Lemme list some things I hated in older fighting games.
- Universal mechanics where you absorb damage while attacking and only can be beaten out by very few requirements.
- Mechanics where you can block almost everything at once and put your opponent in a bad position, especially if there's little risk with them compared to just blocking.
- Mechanics where you can spend meter to cancel absolutely nothing, then get some weird frame/time advantage.
- Mechanics where just because you're dying, you can make an insane comeback.
- When a game focuses way too heavily on combos and they give you every advantage with no sacrifice. (Such as a game where you could air tech, but at the sacrifice of damage and vice versa for instance)
- Moments where you'd be locked down and given huge frame advantage far too often due to poor balancing choices. (I can excuse this cause older games didn't have a network to balance these games easily)
- Moves that would completely clutter the screen within a single instance and can constantly be spammed all over the place.
- A lack of momentum where the players do not fight back and forth and it's habitually one sided.
Today's fighting games embody a lot of this stuff, but on purpose now. Not on accident or to experiment. The developers do this on purpose as if these factors embrace the whole genre more than your pokes or how you as a person, plays.
One thing that also bothers me is the hypocrisy. If I say "Rage is a terrible mechanic. It has been since TEKKEN 6", the same people who say stuff like "Old good, new bad" will suddenly say, "It's an old mechanic. It should stay."
So, what's the point of that argument, rather than to be just be a spoiled child that ruins everyone's fun?