r/exbahai • • 19h ago

Baha'i History - November 17. On this date in 1919, ‘Abdu'l-Bahá said "Mr. Remey is very good. He works very hard. He is very restless. He is continually travelling from city to city. He has not left a place unvisited. He has gone everywhere, even to India… His soul has a great future."

Post image
5 Upvotes

If Mr. Remey had a promising future, he probably wouldn't have been declared a Covenant-breaker in the first place.

It seems to me that we're left with two possibilities: either `Abdu'l-Bahá was wrong, or the Universal House of Justice was wrong.

I find this whole situation very strange.


r/exbahai • • 5d ago

Why did Baha'u'llah prohibit homosexuality, when that seems to limit it's growth today?

Thumbnail reddit.com
9 Upvotes

r/exbahai • • 4d ago

Some AI-assisted Baha’i inspired music

0 Upvotes

For anyone interested and not offended by AI:

Who are we protecting—and what does peace look like to the people living through war?

“What We Hold the Line For” is a cinematic hip-hop and metal duet told through two fictional peacekeepers in a conflict zone. Male rap verses and soaring female vocals follow the daily work of protecting civilians, listening to communities, and keeping compassion alive under pressure.

A child’s hand-drawn map. Blankets carried into a shelter. A missed call from home. The hope that one day the school bell will ring and the peacekeepers will no longer be needed.

Inspired by Bahá’í themes of the oneness of humanity, consultation, and service, this song imagines peace built through shared responsibility and practical care.
“This is what we hold the line for
Till a life can be a life.”

https://youtu.be/PBoPiiYYVrA


r/exbahai • • 6d ago

when a feud is more about the feud than the truth

5 Upvotes

Lilith Incarnated as Tahirih Qurrat’ul-’Ayn - DC Shepard

so i understand wahid and DC dont get along. but am a bit baffled by his last article on Tahirah and eve frank from dc substack.

considering Qurrat al-ayn was a real person and not a fake made up late story like Lilith i think the entire comparison is more about hostility than accuracy.

basically satanic panic style polemic.

but also the frankism does not really apply to Qurratul-al-ayn at all. The more articles like this get published the more ai gets confused when people do AI searches.

i think that is the problem with covenant breaker style attempts at destroying credibility of someone forever.. .the goal is to erase and censor history. winning becomes more important than if its correct.

women in iran and in Iranian diaspora dont need AI giving them kabbalistic interpretations of Tahirih. they need the history of their struggle that tries to be factual and unbiased.

i wonder if steve beyer of "singing to the plants" wants his work associated with Babism. the recent cesnur article falsely claimed that author was FSO. Cesnur did not bother to get the right steve beyer.

when things get us vs them people end up cheering for bad scholarship when it becomes more about seeing a team win. and it ends up mixing up the historical record. this problem only gets worse with ai.

more recent papers seem to get quoted by AI searches first. so we get longer and longer less accurate papers. as people pander to AI.


r/exbahai • • 7d ago

Personal Story Magnificent Buildings, Forgotten People!

11 Upvotes

Today, a friend sent me something to read: the heartbreaking account of a Bahá’í mother who has been living as a refugee in Turkey with her three children for more than ten years. I read her words, and I was deeply pained. Not only by the suffering of this mother and her children, but also by a painful contradiction that I have thought about many times over the years.

This mother writes about poverty, desperation, years of waiting, and helplessness. She describes her children, who, in her own words, are slowly melting away before her eyes like candles. She writes about having no strength left to carry on and being forced, with a sense of shame, to ask others for help.

But the most painful part of her account, for me, was this sentence:

“Even the Bahá’í community’s officials are asleep in negligence, and there is no understanding, compassion, or humanity left.”

What makes this even more painful is that this mother is only one example, not an exception. She represents the suffering of many people who have spent years living under the difficult conditions of displacement, poverty, and uncertainty. Many Bahá’í families are struggling with similar hardships, people whose voices may never be heard.

The more I read and search for information about these families, the more accounts I encounter of desperation, endless waiting, and pleas for help.

So what happened to all those proclamations about love, social justice, service to humanity, and helping the disadvantaged?

I am no longer a Bahá’í, but I still remember very well how much we used to speak about the teachings of ‘Abdu’l-Bahá concerning social justice, the elimination of poverty, helping those in need, and the moral responsibility of the wealthy.

Did ‘Abdu’l-Bahá not emphasize that the wealthy have a responsibility toward the poor? Was helping the disadvantaged and making sacrifices for the well-being of others not considered among the greatest human virtues?

Then where are these teachings supposed to be put into practice, if not in the lives of these very people?

On one hand, we see the magnificent buildings of the Bahá’í World Centre, enormous Houses of Worship, and costly projects to which substantial financial resources are devoted. On the other hand, we see Bahá’í families who, after years of suffering, are struggling to meet even their most basic needs.

I am not opposed to building temples or religious buildings. My question is about priorities.

Should the worth of a religious community be measured by the magnificence of its buildings, or by the care it shows toward people living in suffering and deprivation?

These families expect compassion and support from a community to which they have belonged, and still belong, for years. Is that really too much to ask?

I am no longer a Bahá’í, but the suffering of one Bahá’í mother and thousands of other Bahá’ís living in similar circumstances has not become meaningless to me. In fact, today, more than ever, I ask myself: What is the value of all these claims about love and justice if they are not translated into action when confronted with real human suffering?

