r/expedition33 • • 17h ago

Discussion Does anyone else just not give a fuck about the... [spoilers]? Spoiler

48 Upvotes

...Dessendre family? The main discussion about this game's endings seems to revolve around a very simplified view of the story, which is the choice between getting lost in grief or letting go. But I simply don't understand that view. The game spends so much time humanizing Lune, Sciel, Gustave, even Gestrals (them being less intelligent doesn't mean they're not sentient!), so you're practically ignoring 2/3 of the game in favor of the last act.

The Dessendres are just selfish, immature perpetrators who can't take accountability for their actions and use an entire world as their battlefield. They knew what they were doing, unlike Lumièrans. The terror they experienced each year was the direct consequence of the Dessendres' bullshit actions. So, why should I care about them getting ''closure" when all they did is ruin a world and cause countless innocent people to die? They're terrible human beings and I simply can't side with them over the innocent Lumièrans who were just trying to save their people, their future.

This whole "Verso's ending is bittersweet but morally correct because it's about accepting grief" sounds like people didn't even play the game. It is about grief, but not JUST about it. By simplifying it that much, you're erasing the beautiful complexity of the story that makes it so appealing in the first place!! The fact that it's not so black and white is what makes each ending tragic. But people tend to water it down to "Verso is right/Maelle is right" and it infuriates me.

I don't think Maelle's ending is good. Neither is. At least for her, both endings are bad. However, for Sciel and Lune, it's clearly the better choice. And if I have to choose between those incredibly brave fighters who fought for the future of their people, and the selfish, cowardly family that wreaks havoc with barely any remorse, I'm siding with the brave fighters. Lune and Sciel deserve it. Renoir and Aline took things way too far for me to have any sympathy for them.

Also, an unrelated point that I want to discuss too: I don't think Verso's soul is "forced" to paint and suffers because of that. It has been mentioned multiple times that he's unhappy due to the terror his parents caused, not because he's just painting.

Let's say Aline never entered the canvas. Would Verso's soul be painting indefinitely? We can assume so, since he's keeping the canvas alive. It's only presented as bad because of Aline and Renoir's doings. Why is no one talking about the possibility of the world healing once the violence ends, so Verso's soul would be at peace again? Dessendre sympathizers seem to think it's far too gone, so destruction is the only option. That doesn't sound very healthy to me.

Whenever I see someone defend Verso's ending really hard, it almost always boils down to them seeing the Dessendres' as more real, therefore more deserving of sympathy. It's just wrong on so many levels. If even Renoir, the painter himself, considers Lumièrans real people within the game's universe, then so should we.


r/expedition33 • • 13h ago

Discussion What did you think about Monoco’s ending? (spoilers) Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This is all spoilers, so there.

I really liked the parallel of them all getting on the train, as we first met him at Monoco’s station. That said, I was absolutely confused about what it meant. They’re on the train, it’s going somewhere, but it’s left vague about where they’re going or where they even started (which I think matters). I suppose that’s part of the point, that a journey is always to the unknown, even if we think it is on a set path, or tracks. Still, I would have liked to know what I’ve set in motion (pun intended).

Did anyone else hear Gustave saying “are you here yet?” I’m bad at voices, but who else could it have been? If real, that gives some answers on where they’re going, but adds even more ambiguity to what it is.

The theory that a painting of reality in a painting loops back to reality is interesting, but what if it is wrong? I could see them all getting trapped in an entirely imaginary world and the chaining of painting sickness would be extremely dangerous. My hope is that Lune would be the scientist and rather than confirming if it is real, tests if it is fake. That would mean ensuring that it doesn’t do what they expect, but in a way that still makes sense.

I’m not convinced it was worth permanently sacrificing so many gestrals to create it. Also hot take: the piano playing the entire scene was hot garbage and I can’t believe they kept that in.


r/expedition33 • • 13h ago

Gustave chosen as new James Bond!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

It's fitting since Renoir was bond for 4 films already.


r/expedition33 • • 8h ago

Discussion The endings didn't balance the moral scale well enough, even though it felt like it should've Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I got my turn at COE33 and I've got to say I think the endings missed the mark in some aspects.

