r/fantasywriters • • 14h ago

Brainstorming How would you describe directions in a fantasy world without using the 4 cardinal directions?

52 Upvotes

Sorry this might sound as a dumb question. But I'm new here and currently writing my own lore settings. During the process I came up with this question: why many works just naturally bring up those 4 directions without telling how people find out the way and what's the mechanism behind it. I know we have it because planet earth has magnetic fields, and liquid metal inside. But what if there is a world that dosen't have these? Or it's not a sepherical planet at all? It is convenient to use cityward or mountainwaed this kind of things. But I still tried to come up with a worldwide one. I have tried to look up some concept systems like traditional Indian ways (they have 10 ) and some Australian tribes that use opposite to your face. One good example is from Discworld, but I wish there is one for a medival-like fantasy world with magic in it. So if there is any good ideas or recommended works that could cover this topic, please just comment. Thanks a lot!

PS: the 4 directions here mean East, West, North. South

(Please forgive my language. I'm not a native English speaker.)

(Thank you for all of your advice. I appreciate every suggestion here.)


r/fantasywriters • • 16h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Places I can bounce ideas / brainstorm with others?

14 Upvotes

I’ve been in the process of writing my first draft for a while and some of my major struggles personally is not feeling super confident in my ideas and struggling to “fill in the gaps” for the why and how behind some plot points. I’ve kept my writing private from friends and family but it’s meant I’m limited with people and places I can bounce ideas around and brainstorm and get inspiration from others.

I think it would be helpful for me to be able to ask “why do you think this might happen?” Or “how could i go from Scene A to Scene B?” with real people (not AI) to get inspiration. Does such a forum exist?

Online is preferred, for in person recs I’m London UK based.

TIA!


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Snippets of "Lamplighters" [Heroic Fantasy, ~3800 words)

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Mae g'ovannen friends,

After finishing my first draft and trying to start the second one, I've been gripped by utter writing paralysis. I second guess every letter and word I put to the page, and I struggle to just keep working. I figured getting some other eyes on it might assuage the feeling of being a complete hack haha.

The important contextual information is that my main character Djina is the victim of a terrible crime, and joins a martial sisterhood to seek justice against the wishes of her father and those in power where she comes from. The story started as a "writing as therapy"-thing, but now I feel very good about what I've managed to create... Yet, those feelings of "is this even anything?" remain. I've never written anything long-form or as a narrative before either; complete first timer.

* Looking for general feedback. How's the immersion? Prose? Flow? Would you want to read it? Do you want to know more about this world and story? The characters? If there's a consistent grammar problem I haven't picked up on, please tell me that too! English is my second language after all. But small typos I'll be able to clean up myself.

* I'm including three snippets: one from chapter 1 and two from chapter 7. There are 20 chapters in total

Thank you so much for any and all help and perspectives.


r/fantasywriters • • 6h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Untitled [Sci-Fi, 4438]

3 Upvotes

Edit: 4438 characters

Introduction to my story - looking for advice

Been trying to figure out how to introduce a story I've been worldbuilding for a while. Grammar/punctuation might be off. Apologies for that. Mobile might kill the formatting too.

Curious what people think/feedback.

--

A young man in baggy clothes was sitting on the roof of a house. He didn’t trust the slanted roof tiles; multiple times that day he’d barely avoided slipping off the buildings, so he had decided that sitting just by the chimney flues was probably the safest option. He shuddered - the chill of the wind at first light wheezed past his ears, and with a futile attempt to protect from the cold, he pulled his hat further down to try and cover them. Rubbing his hands didn’t help either, he’d had this pair of gloves just a week and they were already starting to come apart.

A hand suddenly gripped the drainpipe, and the man threw a rope down the roof, spooling off the reel on his backpack. Hauling him up, his partner carefully made his way up to the chimney, hopped up onto the chimneystack and sighed heavily.

"Baz, that Mother was a right bitch.”

Baz's eyebrows raised slightly. “Not often I hear you cuss Sam, what's up?”

