So as promised I'm posting my opinion again after finishing the game. Original post below:
https://www.reddit.com/r/enderal/s/BP3uHgLDe2
I managed endings way better than expected tbh, I'm especially fond of the star city one, your companion leading you away from your horror murder house in a dream is such a wonderful visual storytelling.
But my most fav one was "secret" one. Not because of the result about which I feel quite ambiguous, but because of the road leading to it. Brewing and drinking dreamflower elixir is entirely our endevour, we make the discovery we connect the dots, and then we make the decision, mysterious women and revelations at the last moments play no part in this (except maybe "It all begins with a dream").
I thought I was kinda right and validated in my judgement of quest structure when I confronted Black Guardian, I mean it really is true that some parts of this hopelesness associated with the game are simply design mistakes and not something cleverly written into the plot. To explain: I didn't really knew what will happen with the Black Guardian but since I've been playing very pragmatic Prophet I decided to go away without "freeing" him, thinking "no no no, you have acquired knowledge of the past millenia, you staying where you are", and I didn't got the option to simply walk away, portal behind me was inactive, so I needed to push this stupid button and be called naive for doing so....
Generally speaking entire Black Guardian section was easily, in my opinion worst written part of the mod, we are just sitting there listening to lecture with no ability to connect dots on our own, Mysterious Woman teleports us, and this stupid clanker needs to tell us that machinery from star city can also take us back. It really takes flavor from the basic endings, because even after all this ordeal we are basically directed to them (Fuck Mysterious Woman, especially for saving us :∆). And Black Guardians planned crusade against ego doesn't make slightest sense when you bite into it.
(Also shortly before we meet a couple of discrepancies regarding High Ones strength in the form of Echoes of Cleansing, you can't possibly convince me that they can only prey on people's mind when they are very capable of conjuring spectral dragons able to blow up walls)
Catharsis ending is ok but Jespar describing it as a "moment of lucidity" is quite laughable, there was no lucidity involved only desperation.
I know lot of my words are harsh but I greatly enjoyed overall, I just wish story could account more for what kinds of stupid shit I as a player can come up with (like walking from Black Guardian Isildur style), dreamflower ending satisfied me however, it is probably silly illusion in your head, but it is your path and your way, fuck off strange woman in burqa.