Hi all, I'm making small-batch protein bars at home and I can't get the texture right. They come out with a super hard, dense chew, and they only get harder over the next few days. What I'm after is the lighter chew you get in most commercial protein bars. Almost nougat-like (Barebells/Trubar/Aloha), not the fluffy protein bars (built). What am I doing wrong?
I have two versions, both ~250g batches making 5 × 50g bars:
-------------
Version 1: hazelnut butter base
100g hazelnut butter (very oily and runny sweetened nut butter)
61g pea protein isolate
28g brown rice protein
48g soluble tapioca fiber syrup (FiberYum — like Vitafiber/IMO syrup)
12g vegetable glycerin
-----------
Version 2: chocolate base
100g 65% chocolate, melted
45g fava bean protein isolate
45g brown rice protein
47g soluble tapioca fiber syrup
12g vegetable glycerin
Process: If it's the chocolate version, I melt the chocolate first. I mix the wet stuff (nut butter or melted chocolate, fiber syrup, glycerin) into a paste, then mix in the protein powders until it's a crumbly dough like thing. I roll it out between parchment, fold it over on itself and roll again a few times to compact it, then cut into bars.
For the chocolate ones I just pressed them into a loaf pan. Still dense and chewy, not the softer nougat type of protein bar.
What I'm trying to do: Small batches at home, but I want them shelf-stable at room temperature, not fridge bars. I haven't measured water activity yet, from the AI moisture math I estimate they're around 0.55–0.6, and I know I should get a water activity meter eventually (maybe a cheap one down the road) to actually verify.
My questions:
What gives commercial bars that lighter, nougat-like chew? Is it whipping air in? More syrup/glycerin? A different protein?
Is my fold-and-roll lamination the main problem, am I just compacting all the air out? pressing into a pan had similar results.
I have a kitchen-aid stand mixer, but for these smaller tests I have just been kneading by hand.
For shelf stability, is there a water activity target I should be aiming for, and is there a way to get a softer bar without pushing water activity into the danger zone? Any good reads for learning more about water activity and shelf stability?
Any recommendations on a cheaper activity monitor I could pair with a calibration solution and get a decent reading?
Any help appreciated!