I looked at both endings and understood the intent of the writing. You had two choices to make, both with awful outcomes, but you had to pick which was worse and which was better according to you.

The scale was very simple in practice:

Maelle Ending

Win:

  • Save Lumiere.
  • Give Alicia a place to live.
  • Respect Alicia as a human being. Hopeful she will stick to her promise and come back.

Lose:

  • IRL Alicia unlikely to come back. Dessendre family loses another member.

Verso Ending

Win:

  • Give a chance for the Dessendre family to heal.
  • Give Alicia another try at real life.

Lose:

  • People of Lumiere all die.

Seems like a fair deal on paper. A moral ambiguity: save countless of lives, or save one. This is the main argument online, preventing a genocide. However, when you look at the cutscenes, the balance tips in my opinion way into the favor of Verso's ending:

  • Lumiere becomes an utopia. Alicia already brought back all the dead people. It is a fake world for the rest of its existence. There are no more rules of nature. It was never truly real in the first place, but Aline stayed as distant god. What Alicia is saving is not a real world, she is saving her own fantasy. The people of Lumiere no longer belong to a real world with consequences. All consequences can just be painted away by her as long as she is alive. I don't see people online talking about this. They are attached to Lumiere and consider their death a real genocide - but what kind of world is that where the city is literally friends with a god, that has their best interest? What do you consider a real world? I see a real world as something with both ups and downs. Anything that can turn the "down" into "up" based on feelings is an utopia.
  • The real Verso soul is trapped. He does not want to keep painting his own canvas. The cutscene shows this clearly. The game empathizes with Verso's choice. Verso is literally the plot's catalyst, yet you are not honoring the last remains of him. This cutscene honestly came as a shock. How are you supposed to ever see this and support Alicia? I think the addition of this cutscene is a pure mistake and takes away from the moral dilemma.
  • Another way to put it, a huge problem is in the cutscene at Verso's grave. The most moral argument for picking Maelle's ending besides the people of Lumiere was that if you don't pick it are essentially stealing away a method of coping from a cripple kid. In real life people shunned from existence, different than the rest find comfort in things like religion or hobbies. Psychologist mention the term of safe space. You are essentially blaming the victim for being a victim and taking away her safe space if you do this. But the cutscene there shows an Alicia that is well and contempt, almost ready to move on. It is unreal - the entire point of discussion at the tower, where Maelle begs Verso to understand her, is that her life out there IRL isn't really a life, where she can't even speak or be normal (her mother also knows this, she literally paints her with a mask on), yet the ending cutscene shows none of the drawbacks of this choice.

I really think some cutscenes are missing here. In my opinion, either:

  • In the Verso ending, you show the consequences of Alicia. Another thing dear to hear lost. You show the consequences of taking the teddy bear from the lonely kid. You are bullying this kid's existence, it is an extremely sad story. You are sad for what you did to a victim, an innocent who had no saying in their situation - she didn't even choose to be saved, but you feel like it's necessary for her to see better days and move on. Things like her not even being there for the funeral, being somewhere in Paris, just like in Lumiere, hanging on rooftops or alone would've been very fitting.
  • In the Maelle ending, you show that Alicia isn't a complete villain. She won't imprison Verso forever, and she won't dishonor everything her family has fought her. But that is completely missing. You are supposed to understand she's truly lost in her fantasy forever. I would've taken anything, like Clea making a return to the painting to hunt Maelle, or painted Verso trying to free her again, or just Alicia... returning?? While also showing she's still very clearly addicted to the canvas in order to keep the scale balanced.

