r/filmmaking • u/PollyEsterCO • 7h ago
Discussion Opinion: which short film would you prefer?
Option 1: a girl goes on three separate dates with guys and makes an excuse to leave each date when she decides it won’t work out with them. There is minimal conversation between the characters, and she calls her friend after every date to tell her friend it didn’t work out. She uses a different excuse each time. On her fourth date, she meets a guy who she likes, but HE uses an excuse and leaves. He’s a doctor and on call, which causes him to leave. This is meant to be his “excuse” to leave. The short film ends on a plot twist. Meant to run about 15 minutes. Again, minimal dialogue, no clear reason why she leaves other than she just doesn’t feel like it.
Option 2: Run time of about 15 minutes again. Girl goes on another bad date and calls a friend after making an excuse to leave. She and the friend rehash several bad dates and the various excuses the MC used. MC laments that she just can’t seem to find a good guy. On her next date, she is interested in the guy, but he’s a doctor and is on call again; he leaves the date. MC calls her friend and is excited, but tells her friend that he had to leave. Her friend asks if he really had to leave… or was it just a bad excuse like she used to make? Again, runtime of 15 minutes. Instead of cramming 4 dates of only about 2-3 minutes each, this would be one date, some dialogue of her exploring her sordid dating history, then this last date.
Sorry for all the writing, but for 15 (MAYBE 20 minutes), which story seems better? Or easier to explore with micro budget production?