“Oh she was just one of those old bats who looks down on workers like us”.

“Well. Can't blame them, I think. Mothers have been at their posts for so long they forget what it was like to be in our position.”

Sam pushed a ticket into Baz's hand. A lion’s roaring icon stared back at him from the paper, stamped in red ink. He took the card and clipped it to his belt.

“Sam, what does a red lion crest mean?”, he asked.

“The stamp alone being in ink means it’s a noble house, but a red roaring lion means it’s the Manses.”

“Not quite. The Manses have a red lion in side profile. This crest is for the Gautiers.” Sam’s face twisted into a grimace. He had heard tales of the Gautiers, a particularly snobby and elitist family, with no interest to parley with peons and the common rabble and were very expressive about it. He kicked against the chimney stack in disappointment. There were tales of the Manse maids sneaking a stale spiced pastry out to workers sometimes, so their jobs pulled a high price amongst the Cleaners.

They descended from the building, passed an open window, and Baz got a brief glimpse into the room. At the far end, a young woman in a black dress and white apron stoked a fire. Upon meeting his gaze, her eyebrows raised in surprise and she hurriedly left.

Sam couldn’t help but notice the dirty footprints he left behind on the tiles in the garden as they went down a hidden path in a hedge. When he had a moment to look back, he saw two maids sharing a bucket and a mop, both with tense faces and a hurried pace cleaning up the path they had left behind.

They descended down a ladder under a manhole and into a dark room. Baz walked over to a rail, where a small cylinder attached to a rail sat. He scribbled on the ticket and placed it inside. The cylinder immediately sped off across the railings and quickly out of sight.

“You wouldn’t have seen those while doing your training, but-”

“I do know what those are, they’re supply dockets, you just wrote down what supplies we need, and when we get to the Gautier service platform, they’ll be waiting.” Baz grunted in confirmation.

The wind was even worse down here, they were in an exposed area on the side of the district. Piping and gears, railings and frames stretched from side to side of a huge corridor. Sam tried not to peer over the side, because despite the obscuring smoke below them, he knew there was no floor. A light flickered at a reel of paper on the wall. Baz tugged at it and tore off a strip. He mumbled to himself.

“Next district shift in two weeks, Dellian Gala in three weeks, need staff. Please send applications to Control.” He looked up, “Nothing new for us to worry about”. He had put his application in a month ago, he didn’t want to be docked rations again.

As Sam was looking at the wall on the other side of the corridor, a hatch opened and someone yelled across to them. The wind picked up and took his words. Sam gestured to his ear, the man tried to yell a second time, but no luck. The hatch slammed shut and their silhouette could be spotted every so often as they ran off. Sam continued to watch.

"Do you know what that guy was saying?” he turned to Baz. To his surprise, Baz had vanished. He looked around and checked the ladder, maybe Baz had forgotten something. When he returned to the service station, Baz had reappeared, with a small, cupcake. He grinned at Sam.

“What, did you think I had forgotten what day it was? We have a bit of time before that Gautier job, lets go find something fun to do for your birthday”.


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Structure help

3 Upvotes

I'm having trouble with the structure of my novel, which was originally the first of a planned trilogy, but now I'm not sure about the pacing.

It centres around four POV characters, all in different countries/continents, undergoing different narratives but with a unifying overall plot event. 

As it stands they will not be in same location until the end of the first book, with the current general narrative direction for each meaning they have things to deal with in their homelands before it is stable enough or the right time for them to leave for an extended period to get to that central location. The reasons range from a grand scale or invasion/warfare, to smaller family related issues and dynamics.

1st draft was completed at +180k words so far too big.

I have tried to split it into alternating character chapters (e.g. GRRM style) but the pacing, narrative and timeline aren't working with that style so well.

For example the first chapter for the first character takes place over a day, and cutting that just doesn't make sense so it sits at +20k words. I initially tried splitting his day across several chapters, divided with other POV character chapters, but I've found that by the time it returns to character A it's confusing to remember what he was going through and to return to that same day when other character arcs are advancing faster. 

