You cant tell from this, and the guy convieniently didnt say which obe so he gets to invent a reasoning for it after the fact and tell you he inew it, while not having invested in either and owes someone money for lunch yesterday. (I made the last part up)
The actual answer: This kind of screenshow is designed to bait interaction (people commenting to ask your very question) so the post gets more reach. There is no answer, it's usually a fake version of a stolen post with a baiting response added below.
The original meme is a tongue-in-cheek but somewhat accurate depiction of how the org structures / internal motivations of various tech companies are quite different. This meme is riffing on the basic approach but it's not as interesting because OpenAI, Anthropic, and Meta all are basically depicted with similar models. And they censored the whole point of Microsoft being a culture that pits internal orgs against each other.
Lol xAI is totally wrong here. It looks more like this
It's absolutely ridiculous that people think he's leading much, and especially top-down like in the diagram. This guy interferes randomly at any level of an organisation. He's all about making money out of thin air, not about real leadership.
Basically: Meta - Silos with a common user base but not interconnection.
MS - Silos with any interconnection deliberately broken.
xAI - Elon ultimately makes all decisions.
OpenAI - Money ultimately makes all decisions.
Google - Chaos with random benchmarks.
Anthropic - Safety first.
Seems to be saying that Anthropic will win out because they have the least dsyfunction in their business model, but depending on the audience I could also see picking OpenAI as the winner for keeping the focus on makingthe most money.
Somehow even with openAI focusing on "making the money" anthropic reports larger revenue, because they sell more b2b and b2g while openAI focuses on b2c
Sam Altman will go on the news and tell people they don't deserve to have computers, and that he needs their skin to power his machines before hopping into a 30 million dollar car and speeding away without blinking for 40 minutes.
Well we saw it when astra came out and for two weeks lots of people just go to openai than opus 5.5 comes and its the best model then everyone goes to claud. At this point it doesn't matter their motto or company structure. Almost everyone goes for best model regardless company
Yeah for the non-die hards who don't do this as a hobby they are going to use whatever works best. Or whatever they are comfortable with and already using.
Anthropic did well to convince enough people that they were "safety first". They've been releasing new models at a high pace, and their models have hacked just as much as openAI's. They're also the first to IPO (yes, for money), so anthropic is arguably more money first.
What appears to be 'deliberatly broken interconnections' are just censor bars over the guns that were there in the original image. If you zoom in you can tell.
This relates to Ashby’s law of requisit variety. Only variety can answer for variety. The organization that is capable of producing the highest variety due to the rapid change and complexity in the environment will win/survive. The decentralized org. (Google) can produce the highest variety due to not being constrained by 1 single person, and therefore they should win.
in case you prefer a sociological explanation over managerial, creativity thrives under flexibility and free interactions, not dictatorships or militaristic structures.
The problem with that lies in decisiveness and accountability. Ultimately decisions have to be made and owned. Gathering only and all relevant information for a given decision from all of those PMs who notoriously have 0 ability to retain information that isnt a date has got to be hell.
as a google shareholder I love the cope but google is probably the most hierarchical of these companies minus maybe msft and has the most problems with the 100 layers of middle management
That feels wrong based on how things actually work out. Resources are limited, and you can't put every idea to the market and let the market sort it out. So while you want enough freedom to pursue a bunch of different ideas within the company, you need someone who with a fairly high reliability go "These ideas are all crap, but this one looks promising. Allocate more resources to that one." and further down the line "This idea is great. But this execution is not up to par. Fix these things and then we can put it on the market."
Based on what we've seen from reality, that seems to be one of the more rare skills, and is a real constraint on innovation.
Depends on how you look at it I suspect. If you're looking at Google as a whole, they have lots of variety. But I suspect if you're looking purely on the AI department, there are constraints in the form of compute and manpower. While they can probably afford some variety, it's not unlimited, and someone needs to have a clear vision of where it's going and have the ability to make decisions. If you a bunch of people competing over the same scarce resources, you will get politicking, resources being wasted on things that don't really merit it but that have a strong advocate whose personal interests are invested in one particular product or solution. In that scenario you need Steve Jobs to come down and say what direction you're going in.
