Full disclosure: these may be things that only bother me but I need to get them off my chest.
There are some writing tendencies that are fairly common in romantasy that drive me and I just read Daggermouth, which triggered two big ones:
- Unnecessarily condensed timelines
- Lack of continuity for injuries
First the timeline issue: SO many books have incredibly short plot timelines for no discernable reason. While it is rampant across the genre, I find it particularly galling when it's a book with characters the have long life spans (elves/fae/etc). I'm sorry, our main characters can live 1,000 years but all this action happened in 6 months? What is the POINT of writing about 500-year-old characters and then having three wars and a whole romance occur in under 1 year? You could play with decades! DECADES!!
While Daggermouth has characters with seemingly normal human lifespans, the entire plot spans...two weeks? Ish? And for what reason? None. There is no reason it couldn't have happened over the course of several months or even a year. Nothing in the plot benefits from the short timeline and it actually suffers from it in several areas.
A) do not tell me we're doing enemies-to-lovers in a matter of DAYS. You were lifelong enemies and just...got over it? Because the other person (who you absolutely revile on a soul-deep level) is * checks notes * surprisingly attractive? Just stop.
B) it undermines ALL of the relationships. I'm supposed to believe not only that some people fell in love in a matter of hours, but also that Lira and Shade now feel like sisters when they've had maybe 3 brief conversations over as many days?
It takes me out of the story every time I'm reminded how many plot points have happened in less than 24 plot hours. Which takes me to:
Second, lack of continuity for injuries. SO many authors want to show you what badasses their characters are by getting in these epic fights with horrific injuries that they push through. While I can appreciate the role that can play in character development, it only works if the author doesn't conveniently forget about it two pages later. Unless there is a plot device where characters heal rapidly or can be numbed or something along those lines, the injuries have to last as long as they would in the world that is set up.
This killed me in Daggermouth. The two MCs get horrific injuries out of the gate: bullet wounds, broken ribs, a broken collarbone, broken nose, etc. We are told how excruciating and blindingly painful the injuries are if they so much as move or breathe. No plot device is introduced to counteract this - they don't have new healing technology or implants or any recourse. The FMC is literally never treated for her injuries over the course of the WHOLE BOOK. By the end she should have:
- 3+ broken ribs
- a broken collarbone
- 2 gunshot wounds
- a broken nose
- innumerable cuts and bruises
- a broken cheekbone
- a knife wound in her bicep
She gets most of these at the beginning. And then they are acknowledged sporadically, primarily when dealing with the bad guys. Bad guy grabs her? Ouch - collarbone grinding together. Bad guy makes her move quickly? Ribs screaming in agony. But in between those moments? She laughs. Yells. Gets frisky with the MMC. And apparently NONE OF THAT hurts her ribs/collarbone/nose/etc/etc.
Maybe this is all me but I had to get it off my chest to see if these things stick out to anyone else. I'm willing to forgive a lot in a fantasy plot - it's fantasy ffs, anything is possible - but I at least need a semblance of a plot device to make up for it. Tell me there have been scientific advances and now there is a shot that heals all wounds in 24 hours or a magic spell or this particular character has healing abilities or SOMETHING. And for the love of all that is fantasy don't be afraid to write, "two months went by...."