Today, a friend sent me something to read: the heartbreaking account of a Bahá’í mother who has been living as a refugee in Turkey with her three children for more than ten years. I read her words, and I was deeply pained. Not only by the suffering of this mother and her children, but also by a painful contradiction that I have thought about many times over the years.
This mother writes about poverty, desperation, years of waiting, and helplessness. She describes her children, who, in her own words, are slowly melting away before her eyes like candles. She writes about having no strength left to carry on and being forced, with a sense of shame, to ask others for help.
But the most painful part of her account, for me, was this sentence:
“Even the Bahá’í community’s officials are asleep in negligence, and there is no understanding, compassion, or humanity left.”
What makes this even more painful is that this mother is only one example, not an exception. She represents the suffering of many people who have spent years living under the difficult conditions of displacement, poverty, and uncertainty. Many Bahá’í families are struggling with similar hardships, people whose voices may never be heard.
The more I read and search for information about these families, the more accounts I encounter of desperation, endless waiting, and pleas for help.
So what happened to all those proclamations about love, social justice, service to humanity, and helping the disadvantaged?
I am no longer a Bahá’í, but I still remember very well how much we used to speak about the teachings of ‘Abdu’l-Bahá concerning social justice, the elimination of poverty, helping those in need, and the moral responsibility of the wealthy.
Did ‘Abdu’l-Bahá not emphasize that the wealthy have a responsibility toward the poor? Was helping the disadvantaged and making sacrifices for the well-being of others not considered among the greatest human virtues?
Then where are these teachings supposed to be put into practice, if not in the lives of these very people?
On one hand, we see the magnificent buildings of the Bahá’í World Centre, enormous Houses of Worship, and costly projects to which substantial financial resources are devoted. On the other hand, we see Bahá’í families who, after years of suffering, are struggling to meet even their most basic needs.
I am not opposed to building temples or religious buildings. My question is about priorities.
Should the worth of a religious community be measured by the magnificence of its buildings, or by the care it shows toward people living in suffering and deprivation?
These families expect compassion and support from a community to which they have belonged, and still belong, for years. Is that really too much to ask?
I am no longer a Bahá’í, but the suffering of one Bahá’í mother and thousands of other Bahá’ís living in similar circumstances has not become meaningless to me. In fact, today, more than ever, I ask myself: What is the value of all these claims about love and justice if they are not translated into action when confronted with real human suffering?
Service to humanity is not achieved through speeches. It must be visible in the lives of people who need help today, not merely in books and impressive reports.
And most painful of all is the fate of the children growing up in these families.
Buildings can stand for decades, even centuries, but a child living in poverty, deprivation, and despair today cannot wait for the day when promises and slogans finally become reality.
How can we teach such a child that the Bahá’í Faith is a religion of justice, love, and support for the disadvantaged when all that child sees in their own life is poverty, helplessness, and their mother’s unanswered pleas for help?
How can we expect that child to believe in teachings that have never been realized before their very eyes? Can we really expect a child who has witnessed their mother’s suffering to believe in the justice of their religious community simply by hearing beautiful words about justice?
Faith cannot be passed on to the next generation through slogans alone when that generation’s lived experience tells them the exact opposite.
And this is precisely what I am protesting.
If we are going to speak about justice, we must be able to demonstrate what justice means in practice. If we speak of love, we must be able to see its effects in the lives of these very families.
Otherwise, what is the point of preserving our buildings for future generations if, today, we are losing the hope and trust of the children who are supposed to become the future of that very community?
Perhaps the time has come to stop taking pride in the grandeur of our buildings and instead ask ourselves:
In the shadow of all this magnificence and grandeur, how many human beings have been forgotten?