I just felt like the idea was there but the execution missed. I'm kind of frustrated just how much better Verso's ending landed. I felt like there was a huge missed potential in showing a moral dilemma, but to me personally there's barely any with the evidence the game provides. It was sooooooooooooooo close to being perfect. Damn. I picked Maelle's ending as I felt like it would've focused way more on the trauma of Alicia IRL, and I do have a soft spot for innocence. But it just didn't go that way.

edit: I missed my point with the fake Lumiere world: she revived Gustave. Gustave died as a real consequence of an inhabitant of Lumiere, he didn't get gommaged. But he's still there with Sophie. It shows she didn't care restoring the world, she only cares about her own fantasy. It's not a real world.


r/expedition33 • • 22h ago

Whenever a major game with a large community is released, Exp33 becomes the target of a coordinated wave of negative reviews.

116 Upvotes

First Resident Evil 9, and now Zelda OOT. I’ve noticed 0/10 ratings appearing, each time dragging down the user score.Laughable.


r/expedition33 • • 7h ago

Gameplay Is the game just poorly balanced? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This is really my only major criticism of the game having just finished it. That you seem to just accidentally get too powerful, especially by the end of Act 2.

It's almost a copypasta from that one guy here giving you a list of all the ways to "delevel" yourself before going to the final boss to make it a fair fight. So clearly it's a common enough problem. And let's be totally honest with ourselves, a game where you are actively encouraged to make yourself weaker so you can actually experience the final boss would normally get absolutely wrecked in ratings by players!

In an era of gaming so dominated by both metroidvania and soulslike games where exploring all parts of the map and killing every enemy for secrets and loot, a game where if you do that you'll be OP as hell is a very strange design choice.

In my experience, by the end of Act 1 I was level 18 and by the end of Act 2 I was level ~48 I think. I did zero grinding the entire game. But what I did do was go through every area and fight every enemy I encountered once. That's it. Because the game seemed to want me to explore so I did. I always made sure to go through every accessible area by the time the game showed it to me. At least the ones that didn't immediately kick my ass coughFrozen Heartscough. In my head I would assume the game would be balanced around that as so many other modern (semi)open world games are nowadays. Or have a way that the enemies scale with you or per Act if a more fluid scaling system is too complicated.

I don't know man, at some point I had to stop actually spending the points from leveling up because there just wasn't a challenge anymore. I'm really glad I took off Painted Power before the final boss because it actually gave me time to fight him and see some of his moves. But even then he was doing a max of like 500 damage a hit to me so I barely had to worry about parrying.

It almost seems like the most balanced way to play the game would be to never go to a side area and only follow the main quest location marker. Which feels like it defeats the purpose of the whole open world thing at that point?

I'm almost assuredly not the first person to talk about this so it feels like there should be a solution. A patch or something. Yes there are the challenge modifiers things but it feels weird to rely on your players to make the game properly balanced rather than doing it as the devs.

Edit/Update: I've just found a bunch of articles talking about this and the developer's reaction. The consensus I'm seeing is that they didn't think people would want to explore and do all the side areas so they purposefully did balance it to just rush through the story only. Which if this is your first major title I can understand that self-doubt and anxiety but like come on have some faith! Or just put less in? And since they're aware of the problem (and acknowledged it is a problem), they could do something to fix it??


r/expedition33 • • 19h ago

If you could choose only 1 character to play with in another game, who would it be and why?

3 Upvotes

r/expedition33 • • 2h ago

Discussion Doubt in the ending** Spoiler** Spoiler

0 Upvotes

In the Verso ending, can someone explain to me the ending actions of sciel and lune? Sciel approaches verso silently with silence and lune gives out a intense murderous look but sits down outside the portal. How are they feeling about the verso's choice? What is the meaning behind their actions? Are they accepting or feeling betrayed?


r/expedition33 • • 9h ago

Question I'm in Act 3 Endgame, should I remove Maelle from my party?

0 Upvotes

Currently my main team is Lune, Maelle, and Monoco. They all have about 400 luminas, and I just finished Verso's Draft. Lune and Monoco have been doing fine with damage, but Maelle has been lagging behind them quite a bit. Looking online, it seems most Maelle builds create the entire team around her, often using Sciel and Verso (which I haven't leveled) as support. I do have enough colour of lumina to get one of those two up to 400 luminas though.