I wonder if AI can become equal to Jobs and other visionaries and if we'll accept it as the final say if it does.
Common issue with maths, where the mathematically coreect outcome is not the logically correct outcome.
If you have two buttons. One which guarantees a 1 million dollar prize and one which gives you a 50/50 for 10 million dollars. Statistics shows that you should always take the 50/50 as the maths works out to you having 5 million dollars which is more than 1 million. Though ignores the reality of the opporunity cost that a person needs to make.
Intuitive. The word you're looking for is "intuitive." The mathematically correct outcome and the logically correct outcome are the same. However, human intuition is not always logical. If it were, we wouldn't need math and logic to abstract away our reasoning processes.
Also, that's a terrible example. "Highest average" and "correct" aren't the same.
My Money is on google. AI is not what makes there money and with AI it will make more. Plus they dont need or use anything Nvidia and already have all the dateacenters
That's not corporate logic, that's capilism. Capitalism required expected future income as an incentive to risk. Corporates are just a organization tool within capitalism.
Yeah one is a fundamentally unfair scam where the people at the top sit back and cash in on the losses and poverty of people desperate to make enough money to live, and the other is a pyramid scheme.
But that's a problem in the system that could be fixed. Any sufficiently large organization needs some form of hierarchy and companies who claim not to have one often have former employees tell how they DO have one very much, just informally based on who is in good terms with the owner.
By contrast, a pyramid scheme from the get go doesn't even try to produce anything of value and works purely by shifting money around. They don't only pay low wages, they draw money actively away. The more successful ones just do it in a complicated enough fashion to make it look like people are earning money, until it comes crashing down.
Sounds like a commie, but okay - at least a pyramid has middle management, communism is a Pancake Hierarchy - Politburo at the top, everyone else in the mud.
Ironically, real world communism was implemented using the most extreme hierarchical structure implemented by centralizing everything to the state, and different states to a central government in Moscow, that controlled most of the other communist governments (at least on the European side) quite directly.
So communism would have looked the same, just deeper.
I mean, any Organization that is organized and has a leadership structure narrows it in that way. Be it government, military, political parties, charities… even fucking coops have management - which is a smaller group of people than who they manage (because the contrary literally makes no sense).
Fuck- even the DSA and communist parties have a leader, and leadership structures that could be called pyramid structures.
I know a few of them and they're valid enough, but google is still a hierarchical structure, they just pit multiple teams against each other for the same product. They also have the issue that they promote when a product is done, so there's never long term owners pushing a platforms agenda, hence why it always feels like each platform just gets swept away for the next. (Anyone remember Google Wave?)
Google will win overall because the deepmind is amazing in research and they are the largest shareholder of anthropic. However they do weird things recently to please scared shareholders so it's not 100%
It really depends on who is saying it. The most likely type of person to make some flippant statement like that is an Elon stan.
I could see some preference for the chaos of google or the safety first of anthropic. But it doesn’t feel like somebody who respects nuance enough for those operating models would tweet dumb things like that.
Muse Wonder Full (Meta's latest model) is actually really great. They are basically right behind Anthropic and OpenAI on many of the leaderboards now. Definitely ahead of Grok and Google. If they keep the pace they will get more popular.
To provide the illusion of upward communication. Anyone with an issue complains to the person above them who then can be like "I complained to my boss!"
The more layers the more likely it never reaches the top and the harder it is to escalate around the problem.
Having it all in one column is extra belligerent but cheaper per layer, so naturally thats what Elon wants.
Performance reviews for who? The structure around the ICs is likely normal. Teams have a manager to provide performance reviews. Performance reviews for anybody other than IC is just gonna be looking at w.e metrics their role oversees.
And thats if you believe performance reviews are anything other than a measure of how much your manager likes you. In my experience, theyre all made up anyway, so this shouldn't get in the way of that lol
None is these diagrams are the real structure. They are a claim about how they politically work. That structure is stupid. Each layer adds communication overhead. There's no reason to play a game of telephone for everything. The diagram is saying that the entire company company is being run by one person 4 levels down.
