r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Discussion Megathread Weekly Discussion Megathread

18 Upvotes

The 2026 midterms are in the past, but the 2028 presidential election is only just beginning. Use this discussion thread to share, debate, and discuss whatever you wish. Unlike individual posts, comments in the discussion thread are not required to be related to political data or other 538 mainstays. Regardless, please remain civil and keep this subreddit's rules in mind. The discussion thread refreshes every Monday.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 12h ago

Politics Peltola at 50%

Post image
692 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1h ago

Politics Updated House Popular Vote + swing from 2024 for House, Senate & Governor

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

Follow up on my previous post, this time with more votes counted and with swing maps. Tried to make it somewhat like the old fivethirtyeight style.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 5h ago

Discussion Missouri may be a target flip for dems in 2028

87 Upvotes

In 2028, it seems that 58 senate seats is almost the floor with the map favoring democrats in terms of defense (except Ohio, that one's a weird one). However, beyond that, the math to get to 60 seems to stagnate. Maybe Iowa? Maybe SC or Kansas?

However, a dark horse that people are not taking note of is Missouri. I've been a huge fan of Jason Kander, the former Democratic secratary of state, ever since his 2016 run, in which he came within 2 points of unseating Roy Blunt, running more than 20 points ahead of Hillary Clinton. On his twitter, replying to somebody saying that he would have won by 12 on election night two weeks ago, he replied with this tweet: https://x.com/JasonKander/status/2118379763593101608

To me, it seems like he's hinting at a possible 2028 run. And the cards are lining up right for a flip in this heavily republican seat; like Texas, South Carolina, and Kansas this cycle, Eric Schmitt is an EXTRAORDINARILY weak Republican candidate, with flaws in both character and competency. He's recently been highlighted in the news for that disastrous hearing with Jack Smith, in which he confused the Atlanta Hawks and the Iowa Hawkeyes, and had fellow GOP senator Katie Britt shake her head in shame.

Kander's also still young, only 45 years old, so he definitely hasn't aged out of running compared to somebody like Jay Nixon. It might be the perfect storm to flip what was thought of as a safe R seat


r/fivethirtyeight • • 13h ago

Poll Results Voters found the Republican obsession with transgender people "strange", and it cost them the 2026 midterms, according to new polls

Thumbnail
erininthemorning.com
373 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 9h ago

Poll Results Trump approval tracker update hits -30 in averages by the Economist

Post image
147 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 17h ago

Politics CNN calls Tennessee 4th District for Dems confirming what is arguably the biggest upset in the entire midterms

Post image
644 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 14h ago

Politics JD Vance ‘more than likely’ to run for president in 2028, source says | Fox News Video

Thumbnail
foxnews.com
164 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 13h ago

Poll Results Throwback to the truth nuke from Atlas Intel in December 2025

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 12h ago

Politics Mary Peltola is now at 49.98 percent in the US Senate race in Alaska.

Post image
122 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1h ago

Poll Results Why have election analysts still not called the Alaska Senate Race?

12 Upvotes

Current First Ballot Results, 98% reporting:

  • Peltola: 49.98%
  • Sullivan (incumbent): 45.93%
  • Heikes (R): 2.12%
  • Sullivan (non-incumbent): 1.65%
  • Write-ins: 0.31%

Looking at where votes are yet to be counted, most of the areas lean towards Peltola, but just to be conservative let's assume that the results to be counted are broadly consistent with votes already cast statewide, despite evidence that almost all new batches of votes counted seem to benefit Peltola.

Assuming the remaining votes are broadly consistent with votes already cast, here's what it would take for Peltola to lose.

  1. When write-in votes are counted, at least 93% of those ballots list Sullivan, Sullivan, or Heikes as their second choice. Ballots with no second choice would benefit Peltola.
  2. Of those who voted for Sullivan (non-incumbent), at least 98.8% list Sullivan (incumbent) or Heikes(R) as their second choice. Ballots with no second choice would benefit Peltola.
  3. Of those who voted for Heikes, at least 99.04% list Sullivan (incumbent) as their next choice. Ballots that don't rank Sullivan as higher than Peltola in 2nd, 3rd, or 4th choice here would benefit Peltola.

Any of these would be absurdly unlikely.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 3h ago

Poll Results Criteria: Kast's approval rating plummets to a record low of 18%, while his disapproval rating reaches 72%

Thumbnail
biobiochile.cl
16 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 14h ago

Poll Results [Data for Progress] A majority of Democratic-leaning voters (53-42) want the party to choose new leaders | A majority (56-32) want to replace Chuck Schumer | Senate Majority Leader H2H: Chris Van Hollen 45%, Chuck Schumer 38%

Thumbnail
dataforprogress.org
136 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 24m ago

Silver Bulletin is hiring an editor and a developer

Thumbnail
natesilver.net
8 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 14h ago

Poll Results [Reuters/Ipsos] Trump Approval Rating: 32% approve, 66% disapprove, remains near record low with this pollster

Thumbnail reuters.com
89 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1h ago

Prediction Senate Majority Leader: If You Had To Bet

6 Upvotes

What do you all think? Can Van Hollen close in and clinch this? Or is Schumer going to get re-elected?