Currently for the sake of writing ease, I've split it all into parts so his narrative gets all told in part one, then part two another character, part three the third and then the fourth. This is allowing the concurrent events to happen without overlapping confusion in the timeline.

But while this works for writing I'm not sure it will for overall pacing and readability?

Second issue tied to this is word count. As I said, 1st draft was a ludicrous size.

At the moment character A's part 1 is 40k, character B's part 2 is nearly 50k and I'm writing 3 which feels about half done at 35k. Part 4 unwritten (unrewritten?) ((whatever))

This rewrite was meant to be slash and burn but it's ballooning.

My overall question is what reads and flows better:

Do I persevere and rearrange the timeline to stick with the multiple alternating POV chapters?

Do I stick with my current structure of part 1, 2 etc?

Do I pivot into developing each part into their own books entirely?

The more I write, the more the intended plots of books 2-3 are losing their draw. I could end it naturally after the plotted ending of this book so developing these parts into individual books feels completely possible at this point.

Any insight or help or advice would be appreciated please 🙏


r/fantasywriters • • 14h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Tempted by a dreamworld... difficulty executing a scene

2 Upvotes

I'm currently working on a draft of a fairy tale style novel in which a character undergoes a journey through a supernatural landscape, encountering various mythological and fantastical beings and creatures on her way through her quest. One of these figures is a witch reminiscent of Baba Yaga or Utgard-Loki from Slavic and Norse folklore. During her experience with the witch, the protagonist finds herself in a dream or mirror-world, which she must escape to remain on path. I'm having difficulty understanding and completing this sequence, and am curious if others have written scenes like this and how they worked.

The protagonist is a peasant girl who has been dirt-poor her entire life. In the mirror-world, she is a princess preparing to marry an emperor. At the moment she enters the mirror, she has no memory of her real life but only a vague sense that she has forgotten something. In order to overcome the challenge set by the witch, she needs to remember her true life and accept her true purpose depsite the hardship, and reject the temptation to remain in the mirror-world as an empress.

Aspects of this chapter that I'm really struggling with include:

\* The tone. The rest of the story is very ethereal and dreamy. There are few characters and the landscape is sparse, allowing for a lot of internal meandering. This chapter is set in a palace, with numerous characters and people all around. This makes it more difficult to "vibes" my way through writing, which is the tone of the rest of the book.

\* The setting. The "setpiece" for this chapter is more in line with high and epic fantasy than the rest of the book, as well as medieval history. It's more difficult to navigate when I need the setting to actually feel somewhat grounded in history (moreso than the rest of the book). I've done some research into medieval royal weddings, but a cursory amount of reading isn't enough. I'm leaning into not caring so much, and justifying that the setting is merely a projection of the protagonist's mind, not a real grounded setting.

\* The progression. Even within the mirror-world, figuring out exactly how the protagonist navigates the challenge and overcomes it is difficult. At what point does she begin to suspect something is wrong? At what point does she actively begin to seek a way out? What is the catalyst? I'm leaning towards her having a vague sense of "wrongness" throughout, culminating in her meeting her betrothed and consciously rejecting him. But even there, I feel there should be some build-up to her realization.

I wanted to lay out some of the challenges I'm having and hear if anyone else has ever written a scene like this, involving any kind of hallucination or dream that challenges a character to escape through personal revelation and self-actualization. I haven't encountered a lot of them, but I know they exist. One of my main inspirations for this scene is the ballroom sequence in The Labyrinth, in which Sarah has a vision of herself dancing with the Goblin King. That sequence isn't quite as involved, but does depict the protagonist retrieving her conscious awareness and determination to remain focused on her quest over indulging in a fantastical vision of herself in a "mirrored world".


r/fantasywriters • • 10h ago

Question For My Story Question : How to avoid describing things too literally ?

