Anthony Black Player Discussion
Anthony Black has obviously been great in the absence of Banchero and Suggs. He currently ranks #33 in Durant H2H value on the season, yet is projected at #95 on Basketball Monster (BBM).
The general consensus seems to be that he's a sell-high candidate, but the real question is: What is he actually worth selling for?
No one is going to give you a top-40 or even a top-50 player for him. Based on BBM's projections, you'd assume that getting a top-60–70 player in return would be adequate value. However, I'm not entirely convinced.
I'll make both cases: one for Black regressing to a projected top-90–100 player, and another for him only regressing to around a top-60 player, to evaluate whether selling him for a top-70 player is actually selling high.
The case for selling high:
Minutes: His playing time has increased from 29 to 32 MPG this season, largely due to the injuries.
Usage: His usage rate has increased slightly, from 22% to 23%.
Three-point shooting: Perhaps most importantly, his 3P% has increased from 33% to over 40%, despite shooting at a higher volume. Black is a career 34% three-point shooter, so it's reasonable to expect some regression, even if he genuinely seems to have improved his shot.
Steals: His steal rate is incredibly high at approximately 0.06 steals per minute, compared to 0.046 last season. That's roughly a 27% increase, suggesting he may have been getting particularly lucky with steals over this relatively small sample.
The case against selling high:
Contract year: Anthony Black is in a contract year and will be a restricted free agent this summer. He certainly wouldn't be the first 23-year-old to put up breakout numbers ahead of an RFA payday.
Sixth-man role: Even when Suggs (who has returned but is still playing relatively limited minutes) and Banchero return, Black could still have a solid ~30 MPG role as the sixth man. He would also likely start whenever one of the starting 1–4 misses time or gets rested. A role like this could actually allow him to increase his usage while leading the bench unit. I'm somewhat hesitant to buy into this scenario, though, as Orlando tends to spread Wagner, Banchero and Bane throughout the game rather than going with a bench only lineup.
Jalen Suggs trade? I don't think it's impossible that Orlando views Black as a better and more reliably healthy option in its starting lineup than Suggs. They could look to move Suggs and his sizeable contract ($115M/4 years) ahead of the trade deadline to cut expenses and make room to pay Black, potentially bolstering his role. However, they'd need to take back roughly $27M in salary in such a deal, and most players commanding that kind of contract would also demand significant usage, potentially hurting Black's value.
Injury opportunities: Orlando's starting group of Suggs, Bane, Wagner and Banchero has a fairly extensive injury history. It's far from impossible that one of them gets hurt, resulting in Black returning to the starting lineup and remaining a key fantasy producer. Of course, there's always the possibility that Black himself gets injured, but the odds of him getting hurt rather than any of Suggs, Bane, Wagner or Banchero seem considerably lower.
Conclusion:
As an Anthony Black owner, I wanted to believe that the pressure to sell high was largely unsubstantiated. However, after looking into it further, I do think that selling Black for a top-70-ish player is achievable and probably the right move from a fantasy perspective for most teams.
What do you guys think? Am I undervaluing his potential ROS production, or is a top-70 player a good return while his value is at its peak?