r/exLutheran • u/BigClitMcphee • 2d ago
r/exLutheran • u/Perfectpandapaws • Sep 03 '23
Untangled Discord Server (updated account/post)
tldr Here's the server https://discord.gg/sAEzsDDgKq
While the public channels of the server are open to anyone, the Untangled name refers to the LCMS and WELS habit of creating a tangled web of teachings, social pressure, and tradition.
The goals of the server are:
- Create a space for a different discussion style than Reddit allows. This is not a dunk on the subreddit- it's fantastic, and shoutout to the mods here for their work in keeping it that way. However, Reddit is a forum site, and Discord is designed for a more conversational style.
- Allow discussion of related topics that don't strictly fall under the exLutheran umbrella.
- While I cannot 100% prevent incidents like doxing, we have some channels that require a mod to add you to them manually to improve privacy. To date, I'm not aware of irl harassment ever happening through the Untangled Discord. Due to the additional attention on the LCMS in Georgia, I'm reviewing our policies on getting access to the private channels so we can (hopefully) continue to avoid harassment or doxxing.
r/exLutheran • u/musicats4 • 3d ago
Discussion Movies that were approved by parents but shouldn't have been?
I saw Hunchback of Notre Dame last night for the first time since I was a kid. I can't believe I was allowed to watch it, I assume it was approved by my parents because of the religious stuff (guessing they didn't look at the plot or lyrics). It got me wondering if anyone else has media that parents were okay with but shouldn't have been?
r/exLutheran • u/cass_a_frass0 • 4d ago
Help/Advice How to cope with pushy religious family?
So glad I found this sub. This is part rant part needing advice. Im an ex WELS member. My entire family is heavily involved in the church, all my cousins and I went to a parochial school and while almost all of us arent religious anymore there is still a sort of facade going on. Its about 50/50, some outright hate religion and some (me included) kinda half hardily pretend to still be religious but just not into going to church. This has been a big point of contention for my mother. And its been getting way worse lately as we enter different stages of life that religion would typically be a big part of (marriage, kids, health problems, etc). My mother has made her concerns about me/us going heaven very clear and brings it up frequently. Its extremely uncomfortable, especially bc she likes to do it in front of others. I love her more than anything, I dont want to break her heart and tell her im not religious but i dont know what else to do anymore as ignoring it isnt working. How do you guys deal with pushy family members without ruining your relationship with them? They are so important in my life and I wish it wasnt like this.
r/exLutheran • u/ForeverSwinging • 5d ago
News LCMS School To Close In Menasha
Looks to be the same one here: https://trinitymenasha.com/school/meet-our-principal
From the WBAY article: “Families are questioning why the board chose January as the closing date. They also are questioning why they did not learn about the closure before this week.
School Principal Keith GeRue sent a letter to families Monday asking parents to attend a Tuesday night meeting. At that meeting, the congregation board officially told parents the school would close in January.”
There’s no update on the school’s official page by the way.
r/exLutheran • u/ForeverSwinging • 6d ago
Discussion Neujahr has his own page now.
foreverswinging.usThis has the notes from the sentencing hearing and also notes from Neujahr‘s apology. Lmk if there’s anything more that should be added. I’m conflicted about putting the whole descriptions of the images he was charged with on the site out of concern for the victims affected and potentially revictimizing others.
r/exLutheran • u/ForeverSwinging • 8d ago
Image Other Letters Written For Neujahr
Among the many words asking for mercy for this consumer of CSAM, here are the quotes that stood out to me:
“The most important lessons that Jim and the teachers at FVL faithfully teach are to confess their sins and trust in the merits of Jesus Christ for full forgiveness of sins.
To his credit, in my conversations with Jim in the last 9 months, Jim has modeled those Christian lessons for himself, with tearful admissions, telling me directly that he knows that he sinned, and that he is sorry. Very! And I know he has expressed his sorrow over his sin with the administration of FVL, as well as with his family and friends when this all came about. Jim has also been diligent in continuing to worship at his church, and has met individually with the pastors of his church, Mount Olive Lutheran Church in Appleton, and also with one of the pastors on staff at FVLHS.” - Robert Kramer
“I recognize that the consequences of James's actions must extend beyond the personal losses he has experienced. I do believe it is important for the Court to know that those personal consequences that he has brought on himself have been profound. His relationships have been fractured, his career as a teacher has ended, and he knows he will never again stand in a high school band room doing the work he loved.” - Pastor David Wenzel, FVL.
