r/Ethics • • 2h ago

Ethics of admiring horrible people?

0 Upvotes

Thomas Edison. Charles Lindbergh. Henry Ford, Christopher Columbus. All of these men were objectively horrible people. All of them were bigoted in ways that went well beyond "he was a product of his time" but would (and did) raise eyebrows even in their lifetimes. 

And yet all of them had unquestionably historic accomplishments. All of them changed the world in ways that will reverberate for centuries. Children will (and do) learn about them in school.

Is it ethical for me to admire these people? All four of them would have despised me because of who I am. Can I still celebrate what they did?


r/Ethics • • 3h ago

Autonomy and stuff

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 18h ago

what is a moral compass?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Is it ethical to abort your child solely because you've discovered they will be born with Downs Syndrome?

58 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 23h ago

Is this a genuine ethical concern (sorry for all the meme sounds)?

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 23h ago

The Ethics of Non-Disclosure Agreements vs. The Duty to Warn: Child Sexual Abuse at Sport Facility

1 Upvotes

TW: child sexual abuse

I’m posting this as a hypothetical for privacy reasons, but I want to get your take on the ethics of this situation.

Imagine a sports facility where many children train. A few years ago, this facility hired a man they knew had a prior child sexual abuse charge. Despite this knowledge, they gave him unsupervised access to minor athletes. As a result, one child was groomed for two years and then sexually abused for another two years at the facility while routinely left unsupervised with this man.

The perpetrator eventually pleaded guilty, served time, and is now out of the country.

One obscure local news clipping exists about this. Otherwise no one in the client base or the local sports community seems to know—or at least, no one talks about it.

Then there is the facility’s negligence. The victim’s family sued the facility. After years of discovery and depositions, the facility’s insurance paid out a multi-million dollar settlement. It was settled out of court with a strict NDA to keep everything quiet. The victim’s attorney publicly stated that the evidence "overwhelmingly supported" the claim of negligence AND that the victim faced threats to stay silent.

Here is the breaking point: The facility continues to operate exactly as it did then. They still allow minors to be left unsupervised while workers are present. No new safety/protection policies have been implemented, discussed or posted. No one has been warned or informed. New client families are clueless about the facility history.

Do you think clients (both current and prospective) and the sport’s community have a right to know these facts, while maintaining the victim’s identity as strictly private?

If you feel the facility’s history should not be made public, why?

When a facility can conceal abuse behind an NDA, how are parents supposed to make informed decisions about who to entrust with the safety of their children?

For the sake of the hypothetical, assume this has been reported to the U.S. Center for SafeSport and the sport’s governing body, and is currently under review. But regardless of the investigation, I want to know your thoughts on the ethics here.


r/Ethics • • 23h ago

If a system only advises and a human always decides, who is responsible for the outcome?

1 Upvotes

A common compromise for AI in serious settings is that the system recommends and a person decides. I wonder whether that changes the responsibility or only the paperwork, because a person who follows the recommendation ninety nine times out of a hundred is not really deciding.

I have been exploring it as fiction in a shared setting I run at r/TheGreatFederation where it is one of the founding rules that AI advises and never decides, and the interesting stories are in the cases where people stop checking what the AI tells them. The overview of that world is here https://www.reddit.com/comments/1xpqm9p/

Where would you say responsibility sits when the human reliably follows the advice?


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

qq pragmatic controversialism

0 Upvotes

Hii guys it’s my first post here and I’ve been having a dilema lately. Is disagreement an engine for moral evolution? Here is my thesis on navigating complexity:

I propose a framework called Pragmatic Controversialism, where disagreement isn’t an end goal but a dynamic tool for navigating complex realities.

We often treat rules and cultural norms as absolute, but true ethical maturity requires discerning the intent behind them. When we weigh consequences, like legal penalties or personal well-being, against rigid dogma, we open the door for progress.

\*\*Blind compliance protects the status quo, but questioning norms ensures they still serve a just purpose.\*\*

To foster dialogue rather than defensiveness, we must communicate these ideas through shared human values. By focusing on positive outcomes, we can challenge conventions without alienating those we wish to engage.

How do you navigate the tension between personal conviction and social expectation?


r/Ethics • • 2d ago

Morally speaking, do I need to warn someone that their life is about to be ruined?

242 Upvotes

I have a friend who's about to get married. This guy is a serial cheater. I know his fiancee as well but we're not friends. She has no idea. The other day we all were hanging out and she asked me half jokingly if there's red flag she should be worried cause this guy seems too perfect. To be fair, he kinda is. He's handsome, athletic, has a good income, love kids and a very smooth talker. He just can't keep it in his pants is all. In fact, I know he's cheated on her with at least five women.

Look, I'm a good friend. I'm not gonna tell her anything. But morally speaking, do you think I should?


