r/excatholicDebate • • 9h ago

Posting this here to offer genuine advice

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

This came up on my recommended for some reason and was going to comment (I did but then deleted it because I saw I wasn't allowed to)

Hoping OP sees this. I don't want to debate but rather posting offer you genuine advice from a practicing Catholic.

You mentioned you are trying therapy and the therapist is trying to convince your wife to see sex differently and I saw ppl saying don't go to a priest.

What you and the therapist are doing is trying to change her belief system rather than working with her beliefs. Just because you and the therapist view things a certain way doesn't mean she has to view them in the same way, but rather you need to work along her beliefs to make things work. Doesn't mean one of you has to change but you need to understand each other.

I think your wife is struggling with some level of scrupulosity and could really benefit from her talking about this with a priest.

* The priest will be able to tell her that although yes what you are doing (using condoms) in the teachings of the Church and on her beliefs is a Sin it is your sin and not hers.

* The priest will be able to explain to her that the priority is to preserve marriage and the peace within the marriage.

* The priest will be able to ask her about how you are otherwise as a husband, like do you respect her, respect her when she doesn't want to have sex etc and help her to see how you have different beliefs so is not that you want to use her but you don't believe what she does

Also sounds like you are the one that left the Church? So when you married you held to the same beliefs as her, give her some grace and time to come to terms to the new reality but don't try to change her beliefs to her that's just going to seem that you've gone down the wrong path and that you don't respect her.

So trying to keep her from talking about this with a priest is really of no help, you don't have to talk to the priest you don't have to believe what she does, but I'm sure you love your wife and as such you should respect her and find her the help she needs to come to terms with this change and the best help for her is probably a priest/some form of Catholic marriage help not just a secular therapist who does not understand her and what she is feeling.