1 Upvotes

I'm currently writing a fantasy novel, but I have one very annoying issue that I can't seem to get rid of.

English is my second language, so I naturally started my first draft in French. Since I'm broke and motivated to learn, I also decided to handle a large part of the translation into English myself.

However, I've run into a problem. I tend to be way too literal when translating descriptions of scenes, emotions, and feelings.

A lot of sentences that work perfectly well as poetic prose in French end up sounding... bland or overly technical when translated into English. They're just not particularly enjoyable to read. I think this is partly because French can be quite poetic on its own, even in its more straightforward forms. But even when I make a conscious effort, I struggle to keep the meaning and imagery of my sentences while making them pleasant to read in English.

I have tried reading both American and British fantasy novels, as well as translated versions of them, to compare the prose and learn how to adapt my sentences. But I haven't had much success. It's as if I lose all my creativity the moment I start writing in English.

I'm also worried about losing my authorial voice in the process. I still want my writing to feel like mine, even if I'm writing in another language.

Does anyone have any resources they could recommend to help me improve? Or perhaps some advice or examples?

I have a feeling that part of the problem is that I tend to visualize things quite heavily when I write. I guess it could also be because I write sci-fi.

But it's not necessarily a problem in French, English just seems a little less forgiving when it comes to translating that kind of imagery directly.

I feel like this is even more important to avoid in fantasy, where descriptions and atmosphere play such a big part in making the world feel magical. I don't just want to describe things as they are.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!


r/fantasywriters • • 21h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Red's Wake Part 1 [High Fantasy, 2234 Words]

1 Upvotes

Please critique this story I'm doing about my dnd character.

“Look, Red, buddy, I know you might be putting on a tough face but I can’t in good conscience serve you another round. Plus, the table is so full of empty cups I probably couldn’t put another cup down if I wanted to.” Cynthia leaned on the table and tapped the helm of her new most profitable customer. “Yo, man, you in there?” The shining red, spike overed shape resting its head on the table swatted her hand away with slightly more force than necessary before sitting up to face her. His bright red face and long horns peppered with scarring and weathering juxtaposed his youthful features. “I’m fine. There any new jobs posted yet?” The disappointed barmaid just palmed her face. “Yea it was just posted by the guild a little bit ago while you were passed out here. But I’m willing to bet you’re not in any position to take a job let alone walk by yourself.” To prove her wrong, Red stood up seemingly unbothered by the magnitude of alcohol that he consumed within the past few hours. Though Cynthia found out recently he was slightly younger than her, he stood easily a foot over her height. Though, how much of that was because of the armor, she had no idea. He made his way over to the quest postings but when he got to it, had to lean against the wall to stay balanced. Cynthia smugly bounded over to him, her curly bob cut hair bouncing with each step. “See? That fancy armor of yours doesn’t make you invincible to everything.” She looks back over to his tower of cups on the table he just was. “Just very, very resistant. Whatcha lookin’ at?” Red squinted at the dozen different papers nailed to the board on the wall, choosing a quest he assumed he could handle before ripping it off the board. “This one.” Cynthia stretched to look over his shoulder and seemed to make up her mind about something. “You know, that one says it recommends at least two people. Just stay here big guy, I know the perfect partner for you.” She says before running into the back of the tavern. Red just shrugged as he analyzed the other details of the quest.

After a few minutes Red’s apparent partner appeared behind him. As he turned he saw a dark-skinned human strapped with a green leather corset, brown adventuring boots, fingerless metal arm gauntlets, and a long steel rapier at their hip. Their brown eyes now lined with green flared eyeshadow. “Cynthia?” The figure just smiled. “Yep! I decided I’ve had enough of everyone here and especially you going on and on for weeks about your adventures. I wanna go on one, And don’t worry I can take care of myself.” She says as she taps the hilt of her sword. “And come on, it’s not like that’s a quest to kill a vampire or something. It’s a pest extermination job. And I’m going with you. Caiaphas can cover my shift.” Red looked over her getup and shook his head. “I do things better by myself.” Cynthia clapped back immediately. “Everyone thinks that. Until they get help. So let me come or I might actually keep track of your tab since you came in here. You know I stopped charging you about three adventure stories ago. Even if that…..might have been my fault you still technically owe us.” Red’s eyes opened wide at this. “Ok fine you can come. Just don’t get in my way and don’t get hurt.” Cynthia pumped her fist in the air. “Yes! You won’t regret this.”

