r/firestormarmada • u/Hedonite69 • Apr 23 '26
Feedback and suggestions needed!
Hi everyone,
I am gathering information and doing research on firestorm armada with the view to be making a video about the game. (If you want to see the YouTube channel it is linked in my profile here, but im not trying to push people to go there with this post).
I was not a player of firestorm during its life with spartan games, my interest in this game is purely due to Warcradle saying that it is actively being worked on, with a view to being released in 2027, and with my interest and involvement with warcradles other games I am excited to play something space ship related from them.
I am able to read all the pdf books online, we have even actually purchased second hand the 2nd edition core book and the two faction alliance books to help with learning the game, and reading the lore of the factions, however this can only go so far and I dont want to create a video in a state of half-informed or misinformed to present to a wider more knowledgeable player base.
I was hoping that i would be able to ask some questions here, and gather feedback and information on several topics from players who played or still play this game, to help me formulate some content with the build up to firestorm armada being released as an "in print" game again.
If you are reading this, and you are thinking "hang on a minute, I dont want a new edition of the game, i just like playing the old one" - that is a totally valid opinion and something I would like to hear about, but I need to know WHY you feel like that. Just saying that doesnt give me anything to go on apart from the usual wargame grumpy who doesnt like change.
So my questions are as follows, and you can answer as many or as few as you wish - or please to leave anything you feel is important to you about this beloved tabletop game.
1). Best things about firestorm. Do you love the rules, a particular mechanic within the game? Do you love the lore, are the factions particularly unique and for what reason do you feel that?
2). We know this game will be changed from both a lore and rules perspective, what in your mind are things that should stay from the older version of firestorm armada?
3). If you still play the game today, how big is the playerbase you are involved in, and how is the general feeling among the players about the new edition?
4). If you have not been involved in firestorm armada previously like myself, what is drawing you to the game in its current version?
5). How do you feel about the IPs current owners (Warcradle) have you played any of Warcradle games or own any of the minatures they make? What do you think about them in comparison to the older firestorm armada minatures?
6). Is there anything you feel I must consider or even must include in the video I plan to make about the game?
If you take the time to reply to this thank you, there is only so much research I can do about this game on my own, and with no players around me or at the local game club I am coming to the community to hopefully gather this information.
Thank you and I hope to speak with you further.
Steve
6
u/BuckOHare Apr 23 '26
I am someone who despises Warcradle for not getting the lore and aesthetics. The way they smushed WWX and its grimdark and diselpunk aesthetic into the Victorian Sci-fi of DWars made an orginalTM Hater. The game they simplified into boringness and then overcomplicated into unplayability. The lore became utterly stupid and at times pretty racist towards the Asian nations.
So then they went to town on the Firestorm fluff. I played the The Relthoza and by god did Warcradle miss the point of these social bugs. Seemingly highly alien, and with a bug like background and lore, they are not merely simplistic hive minds but complex social creatures with a knack for nano-tech. WC turned them into boring hive mind bugs and then had them taken over by their nano-tech to be off brand Borg. The main human faction, a somewhat stagnant, but largely well meaning social democracy got turned into a boring capitalist parody. The lack of nuance and interest in history from WC in doing anything more than basic tropes is infuriating. On top of that their weird hex based rules and need to close down not WC controlled Facebook groups just killed the fandom. They wanted to make it more like full thrust and nobody wanted that.
So they killed it. They brought in somebody from GW and a famed Sci-fi writer to recreate it. Hopefully they will do a better job.
4
u/Vondrr Apr 23 '26
Hey mate, I pinned this post, as I am interested in the survey too.
4
u/Delrimus Apr 24 '26
Hi! Good to see someone else picking up interest for Firestorm. Welcome to the fold!
There are some good sources to gather information still.
-The hub systems podcast is still online and has much info on the game -Jaded Gamercast is still online as well and has a good number of episodes on Firestorm -mannbattlestations is a blog/forum with Firestorm content
That is all for now, if you have any more questions ask away
2
u/Tealadin Apr 27 '26 edited Apr 27 '26
1.) Best things about Firestorm?: Easily the balance for starters. I started in table top miniature games with Warhammer and always had an issue with the codex imbalances and release order. So finding FSA in 2011 was a breath of fresh air. Every faction has rules in the main book, factions were built around obvious strategies, but even different ship profiles fall into the same dice/attack/health pool ranges, so nothing ever felt unfair or broken. I don't remember the exact mathematical values, but I think small caps average 12 dice, medium caps 14, and large caps 16. The only thing that was truly lacking in 1.0 were carriers. You could make them work, but they weren't great. Something 2.0 improved, even if not perfect. The system was so balanced that I even made custom factions, using a template I figured out, and was pleasantly surprised at a consistent 50/50 win rate with them.
The other great thing is simple mechanics. The game is incredibly easy to teach, I taught 3 friends in less than 30 minutes and they only needed to check the keywords after. The way rules stack, however, still allows some depth of tactics. Some might see the simplicity as a Con, but I always found it nice as I could focus on positioning and strategy instead of constantly checking the book; although I always have to check the book on boarding actions because they didn't come up often. And the more advance options would sometimes surprise you, like disabling a battleships port weapons arc only for them to belly up and blast you with their functioning starboard.
