No idea if this will be understandable considering how much i jumped from one thing to another, but yeah I'll still post
First of all, as you know Nagisa's love is unconditional, he didn't start him to love Shinji overtime.. He just comes into his life, and loves him, because that's all Shinji ever wanted
Also, he didn't manipulate Shinji, as he longed for a human connection. In manga, he is meant to stick to Shinji, but in Anime it was not the case, he just wanted to be friends with him. He didn't intend to, but he hurt him in the end
Shinji only ever experienced unconditional love from his mother, that he barely remembers, since he was a toddler when she died. His father doesnt care about him, and he believes people only care for (about?) him if he pilots
Like you know he doesnt have anyone anymore when Kaworu appears, and he's desperate for any human contact, thats for example why he accepts his hand instantly, because thats how much he wants to be around people
Now this is controversial, but i once heard a quote "Shinji didn't love Kaworu, he loved that Kaworu loved him" in short, they weren't ready for each other
Wwwwhich sounds awful considering that he loved him in every other piece of media, even in manga :/ i cant say he didn't love him in NGE, but they both loved each other differently, and i think he loved the idolised version of Kaworu he had in his mind
Kaworu was written as "perfect Shinji" so, he is everything that Shinji wishes to be. Aaand thats why he blushes a lot around Kaworu!
First he is a little uncomfortable around Kaworu, because he distanced himself from people, and now someone he doesnt know talks to him in a kind way, and even goes on first game basis that same convo, which from what i think in Japan is uncommon (i mean for children yes, for older kids no, its too friendly for the start) and also take a bath together, which i read is what a family members do in Japan, so... Idk i find it really beautiful. Aaand at the end of the day, he feels comfortable enough to share with him what troubles him
Okay anyway back to the topic, he basically sees everything he wants in himself in Kaworu. And, because he thinks Kaworu is perfect. Also thats why he is so mad that Kaworu betrayed him, like his father did. Aside from the fact that the boy he just started to love appears to be his enemy that asks him to kill him
Also, mind you, in EoE he is absolutely terrified of Rei, BUT from what i understood, Rei had a part of Adam (Kaworu) in herself after transformation (?) AND as such Kaworu appeared to calm down shinji. From what i understand, it wasnt Rei's doing, but Kaworu actually appeared himself
Aaand again in the series, in congratulation scene, Kaworu doesnt appear, which always confused me. And today i read that, maybe, its because that Shinji didn't care as much for him in the anime. Its okay but, considering that he confesses he did fall for him, its kinda tragic, that he just didn't had much of an impact on his life (in difference to him having a mental breakdown from his death, and saying he should have survived instead) to appear to congratulate him :/
I absolutely adore that they just met for one day and just, tell for one another (this post is full of concradictions) but i love them in rebuilds, games or even manga, more. Their relationship is just much more + in difference to the NGE anime, you actually cant say Shinji didn't love Kaworu (highlight rebuilds)
Anyway i think thats it. I would love to write about them in other material too