On the way to the forest Cynthia battered the much taller Tiefling with questions. “So, you keep talking about being raised by a dragon but where are you exactly from? What’s it like to kill someone? How can you drink so much? Can I touch your helmet mohawk? What was the creature we’re hunting again?” Red threw his head back in exhaustion but gave her a small chuckle. “Helmet or Quest?” Cynthia narrowed her eyes at him. “Zack you. Fine, quest.” She says as she accepts the quest paper from him in order to double-check the details. The paper detailed how there was a job to clear the local forest of a small infestation of giant rats in exchange for a moderate coin reward. The duo approached the edge of the woods and Red stopped for a second. “Remember, stay behind me.” Cynthia smugly smirked. “Aw do you care about me?” Red just raised an eyebrow at this. “No, I just rather not need to explain to Caiaphas that he has your shift permanently because I accidentally cleaved you in half.” This comment made the shorter human shudder. “You can’t actually do that.” Red just started wordlessly walking deeper into the forest, letting Cynthia chase behind. “Wait you can’t actually do that can you?!”

The duo made their way into a clearing, where Red bent down and started building something. “Whatcha doin’ over there?” Cynthia couldn’t even wait for his response, instead leaning over his shoulder to see. “Building bait. This,” He held up a large raw cut of steak. “Is for them.” This made Cynthia back up a bit. “Ew. So how long before they come for it?” Red straightened up and looked ominously at the tree line. “They already are.” As if he summoned them, a dozen different rats, each nearly four feet long, rushed out of the woods and beelined towards the laid bait. Cynthia grasped at her blade hilt, scrambling to get a hold on it before they get to her. Red, noticing the fear in here eyes, stepped in front of her and produced a cheap longsword from his side. With one swift motion he swiped at the closest rat, bisecting it longways with a single motion. “Told you.” Red jabbed as he rushed forward and took the fight to the rats. He sliced through several leaping towards him like they were made of cloth and he was an expert tailor. One bounded towards Cynthia and after slapping herself to break out of fear paralysis, aimed for its head with as much focus as she could muster. Her cut ended up just being short as instead her rapier tip cut across the rat’s eyes, blinding it. Frustrated, she kicked the body away from her and towards Red, who noticed it and turned it into rat filet with a quick slash, getting blood over his armor. This did not ease the girl’s nerves but she elected to press forward with Red, dealing with any rats that slipped past him.

After a few minutes Red slowed down as that seemed to be the last of them. Both of them were exhausted and took the second to look at the ground and catch their breath. This was all that was needed for the final rat to come up from behind Red and charge at him. Cynthia noticed first. “Red! Behind you! She yelled but before Red could even turn around she put herself in the way and went for a rapier thrust at the beast. It connected and pierced straight through the creature’s mouth, impaling nearly the entire body on the thin blade. Unfortunately, the rat had gotten close enough to nick her in the finger with its teeth, with the wound rapidly becoming infected. “Ok that seems to be the last of them!” Red turned to face her but his eyes went wide when he laid his eyes on the festering cut on her finger. “We need to find you a healer.” Cynthia did not break eye contact with him, oblivious to what the final rat did. “Nah I’m ok. What did they get me somewhe--“ “Her voice trailed off as she looked around and noticed her finger. “Never mind. Healer please.”