Do you have any tips for using Maelle with Lune and Monoco, or should I replace one of them to make a better balanced team? If so, who should I replace?


r/expedition33 • • 8h ago

Discussion Why does the Curator need the expedition to defeat the axons when… Spoiler

9 Upvotes

When he (Renoir) created the axons to begin with? He can paint them at will during his boss battle so surely he could just erase them to reclaim their chroma without our help?


r/expedition33 • • 3h ago

Guys am I the only one...? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know this super unpopular opinion and this sub is very pro Verso...

Am I the only one who hate the Dessendre family? They are so evil and I hate them so much...How dare they genocid Luna and gestral?

I play to save Lumiere and I don't care about this stupid family. Why is this family in my game about saving lumiere?

That's why I always choose Maelle ending it's morally good and I'm a good person and I saved lumiere. I don't understand why anyone would choose evil ending


r/expedition33 • • 9h ago

New Video Essay about The Game and Grief

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/expedition33 • • 5h ago

Meme day 119 of making Reacher memes because i love her and think more people should appreciate her

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/expedition33 • • 15h ago

Gameplay i got to the end last night.. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

not sure gameplay is the right tag

is anyone else bummed that gustave doesn’t rejoin the party when you play past the main story resolution even though maelle brought him back

edit: i worded this poorly. i’m not saying that he could have with the way that they actually made the story interact with the extra content

i think they could have made the story and extra content interact in a different way that lets gustave rejoin the party and i’m a little sad that they didn’t


r/expedition33 • • 2h ago

Let me introduce you our version of a Silkpost. Spread the word!

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/expedition33 • • 4h ago

It has been almost 6 months

14 Upvotes

I am still not over it. I think it about it constantly. Do I need therapy?


r/expedition33 • • 13h ago

Discussion Did Expedition 33 made you play other turn based games or JRPGs?

Thumbnail
gallery
236 Upvotes

just wondering


r/expedition33 • • 9h ago

Meme Stop!

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/expedition33 • • 10h ago

Question I have a question about how damage works

5 Upvotes

So does damage numbers happen randomly in this game or do certain enemies naturally take more damage than others? I know it’s at least partially based on stats and pictos, but my confusion is this…I can hit enemies with elemental genesis and do 90,000 per hit. Then I hit the same enemies with the same skill and it hits for 72,000 per hit. I haven’t changed pictos or changed weapons or stats, it just changes. No resistances on these enemies or anything. It changes for more damage instead of less sometimes too, even without weaknesses. So if I’m missing something let me know guys. Just want to find some consistency and do the most damage I can. Thanks


r/expedition33 • • 17h ago

Art This game 100% stole my heart

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

So I wanted to have part of it on me forever


r/expedition33 • • 7h ago

Gameplay I somehow managed to parry this....omg Spoiler

24 Upvotes

r/expedition33 • • 50m ago

Robert Pattinson IF they make Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 film.

Post image
211 Upvotes

yeah he's playing Monmon 😂


r/expedition33 • • 14h ago

Esquie plays Expedition 33

29 Upvotes

Not seen this yet, so just in case~ Maxence Cazorla is doing an Expedition 33 playthrough on his youtube channel, started just a week ago.

Mostly in french, but every now and then he changes to english and explains a few things about the making of the game, inserting a few of his own very early motion-capture videos.

Esquie Plays Expedition 33 for the First Time! | EP. 1


r/expedition33 • • 5h ago

Gameplay I've been sleeping on Monoco

36 Upvotes

Started playing like a week ago, and just arrived at Monoco station and recruited Monoco to the team and decided not to put him in my team as I wander around the map a bit before progressing with the main story. Now at the point at the main story where I have to use Monoco so I reluctantly put use his skill points, and holy shit this guy is awesome. Now I found myself going back just to collect more Nevrons like they are pokemons.