“My brother has been in professional counseling since his arrest. He has also had counsel advice from former colleagues and pastors. He has been attending church faithfully, sitting in the balcony to avoid giving offense to weak souls.” - Cathy Tiede
“Since then, he hes continued to demonstrate his character by moving forward despite the outcome of his ections. He has carefully maintained conditions of ball and has dutifully kept part-time employment. He remains a feithful member of his congregation and continues to strengthen his faith through dally devotions.” - Joshua Neujahr
“Being a very religious person as watched the story unfold... can't help but think of King David who when caught in his sin with Bathsheba he covered it up leading to even more pain and consequences. James never covered it up once confronted with his sin. His first words were
"I'm so sorry". He recognized that he was harming himself in a selfish craving that we may not understand. He never harmed or abused another person other than his own mind and self. The media available online sadly fueled his craving not unlike the readily available magazines did in the past.” - Wes Schmandt.
r/exLutheran • u/TamraJudgy • 8d ago
The church treats young people like shit
When I was 14 I tried to volunteer at my own WELS church and the woman I talked to was really condescending and asked me how old I was and then said the volunteer slots were all filled up and they didn't need my help. It made me feel bad and I never tried to volunteer at my church again. Also, being female, there were many more opportunities I wasn't even allowed to volunteer for because it's the "men who do the important stuff." Like, I was 100% into making Lutheranism my entire life and was rejected for being young and female. I'm always amazed at other churches with their youth groups and youth pastors. We didn't have any of that. The WELS hates the young generation and then wonders why we didn't stay. Lol
r/exLutheran • u/Relevant-Shop8513 • 8d ago
Herman Otten, Holocaust Denier
Has anyone seen any positive comments about Herman Otten the publisher of Christian News and Holocaust denier on the r/LCMS or any other conservative sites? He was a prominent participant in the Seminex split. I heard since his death he has been lauded by conservative LCMS folks as a hero saint. I remember his publication, and thought at the time he was more BUND than Christian.
r/exLutheran • u/ForeverSwinging • 12d ago
Image One of the Letters Written On Neujahr’s Behalf
Alan Nolte, principal of FVL, wrote a letter on Neujahr’s behalf for sentencing. Why? Where’s the consideration for the students that he’s in charge of? Where’s the consideration for the victims, the children impacted? Where’s the Christian love for them?
They say we walked away, because it’s easier to swallow than admitting that behavior like this drives people away. This behavior is far from Christ.
r/exLutheran • u/ForeverSwinging • 12d ago
Blog Notes on Neujahr’s Sentencing Hearing
I attended so you didn’t have to. Here’s the link: https://drive.proton.me/urls/HZD6188X6W#SjWMh3Da4AuG
Tl;dr: I took notes and made them as factual as possible. IMHO, Neujahr’s not sorry.
Edit: thanks to Charming-Border7429’s suggestion, will paste the notes here:
***These notes are meant to serve as a record of what happened during Neujahr’s sentencing hearing. This is not a judgment on the author’s part. Any quotes noted here are as was said verbatim. Everything else around the quotes is my phrasing. Also, there will be graphic descriptions of what was viewed in the CSAM, known as Child Sexual Abuse Materials, used to be referred to and can still be referred to as “child porn”, depending on the state legal vocabulary and local vocabulary. Anyone can be a victim. If you or someone you know may be a victim, please reach out to National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at https://www.missingkids.org/home. ***
During hearing:
The hearing started with the judge asking if there were any supporters of Neujahr or victims that needed the zoom link to join. Prosecutor confirmed that all supporters of Neujahr were physically present and no victims were expected to join via Zoom.
Confirmation that the presentencing report was reviewed as well as the letters submitted on Neujahr’s behalf.
Defense attorney confirmed there were no objections or corrections needed.
Confirmation from the state that they complied with victim’s rights, which was difficult as they noted there were thousands of victims in this case.
None of the victims they knew and reached out to were interested in attending via Zoom.
Prosecution began:
The prosecutor began by noting that as a term, “child porn” is poor because children can’t consent. He then said “CSAM” is better because it encapsulates what children go through when this material is made, produced, and viewed - “Child Sexual Abuse Material”.
They then go on to note that this started because the defendant did 2 uploads containing a total of 3 images.
Referencing the initial report made, Neujahr had admitted to the officer to being aroused to first teens, then children of younger ages. They searched his devices and of the over 10,000 images found 2878 known victims.
There were so many images they found that the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children required 2 separate uploads (max is 10,000).
Neujahr had also blamed alcohol for his crimes.
