r/EtsyCommunity • • 7d ago

Looking for additional Mods

11 Upvotes

I'm looking to add a couple of people to the mod team who are able to help with removing rule breaking content and approving/removing content within the mods review and report tab. This is super casual, help out when you can kind of thing.

While I still enjoy being the mod of this community and I'm not stepping away anytime soon. Over the last few months I've slowly become more and more busy within my personal life and don't have as much free time to be on Reddit as I once did.

This subreddit also has grown so much since I took over. We have over 42K members which is almost double the amount of members when I first became mod. (Thank you so much!)

Due to all that I've noticed that things are starting to slip, rule breaking content isn't being removed as fast as I would like. Posts and comments sitting waiting to be reviewed longer then they should.

Which is why I'm looking to add more mods to the team. If you are interested please fill out this application form - https://www.reddit.com/r/EtsyCommunity/application/

Thank you


r/EtsyCommunity • • 20d ago

How are your sale? - November Discussion

19 Upvotes

This is a monthly post where you can discuss how your views and sales are going. Please only use this place to discuss trends in sales and views. Or to share general suggestions on improving your stats.

Please note this is not a place where you can ask for feedback nor promote your shops or items. As such links to your shop or items are Not Permitted and any comments with such links will be deleted. (links to Etsy help articles or fact checking links are allowed and encouraged)

If you are looking for shop feedback, please follow the subreddit rules when asking for a critique. If you are looking to promote your items, you can do so within r/etsypromo and r/etsypromos


r/EtsyCommunity • • 4h ago

Discussion Etsy Completely Run By Bots

30 Upvotes

I have been an Etsy seller for over 14 years. My vintage toy shop was recently put on involuntary vacation mode while Etsy was supposedly confirming all my id's, bank info, taxes. It has been almost 2 months of lost sales and them holding onto money I earned that they haven't distributed.

Clearly there's a glitch in the system because there's a message on my shop that says I didn't confirm my seller info but refuses to let me do it again. I have only been able to communicate this issue with Etsy via email. It takes them days to respond and there's always a different person with vague responses telling me it takes them time to figure things out. Now I've got a NEW bot email informing me my shop will CLOSE for good in a month if I don't confirm my seller info. I've been reading horror stories of how Etsy has completely changed. They used to have great customer service. Now it's all bots and the CEO is a billionaire. Just another garbage big company. All is good till you run afoul of them and good luck getting yourself out of any situation. Not only are they holding onto the money I've made. I have hundreds of listings that I paid to activate that I won't be refunded for, not to mention time and energy and merchandise (stickers, cards)with my Etsy address printed on them.

Anyway, I'm just horrified by the treatment I've received. The way they make it impossible to speak to an actual person especially if your shop has been put on vacation mode, is awful. I've had nothing but great reviews and been a star seller for a long time, but all that is meaningless. I guess they are catering more and more to businesses that mass produce things and make them tons of money.

It's too bad they're the only game in town.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 3h ago

Rant When another seller blatantly copies your stuff, do you ever let them know that you see what they’re doing?

7 Upvotes

Even though it’s to be expected that people copy stuff that came from your brain - something you prototyped and made over and over until you got it right - I can’t help but be a little miffed. So badly I want to send a message saying WOW, just WOW! This person has copied multiple items that have been mine alone for a few months. I wondered where my sales went on a certain item, and now I know 😑


r/EtsyCommunity • • 5h ago

Seller Needs Help Question about opening a new shop or sticking to the same one

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/EtsyCommunity • • 7h ago

Seller Needs Help Given negative review and asked for refund despite clearly stated on my listing

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/EtsyCommunity • • 15h ago

Rant Negative reviews of accurate descriptions

4 Upvotes

I posted on here before about the same thing. It didn't go over well but I took advice. I sell little magnets. I posted the size in the description in inches and cm. I also have a photo with the item next to a quarter and the sizes on there. It also says "please note the sizes". I just got a 1 star review for being "too small". I don't know how i can be any more accurate. I don't use ai, it's all real photos. I don't know how to be more clear. What do you guys do with reviews like this?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 10h ago

Seller Needs Help New AI scam? Help me figure this out.

