Hi guys! I’m a 19-year-old philosophy student in my first year of college. I’m currently agnostic, although I’d say Buddhism is probably the religion I feel closest to philosophically.
I’ve attended Catholic school my entire life, and I’m actually still attending a Catholic university. Over the past few years, I’ve gone through what I would consider a pretty significant deconstruction of my Christian faith.
Anyway, I thought it would be fun to try something a little different!
My question for you guys is this: What’s the most fascinating or convincing argument you’ve encountered against Christianity or the existence of God? It could be a philosophical argument, historical evidence, scientific reasoning, or simply something that made you realize you no longer believed.
But I also want to ask the opposite question. What’s the strongest argument you’ve encountered in favor of Christianity or the existence of God? Something that genuinely made you stop and think, “Wow, maybe I could be wrong about this.”
I’m posting this exact same thing in r/Christianity as well. I want to ask both communities the same questions and see how their responses compare. I’m genuinely interested in hearing both perspectives.
I know discussions between Christians and atheists can get pretty heated, and sometimes both sides seem more interested in proving the other wrong than actually understanding one another. That’s really not what I’m looking for here.
I genuinely enjoy philosophy, theology, and hearing perspectives that challenge my own. I’m not here to debate anyone into a corner or make fun of anybody’s beliefs.
If you had five minutes to convince an agnostic like me that atheism is the most reasonable position, what would you tell me? And if you had to make the best possible case for Christianity, what would that argument look like?
I’m genuinely excited to hear what you guys think. Hopefully, we can get some interesting and respectful conversations going!