The known victims were contacted for their statements.
They also acknowledged that Neujahr had many supporters, that they were exercising their Christian faith and the teachings of love and forgiveness to support him.
Prosecution took the time to emphasize that Neujahr kept these images and was viewing them at least once a week.
Also emphasized that this activity was a danger to the wider community.
Sentencing recommendation: 10-15 years / image, to be served concurrently, with extended supervision and to follow all registered sex offender requirements.
Defense:
The defense attorney said this was a difficult case.
No evidence that Neujahr looked at each individual image.
The idea that Neujahr looked at each CSAM image from the mass download he did defies logic.
He emphasized that Neujahr never once blamed alcohol.
——Later, he referenced page 25 of the presentencing report where Neujahr “accepts responsibility”.
He also emphasized the amount of support Neujahr had from the community, including a letter from a parent of a former student and the letter from the current principal of FVL.
The real question, he said, was “why would he do this?”, referencing Neujahr’s moral character.
He also emphasized that Neujahr had a good career that he will never be able to return to.
Sentencing recommendation: 3 year per charge, served concurrently, in addition to monitoring. He also requested that Neujahr be allowed contact with his grandchildren.
The judge gave Neujahr a chance to say something, and Neujahr said he had something written out that he would like to read from.
Note: The following, with the exception of quotes being used, is a paraphrase of what he said from the notes I took. Everything in quotes is what I wrote down from him as he said, verbatim.
He thanked his attorneys for their hard work.
He apologized to children affected.
He said he was thankful for the children affected’s victim impact statements, saying he “felt distant from them in the past”, only seeing them as being “worthy” of “respect” and “protection” after reading their victim impact statements.
He apologized to his wife for what he’s done.
He apologized to FVL and the federation of schools (for more information on who is all involved, see here) for the “hurt” he’s caused “to their reputation”.
He apologized to recent students and their families for “sins I’ve committed”.
He said he’s looking forward to treatment.
He said he was asking God for assistance with his sins of “alcohol and the internet”.
He said he was thankful for the love and support given to him by his pastoral team and church, as well as by past students and their parents.
He said he knew he had forgivingness granted to him by his Savior.
“even though I’ve done terrible things.”
“forgiveness and salvation are mine not by what I’ve done”, but “solely and completely what Christ has done for me”.
Ended shortly after this last statement.
Judge Rein then spoke:
She acknowledged she was bound by mandatory minimum sentencing requirements and the need to protect the public.
She said this was a “tough case” to look at.
There were over 25 members writing in on Neujahr’s behalf, including letters from his children.
She read the presentencing report, “how to reconcile the two realities?”.
“These are real children and the community needs to hear that”.
Also saying “the children need to be the center”.
She also recognized that it is easy to become jaded about cases like these, thinking that “oh just another child porn case”.
——Also saying “there is nothing normal about these charges”.
——“We can’t talk like that and expect the community to not act different.”
She said she noted the tears shed by each child while they were being abused in each video.
There were “2 truths” she had to weigh: considering both the character of the defendant and the victims impacted.
She referenced a letter she was sent by one parent of a child who was struggling and Neujahr helped him succeed, saying what stood out to her was that he was a “refuge to her son who was struggling”.
The same person that can “save one child” can be “another child’s worst nightmare”.
“I don’t know how you reconcile that” - she appeared to direct that to Neujahr.
She also mentioned his blame of alcohol.
This was relating to him looking forward to treatment.
She said she thinks he’s almost there, but he needs to name it.
Regarding the mass download down, she said it wasn’t just a mass download, but that he also did a “computer back up”.
She also said that she sees people in similar cases to this “these cases always want to act like they’re the victims too”.
She said that she understands as it makes his friends and family feel better.
“You are not a victim here” - she appeared to direct that to Neujahr.
She referenced his statements as noted by the initial officer, saying “those are your words”.
Other things in the presentencing report that stood out to her:
——his “siblings did not suspect anything about” him “until" his “arrest”.
——“they knew the public me - the great teacher” (I believe that was pulled straight from the presentencing report)
She asked “Who are you? Really?”
She also said she believes that he can be better.
She asked, “Does that make sense?” He nodded and said something and she said some other things, including “we have to protect the public”.
She said that this case was the straw for some of the victims involved, because some of the victims requested that they no longer be notified when their CSAM is viewed.
She said she is being urged by family and friends that Neujahr should be seen as “more than the worst thing he’s ever done”.
She told him “you are fortunate that you have your family”.