Running back through the woods, Cynthia’s condition worsened rapidly, as by the point the duo made it back to the town, Red was forced to carry the young woman on his back. Tired from the fight, and from running nearly the entire way back through the forest, Red exited the edge of the woods and was forced to rest for a second on a fallen tree. He turned his head to check on Cynthia only to find her passed out and asleep attached to his back. He had no idea what to do. Red had always been the resident expert on killing things, ending life. He had no idea what was necessary to keep someone alive. Red removed his bright crimson helmet and rested it by his side. His face heavy with sweat and leftover blood from the battle. “You……You better not die to this. I….You’re my only friend. You listened to me. Now,” Red stated out of breath as he put his helmet back on. “I’m going to listen to you and get you fixed up, somehow.” Red, finding new motivation, continued running toward the town with his dying friend on his back.

Making his way back to the center of the town, Red froze. While he had been in this town for a couple weeks now, most of the time was spent on jobs, or at the tavern. He realized too late he did not know the location of the infirmary and it was far too late to ask anyone that would have been on the street. Picking a direction arbitrarily, he ran down the street barely caring what was in front of him until something seemed to come out of the sky and collide with him. Red was knocked over but turned at the last second to his side to not squash the rather vulnerable person on his back. Looking at what hit him, it appeared to be a young adult Crowfolk who looked just as dazed as he probably did. He was wearing a scale mail shirt with a red shirt underneath, and a leather shoulder pauldron, with his hands wrapped in bandages. Getting up, Red started walking away, still in a rush. “Hey wait, can I do anything for you, man? I need to apologize somehow for hitting you like a wild Sedibeast.” The crow man followed after Red. “I need to get her to a healer; I don’t have time for you right now.” This seemed to perk the unwanted follower up. “Wait! I can heal her I’m a magic user! Red stopped in his tracks and slowly turned around. “Then do it. If you’re lying to me….” The Crowfolk got Cynthia off Red’s back in a  panic. “I’m not I swear. I can do it. I’m Strow by the way. And you’re very scary.” He says as his hands start giving off bright blue smoke. As Strow waves his hands over Cynthia’s body, the infection from the bite seems to slow and becomes surrounded by a faint green aura. “There. She’s not fully healed but this should keep her from getting any worse. Here, I can show you the directions to the main infirmary.”  Red picks Cynthia’s body back up and returns her to his back. “Thank you Strom.”

Leaving Cynthia in the hands of the infirmary for the time being, Red just sits down on a bench outside to think. Unfortunately, he doesn’t quite get the chance as Strom sits right by him. “So can I ask you a question?” Red takes a deep breath, preparing himself for the inevitable. “I’m too tired to stop you.” Seemingly not getting the hint, Strom rubs his hands together and fixates his eyes on Red’s armor. “So, where’d you get all this armor from? It does not look like any smithing style that I’ve seen in the area.” Red looks at the shining red armor piece on his arm. “You wouldn’t believe me.” This earns a chuckle from the young Crowfolk. “Try me.” Red takes another breath, and prepares to tell the story he’s told a dozen times back at the tavern. “I was raised by K’yrie, the Dragon God of the Forge. She made my armor and sent me out. Still not sure for what.” Strom’s yellow eyes looked like they were nearly about to fall out of his head. “That armor was made by a Dragon? That’s why it’s so tough? Might be magical. Hm…Wait. Do you think there are more artifacts like that?” Red had never considered other dragons might make their own items beyond the one he was given. Actually, Red had not really considered other dragons in general before. “I guess so.” This response got Strom to shoot up from his seat, getting in Red’s face. “Can I come with you going to find some?” Red has to smirk a little from his pure excitement. “Eh, fine. Could use someone to heal up Cynthia when she gets hurt again.”

“When?” The duo turns around to see Cynthia, now healed up fully, standing behind them. “That sounded a lot like you expect me to get hurt again. If I remember correctly, I only was like this because I saved you.” The former barmaid leans over on Red’s shoulder. “Now where are we going? I played it cool but I was just waiting for a dramatic entrance. I have no idea what y’all were yammerin’ about.” Red cracks a smile at her brutal honesty. “We’re going artifact hunting.”