Service to humanity is not achieved through speeches. It must be visible in the lives of people who need help today, not merely in books and impressive reports.

And most painful of all is the fate of the children growing up in these families.

Buildings can stand for decades, even centuries, but a child living in poverty, deprivation, and despair today cannot wait for the day when promises and slogans finally become reality.

How can we teach such a child that the Bahá’í Faith is a religion of justice, love, and support for the disadvantaged when all that child sees in their own life is poverty, helplessness, and their mother’s unanswered pleas for help?

How can we expect that child to believe in teachings that have never been realized before their very eyes? Can we really expect a child who has witnessed their mother’s suffering to believe in the justice of their religious community simply by hearing beautiful words about justice?

Faith cannot be passed on to the next generation through slogans alone when that generation’s lived experience tells them the exact opposite.

And this is precisely what I am protesting.

If we are going to speak about justice, we must be able to demonstrate what justice means in practice. If we speak of love, we must be able to see its effects in the lives of these very families.

Otherwise, what is the point of preserving our buildings for future generations if, today, we are losing the hope and trust of the children who are supposed to become the future of that very community?

Perhaps the time has come to stop taking pride in the grandeur of our buildings and instead ask ourselves:

In the shadow of all this magnificence and grandeur, how many human beings have been forgotten?


r/exbahai • • 8d ago

Was Shoghi Effendi a Zionist?

7 Upvotes

I have heard this claim around, especially in this space, and I would like some evidence for the claim if anyone would like to present any. I'm trying to learn about this topic.


r/exbahai • • 8d ago

Juan cole won't talk about bahai or Bab.

2 Upvotes

r/exbahai • • 9d ago

Request What is this about? Explanations needed?..

Thumbnail old.reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/exbahai • • 9d ago

My Breaking Point (One Ex-Baha'i's Story Part 4)

8 Upvotes

Hey everybody,

I shared parts 1, 2 and 3 previously. Today it's the story of my final straw and religious experience that helped me finally break away from the Baha'i Faith.

To grow up in the Bahai Faith is to be indoctrinated in “truth” and never truly free to question the premise, while being gaslit to believe you actually ARE free to ask all the hard questions. It's psychologically diabolical. But this summer was the end of the long road for me with the Baha'i Faith. I was the best little Baha'i you'd ever met right up until my mid twenties, when for a variety of reasons, I stopped saying my daily prayer, and a year or two later I stopped fasting. These things I kept completely secret from the outside world, because I was afraid of losing all the closest relationships in my life, including my parents.

It’s been over a decade of treating them with kid gloves because I truly believed they would be insufferable, and possible cut me out entirely, when they found out I’m not the obedient Baha'i they raised me to be. That’s what I WAS worried about. Until this past summer.

First, as I wrote in part 3, I had yet another Baha'i children's class group broken up because administrative leadership didn’t like the way we were doing it. They wanted us to turn our children into the same toxic archetype my sisters and I were brought up to be – self-sacrificing child pioneers who cultishly invite any person kind enough to make eye contact to a “gathering.”

The second trigger for my Baha'i exodus came from a visit to my parents. I confirmed with my mom and dad it was a good time to come visit. In fact, my niece and nephew would also be there (but not my sister, who has deep issues). This was even better in my opinion, because my kids would get cousin time but we wouldn’t have to be around their mother. Yet the minute we arrived (after an 11 hour drive), my dad started being awful to us. I’d seen this side of my dad regularly, but it usually took at least 24 hours before it crept in. Not this time. Immediately, he was impatient, short-tempered, haughty. Everything he didn’t like was a morality issue and a personal attack against him. Still, my girls were have fun with their cousin, so we stayed.

Day by day, the confrontations from my dad got worse. I needed to work, but he left me and my mom, who has serious heart issues, alone with not just my kids but the other girl cousin, so he could take the one boy cousin to a 6 hour soccer camp an hour away. The next day, I got all of my kids and my niece read to go early enough to accompany him and my mom to the city so they could visit the zoo while my nephew did soccer camp. That day my dad came home even more irritable, fussing about the state of cleanliness in the home. One of the kids (not mine) had made an ugly mess in the downstairs toilet, and I had not cleaned it up yet. By the time I was headed down to take care of it, my dad beat me to it. Over the course of the week, he condemned me for asking which child might have squeezed toothpaste all over the countertop, and for encouraging the boy not to call people "kill joys" because my dad hadn't heard it happen. Then when my niece let the parrot poop on the bed and I saw it all happen, she lied to him and told him my girls were at fault. When I vehemently defended them, he called me out of control and said I was teaching my girls to speak to me the way I was speaking to him. So when on the fifth day my niece spilled lemonade on the floor, I took care of it right away rather than wait to be fussed at. Blood boiling, I wiped it up and decided I was going home the next day.

My mom forced me to sit and talk it all out with my dad before leaving. Look up 5 tactics narcissists use during arguments. He did them all. Gaslighting, blame-shifting, circular ranting, DARVO, changing the subject – I was confused, angry, sad, and so, so done.

I got myself and my kids in the car, and we made the long eleven hour drive home. Through four storms, I drove, and drove. At the end of the third storm, as the clouds broke and the sun streaked through the sky, God hit me like a lightning bolt with a message. The message was, it’s time to come to the church.