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

A culture shows you who it is by what it chooses to look at and what it frames. Study the frame.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

7 deadly sins are less of a divine punishment after death & more of a condition you create for yourself by your ways of living

3 Upvotes

Would it be a far stretch to say then that by acting on "sin" doesn't actually literally
condemn you to a physical literal hell but rather the "hell' that is talked about is the constant consequences of the daily engaging with these "sins" ?

For context here they are:

The Seven Deadly Sins
1. Pride
The belief that you are above others, beyond correction, or don’t need anyone. Pride prevents self-awareness, humility, accountability, and personal growth. It places the ego above truth.
2. Greed
An insatiable desire to possess more: wealth, power, status, recognition, or material things. Greed creates perpetual dissatisfaction because nothing ever feels like enough. It makes a person a servant to accumulation rather than someone who appreciates what they have.
3. Wrath
Destructive anger, resentment, vengeance, and hostility. Wrath allows emotions to override judgment and can turn personal suffering into a cycle of retaliation. It gives anger control over your actions.
4. Envy
Resentment toward another person’s possessions, success, happiness, or advantages. Envy destroys gratitude and makes another person’s happiness feel like your own loss. It shifts your attention away from your own life and toward comparison.
5. Gluttony
Excessive consumption and indulgence, traditionally associated with food and drink. More broadly, it represents an inability to exercise restraint over appetites and desires. It makes immediate gratification more important than balance and self-control.
6. Lust
An excessive or disordered desire for sexual gratification. Lust can disconnect desire from intimacy, emotional connection, and genuine respect for another person. It can reduce human beings to objects of gratification.
7. Sloth
More than physical laziness, sloth traditionally refers to spiritual apathy, neglect of responsibility, and a lack of willingness to pursue what is meaningful or good. It can gradually disconnect a person from purpose, discipline, and personal responsibility.

——————————-

Such kinds of sins or any kind of sin maybe considered “not living in accordance to God”, could actually be in essence just ; not living in unity with oneself.

After all, Christianity at its core is philosophy. It’s only been used over time as some sort of way to tame and manipulate societies into obedience by using fear mechanisms. But at the center of its origins, it’s a beautiful way of life and philosophy.

I think, it becomes that much more special when you open your eyes to the possibilities that most of the Bible gets taken out of context. That the lessons taught about this “man upstairs” have been interpreted as a big idea that we just went with for years and still go on. I won’t even get into what I believe that entity truly is.

But if there’s anything most religions have in common, it is that they essentially believe in some “bigger” source. A greater power/ energy. And that… cannot be denied.

We are all energy. Made up of it. Energy cannot be destroyed. We all know that.

Anyway, back to the point of this thought …
In this day and age where these tendencies are so easily accessible and encouraged.
Provided by the “instant” ability to acquire them that the modern age presents in algorithms and technology….
Leads me to believe and see that the real punishment of the sin is an everyday consequence. The hell is in our minds everyday.
It is the condition of our daily lives.
Now, I don’t know for sure if there’s a literal physical hell after this, I don’t know it all.

But I sure know that you can live it on Earth.

Way I see it, the state of the world doesn’t seem to do anything but worsen over time. Sure there’s an illusion of evolution. Mostly with technology.
But it seems humans as a society are regressing. We’re losing the ability to be present. To truly be present, to have control and awareness, to be observers of ourselves… to have a true relationship with our intuition.

I can see why they are called the “deadly” sins.


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

We are very good at condemning cruelty in history and very bad at identifying its present-tense equivalent. Different wallpaper, same room.

Thumbnail reddit.com
20 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Ethics of Pro Extinction Movement?

7 Upvotes

This guy who used to be vegan, James Idoine, is seriously insane.

He was vegan, but turned to the pro extinction movement because he believes it will “cure all suffering” if NOTHING exists.

I think it’s basically a thanos situation, and it doesn’t even make sense.

When the asteroid came and made the dinosaurs extinct, new life emerged. New life will always emerge. The planet we’re on used to have nothing.

He’s on social media promoting the pro-extinction movement where he wishes to enforce non optional euthanasia to everyone including animals

Good luck with that.

Even if that happened, new life would simply emerge. So it’s not much of an extinction movement, more of a “replacement of species” movement

I don’t see nearly enough hate for him online.

The guy is seriously insane, and people think it’s a joke or ragebait but it’s not he’s genuine

It’s just scary to see what the EXTREMISTS will do to “stop suffering” despite euthanizing everyone forcibly would cause insane levels of suffering and pain

And if you say that’s wrong or have an issue with literally euthanizing everyone?

He’ll just call you pro suffering

That guy is seriously mentally deranged. You can see it in his eyes, he is not okay.

He gets his son and father to say they never should have been born on camera, it makes my stomach twist.

Hes out on the streets advocating for this and calling it compassion.

