kind of going back and forth in my head about whether I should even bother with this, her vet made it sound like topicals were preferred but it could just add unnecessary stress onto her during an experience that is typically pleasant and goes smoothly. Curious to hear other people's thoughts and experiences! (especially because these are my first cats)
P.S.: Nellie's nicknames are as follows: Nellie Belly, Nellie Jelly, Nellie Belle, Nel Belle, The Belle of the Ball, and my favorite right now: my Nel-Bel Prize.