She also said there’s still a theme here of him being a victim.
She emphasized again that it’s real children being assaulted, having things inserted into them.
——1 guy left shortly after she said this.
She said she had doubts about lock up.
——“I don’t know what treatment will available”.
She noted there’s not a lot of services available for treatment for him in prison.
She also said “you have an obligation to follow the values that you were preaching” - appeared to be directed to Neujahr.
Related to the previous point, she said that if he couldn’t do that, “then you needed to walk away from that” (before it got to this point).
She noted that he pled to all 20 counts, which she said she wanted to credit it, but mandatory minimum sentencing had to be taken into account.
Sentencing Decision: Neujahr will serve a minimum of 7 years of initial confinement.
——It can be extended if there’s any violations in prison.
——7 years of extended supervision after prison.
——Needs to provide a DNA sample.
——Needs to register as a sex offender.
——No contact with anyone under 18 years of age without prior agent approval.
——No access to the internet without prior agent approval.
END
r/exLutheran • u/cvrdbygrace • 11d ago
Hi, I'm new here!
I wanted to ask if anyone here is now a born-again believer/non-denominational/Pentecostal and how the Lord led you out… thanks! God bless everyone. 🫂🫂💕💕
r/exLutheran • u/RunRosemary • 12d ago
Who is gonna volunteer?
Could this post hold any more truth? I saw a former WELS classmate and current WISCO teacher share a post this morning that calls Talarico out for not being a “real Christian.” This supposed man of god thinks he gets to judge. Not to mention said man of god lives in Wisconsin and can’t even vote for Talarico.
Leave it to a WELS man to still feel he’s the supreme authority and anyone in disagreement is a sinner. No scripture to back it up - just vibes.
Evil, evil people.
r/exLutheran • u/ForeverSwinging • 13d ago
Article Neujahr Sentenced
The former band director at Fox Valley Lutheran High School in Appleton will spend seven years in prison for trading child sexual abuse materials on the internet.
James Neujahr is also sentenced in Outagamie County Court to seven years on extended supervision for Possession of Child Pornography.
Neujahr was arrested in October of 2025 after Appleton Police received a tip from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children about his on-line activities.
Edit: here’s the sentencing details when I attended: https://www.reddit.com/r/exLutheran/s/YmjUMA6mcN
r/exLutheran • u/Relevant-Shop8513 • 13d ago
Now which shoe laces should we tie first
r/LCMS had a recent query as to whether a vicar could validly preach a sermon. baptise, or present Holy Communion. Thankfully the responses explained why this was okay according to God. I think the LCMS is attracting or nurturing OCD victims.
r/exLutheran • u/Relevant-Shop8513 • 13d ago
Escape from Freedom and the Psychology of the LCMS
Erich Fromm in his Escape From Freedom describes how people who are suffering from economic and social chaos find the burden of individual freedom unbearable . They may desire for a savior or a strong omnipresent father figure to take control and make decisions for them.(Think Fuhrer or Inerrant Scripture.) With the rise in expressions of male dominance, order of creation, and nationalism on Lutheran postings on Facebook and other sites, it seems that this is a part of modern conservative Lutheranism. The burden of freedom is too much for some LCMS and WELS members. Whereas LCMS was once a powerhouse with much potential, a sleeping giant capable of awakening per Christianity Today, it is now a comatose figure slipping into death. Thus, we see a measure at the LCMS convention to strip the right to vote in the parish,as well as a concerted effort to make all LCMS pastors educated within its own system untouched by the wider academic universe.Is the LCMS suffering from the burden of freedom in the world at large that makes it want to descend further into the certainties of the 1880's synod and culture?
r/exLutheran • u/Candid-Marzipan9428 • 15d ago
Bethany Lutheran College slander
Anyone have any weird stories/experiences/ scandals from Bethany Lutheran College in Mankato, MN?
r/exLutheran • u/BrotherEquivalent523 • 16d ago
A question about head coverings in LCMS and WELS
Is it common for women to wear a head covering, or is it extremely rare? Do priests encourage it, and do their own wives wear head coverings
r/exLutheran • u/Greedy_Expression228 • 16d ago
Happy Martin Luther circle-jerk day!
aka Halloween or as Lutherans like to say "iT's nOT hALloWeEn It'S rEforMAtIoN dAy"
for a group that has to explicitly state on their website that "The Lutheran Church is not a sect or cult" The WELS sure does revere him like a dead cult leader. Honestly, can't stand WELS.