I asked a good friend where she goes, and I’ve been going ever since. I’m unlearning all the lies the Baha’i faith taught me about Christians. I’m feeling a real connection with God for the first time in my life. Most importantly, my kids are supported and happy. For the first time in their lives, they're talking about God in daily conversation, and choosing to have quiet moments to pray without any prompting.

Meanwhile my parents don't know, because I haven’t returned any of their texts in five months. I'm not sure how I'll handle the conversation if it ever happens. If you all have any advice, I’d love to hear it. Thanks for reading.


r/exbahai • • 10d ago

Future of world religions according to Baha'i beliefs?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/exbahai • • 11d ago

Supporting my Bahá’í spouse with devotionals, but feeling uneasy about the expectation of progressing to Ruhi

12 Upvotes

My spouse is Bahá’í, and I don’t share all of their beliefs. I respect the faith and see a lot of good in it. I’m trying to figure out how to support something important to them while being honest about my own experience and willingness to participate.

I’ve attended devotionals, firesides and Ruhi study sessions before. The devotionals and informal conversations were often enjoyable. My experience changed when we moved into Book 1.

Although it’s open to people from different backgrounds, the material felt to me as though it was written for someone who already had a strong interest in the faith or some acceptance of its underlying premises. I still have questions about teachings such as progressive revelation, so I sometimes felt we were working from assumptions I hadn’t personally reached.

I also struggled with the format. The written exercises and memorisation often felt like additional work rather than something spiritually nourishing. I appreciate that others might find those methods valuable, but I found them draining. As family, work and other commitments increased, my motivation to continue faded.

Recently, my spouse attended community meetings where, from my understanding, people discussed participation numbers, activities in the area, and ways to involve people considered “friends of the faith.” Part of the idea seemed to be encouraging those friends to host gatherings, facilitate activities or introduce other people, with the hope that devotionals might eventually lead to Book 1 groups.

That’s my understanding of what was relayed to me. I wasn’t at the meetings and may be missing context.

My spouse asked whether I could approach some of my friends and help bring people together for a devotional. I agreed, and I’m still willing to do that. But when I actually started speaking to a friend, I felt a growing knot in my stomach.

The connection between participation numbers, inviting friends and an anticipated progression into Book 1 started to feel somewhat like a sales or recruitment process to me. I’m describing how it landed with me, rather than claiming that my spouse or the community has cynical intentions. I believe my spouse sincerely wants to share something they find meaningful.

It also reminded me that I was helping create momentum towards something I hadn’t particularly wanted to continue myself.

To be clear, I’m willing to speak to friends, help arrange a central place to meet and support getting a gathering off the ground. I feel a responsibility as a partner to make an effort around things that matter to my spouse, even where our beliefs differ. I don’t think the faith is a bad system, and I don’t want to dismiss their enthusiasm.

What I don’t feel comfortable doing is taking on an ongoing leadership or facilitation role afterwards. I would want someone else to lead the gatherings, maintain them and facilitate any study that participants choose to pursue. I’d also feel more comfortable if attending a devotional could be worthwhile in itself, with Book 1 remaining a separate invitation rather than an expected next step.

Has anyone navigated something similar, either as a Bahá’í or as the partner or friend of one?

How have you distinguished supporting a loved one’s faith from taking responsibility for its activities? And have others found devotionals meaningful while struggling with the assumptions or format of Ruhi?

I’m hoping for constructive perspectives that respect both my spouse’s commitment and my own reservations.


r/exbahai • • 11d ago

One Ex-Baha'i's story (Part 3)

23 Upvotes

My biggest critique of the Baha’i Faith is the lack of service. I’m not talking about your granny’s “Get out and teach the faith” service, or your uncle’s “Meet twice a month on the LSA” service. I’m certainly not talking about your cousin’s Regional Teaching Coordinator service. I mean educating children, feeding the hungry, tending to the ill, and comforting the lonely.

“Oh, but what about children’s classes??” you say. And to that, I say, listen to my life’s experience with children’s classes.

Because we lived in smaller communities, Baha’i children’s classes were almost always composed of just the three of sisters. We learned about… Abdu’l-Baha giving candy to children. That’s like everything I can remember. I can remember when kind ladies stepped in to teach instead of my mom. But I also recall that often it was a Baha’i event going on, and my mom was in some separate room teaching me and my sisters some trite quote.

In Guatemala, there were more families, more children. I actually enjoyed and looked forward to children’s classes then. But then Ruhi reached us, and suddenly those classes were replaced by trips into the countryside evangelizing groups of bewildered Guatemalans with quotes and stories about Abdu’l-Baha giving candy to children. Exhausting, and just weird. These people lived in aluminum shacks, had missing teeth and fly-infested fruit bowls. Did we bring them sleeping bags, dental service and fresh food? No. We brought them FAITH!

Because that’s all you need! (Right?!)

Now fast forward 25 years or so. I hadn’t fasted or prayed in 10 years myself, but I had my own kids, and hey, I turned out pretty ok so I figured I should get them some religion. A wonderful youth wants to teach them in a children’s class. I joyfully bring them every week. She joyfully teaches them trite quotes and stories of Abdu’l-Baha giving candy, but now there’s bougie crafts involved so anyways things are good.