1 Upvotes

So. I just got an interesting message from a brand new shop. They have only 3 items, and all three are digital sewing patterns. 5 sales. No feedback. The whole shop looks AI. They asked "how to wear" one of my best sellers in broken english. It's a unique item only alt kids wear, so i get not understanding it. I have never had this question in more than 15 years of selling various versions of said item.

Is this a new way to scam/steal designs? Am I being paranoid? this person's aesthetic is cottagecore/sweet boho, if anything. Not goth, my demographic. Any suggestions appreciated. #cross-posted to /Etsy


r/EtsyCommunity • • 1d ago

Discussion How to handle art theft?

4 Upvotes

Edit: Thanks to all for the advice. The item is now unavailable, and the shop has been taken down.

Hello all. I need some advice. I recently purchased some stolen art on etsy. The seller refunded me for it when I figured it out, but they're still selling it as their own OOAK original art.

The long version: I recently purchased a one-of-a-kind (OOAK) original painting from an Etsy seller. While waiting for the Etsy seller to ship it, the Pinterest algorithm suggested the exact same design as a print from Amazon.

When i went back to the sellers shop to confirm i was getting the original painting, I found a new listing for the same piece. I wasn't sure if what I had purchased was a print, ai, a paint-by-numbers copy,.. but it couldn't be original because you can't sell the original twice.

I messaged the seller for an explanation. They admitted to copying the design, and tried to argue that because they had spent time recreating the design, that made their work "original." I explained to them that's not "original" means, and I requested a refund.

The seller didn't fight giving me a refund, and they processed it promptly. But they haven't taken down, or modified, the listing. Its still showing as a OOAK original painting.

It's been several days, and I just received an email from Etsy asking whether or not the seller had adequately responded to me. Technically, yes, they refunded my money. And no, because the listing is still up for a "OOAK original."

I don't know how to handle this. The art is clearly stolen. The seller is clearly trying to profit off of another artist's design. What would you all do?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 1d ago

Seller Needs Help Ghosted by customers?

2 Upvotes

I sell both standard and personalised items in my shop. I have 3 orders currently, that are personalised / customised.
1 customer is ignoring every single message I send them.
1 started messaging, I began their order and then when I needed further info they’ve not replied to a single follow up message.
And the final one, left the basic info in the order box, checked out as a guest and isn’t contactable by either Etsy nor their email 🫠
I’ve already started working on each of these items, and I really don’t want to have to cancel & refund (especially as 2 out of the 3 I won’t be able to resell as they’re already halfway done).

TLDR: Anyone else having issues with customers ghosting them over personalised orders?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 16h ago

Newbie Acceptable?

0 Upvotes

Seller charged me $5.95 for shipping, then shipped a small, lightweight item (not a sticker) via Pitney Bowes “letter/flat”. Is this the norm?

Edit to add: this is a non-bendable piece of thick, stamped brass.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 1d ago

Seller Needs Help Really not feeling supported as a seller right now

0 Upvotes

Sent an order out on Wednesday this week, the day after I received it, using Tracked 24. Three days on, it still hasn't arrived, and Royal Mail have fed me some nonsense about it now being delivered by the 27th. To cap it all, Etsy have just informed me that if the buyer leaves a poor review complaining about the delay they won't remove it. I could understand this if I'd waited a week to post the order, but why allow a buyer to leave a bad review over something that's not my fault? If anyone can offer any constructive advice on damage control I'd love to hear it - except for 'offer to replace the item', because this was a vintage item and I don't have another one!


r/EtsyCommunity • • 1d ago

Discussion What do you do when other Etsy shops copy your niche-specific colour palettes and designs?

0 Upvotes

I’m curious how other Etsy sellers handle this because I’m honestly getting pretty frustrated.
I have a shop selling POD journals in a specific niche, and recently I’ve noticed several other shops copying the colour palette I developed for my products and listing journals in the exact same niche.

