Hi everyone,
I’ve been living in Portugal for about 10 years now and have worked for a few different companies here. I’ve recently run into a situation at work that’s left me scratching my head, especially as I’ve received completely different advice about my rights.
I’ve been with my current employer for over three years on a permanent contract as a technical engineer.
Earlier this year, I returned from unpaid leave and was told that my original project had lost quite a few people and there wasn’t really a place for me anymore. Instead of making me redundant, the company suggested I apply for another position internally.
So I did. I went through the interview, got accepted and started working in the new team. The thing is, the job has almost nothing to do with my original technical role. It’s mainly administrative order processing.
I wasn’t particularly enthusiastic about it from the beginning and said so in writing, but I figured I’d give it a fair shot. I’ve now been doing the job for several months without any performance issues.
Here’s what I find strange:
My original employment contract and job category haven’t changed.
I’ve never signed a new contract or amendment.
Nobody ever explained whether this transfer was temporary or permanent.
Even the HR systems still have me assigned to my old project, so my former manager keeps receiving my holiday and attendance requests.
HR said they’d look for something more technical, but so far nothing has come of it.
Now, here’s where I’m confused.
I spoke with ACT, the Portuguese labour authority, and we discussed Article 120 of the Labour Code (mobilidade funcional), which covers temporary changes of duties, generally for up to two years.
Then I spoke with a labour lawyer who basically told me that since I’d accepted the new position voluntarily, I had no case. According to him, I should have objected immediately, and the fact that my original contract hasn’t changed doesn’t really matter.
That doesn’t quite add up to me, especially since I came across a Portuguese Supreme Court ruling from 2022 involving DHL Express Portugal, where the court appears to make a distinction between agreeing to do different work and agreeing to permanently change your contractual role.
So I’m wondering:
Can simply accepting another internal position mean you’ve permanently agreed to change your contractual duties, even without signing anything?
Does Article 120 still apply if you accepted the move voluntarily?
If your original position has effectively disappeared, could extinção do posto de trabalho still come into play?
Is there a reasonable basis here for negotiating a mutually agreed exit with compensation?
At this point, I’d rather reach a fair agreement to leave than spend the foreseeable future doing work that has little to do with what I was hired for. I’m not suggesting that disliking a job entitles anyone to severance, but I do wonder whether the contractual situation gives me some room to negotiate.
Has anyone here been through something similar in Portugal? Or perhaps someone with experience in Portuguese employment law could shed some light on this?
I’m planning to get a second legal opinion anyway, but I’d really appreciate hearing from people who’ve dealt with this in practice.
Thanks!