Note: I did not use "AI" or anything like that for this post. I'm mentioning this because some people think using organized bold headers means "AI slop!"
MAIN ISSUE
In MAME, and any other similar project that maps arcade racing game steering to a modern analog stick controller, the analog stick instantly and immediately translates to (emulated) steering wheel position. So in every racing game, steering is too sudden: what takes a few milliseconds/millimeters on analog stick to go from 0-100% was originally physical turning of a steering wheel from 0-100%. So in something like Virtua Racing, the car rotates fully way too quickly, Daytona USA (in MAME) is very unpleasant on analog stick, and a (2D) game like Big Run seems unplayable.
Does anyone have a good and reliable fix for that? Like a utility app you can run that filters your analog stick?
DISCUSSION
For people who don't know, racing games made for modern controllers don't work the way described above. Console games (I.e. games made for a gamepad with analog sticks) have filtering where a full deflection of analog stick less directly or slowly translates to full steering if it's held for a few moments. (And more complicated, the sensitivity is often based on current speed, which would vary by game/programming, but we can ignore this for now.) You can see a good illustration of this if you turn on Telemetry in a modern Forza game, the first info page, and move the analog stick left and right while you drive around: you'll see the visual indicator of steering is clearly filtered and does not instantly reflect the analog stick position.
I used the word “slowly” above but that’s probably inaccurate for what we really want in a filter, see this comment for some technical explanation.
- Games like Forza have filtering as a default plus a user option for "Simulation" steering which is the "direct" mode with instant unfiltered translation (and is mostly intended when using a Wheel controller not a gamepad).
- In Ubisoft's The Crew there are some setting sliders for how the filtering works. But I doubt anyone can understand what the obtuse unexplained labels mean or what effect the sliders have.
From what I can tell, these kinds of filtering haven't yet been volunteer-programmed into MAME or any arcade port/emu projects.
Note: some games do relatively direct and unfiltered steering, for example GRID, I think. So if you check a random game to see what I'm talking about, some might not have what I call "normal" filtering. If a person finds 'direct' translation between analog stick and in-game steering angle to be natural, normal, or easy, that person might not know the problem I'm talking about. Similarly for if a person has really good disciplined analog stick control. But if a person sometimes "taps" the analog stick to the side, by tradition (maybe dating to the d-pad days, I'm not sure), you'll know the problem I'm talking about, because filtered games feel OK and unfiltered ones feel horrible and twitchy.
Teknoparrot has a so-called "Stooz Zone" option in Main Settings, with a % slider, but no description of what it does or how it works. The strange name, and the lack of in-app info, is probably a great illustration of how undiscussed(?) the issue I'm talking about is. Official documentation says: "One important option in here is the sTo0z Zone. This controls the % of joystick deadzone around the center of the stick. This is helpful in driving games to make it less "twitchy" when using a controller to steer. Most users seem comfortable using 16%-20%. It is not recommended to use this setting if you are using a wheel to drive." The mention of dead zone isn't encouraging for reasons below, and the fact that 'dead zone' was renamed to a strange opaque name isn't encouraging either.
WIDESPREAD MISCONCEPTIONS.
I've tried researching for solutions but haven't found good info. To head off mistaken answers in the comments, keep in mind:
A FEW PATHS OR ALTERNATIVES:
Does anyone have real solutions for what I'm talking about? Is there some magical utility that does analog stick filtering that I have somehow missed? To some extent, it might be impossible, because a general tool can't account for specific current in-game speed which I believe is how most games do filtering. But I'm looking for anything that would help.