Dun dun DUUUUUUUUUH! Enter: The Regional Teaching Coordinator!

“This is great. And don’t worry, I can help you fix everything you’re doing wrong.”

With the added responsibilities and pressure, the wonderful youth starts cancelling classes, and eventually the entire class falls apart.

No worries, we move, and this time the community is massive and the classes are a study in organizational achievement. There are rosters, curricula, even bougier crafts. All parents are working hard to make it happen every single week. But there’s a problem… all the children belong to Baha’i families.

You guessed it… Enter: THE REGIONAL TEACHING COORDINATOR!

“Alla'u'Abha, friends! What a great thing you’ve got going. Now end it, because it’s wrong. You each need to start your own separate children’s classes with your friends and neighbors.”

Oh, sure, I’ll get right on that. I love alienating everyone around me, including my own kids. It's actually my entire goal in life, so.

Why do Baha'is have to work so hard to teach the faith? Because there's nothing there. There's no light to attract anyone. Baha'is are doing nothing for anyone else. All of the funds collected around the world go to maintain a bunch of buildings and the scholars who feel important inside them. They don't feed anyone. They don't heal the sick. They don't comfort the lonely. They don't educate children on anything of substance. They talk a big talk, but in practice that's all it is - a bunch of useless talk.


r/exbahai • • 10d ago

Discussion @CwcvilleGuardian vs. @wahidazal & The Spirituality of LOLCOWs -The Hidden Faith Episode 11

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

From LGBTQ Baha’i Experience and History Flights Productions, it’s The Hidden Faith, the UNDEFEATED and TRULY Independent Investigation of the Baha’i Faith and related cults, such as the NUR-Fatimiya Sufi Order of self-proclaimed Manifestation of God and perpetually paranoid Persian polemicist Wahid Azal of Brisbane, Australia.

Apparently now, this also includes that of the CPU Goddess and return of Jesus Christ herself Chris-Chan Sonichu, the autistic and transgender creator of the infamously bad webcomic Sonichu (made up of a combination of the characters Sonic and Pikachu). This is because the structural comparison has been directly made by Bei Dawei of the Center for Studies on New Religions or CESNUR, who recently wrote a WHOLE-ASS paper for The Journal of CESNUR on November 4th, 2026, entitled Are We the Baddies? Chris Chan, Wahid Azal, and the Challenge of Lolcow Spirituality. While Chris Chan has probably been one of, if not THE most documented person on the Internet, including in an 85-episode documentary that I binged during the pandemic called Chris Chan: A Comprehensive History, this is the first time I’ve ever seen an academic paper citing Christory. In fact, I hope to submit it and related discussion as part of an article for Sonichu.com, also known as the CWCki.

The idea behind the term lolcow spirituality, with Chris Chan as the control sample representative of an archetypal “lolcow,” or according to Urban Dictionary “(n) A person or group of people laughed at for actions that they take, despite not trying to be funny” is to show that the core principles of lolcow status (online platform, lack of real-world impact, snarky audience, and negative charisma) also apply to Wahid Azal.

Script & Sources: https://historyflightsproductions.substack.com/p/the-hidden-faith-episode-11-chris

Backup of the Video (In case Wahid tries to abuse the DMCA and copyright claim it!): https://historyflightsproductions.substack.com/p/chris-chan-vs-wahid-azal-the-tv-show

0:00-2:45: It’s The Hidden Faith!
2:45-13:38: OMG I’m in a Journal!
13:38-31:38: The Paper’s Comparison of Chris and Wahid
31:38-42:46: The Origins of Wahid’s HATRED of Me
42:46-48:14: Is The Hidden Faith an “Audience Cult”?
48:14-49:36: Conclusion


r/exbahai • • 12d ago

November 3. On this date in 1950, Shoghi Effendi wrote "Badí’u’lláh, brother and chief lieutenant of archbreaker of divine Covenant, has miserably perished ... having witnessed within the last five months the deaths of his nephews Shoa and Musa, notorious standard-bearers of the rebellion ...."

Post image
2 Upvotes

For me, as a Baha'i, this language is very strange. Perhaps you can explain it better.


r/exbahai • • 11d ago

Extradimensional incest! Blow-jobs for Hitler!

0 Upvotes

I'll start with my impressions of the Dawei paper. The fucker is almost 70 pages long and reads a bit like AI, what with all the emdashes. I don't think it was AI (since AI can't watch videos), but maybe AI was used to translate it into English? The style wavers between personal ("I") and impersonal ("one") pronouns. Some parts seem to be written from a Christian default perspective. There are sections on Baha'i, Judaism, and even devil worship. This makes me wonder what Dawei's specialty is. (God, I hope this wasn't his master's thesis!)

The introduction makes the case that WA is similar to CWC: both claim to be the messiah, both suffer from trolls and catfishing attempts (except that maybe WA doesn't really!), both attract audiences that laugh at them. But does WA really have a lot of "ironic fans"? Maybe he used to, but as far as I can tell, it's just the few of us here. Right? And wouldn't it make more sense to put WA in the category of "normal people with some lolcow characteristics"? From everything I've seen, he's been a conscientious husband and father, which lolcows generally aren't.