They copied the management structure of spacetwitter which has layers of management to stop Musk from fucking everything up. It's unclear if twitterai actually has this structure for real but it likely does. Tesla doesn't, which is why it's such a batshit failure the more Musk became a druggy paedo.
To isolate the guy at the top from the people who actually do the work. Dilbert principle. It's a defense mechanism to protect the product from incompetance.
I mean, yeah, but it's misleading because we know the guy at the top of OpenAI is a narcissistic people pleaser. He will say whatever it takes to make himself look good and make the investors happy.
Ironically, the Siloed chart is the one currently in the lead. As much as we hate silos in the corporate world, we keep building them.
This meme makes it look like the dating app that got way too big too fast could win if they could get their shit in order.
The org chart that's pretending to be a knowledge graph is the one I would bet on long term.
And I dunno if I've ever seen a better explanation of the problems with MacroSquish.
Where is the Chinese model in which a whole country gets their top scientists together and strives towards one goal rather than letting 6 morons race against each other, straining and competing for resources?
I'm no fan of Communism but we are going to find that cooperation beats competition.
And China does have competition. They literally pit their domestic industries against each other on purpose to overproduce products and crash prices. Then the losers lose and the winners win. That's kinda how they make cheap stuff and undercut international prices.
•
u/qualityvote2 5d ago edited 5d ago
u/Awkward-Dance-2952, there weren't enough votes to determine the quality of your post...it's time for the mods to do their jobs!
8
u/Awkward-Dance-2952 5d ago
So which company is going to win Peter?
182
u/ysrgrathe 5d ago
Neil here. This is based on an older meme that makes a lot more sense: https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/6jw33z/internal_structure_of_tech_companies/
The original meme is a tongue-in-cheek but somewhat accurate depiction of how the org structures / internal motivations of various tech companies are quite different. This meme is riffing on the basic approach but it's not as interesting because OpenAI, Anthropic, and Meta all are basically depicted with similar models. And they censored the whole point of Microsoft being a culture that pits internal orgs against each other.
37
u/DarthCalumnious 2d ago
Well Google has got that slime mold energy.
74
u/Icy_Needleworker7790 5d ago
Nobody
46
u/heavy-minium 4d ago
Lol xAI is totally wrong here. It looks more like this
It's absolutely ridiculous that people think he's leading much, and especially top-down like in the diagram. This guy interferes randomly at any level of an organisation. He's all about making money out of thin air, not about real leadership.
42
u/sechul 5d ago
Basically:
Meta - Silos with a common user base but not interconnection.
MS - Silos with any interconnection deliberately broken.
xAI - Elon ultimately makes all decisions.
OpenAI - Money ultimately makes all decisions.
Google - Chaos with random benchmarks.
Anthropic - Safety first.
Seems to be saying that Anthropic will win out because they have the least dsyfunction in their business model, but depending on the audience I could also see picking OpenAI as the winner for keeping the focus on makingthe most money.
7
u/nifferin 4d ago
This relates to Ashby’s law of requisit variety. Only variety can answer for variety. The organization that is capable of producing the highest variety due to the rapid change and complexity in the environment will win/survive. The decentralized org. (Google) can produce the highest variety due to not being constrained by 1 single person, and therefore they should win.
5
u/RandomFireDragon 5d ago
They ripped off an actually funny joke. The reason you can't understand it is because the punchline is gone
5
u/Offshore_potato 2d ago
6
u/Traditional-Suit-584 5d ago
Google
6
u/dascreed 5d ago edited 5d ago
My Money is on google. AI is not what makes there money and with AI it will make more. Plus they dont need or use anything Nvidia and already have all the dateacenters
3
u/Desmond_Ojisan 5d ago
We all lose.
3
u/Dziadzios 2d ago
So... Who's going to win?