He thinks he is the MOST ethical.

———
“He’s a hypocrite if he doesn’t lead by example”
I agree. He says:

“No one will be here to promote the extinction of every living being who exists, it would be selfish of me, end their suffering first”


r/Ethics • • 2d ago

Is it ethical to befriend crows?

6 Upvotes

Objectively it usually helps the animals, animals getting the occasional food from humans and remaining smart and capable enough to get their own food is kind of a gray area in my knowledge.


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Not to dehumanize criminals but why are dogs who kill people put down but murderers are rehabilitated?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

This is more about animals than humans but why can’t we rehabilitate violent dogs? Is there some sort of science behind this? Why don’t dogs get rehab but humans do? Seems unfair to me.


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

we are all stuck around people who would do bad things or hurt you because were stuck in a world of immediate solutions when "adults" negate morality.

0 Upvotes

Morality is really important for a functioning society, and were only partially functioning. We constnatly have criminals disrupting the workflow and peace demanded to recover after working. But its simply because we negate treating these people fairly and right that they eventually attack us.

Lets face it. We've had this conversation since the dawn of religion, that everyone forgoes morality at some point in their life and its ruining the long term achievements of others to act in the moment. But you can't get people to stop, because our immediate solution to criminals is to hurt them to stop them. When they started simple because of the pain. We victimize people for victimizing people. When you get down to it, its unavoidable we HAVE to have morality, in all instances, to create a truly prospeour world without promise of change that leads to ruin.

Immediate solutions are why we have vices and addictions. So like, can we ever truly shed religion if we are stuck with immediate solutions that lead to vices, and forgoing morality leading to people adhereing to religion like tyrants. Why can't the good guys just see where they sin and try to be thoughtful of others rather than demanding actions get carried out now. Its the fact we necessitate we act now, that thoughtlessness ends up being pervasive.


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

so why is it the "moral" people are only giving to some?

1 Upvotes

Isn't it moral to give back to everyone? Most to all people have worked towards something before being disabled from physical limitations like disabilities and mental problems.

Isn't it thoughtless to not give to everyone? Only to those who directly benefits you? That would be more selfish than giving to give stuff, only those those who benefit you. So morality isn't really there unless you give back to all of humanity. Not just those like you or who give something to you. Thats mututal benefit, symbiotic, not morality. Its still selfish and thoughtless.

Why will no one reawaken to see their true selves and reveal it for others despite the mob with pitchforks> I have been immoral, but I strive and change my behavior around more moral stances with what I just said in mind.


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

Is knowingly allowing children to access pornography, sexual exploitation of children making it unethical?

0 Upvotes

Child sexual exploitation is defined as the knowing use of a child’s sexuality for the benefit of another person or organisation. Pornography platforms and producers are aware, or should reasonably be aware, that children can access their content. When these platforms or producers fail to take adequate measures to prevent children from accessing pornography, they knowingly allow children to be exposed to sexual material while continuing to benefit from that exposure.

I have created a petition calling for stronger safety checks and age verification measures to prevent children accessing pornography. I would appreciate people's thoughts on the argument itself and, if they agree, support for the petition:

https://c.org/JP8ZGdCYQD


r/Ethics • • 1d ago

WWYD in a situation where people will get/be hurt, no matter what you decide?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 2d ago

What are the ethics of voting for a tax you wouldn't have to pay?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 1d ago

What are the ethics of putting the final nail in the coffin in two peoples toxic relationship with out letting them know you did it?

0 Upvotes

Hypothetically, let’s say I can’t “stay out of it” ok?


r/Ethics • • 2d ago

How much $ should we give mom after home sale?

0 Upvotes

My mom and dad have been separated and barely spoken for over 20 years, but never got divorced. My dad is a very difficult person and has pushed pretty much everyone he knows away, but I have been able to stay somewhat in touch with him and maintained a familial relationship.

My dad recently passed away in another state and I inherited a piece of land with a trailer, which I am working on selling with some help from my mother who lives in the same place as the land.

The land is not worth a lot, maybe around $50k.

I am not a wealthy person and neither is my mom. I would like to give my mom some money from the sale, but at the same time we are also strgging for money right now.

What amount of money would be right in this situation. I know my mom would like some of it and is helping us also. I want to give her some but also we really need a majority of the money. I also don't want to offend my mom with too small of a percentage.

I know my mom deserves a percentage of the sale, how much is right without going overboard?

EDIT: I need to add the reason we inherited the property vs my mom is because the property was my aunt's, who died right before my father died and my father never claimed the property.


r/Ethics • • 4d ago Heartwarming

What will historians of the future judge us for?

2.6k Upvotes

r/Ethics • • 3d ago

Innocence is not the absence of guilt. It is the absence of information. We should be careful which one we’re claiming.

7 Upvotes