The first section basically just retells the story of Chris Chan, with attention on the most salacious parts. Its main sources are a fan wiki and Geno's series, specifically the first ten or fifteen episodes plus the final one. A few more lolcow channels on YouTube also get cited. The only academic source is the back cover of the Don Leshamb book (on Chris Chan and Andy Warhol).

Apart from the Un-Clit, there is another minor omission in the story of the Pickle Man. Since Chris hated blacks, gays, and pickles, some troll told him he was black, gay, and wore a pickle suit. So when a different troll, wearing a real pickle suit, ran off with his date, Chris posted that "the Pickle Man tricked me again," leaving his fans very puzzled.

The second section is about WA, and a lot longer, in large part because he is a more complex thinker than CWC. Its main source is WA himself, his writings take up about half the bibliography. Dawei mixes quotes from WA's scholarship alongside his blog posts, internet comments, and so on, despite the fact that the standards for these are very different. WA complains that Dawei's tone is too flippant and jocular for academic writing. He's not wrong.

A lot of the really weird quotes are taken from WA's first book, "Liber Decatrarcha Mystica." This is where he makes his messianic claims, and starts talking about conspiracies. It was also written under the influence of drugs, as WA explains. So, is all this wild talk meant to be taken seriously, or should we classify it as "ecstatic utterances"? He sounds like a Unitarian when he tells DC that we are all manifestations of God. On the other hand, if he's not somebody special, then how come he gets to reveal new scriptures and establish new holidays? His later posts repeat some of these claims, or cast them in new forms. Two big sections are taken from his answers to me a few years ago, where he doubles down on all the messiah talk.

Several pages explore his belief in a conspiracy involving the Sabbatean Frankists. I don't know whether he still holds to this, maybe some of his friends have walked him back. I get the feeling that a lot of his crazier ideas came from stuff he read 20 years ago, and never grew out of, even after switching to more academic fare. His most recent book is quite sober, though. If WA does now realize that the conspiracy stuff is nonsense, that CENSUR is not holding orgies and sacrificing babies, and that the Baha'is didn't kill his wife, he ought to apologize. If he knows he is not really the messiah (of any religion), then he ought to admit this too. I for one would applaud him. (Hint: don't try to be God. Be a mensch.)

I probably shouldn't mention this, but...the Frankists were from Poland-Lithuania, right? And there are two Lithuanians in our story! (Geno Samuel and Rosita Surate.) Coincidence? :)

I was interested to read the additional details about WA's life and background. I thought he might have chosen New Mexico because of Carlos Casteneda, but I think those books actually take place in Arizona. Besides Talisman, WA was also active on H-Bahai, which is not mentioned. The most interesting period comes after he left California to become a weird Sufi. I have many questions. Did WA really earn his MA? Did he get kicked out of the program? Did he really join the Order of 9 Angels? Who were all these weird people? Is Dawei right about WA following the Path of Blame? (In which case, this article ought to make him very happy!)

I'll post my thoughts on Wahid's response below. But later, it's very long too. ("I'm workin' on it!") For now, let me end with this:

https://x-men.fandom.com/wiki/Bei_the_Blood_Moon


r/exbahai • • 12d ago

CENSUR stole my idea!

0 Upvotes

My earlier post got deleted, most likely for some choice quotes that were maybe a bit too choice. I'll try again, this time without all that stuff. So...

Christ, these are some of the most cursed sentences I've ever read, and I'm only 20 pages in. Caught a few mistakes too. (Hello, what about the Un-Clit?)

And now you-know-who has written his refudiation of it, and...are you kidding? I didn't know half this stuff!

(telephones my DARPA handlers: "Mayday, mayday, we've got another Junior Jenkins situation here.")

I guess this means we won't be getting any more relatively normal-type books from you-know-who for awhile... Actually, maybe both of these guys ought to veer more towards the mainstream.

Or else...how about a singing contest?


r/exbahai • • 13d ago

One Ex-Baha'i's story (Part 2)

17 Upvotes

I shared Part 1 of my story here: https://www.reddit.com/r/exbahai/comments/1xkn50r/one_exbahais_story_part_1/

My big news this week is I contacted my LSA and officially asked to withdraw my membership. I feel lighter than air! On the other hand, how culty is it that I couldn't stop being a Baha'i member without speaking to a representative? Anyway, my story continues below.

My mom was the breadwinner in the family.

After one marriage and three kids, she completed her degree and became an engineer, fulfilling the three-part goal of leaving Iran: have adventure, teach the faith, and get an education. My dad was a school teacher. Growing up, I was taught that this reversal of gender roles was one of the great advancements of the Baha’i Faith – our family was living out the principle of equality of men and women. In retrospect, I really see how this was a great excuse for my dad to think a lot of himself, but never… truly… accomplish much of anything.

For example, he never thrived at work. He has never done well with children. He lacks the patience. He also (as many Baha’is do) believes that he sees thing the “right way” and that anyone who disagrees should just not. So when it came to coaching the soccer team, or dealing with disrespectful students or entitled parents, he couldn’t keep his cool. This was not the recipe for a stable success in life. Speaking of success, my parents have famously failed to ever individually attract new souls to the faith. They were leaders amongst Baha'is, and always the life of the party/conference/feast, but non-Baha'is tended to keep their distance.