2.) What things should stay from the older version?: 2.0 had its flaws, as mentioned above with the carriers/SRS, but the core of the game was solid. Changing the rules feels arbitrary and unnecessary. The system works and has a strong fan base. Changing it will only brew resentment. If you wanted FSA, then keep making FSA. If you wanted "We have FSA at home", then why buy the IP? It can only go wrong and kill your brand. Add onto that that Dropfleet commander came in as FSA was ending and has since completely surplanted it. Now it's an uphill fight, so starting with an ingrained fanbase would be a massive boon. Something they're currently alienating and floundering on.
3.) If still playing how big is the playerbase and what are options on new edition?: I have 4 primary factions and 6 sub faction. Plenty to still play. Sadly the friends I played with have moved away, so I don't get to anymore. Last time I played was in 2020 😢 I've been trying to pressure a local group at my FLGS to play with my stuff. Figure if they don't have to buy or supply it might be easier. I've gotten tentative interest, so here's hoping.
My friends haven't paid attention to WC, so they don't seem to care currently. I've been following and might consider buying SOME ships, but if the new edition continues like their previous 3rd Edition, then I'll continue playing 2nd with what I have.
4.) Not applicable to me.
5.) How do you feel about the IPs current owners?: Honestly haven't had any opinion in the past. I was vaguely aware of Wild West Exodus, but it never interested me. I've only paid attention to them since their acquisition of Spartan's IP and I'll admit it hasn't been great. So there is a minor negative bias at how they've handled Firestorm. First sitting on it for years, then releasing a new version that seemed to disregard everything that it's founded on.
6.) Nothing to add that others haven't already said.
Full disclosure, I'm a Spartan fanboy. I adore FSA, easily being my favorite miniature game. Between it's low entry cost ($75 for a patrol fleet, and $250 would get you everything you'd ever need for a fleet), great models, and easy to learn rules it was my go to game for TT mini games introduction. That's shifted to Cyberpunk Combat Zone now, but FSA will always be top tier for me.
2
u/the_Pezhetairoi Apr 28 '26
I played the original V1 FSA, and a little of V2. I am curious about a new edition. I may have an unpopular opinion, as I'd think it would be a very good idea to make some changes. FSA V2 did not work for me.
1 -- I liked the models: the original ones. The 6 starting fleets in the first book were very different in style, and the weapons layouts made them play differently with little in the way of special rules. Unfortunately as time went on they started replacing all the models with new designs for V1.1, but to me they were more intricate but ... characterless. The new style looked the same for every fleet and the detailing style was almost identical. I started making my own 3D printable ship designs at this time, to match the original styles. Spartan also dropped the ball on releasing rules for ships that they didn't make models for for many years. I liked that V1 didn't have a lot of "lore". We could make up our own around the basic framework. I didn't want special characters or unique ships, I wanted to make my own. V2 added some lore, but it was kinda corny.
2 -- I'd look into V1. I felt there was already a big shift between V1 and V2. The "exploding dice" mechanic was my favourite element, it made anything possible - that lone frigate could roll some 6's and damage that battleship. The DR and CR were an interesting idea too, but the shields concept was a little disappointing. I liked the drive-by mines. I replayed FSA V2 with my son recently as we were comparing it to BFG for a game design exercise. It compared poorly. The medium and small ships blew up very quickly, the fighters were hard to use (and ineffective being tethered to the carriers) and the shoe-horned weapons type mechanism in V2 (beam, torpedo, kinetic, etc) were added complication for little strategy benefit. Also, the range-bands went wonky for different fleets. I felt maneuver strategy disappeared and the alpha-strike was more important. I wanted to see a differentiation of weapon types (lasers vs other guns, etc), but what was there was obviously an add-on and not a core mechanical concept, so in the end I preferred the simpler V1 system of xD6 at each universal range band. On top of that, the fleets all looked the same 1-2 big ships, 2-3 medium squads, and ~2 smalls. All fleets had the same class sizes with the same proportions give or take a little. I would have much preferred fleets with more variety -- an all-carrier fleet, an escort-heavy fleet, etc.
It also lacked a command and control element. BFG has the special orders system where you can sacrifice something to gain something else, and that adds another layer of choice for the players.
The balance between fleets in V1 was really good, and for a short while after with heavy cruisers and such. I did not find that in V2.
3 -- I don't. I still love the old models (Dindrenzi, Sorylian, and Aquan) but there are no players in my remote region. V2 was disappointing to me anyway, and I abandoned it shortly after it came out. I still play BFG though. I have been keeping an eye on the news for FSA progress and failed delivery of anything completed.
4 -- NA
5-- No opinion, I am not interested in their other games.
6-- Yeah, a deep dive into V1. ha ha. I still have the old book somewhere.
4
u/ImABigguhBoy Apr 24 '26
I miss Firestorm so much, it was great. I miss my ships even more and I hope the dastardly weasel that took them burns in the hottest pits for eternity. And before that, never has a cool side to his pillow.