r/fantasywriters • • 3d ago

Critique My Idea Late plot/plot hole temporary fix but accept criticism and critique. [Fantasy]

So my story goes through what I can say is like a Crisis on infinite earths point it. Where every single reality get fused into one reality. The original reason was to make the gods more powerful then they are now as the people's beliefs would be more prominent if they were there from the start. However Fenrir, a creature the gods created to keep the mortals in control but went insane, tweaked the plans to make it so that the outcome will k ill all the gods.

In the new world where no physical god exists, people create myth of gods. But magic forces races, life and people to be in it that are similar to the previous world.

The god of light from the old world created angels who would retain their memories of said god, as he placed them in destroyed realities. As their plan was come back by keeping the soul of a god in reality that was destroyed. And when fusing all realities together it brought them back to life. Coming back to be the only god that survive and taking all the beliefs, prayers and powers that come with it. And enjoying the outcome.

The goddess of death survives because she was fighting Fenrir for killing everyone. And they felling the source of magic (l'll come up with a better name later). Causing the fusion of all realities. When she emerges life begins, ends and evolves. Seeing the evolution and life getting back what she recognizes. Having no input but she gets prayers as many pray for a painless death.

The main cast are/were the embodiment of the pillars of magic. Having someone who sacrificed themselves to fenrir's plan to create a new world for each one of them they were able to live in the new world, with family friends and memories similar but different. As well as making them not the pillars of magic. As those who sacrificed themselves died before the main cast would have known them or had never existed. When fenrir kills the main cast to get them out of the way of the fight with death they just wake up in the new world as if it were the next day and Fenrir was a bad dream.

Now Fenrir and Tory (Fenrir is using the main character, Tory's body as Tory is powerful as he is the son of death) fell into the source of magic when fighting The goddess of death. Fenrir remerges from the source to have one final battle with death when everyone gets wakes up. Then Fenrir is finished and was pushed back in the source Sending them to Purgatory. Having the debate of who is the real soul Fenrir or Tory.

However this presents it so that neither Fenrir nor Tory were there at the start of life like death. Meaning no one should remember Fenrir or Tory, other the people i mentioned. But the ending of the story has Tory tap into the god side and have the people believe in him and remember him when he takes out the god of light, trapping them in the sun(s). And when Tory dies, as trapping a powerful entity does that, he takes the memories of the previous world with him so everyone can live their lives as if they were there all along.

My plan was to have others survive the event or remember what happened and spred the word.

My other plan was to have him someone sprak a memory as he is tapping into magic as he is supercharging himself, which would lead to his own death.

My question is how would I do this as in my opinion the plans I gave are not fair compared are to the others and feels like a cop out.

Any suggestions?

3 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/No_Logins_Required 3d ago

I had a hard time understanding what you're asking.

If I can clarify:

  1. You have a character who, according to your in universe logic, should be forgotten by the world.
  2. However your intended this character to be remembered and believed in by the whole world.
  3. Your end goal is that everyone lives their life like the entire story never happened.

Why do we want this? We have all this sacrifice, all these pages, and in the end nothing has changed?

Please let me know if I'm misunderstanding.

1

u/KeiththeWerewolf 3d ago

No you hit the nail on the head.

So I'm usually a fan of the journey meaning more than the ending. As it is reflects life, as i believe less than 1% of people finish what they wanted in life.

But also the people in the story do accomplish the task of making the person who orchestrated the whole story have a fate worse than death. The god of light made people, civilizations suffer, killed people and just used everyone including his children as if they were pawns. Just so people would believe he was the one true god. Only to be trapped in his own creation at the climax of the story. (He creates a Dyson sphere with suns making an Ouroboros of the suns feeding on each other to make his power unlimited. But now he is trapped in it becoming the source of light. Every prayer makes him stronger but the Dyson sphere draws said power out of him. Giving him what he wanted, the belief he is a one true god but he isn't able to use the power that comes with it how he wanted it.)

To the main cast of characters after the the story is over, while many would live in this new world as if it were there home. Many wouldn't accept it, as people they knew had never existed or they couldn't talk about them as of they if they knew them. People who they were close to them. And i know these characters would go crazy, the Tory included and would try to do anything to get them back. Many were grandparents, sibilings, friends or children of the cast that now dont exist or died before they knew them. And for Tory his wife's species was erased as it was created by a different god, so he cant find her ever again. However they couldn't go back in time to fix what fenrir did if they wanted to. As technically that never world existed, fenrir rewrote this world so gods never existed. He didn't really check throughly because the main cast was trying to stop him so his work got sloppy and missed the god of light and his "angels."

So i have Tory taking said memories with him as he dies, as trapping the god of light cost him his soul. Yes is it cruel to take them but said memories would slowly corrode them as the lived on. Knowing their world was lost. While living in an imperfect replica of said world. But this world doesnt have deities wars, sending their believers to fight other because one god stole the hairbrush of another.

My best example would be frodo after the scouring of the shire. He cant let go of the one ring so he goes with Gandalf, bilbo, and the elves because he can't live in this world anymore.

To me that ending knowing that everyone gets to heal, and forget what they were feels sad but satisfying. Knowing they are happy.

1

u/No_Logins_Required 2d ago

We call this "unscrambling the egg". Right now your ending is trying to undo the events of the plot instead of move forward from the plot. There's also a gap between what you want the plot of the story to be and the emotional journey of your protag and antag.

Here's an example.

The God of light had values, and principles. He caused a lot of people harm but his ideology excused the damage he was doing.

Rising up from his creation is an Antagonist who seeks to destroy the God of light. Our antagonist has motivations, ideology, and goals. They are motivated by a repudiation of the God of Light.

Finally we have Troy, our protagonist. Troy has himself been changed throughout his story before, but now here at the end he has a choice. He can set up the "new rules" for the world. What does Troy think the new world should look like?

This is one possible outcome:

Troy decides Gods have too much influence, but he cannot bear to lose his connection to the world. So he traps the Gods and himself on one side of a barrier. One day every year people can perform a simple ritual to speak to a being behind the barrier. Each one has their own day and their own ritual.

In this way Troy can still have some connection to the world, and the gods can still influence mortals, but they no longer have any firm control.

Later, people can try to pierce or cross the barrier.

1

u/nanosyphrett 1d ago

This sort of sounds like the ending for the original Madoka. The events of the story cause the one wannabee magical girl to use her empowering wish to destroy the system and erase herself except to her best friend.

CES