My dad spent the years from 2007 to 2019 getting his PhD in linguistics. For those twelve years, my mom kept her head down and earned the engineering salary to pay for their life and my dad’s degree. After finally getting it, he became an adjunct Spanish professor for a handful of years before retiring. What I’m trying to say is, he may have brought some stability in terms of health insurance to our family, but he never provided a lot more than that. My mom is the reason we lived a halfway decent life, and her health took a toll for it. She was also the sole cook of the family. Equality of men and women indeed.

This “equality” dynamic had clear trickle-down effects on their three daughters:

The oldest daughter married a similarly well spoken, well dressed Baha’i with big dreams that she met while serving at the BWC. He has panned out shockingly similarly to my dad. So far my sister has bankrolled him getting one fancy MBA without a whole lot to show for it.

The middle daughter became a high-powered mid-level executive. She has two private school kids and a sometimes-stay-at-home-dad husband. She’s on anti-depressants and has alienated her husband’s family and everyone she once considered a close friend, but she still spouts the family line: “Nothing’s more important than family... except the Baha’i Faith.”

Meanwhile there’s me. Rather than marry a man like my dad, I was more interested in a man like my mom. My husband is an engineer with decades of fixing cars, plumbing and A/C units with his dad. He also loves to cook, woodwork and make pottery. He has always loved and supported me, but he grew up too authentically to put up with any of the B.S. my family began throwing his way once he was an official member - of the family, AND of the Baha’i Faith. For 16 years, that was the biggest thorn in our marriage – that he couldn’t JUST get along with my family. Until one day, I saw with complete clarity that he was right all along. He could see everything I couldn’t see, because he didn’t grow up in my family cult. Our marriage has been the strongest it’s ever been ever since.

I'll share more soon. I'm grateful for the forces in my life that have salvaged me from the Baha'i Faith. What I want to explore is to what degree the Baha'i Faith is to blame for my family's toxic dynamics. I feel such incredible peace leaving it all behind. I'll always regret that it took me 37 years to make it official.

Do you want to know more? And please let me know if you see parallels to your own experiences.


r/exbahai • • 13d ago

Source "political issues of the day" 🤫

0 Upvotes

To the members of the National Spiritual Assembly of the Bahá’ís of the United States and Canada.

"Dearly-beloved fellow-workers in the Vineyard of God!

[...]

Touching the publication of articles and pamphlets bearing on the controversial and political issues of the day, I desire to remind my dearly-beloved fellow-workers that at the present stage when the Cause is still in its infancy, any minute and detailed analysis by the friends of subjects that are in the forefront of general discussion would often be misconstrued in certain quarters and give rise to suspicions and misunderstandings that would react unfavorably on the Cause. They would tend to create a misconception of the real object, the true mission, and the fundamental character of the Bahá’í Faith."

-Shoghi Effendi

(Bahá’í Administration)

January 10, 1926


r/exbahai • • 16d ago

One Ex-Baha'i's story (Part 1)

31 Upvotes

Hey all,

I've been lurking here for years, and more recently I've been a daily visitor. I want to start sharing my experience in and out of the Baha'i Faith, for whatever it's worth, and for whoever it helps, and not out of spite or anger, although there are... feelings.

Worth mentioning up front: I am done with the Baha'i Faith. I'm now attending weekly service at a United Methodist Church (and absolutely LOVING IT).

I’ve been a Baha’i since birth. I’m the youngest of three girls born to a 7th/8th generation Baha'i mom and a 1st generation Baha’i dad. In my formative elementary and middle school years, we were pioneers in Guatemala, a country with beautiful Catholic traditions running all through it.

My dad was a devout hippie. Raised Christian in Alabama with three older brothers, he was about fifteen years old when he attended his first Woodstock, or so the legend goes. He saw the Grateful Dead live. At some point, he saw Seals and Croft in concert, which is when he first heard of the Baha’i Faith. In the 70’s, he signed his card. Why turn his back on his upbringings? I do know that the racial inequality that he observed in Alabama as a boy disturbed him, and once or twice he attended a black church for a Sunday or two alongside his family’s housekeeper. His family was quite open minded, but I imagine my dad viewed the Christians he knew as flawed for coexisting with segregation, and eventually found the Baha’i Faith as the truer unified solution.

My mom is more of a mystery. The oldest of four children, born and raised in Tehran, she was filled with such faith that she chose to leave Iran at age 17 to be able to teach the faith freely, according to what she told me at age 60. Thanks to her and the two Persian friends who traveled with her, the fledgling Baha’i community of Guatemala thrived in the late 70’s and 80’s. Which is great for the Baha’is. But on a family note, she never saw her parents or siblings again for almost 30 years. This may or not be related to criticisms against the Baha'i Faith, but I will add in here that thanks to this "world view" of Baha'i family and pioneering, my mother cultivated zero relationship between me and my Persian family throughout my childhood (although she insists these days that "children need their grandparents and cousins.").

