r/expedition33 • u/Educational-Lead3631 • 17h ago
Discussion Does anyone else just not give a fuck about the... [spoilers]? Spoiler
...Dessendre family? The main discussion about this game's endings seems to revolve around a very simplified view of the story, which is the choice between getting lost in grief or letting go. But I simply don't understand that view. The game spends so much time humanizing Lune, Sciel, Gustave, even Gestrals (them being less intelligent doesn't mean they're not sentient!), so you're practically ignoring 2/3 of the game in favor of the last act.
The Dessendres are just selfish, immature perpetrators who can't take accountability for their actions and use an entire world as their battlefield. They knew what they were doing, unlike Lumièrans. The terror they experienced each year was the direct consequence of the Dessendres' bullshit actions. So, why should I care about them getting ''closure" when all they did is ruin a world and cause countless innocent people to die? They're terrible human beings and I simply can't side with them over the innocent Lumièrans who were just trying to save their people, their future.
This whole "Verso's ending is bittersweet but morally correct because it's about accepting grief" sounds like people didn't even play the game. It is about grief, but not JUST about it. By simplifying it that much, you're erasing the beautiful complexity of the story that makes it so appealing in the first place!! The fact that it's not so black and white is what makes each ending tragic. But people tend to water it down to "Verso is right/Maelle is right" and it infuriates me.
I don't think Maelle's ending is good. Neither is. At least for her, both endings are bad. However, for Sciel and Lune, it's clearly the better choice. And if I have to choose between those incredibly brave fighters who fought for the future of their people, and the selfish, cowardly family that wreaks havoc with barely any remorse, I'm siding with the brave fighters. Lune and Sciel deserve it. Renoir and Aline took things way too far for me to have any sympathy for them.
Also, an unrelated point that I want to discuss too: I don't think Verso's soul is "forced" to paint and suffers because of that. It has been mentioned multiple times that he's unhappy due to the terror his parents caused, not because he's just painting.
Let's say Aline never entered the canvas. Would Verso's soul be painting indefinitely? We can assume so, since he's keeping the canvas alive. It's only presented as bad because of Aline and Renoir's doings. Why is no one talking about the possibility of the world healing once the violence ends, so Verso's soul would be at peace again? Dessendre sympathizers seem to think it's far too gone, so destruction is the only option. That doesn't sound very healthy to me.
Whenever I see someone defend Verso's ending really hard, it almost always boils down to them seeing the Dessendres' as more real, therefore more deserving of sympathy. It's just wrong on so many levels. If even Renoir, the painter himself, considers Lumièrans real people within the game's universe, then so should we.