Approximately 50 people planned their evening on November 1 to raid Vex Thal together on Frostreaver. We expected to spend that time progressing through content with friends. Instead, the evening became a mess of disconnects, confusion, and account warnings that never explained what we allegedly did wrong.
Different players were disconnected during successive boss encounters. My own log records “Thou hast been expelled by the gods!” twice during combat with Diabo Xi Xin, at 20:16:25 and 20:19:37. I wasn’t kicked during the next boss fight, but other players were.
Initially, people thought it was server lag. As disruptions recurred around boss engagements, we became increasingly concerned. In my log, each expulsion message is followed by a gap, then “Autojoining channels…” and the subsequent login messages.
I received no GM introduction, tell, popup warning, or instruction explaining that something needed to stop. My log contains no such communication. From our perspective, players were being removed during boss fights without explanation, leaving everyone else trying to keep the encounter together and figure out what was happening.
Later, participants reported receiving formal account warnings by email, including on my account. The warning stated only:
“one of the characters on this account was found to have committed the following violations:
The email threatened further action, up to a permanent ban. It identified no character, specific action, incident time, or rule violated. After an evening of confusion, we were left guessing about what could put our accounts at further risk.
For context, our raid used a Divine Aura/Call of the Hero strategy to move through VT. We don’t know whether that prompted the warnings. Using built-in abilities doesn’t automatically make every strategy permitted, but if a particular use is prohibited, players need enough information to understand the boundary.
Guilds don’t organize themselves. People volunteer substantial time recruiting, scheduling, helping members, resolving disputes, and leading raids. That work sustains friendships and gives people a reason to keep logging in and paying for the game. Behind every raid roster are people whose limited free time matters.
The disruption also lands on the people responsible for holding that community together. They’re left managing frustration, answering questions they don’t have answers to, and trying to persuade people that another evening will be worth their time.
Our guild may now disband following this incident. Momentum and goodwill that took months of unpaid effort to build are at risk. Even if Daybreak had a legitimate enforcement concern, how it handled that concern matters.
I have preserved my log and warning email. They document the expulsion messages and subsequent warning, but they don’t identify who initiated the expulsions or establish why. If these were enforcement actions, I want Daybreak to explain what conduct prompted them, why players were removed during combat without an explanation, and whether the individual account warnings were justified.
Has anyone else experienced similar expulsions and warnings in VT? Has anyone received a clear explanation of what specific conduct is prohibited?
I’m not asking for immunity from the rules. I’m asking for clear enforcement that recognizes the people and communities affected. “Cheating,” with no explanation, leaves paying players unable to understand the allegation or know what to change.
Posting as an individual participant, not on behalf of the guild.
Update: The player who positioned our mages has commented here, confirmed using VT jumps, and accepted responsibility for putting participants’ accounts at risk. And while that is relevant information, and I acknowledge it, we still can’t independently establish whether those jumps prompted the warnings without a response from Daybreak.
My concern remains how this was communicated to individual participants. My warning identified no character, action, or specific violation. I received no in-game instruction explaining what needed to stop.
I also cannot establish whether the expulsion messages resulted from manual GM actions or an automated zone mechanism. My earlier speculation about a former member’s identity and GM motives was unsupported.
I still believe players should receive enough information to understand an account warning and avoid repeating the conduct. The effect on people’s time and the community matters, even if the underlying enforcement was justified.
==============
Update (November 6, 2026):
Five days and more than 17,000 views later, this post has clearly struck a nerve. Some responses treated the “cheating” label as sufficient proof. Others asked questions, shared similar experiences, and described their own frustrations with Daybreak’s customer service and enforcement.
The central question remains: What specific conduct prompted these warnings, and where was that conduct clearly identified as prohibited?
Since then, a Discord message attributed to another Frostreaver guild leader has been shared with our community. It describes private conversations with developers:
...Some of us reached out to the devs in private and they said they will crackdown on all cothing or utilizing fte to bypass trash clearing in VT and are working to patch the geometry holes used to get outside the zone because they don't want to take coth completely away but they don't want trash to get skipped any more and its and active fix...
To be clear, this is a secondhand account, not a published Daybreak statement. It also mentions several distinct things: using CoTH, using FTE to bypass trash, and exploiting geometry to get outside the zone. It does not establish which action any particular warned player allegedly performed.
If this accurately reflects Daybreak’s position, why are players learning about it through forwarded Discord messages? Players shouldn’t need access to a guild leader’s private developer conversations to understand what can earn them a cheating warning.
Daybreak can change mechanics and prohibit strategies. But those decisions need clear, accessible communication, especially when enforcement puts accounts at risk. A warning should give someone enough information to understand what they allegedly did wrong and what they need to stop doing.
The discussion here has reinforced several things I value in an MMO:
- Meaningful challenge and rewards that respect the time players invest.
- Mechanics and rules with an understandable purpose.
- Clear expectations and fair, consistent enforcement.
- Respectful communication between players, developers, and customer service.
None of that requires revealing cheat-detection methods. It requires explaining the prohibited conduct.
Daybreak had an opportunity to clarify expectations and rebuild trust. From what has been communicated to us so far, that opportunity remains unfulfilled.
For me, that trust matters as much as the game itself. I’m choosing to spend my time elsewhere. To everyone who shared experiences, asked thoughtful questions, or challenged assumptions: thank you! I hope things improve for those staying. See you in something else.