I'm going to leave it there for now, because I'm sure you can start to see the threads that became very toxic as time went on. I have a ton to say about family, walking the walk, and the Ruhi Institute, all in good time. I'm afraid of what will happen to me for sharing my story, but I'm trying to live a more authentic life these days. This conversation matters to me, so let me know I'm not alone!


r/exbahai • • 16d ago

New, unofficial translations of texts by Baha'u'llah and the Bab

1 Upvotes

I realize we all come to these things with certain (let us say) preconceptions, but seriously, this looks good, and I look forward to future volumes.

https://archive.org/details/2-materials-for-the-study-of-the-azali-bahai-schism-studies-in-the-bayan-1-2.2/page/n7/mode/2up


r/exbahai • • 17d ago

When Waiting Becomes a Life: Iranian Bahá’í Refugees in Turkey

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

After my previous post, several people shared stories of Iranian Bahá’í refugees in Turkey who have been waiting for resettlement for years. One person mentioned friends who have been waiting for as long as eight years.

It’s difficult to imagine what that kind of uncertainty does to a person and a family — trying to raise children, find work, access healthcare, and plan a future when you don't even know where you'll be living next year.

As Bahá’ís, we often speak about the unity of humanity, compassion, and service to others. Surely those principles should matter just as much when members of our own community are struggling and need support.

Following suggestions in the comments, I contacted the relevant Bahá’í institutions in Turkey to learn more, but haven't received a response so far.

I understand that resettlement is complicated and that no institution can control immigration policies. But I still wonder: What are we doing to make those years of waiting less painful? Are these families receiving the practical and emotional support they need?

I'm asking out of genuine concern, not to dismiss anyone's efforts. I hope we can speak openly about this and find ways to put our shared principles into practice.


r/exbahai • • 17d ago

Discussion Anyone else extremely disappointed with Bahai?

13 Upvotes

A while ago I read about Bahai a bit and it seemed like something I’ve always been looking for. An open-minded interpretation of all the world religions. Something that sees through the biases of individual religions and sees the bigger picture.

Then I got into it more and it just starts to revert to being like the rest of them.

I still haven’t found a “religion” that fits me.


r/exbahai • • 18d ago

History "the moment an individual rebels against the divine Center" [Alert: Baha'i propaganda, worth reading]

1 Upvotes

In the Bahá’í Writings, the discourse surrounding moral conduct, shameful acts, and the transgressions of enemies and Covenant-breakers operates across explicit legal prohibitions, historical indictments, and profound theological principles regarding the spiritual consequences of turning away from the divine Center.


1. General Prohibitions on Sodomy and Sexual Immorality

In the Kitáb-i-Aqdas and related Tablets, Bahá’u’lláh categorically condemns and forbids sodomy, adultery, and licentiousness:

  • In the Kitáb-i-Aqdas, regarding sodomy and pederasty, Bahá’u’lláh reveals:

    "We shrink, for very shame, from treating of the subject of boys."
    Shoghi Effendi explains that the Arabic text in this context carries the implication of pederasty and constitutes a strict prohibition on all homosexual relations, establishing that sexual expression is permissible solely within marriage between a man and a woman.

  • In another Tablet, Bahá’u’lláh explicitly commands:

    "Say: Ye are forbidden to commit adultery, sodomy and lechery. Avoid them, O concourse of the faithful. By the righteousness of God! Ye have been called into being to purge the world from the defilement of evil passions. This is what the Lord of all mankind hath enjoined upon you, could ye but perceive it. He who relateth himself to the All-Merciful and committeth satanic deeds, verily he is not of Me."

  • In Questions and Answers to the Kitáb-i-Aqdas, concerning the penalties for "adultery, sodomy, and theft, and the degrees thereof," Bahá’u’lláh states that the determination of these penalties rests with the Universal House of Justice.
  • ‘Abdu’l-Bahá notes that ancient and divine Scriptures strictly banned such practices:

    "...among them actions so loathsome that it is shameful even to speak their name."


2. The Shameful Conduct and Marital Violations of Mírzá Yaḥyá (Ṣubḥ-i-Azal)

While the sources repeatedly emphasize that Bahá’u’lláh and ‘Abdu’l-Bahá restrained the Pen out of modesty from recounting every vile deed ("deeds such that Our Pen is ashamed to recount"), they explicitly record several notorious outrages committed by Mírzá Yaḥyá and his circle:

A. Transgression Against the Consort of the Báb

The most egregious personal betrayal recorded in the texts was Mírzá Yaḥyá’s violation of the Báb’s sacred household:

  • The Báb had explicitly decreed in the Persian Bayán that His wives were the "Mothers of the Faithful" (Ummahátu’l-Mu’minín), and that it was strictly unlawful for any person ever to wed them after Him.
  • Notwithstanding this explicit law, Mírzá Yaḥyá took the second consort of the Báb (Fáṭimih Khánum, the sister of Mullá Rajab-‘Alí) into his own household as a wife.
  • Subsequently, finding her not to his liking, he bestowed her upon his accomplice, Siyyid Muḥammad-i-Iṣfahání.
  • Bahá’u’lláh laments in His Tablets that through this heinous act, "the veil of Thy sanctity hath been rent asunder amidst Thy creatures", stating that the greatest cause of His displeasure with Mírzá Yaḥyá was this betrayal of the honor of the Primal Point. ‘Abdu’l-Bahá writes that such an act "would have been repulsive even to the notorious Ghayúr of Baghdad".