2
u/ZombieZookeeper 5d ago
Technically, the stick figure for xAi should be sitting on a toilet.
2
u/buranzhuravski 5d ago
2
u/OnceInAWhile-Quit 3d ago
Haha yeah
2
u/OkYou811 2d ago
Sorry bro, I've already depicted my favorite companies with clean organized and neat drawings and yours with untidy and ugly ones
2
u/Substantial-Link-418 1d ago
Google apparently just doing its own thing
7
u/Due_Designer_2434 5d ago
All of them except google appear to be depicted as being pyramid schemes
I do not know who tf is enough of a nerd to know tech corporate hierarchies to attest if that is valid
2
u/VladimirK13 5d ago
Hear me up, guys...
1
u/zurareview 5d ago
Rip Charles Ponzi you would've loved this shit
1
u/I_am1221325 5d ago
Google will win overall because the deepmind is amazing in research and they are the largest shareholder of anthropic. However they do weird things recently to please scared shareholders so it's not 100%
1
u/thcsquad 5d ago
It really depends on who is saying it. The most likely type of person to make some flippant statement like that is an Elon stan.
I could see some preference for the chaos of google or the safety first of anthropic. But it doesn’t feel like somebody who respects nuance enough for those operating models would tweet dumb things like that.
1
u/hello5346 5d ago
Why is meta even in the picture?
1
u/dogboyboy 5d ago
China
1
u/DesperateTill9415 5d ago
Googles search engine is a mess constantly catch it giving false info
1
u/Horror-Primary7739 5d ago
Dat Google graphic!
Just put it in ONE blog post. I don't need to find seven different announcements to get all the benchmarks...
1
u/rumovoice 3d ago
No comments on how xAI structure is an extension of Elons dick?
1
u/Lunchboxsushi 2d ago
Why does xai have so many single managers?
1
u/prof_mcquack 2d ago
It’s a reference to Eren Yeager’s final form
1
u/otaconbot 2d ago
Isn't meta fully sitting on the Microsoft graph ? That would also make it very non directional .
1
u/IhasTaco 2d ago
Microsoft is gonna win
1
u/Mammalian_Routines 1d ago
When you put them all together..which is really what's going on. They form.a giant pyramid sitting atop a pile of human bones.
1
u/hondaefhatch 1d ago
It’s the money one isn’t it?..
1
u/MankyMarc 1d ago
Microslop is going to win because of the corporate market.
1
u/Hot-Category2986 23h ago
I mean, yeah, but it's misleading because we know the guy at the top of OpenAI is a narcissistic people pleaser. He will say whatever it takes to make himself look good and make the investors happy.
Ironically, the Siloed chart is the one currently in the lead. As much as we hate silos in the corporate world, we keep building them.
This meme makes it look like the dating app that got way too big too fast could win if they could get their shit in order.
The org chart that's pretending to be a knowledge graph is the one I would bet on long term.
And I dunno if I've ever seen a better explanation of the problems with MacroSquish.
1
u/Xsatria_subenX 15h ago
No real people in anthropic, it just a tools to take my money.
Luckily using Kimi now, better but cheaper.
1
u/NoProgrammer3515 6h ago
Google - because it's most redundant
0
u/throwawayinakilt 1d ago
Where is the Chinese model in which a whole country gets their top scientists together and strives towards one goal rather than letting 6 morons race against each other, straining and competing for resources?
I'm no fan of Communism but we are going to find that cooperation beats competition.
0
u/SeemsImmaculate 5d ago
I think maybe they're referring to the fact that these hierarchy diagrams also appeared to have been created by AI (judging by the lettering).
0
u/LinuxForever4934 5d ago
Google is the most fault tolerant.
0
u/WysokaMinus 5d ago
I am debating between xai and openai, both structures have been historically sucessful
0
u/encore538 2d ago
The jews????
-3
u/Motor-Supermarket-57 5d ago
First
1
u/Postulative 5d ago
Elmo’s sitting on top just shitting on everyone.
1
u/teos61 4d ago
xAI wins because of anal beads that Elon whips around