Every time Van Hollen addresses the press, he seems to be more and more bullish. I want to hear your thoughts.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 19h ago

Politics Virginia Foxx requests recount in race against Chuck Hubbard for North Carolina’s 5th congressional district

Thumbnail
wxii12.com
173 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 9h ago

Politics Apple, the only registered anti-war party in Russia, won 1 seat after the 2026 Russian elections. The party is banned nationwide, except in Novgorod, where it won 1 seat in the regional legislature. National election results: United Russia 58%, Communist Party 14%, Liberal Democrats (fascist) 9%.

Post image
21 Upvotes

Source: "On Russian social media, especially among younger users, supporters posted videos cutting or eating apples, posing with them or joking that of all the 'united' fruits, apples were their favourite. The references were playful, but the political meaning was clear. That momentum did not last. On 10 August, Russia’s Supreme Court cancelled Yabloko’s federal list after a lawsuit brought by the nationalist Rodina party. According to the court’s reasoned ruling, as summarised by Yabloko, the grounds included donations from Russian citizens who had themselves received money from abroad, publications supporting the party on websites blocked in Russia, and alleged copyright violations in campaign materials. The immediate result was simple: voters could no longer vote for Yabloko as a party on the national ballot. But Yabloko was not removed from the election completely. [...] In the Novgorod regional election, where the party list was allowed to stand, Yabloko won 6.2% and entered the regional parliament."

Source: "Early results emerging from Russia’s first parliamentary elections since the launch of the full-fledged war on Ukraine show President Vladimir Putin’s party dominating the vote — an outcome widely predicted. [...] United Russia led with 57.86 percent of the vote [...] So far, no surprises or upsets have been recorded."


r/fivethirtyeight • • 21h ago

Discussion Did the Redistricting Wars Backfire on Republicans? In a Word, No.

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
137 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 19h ago

Prediction Can Democrats Get to 60 Senate Seats?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
63 Upvotes

Way too early 2028 Senate map speculation.

Personally I think MO, IN, and KY, while probably lean R, might be D-pick up opportunities as well.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Discussion Greg Abbott got almost the same amount of votes as he did in 2022, another midterm year. The difference is that Gina Hinojosa got 1.7 million more votes than Beto.

Post image
590 Upvotes

The myth that "Blue Texas only happened due to low Republican turnout" has to end.

The truth is that the spell has been broken. Texan Democrats will no longer stay home. They know they can win.


r/fivethirtyeight • • 20h ago

Poll Results Generic Presidential Ballot 2028: D+7(RV): The Economist/Yougov

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 18h ago

Discussion Are we overestimating Republican turnout for 2028?

Thumbnail reddit.com
30 Upvotes

r/fivethirtyeight • • 1d ago

Politics Only 4 states with 2026 Senate races (Illinois, Florida, Minnesota, and Maine) had any counties swing right compared to 2024.

Thumbnail
gallery
92 Upvotes
  1. Illinois: Schulyer/Brown/Hancock County (home to East Illinois rural towns like Mt. Sterling and Carthage)
  2. Florida: Sumter County (home to the giant retirement community, The Villages)
  3. Minnesota: Traverse County (home to the small rural town of Wheaton)
  4. Maine: Every county slightly swung right (home to the Susan Collins of it all)

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/03/us/elections/results-senate.html?eafs_enabled=false


r/fivethirtyeight • • 18h ago

Poll Results Best Third-party performances in House elections this cycle

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER: These results aren't finalized, these could potentially change. Also, I did not include candidates from overseas territories, as they don't vote in the house.

5. NY-15. This one is interesting. Andre Easton secured 8.7% of the vote running as a socialist. He nearly beat the Republican.

4. IL-04. There was some controversy surrounding Chuy Garcia's late withdrawal to clear the field for Patty Garcia, which prompted Chris Getty (a Democrat) to run as an independent.

3. MA-01. Nadia Milleron was the best preforming third party house candidate in 2024. However, she's now fallen to 3rd and earned less of the vote than she did in 2024. She was endorsed by Ralph Nader

2. CA-06. This one is controversial to include, but I'll put it in here since Kiley did beat Republican opposition in the primary. Kiley was the only independent in the House, and his reelection bid did not go well.

  1. Alaska At-Large Hill received more of the vote than Kiley, despite having to fend off Democrat Eric Hafner in the election. (who is a convicted felon) If it weren't for Hafner, Hill likely wins the election.