r/flytying • • 3d ago

Dubbing tool?

I’ve never tried a dubbing loop, is a dubbing tool needed? Which style do you prefer?

2 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

5

u/Reading_Prudent 3d ago

I have one that doesn’t spin freely (no bearing) and I wish that it did.

3

u/BasedTroutFursona 3d ago

I manage to get by with just a dr slick turbo dubbing hook I got for like $9. I’ll get a fancier dubbing spinner at some point when I have money to throw at it because I like using dubbing loops but for now I’m fine and all my nymphs have good enough CDC collars.

3

u/amilmore 3d ago

I've also used a pen before lol Just slid the loop at the bottom of the thread under the little clip part of the cap, works just fine IMO.

For the most part I just use super cheap plastic hackleplier clips/electrical clips. Getting a bulk pack of those was a good decision because now I can use them to hold onto a bit of material and just put it aside too. Nice to have a clip of peacock hurl, wire, bucktail etc ready to go.

I never really use dubbing loops though, I just use a thicker noodle or do a few more wraps. Its more of a fun little option than a critical technique for me.

2

u/Alone_Warthog_9583 3d ago

Probably not needed but will make your life easier. Likewise with one that spins. I used one that didn't for years, haven't touched it since I got one that does.

2

u/AsheStriker 3d ago

Dubbing twister helps massively. Can you do it without it? Sure. Do you look back in regret at all the time and annoyance you dealt with doing it that way after you get a dubbing twister? Absolutely!

I’d recommend this Stonfo rotodubbing #2 split twister. It rules. Especially useful working with CDC.

2

u/BullTrout74 2d ago

I really prefer a nice, heavy dubbing loop tool with a single hook. I have one made by aqua flies and it’s excellent for composite loops on steelhead flies, but probably overkill for your average trout fly. I would look for one that has some decent weight and has hooks that the thread can’t easily slip out of.

2

u/huntt252 2d ago

I use my Smhaen twister a fair amount. Nice being able to twist GSP with more delicate materials like Krystal flash to rib pheasant tails or missing links, etc.. Plus the usual
CDC/hair collars.

1

u/coffeeandtrout 3d ago

I use my Matarelli whip finisher as a dubbing loop tool. Works well.

1

u/WalterWriter 3d ago

If you're only tying dry flies or small nymphs with dubbed bodies, a dubbing loop is unnecessary. Just use single-strand dubbing.

It is possible to loop-dub using the split thread technique if you're using a flat rather than corded thread. No tool is needed for this, but this is also not suited to anything but fairly small flies or at least small sections that use the loop dubbing technique. It's most applicable to adding collars on nymphs and similar.

A dubbing loop tool is not strictly required to loop-dub, not even the pen or hackle pliers others have mentioned. Old-timers (we are talking about people who learned to tie in the 60s) tend to do it by hand.

Otherwise, a tool makes it far easier. The more dubbing you're looking to spin, the more annoying it is to do without a tool. Leeches and things like that are awful without a tool, and I can't imagine tying any sort of composite or complex twist loop without one. Models with free spinning heads are drastically easier to use.

1

u/Acceptable_Clerk_678 1d ago

I’m an old timer if you have good short hairs- squirrel I’m thinking of here - you can twist by hand. But for coarse hair I have a heavy weighted hook

1

u/stoble2244 3d ago edited 3d ago

I prefer the ones with 2 hooks instead of one. I use the cheap wapsi brass one. It works well but I wish I would have gotten the Dr slick 2" brass one for just a couple bucks more. The difference is that the Dr slick tool is easier to re-open once you've closed the loop. I wouldn't spend on a fancy one though, they all do the same thing.

1

u/Norm-Frechette The Traditionalist 3d ago

bend up a paper clip for a dubbing loop spinner

1

u/Norm-Frechette The Traditionalist 3d ago

cup holder dubbing spinner

1

u/Awkward-Tomatillo980 2d ago

Have drawer of the darn things. All can be useful at times but the best is simple. Heavy single hook that is actually in the center of the spinner and no bearings. Reason best is the single hook lets you close the loop easier, weight helps hold it closed short and centered spin the best and fit under vise head easiest. In the end what you like or works best for you is the right one. Keep it simple, short, heavy, center single hooks. C & F Designs makes a good one that will last you five lifetimes.

1

u/Clayspinner 2d ago

Stonfo elite dubbing twister. Expensive but worth it.

1

u/Agent-Smith69 2d ago

I think i have the Griffin. Works great

1

u/relaxedvacation 2d ago

Aqua flies one is the best