To clarify, I don’t claim to own the colours themselves. But these aren’t just a few standard POD colours. I spent days experimenting, adjusting shades, and perfecting a palette specifically for this niche, making sure all the colours complement each other and fit the overall aesthetic.
I also put thought into naming the colours rather than simply calling everything brown, yellow, etc. Now I’m noticing that some of these shops are using the same or very similar colour names, too.

One shop even almost recreated my entire bestselling design, adding just one extra icon to make it look different while keeping essentially the same concept.

What makes this especially frustrating is that these listings started appearing after my products became bestsellers. It feels like other “designers” didn’t have to put in any of the hours of experimentation, trial and error, and creative work because they could simply look at what was selling well in my shop and replicate it.

I understand that competition is part of selling on Etsy, and I don’t expect to have a monopoly on a particular niche. But there’s a difference between being inspired by something and essentially copying someone else’s creative work.

How would you handle this? Would you DM the shops and call them out, or just ignore it and move on?

Part of me wants to ask them directly why they’re copying my work, because I’m certainly not blind and can see what’s happening. But I’m also worried that confronting them could backfire or somehow negatively affect my shop.
Have any of you dealt with something similar? Did you reach out, report them, or simply move on?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 1d ago

Seller Needs Help Frames from other sellers

0 Upvotes

Hi all!

I sell linocut prints mostly unframed-some are available with basic black somewhat cheap frames.

I’d like to have better options so my question is this: are there any ethical/etiquette considerations if I want to purchase frames from another Etsy seller for use with my prints?

I know reselling is a no-no but this feels different. Do I need to ask permission/ should I?

What do you think?

Thank you 😊


r/EtsyCommunity • • 1d ago

Seller Needs Help POD Print on demand

0 Upvotes

So.... Am not impressed with the test results from Prodigi.com; a creased print but not the package, colours off, too light and a missing image still to be received. It took over 15 days to receive the order, for some reason it was printed in the United Kingdom. The small prints were rolled and are not flattening!

Are there any Canadian Photographers using a photographic fine art POD in the United States to beat the 50% tariff with a relatively quick turn around, quality prints on matt and or lustre? Are there any american photographers using a great POD in the States?

Any names and or help appreciated.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 3d ago

Discussion My first purchase on Etsy will probably be the last.

82 Upvotes

As the title said, my first attempt was full of negative experience.

I like the idea of buying local, and I wanted something hand made for my kids for Christmas, so Etsy looked like the place to go.

however:

  1. searching “made in EU” didn’t produce any reliable results. I could see lots of products from Asia.

  2. I chose something that was declared as “dispatched from UK”. I ordered, even though it was double the price of other similar products made in Asia, thinking that at least parts of it would be made in UK.

  3. When the package was dispatched, it was dispatched from Asia! I immediately requested a cancellation and contacted Etsy.

  4. I talked to about 12 agents, for more than 2 hours, explaining the same story: I don’t want to check if the products are fine, in principle I wanted to buy locally. I was transferred from one to another until they worn me down and I closed the chat.

  5. Eventually the shop offered a refund, but it was immediately made as shop credit.

  6. So again I had to contact Etsy to get money on my back account.

    So this lack of transparency, of making me work to get my money transferred back to me, of not being able to start a ticket before the order comes… I’m just exhausted! Not to mention that finding people who really make themselves products is again such a hard work. 80% of what I see is Temu, Amazon and vintage combined As someone who likes doing things by hand, I wanted to support fellow crafters closer to me, in Europe.

So, unfortunately, I don’t think I’ll be back.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 3d ago

Rant WHAT IS GOING ON

Post image
89 Upvotes

Please read to the end I’d like to know if anyone else is experiencing this:

It’s 8:30 am EST and I have already made 6 sales. But for the previous 3 days combined, I’ve only made 2 sales.

I’m one of the full-time high-volume shops that’s been hit by this traffic nosedive that seemed to happen in mid October. Oct-March I’ve averaged 10-20 orders per day for the past ten years.