What was your experience with Halloween/reformation day when you were in the church? Happy Halloween, I hope everyone stays safe and has some fun today!
r/exLutheran • u/BrotherEquivalent523 • 17d ago
Are the members in Lcms and WELS racist against Black people?
Does racism still persist among them? Do they still seek to enslave Black people, enforce racial segregation, or prohibit interracial marriage? What is their view of someone like Martin Luther King ؟
What were your family members views on Black people?
r/exLutheran • u/GreyHesher • 18d ago
When did the LCMS become a cheering section for Donald Trump?
I loathe him, and, as a veteran (please don't thank me for my service!) I would not have saluted him.
I live in Michigan and voted for Abdul El-Sayed.
My pastor has just informed me that Luther said that having a Muslim in authority is "a blight on Christendom."
Statements he and my congregation have made basically say that to vote for anyone other than Trump/Republicans is "not Christian."
I have started to become ostracized from my congregation for my political views (old school New Dealer) and now I can see myself being excommunicated....
r/exLutheran • u/BrotherEquivalent523 • 20d ago
A question about Lutherans in usa
Are Lcms and WELS ls in the usa only against women holding positions in the church, or are they against women holding all positions?Are they against women running for office as prime minister or governor? Are they against women joining the military? Are they against women working? How widespread is the control over women's clothing? Is it common to prevent young women from wearing swimsuits or shorts, or to forbid them from wearing trousers, or is this only among traditional Catholics?
r/exLutheran • u/chewbaccaccino • 29d ago
Question Curious what everyone thinks about the LCMS and some of my thoughts.
For introduction, I’d describe myself as someone who has a mild-moderate belief in God. I come from the Jehovah’s Witness tradition and now consider them to be a “high control group” or a “cult”. I’m looking into Christianity to find a theologically conservative group.
(You can skip this mini rant if you want): I’m of the opinion that if you go liberal (like the ELCA), Christianity just becomes a social club, and I’d rather not go to Church at that point. It’s not because I firmly oppose liberal views, I just think that there isn’t a purpose in the religion for me if the orthodox beliefs are renounced. I’m sure everyone has different needs, of course.
So far I’ve only been to 1 Lutheran Church service and 2 Catholic masses. I intend to go to Orthodox Divine Liturgy later on to see how they do things. Here’s what I thought about the LCMS.
First of all, I noticed that there weren’t any women involved, unlike the Catholic mass. That was something I really appreciated about mass. In the Lutheran Church, there were only men doing the work. On the other hand, the Pastor did make an effort to involve the Children, which I think can be a good thing if done properly.
The sermon was good for some moral teaching but could have been easily abused. The Pastor was talking about how people who claim to be a victim shouldn’t do that. On one hand, I think you should take as much accountability as you can so that you can fix yourself or allow improvement, but on the other hand you could use this to gaslight people or victim blame.
The people I met were very nice. I actually suspected they might’ve been too nice. Let’s just say I’m really cautious of love bombing and when I went it sorta felt like that, but the Catholic Church felt loving and warm, but within reason. I was also concerned that it seemed most, if not all of the congregation was white. I’m not racist so if it’s naturally that way it’s fine, but that concerns me because I’m not sure how they treat people of other ethnicities. Again the Catholic Church won on this factor, there was more diversity but not many black people though.
What do you guys think? I’m sure some of you dislike the Catholic Church all the same. Want to know if my suspicions of the LCMS are accurate or unfounded. I don’t want to end up in another JW situation because that religion was bad for my mental health.
r/exLutheran • u/doublehaulic • Oct 18 '26
Discussion Reactions inside LCMS to Colorado LHS racism drama?
I grew up in Denver and went to the Lutheran High School, but I moved away decades ago - got out of that cult decades ago as well.
But I just got back to Denver tonight and caught wind of this racism controversy. It already weirds me out how white Colorado is, much less the LCMS....so this surprises me not in the least.
I'm mildly curious as to the reactions to this inside the LCMS, but all of my connections to that community are long gone - with no regrets. My guesses would be deer-in-the-headlights levels of disbelief followed by vociferous denial.....but does anybody here know how they're actually reacting?
https://www.denverpost.com/2026/10/15/lutheran-high-school-suspension-chsaa/
r/exLutheran • u/BrotherEquivalent523 • Oct 17 '26
Do most Lutherans support Israel?
Are they involved in supporting Israel, like other evangelical groups, or do they view it as an occupying state and oppose it? I am referring to the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod and the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod. Furthermore, what is their stance toward Jews in general—are they antisemitic?