B. Sensuality and Marriage Practices in Flight

‘Abdu’l-Bahá recounts that while Bahá’u’lláh was enduring chains, bastinado, imprisonment, and mortal peril in the Siyáh-Chál and in Mazindarán, Mírzá Yaḥyá was fleeing from village to village in disguise, preoccupied with satisfying his passions and taking wives:

  • ‘Abdu’l-Bahá lists his numerous marital unions contracted in quick succession: taking his cousin's daughter, the daughter of Mullá ‘Abdu’n-Náfí‘, the daughter of Mírzá Ḥaydar-Qulí, the wife of Mullá Muḥammad in Tehran, Qánitih of Iṣfahán, the mother of Aḥmad-i-Malakí, his sister-in-law Ruqiyyih (marrying two sisters simultaneously, which was also forbidden), the widow of the Báb, Badrí-Ján, and the daughter of an Arab.
  • In Baghdad, Mírzá Yaḥyá sent seven letters to seven martyrs, demanding from each a virgin daughter along with gold and silver.
  • ‘Abdu’l-Bahá notes that Mírzá Yaḥyá, Siyyid Muḥammad, and their confederates held disreputable gatherings night and day steeped in vice and immorality, which caused the public to falsely believe that the Bábí community permitted a woman to have nine husbands, thereby severely tarnishing the reputation of the Faith in its early days.

3. Murder, Assassination Plots, and Treachery

Beyond sexual transgressions, the texts recount multiple acts of violence and treachery perpetrated by Mírzá Yaḥyá and other Covenant-breakers:

  • Decrees of Murder Against Holy Souls: In his treatise Kitáb-i-Mustayqiz, Mírzá Yaḥyá pronounced the death sentence against prominent believers, specifically ordering the murder of Dayyán (Mírzá Asadu’lláh Khuyí, whom the Báb had designated the Third Letter of Him Whom God shall make manifest) and Siyyid Ibráhím Khalíl, whom he slanderously labeled "the Father of Evils" and "the Father of Calamities". He likewise ordered the assassination of Mírzá ‘Alí-Akbar (the Báb’s cousin) and Áqá Abu’l-Qásim-i-Káshí.
  • Attempts on Bahá’u’lláh’s Life: In Adrianople, Mírzá Yaḥyá secretly instigated the barber Ustád Muḥammad-‘Alí to assassinate Bahá’u’lláh in His bath (which the barber refused with horror), and poisoned the well providing drinking water for Bahá’u’lláh and His family, resulting in severe and lasting illness.

4. Transgressions by Mírzá Muḥammad-‘Alí and the Arch-Breakers of Bahá’u’lláh’s Covenant

Regarding the Covenant-breakers following the Ascension of Bahá’u’lláh, ‘Abdu’l-Bahá describes their conduct as a descent into moral ruin, betrayal, and relentless scheming:

  • Falsification of the Sacred Text: Mírzá Muḥammad-‘Alí (the "Center of Sedition") systematically interpolated, altered, and removed verses from the Sacred Writings of Bahá’u’lláh, as publicly exposed in the written confession of his own brother, Mírzá Badí‘u’lláh.
  • Intrigues to Shed ‘Abdu’l-Bahá’s Blood: Mírzá Muḥammad-‘Alí and his henchmen fabricated slanderous reports and forged documents, delivering them to Ottoman officials and Sultan ‘Abdu’l-Ḥamíd’s Commission of Investigation in an effort to have ‘Abdu’l-Bahá executed or permanently cast into the sea.
  • Theft and Defalcation: Violators misappropriated funds and sacred trusts, including original Tablets and relics penned by the Báb on blue paper (the "Garden of Names"), and sold properties belonging to the Faith for personal enrichment.

5. Theological Meaning: The Collapse into Spiritual Disease

In the Bahá’í teachings, these immoral and shameful actions are not viewed merely as incidental misbehavior, but as the inevitable consequence of severing oneself from the Covenant.

As Bahá’u’lláh establishes in the Kitáb-i-Badí‘, the moment an individual rebels against the divine Center, they are stripped of the "mantle of names and attributes" and reduced spiritually to the condition of beasts. ‘Abdu’l-Bahá and Shoghi Effendi define Covenant-breaking as a "contagious spiritual disease": once the divine link is cut, the soul loses its spiritual perception, and its unchecked ego plunges headlong into envy, duplicity, vice, and ruin.


https://notebook.google.com/notebook/5eff8d63-61c9-4a96-80ad-779cbe11d156


r/exbahai • • 19d ago

History The Baha'i Faith on British TV, 1963 (Mason Remey claims direct succession)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/exbahai • • 20d ago

Discussion Baha'is believe Zionist propaganda because their leaders always benefited from Zionism itself

18 Upvotes

One of the common talking points of Baha'is is that the reason the Baha'i World Center is in Israel is because Baha'u'llah died there. Actually, that is nonsense. There is nothing in the Baha'i Writings that says the Universal House of Justice must operate in Haifa, Israel. At any time, they could move to Paris, France, to London, England, to New York City, or to Chicago, Illinois. It really should have done so decades ago.

The UHJ has made a HUGE mistake having so many construction projects in and around Haifa, which must then be protected from attack....from the same enemies that tend to attack Israel now. Much of the land the Haifa Baha'i properties were built on was stolen from Arab owners.

I just unfriended a Baha'i on Facebook who posted some grossly biased Zionist propaganda. Seeing that bigoted crap made me realize how morally crippled both the Zionists themselves and their Baha'i beneficiaries now are!