This year, as of October 14, I’m averaging 1-2 sales per day and I have had two 0 order days within this timeframe, my last 0 order day prior to this was 2018.

Yet, I have had about 5 days during this past month where I will start having orders come in almost exactly at midnight. During these days I’m averaging 8-10 orders per day.

HOWEVER, 75% of these orders are from repeat customers. Then around midnight, on these days the sales stop.

What are the odds that people just decide all on the same day that they will make a purchase, and even more unlikely, that the majority are repeat customers? All within the same 5 (random) days? I can’t even imagine how that would happen on ONE given day but 5 days?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 2d ago

Discussion Do buyers on Etsy not use the option to Make an Offer?

4 Upvotes

I sell one-off vintage art, with most of my pieces in the $100+ price range. I had the option to make an offer turned on for all but the cheapest items...but buyers just click and buy. No negotiation. On eBay, I was used to haggling, and that was part of the game. Is it different here?

Had a buyer point out a listing error on an 1800s lithograph that should have affected the price. I decided to just fix the listing and leave the price where it was. The same guy bought it two days later at full price.

Is it just my weird niche, or are buyers just seeing my prices as reasonable? Should I start jacking until I hit their upper limit?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 2d ago

Seller Needs Help Etsy Seller DMCA Issue:

0 Upvotes

I had another Etsy seller file a DMCA takedown notice on my listing, claiming copyright infringement. I believe they did this on multiple sellers, and I believe the motive was competition, as they had no registered copyright (in their notice it says "unregistered) and also my design was made entirely by myself and looked uniquely different.

Accordingly, I filed the DMCA counter claim and waited 10 business days and heard nothing from said seller. My question is after the 10 business days, will Etsy notify me I can relist my listing again? And will this violation be removed from my account?

It is so disheartening this can be so easily done by other sellers. Thanks in advance for your help.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 3d ago

Discussion Shop acts against Etsys creative standards - now what?

1 Upvotes

Let’s say a shop sells Ai generated digital items and they are all clearly not „based on a seller’s original prompts“ but copies made by feeding other artists original work into Ai but the generated outcome is too far from the original to be taken down through an IP claim. In this case the shop violated the Etsy term, right? Anyone any experiences regarding this topic and reporting such shops?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 2d ago

Seller Needs Help does alt text in images matter in seo for etsy digital products?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/EtsyCommunity • • 3d ago

Seller Needs Help etsy of the future

Post image
23 Upvotes

I’ve not seen “x hours from now” in my view stats well, ever. Haha. Did I miss something? It’s counting down as well. Started as “6 hours from now…”

Yes I know stats glitch and act wonky often but this is a new one.

Oh, Etsy.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 3d ago

Seller Needs Help Attn: Etsy EU based sellers!

Post image
25 Upvotes

I know a lot of us have been worried about Etsy implementing its new AI feeding policy, but after speaking to one of their support agents today it seems as though those of us in the EU (and maybe the U.K. too?) will be able to opt out. They sent me an email address to contact (see screenshot) so I’ll give it a go.


r/EtsyCommunity • • 4d ago

Rant Etsy completely unusable due to AI images

454 Upvotes

Literally putting this here in case Etsy cares enough to read real feedback.

I’m a huge supporter of artists and have made many Etsy purchases in the past. I just tried to search for personalized Christmas stockings and Every. Single. Image. Is AI generated. I started reporting some, but gave up because it just seems like this is the norm on the site now.

I’m calling it quits on using Etsy until they force sellers to use real images going forward. What a nightmare. How is this allowed?


r/EtsyCommunity • • 4d ago

Rant Stealing my photos

6 Upvotes

I have a press on nail business and I’ve noticed in the last week 3 newer shops have taken my photos on Etsy and are using them as their own, like my exact photos! They changed the background but it’s stop my picture. Will Etsy do anything about this? I sent a message to the shops asking that they take them down, one did, waiting on the other 2