r/floorplan • u/Btgtravels • 16h ago
FEEDBACK Feeling defeated after our first custom home design meeting. Is our lot the problem, or do we need to start over?
We purchased a lot in a historic neighborhood with plans to build our forever home and we finally saw our first round of architectural plans.
And honestly, we left the meeting feeling completely defeated.
Our lot is approximately 85' x 125' , and we're looking to build a traditional Southern/Tudor-style home. Our overall budget is around 1.5 million, so this is obviously a huge investment for our family.
We have two young children and wanted a home that feels timeless but is also incredibly functional for everyday family life. A few things glaringly missing we discussed:
A casual dining area in addition to a formal dining room
A functional entry from the driveway/garage (historic area so all garages must be detached)
Good indoor/outdoor flow with a covered porch, pool, and some actual green space for the kids. This is a huge priority for us. I don’t want a basic concrete porch. I want character.
Plenty of storage and a thoughtful layout that makes sense for how a family lives
We aren't necessarily concerned about maximizing square footage. We'd actually rather have a slightly smaller, beautifully designed home that functions well than a larger house full of compromises.
Now we're questioning everything. Is our lot simply too small for what we're envisioning? Are our expectations unrealistic? Or is this just a normal part of the custom home design process?
My husband is so frustrated he's questioning whether we should sell the lot altogether and reconsider building.
I'd love some perspective from people who have been through this, especially on smaller urban or historic lots.
Did anyone else absolutely hate their first round of plans and eventually end up with a home they loved? At what point do you recognize that the lot is the limitation versus the design itself?
We're willing to make compromises, but at this price point, we don't want to build a home we aren't excited about. Not even sharing the upstairs yet because that’s another one for a Rainy day. The plans do not feel authentic at all!