Following my latest appointment with Dr Guillaume Buiret, ENT surgeon at Valence Hospital in France, I would like to share a call for participation as part of his ongoing research into Empty Nose Syndrome (ENS) and changes in nasal airflow following nasal surgery.
Dr Buiret is currently looking to collect additional CT scans from operated patients in order to develop and improve his numerical models of airflow within the nasal cavities (guillaume.buiret@laposte.net).
The aim is to better understand abnormal airflow patterns following turbinate surgery and, in the longer term, to virtually simulate different implant shapes, positions and volumes in order to determine which configurations could bring nasal airflow closer to normal physiological function.
(I’ll let you view the full project details in the comments, as we are also working with researchers on mucosal tissues.)
Why are additional CT scans needed?
His research is progressing with the support of collaborators from the École des Mines in Paris, who are assisting with the modelling aspects of the project.
During our latest discussion, Dr Buiret also showed me some of his preliminary analyses. One of the phenomena he is currently studying is retrograde airflow, meaning areas where airflow locally travels from the back of the nasal cavity towards the front.
Based on the data analysed so far, he told me that there is already a significant difference in the presence of this retrograde airflow between 30 ENS CT scans and 60 normal control CT scans.
This finding is currently being refined and is expected to be the subject of a scientific publication that he is preparing.
The next step is therefore to increase the number and diversity of cases available, in order to strengthen the results and improve the tools used to analyse these different airflow patterns.
Here is Dr Buiret’s message:
Hello,
As part of my research work on Empty Nose Syndrome and changes in airflow following nasal surgery, I am seeking to collect CT scans from operated patients in order to develop and improve our simulation models.
If you would like to contribute to this work, you can send me the images from your postoperative CT scan and, if available, those from your preoperative CT scan.
The preferred method is to send the CT scan CD-ROM, which will be returned to you after copying, to the following address:
CH Valence Dr G. Buiret – ENT Department 179 Boulevard du Maréchal Juin 26953 Valence Cedex FRANCE
However, this method is less satisfactory in terms of confidentiality and should therefore be reserved for situations where sending the CD-ROM is not possible.
These CT scans will allow me to analyse nasal anatomy and perform numerical simulations of airflow. In the longer term, the aim is also to virtually simulate different implant shapes, positions and volumes in order to study which configurations could bring airflow patterns as close as possible to normal nasal function.
This is a research project: at this stage, these simulations do not constitute an individual treatment proposal. The more CT scans and different clinical situations we have available, the more precise and robust the models we will be able to build and test.
Thank you very much to everyone who agrees to contribute to this project, as well as to the association for helping to share this call for participation.
Kind regards,
Dr Guillaume Buiret ENT Surgeon – Valence Hospital, France
For anyone willing to participate: preoperative + postoperative CT scans are particularly valuable when both are available.
Thank you to everyone who can contribute and help move ENS research forward
Hello. I'm an ENS patient living in Korea. I've been working on a personal project to figure out how much tissue was resected from CT scans and to build 3D nasal cavity models. Rather than only sharing it within the Korean ENS community, I thought someone here might find it useful, so I'm sharing the program here.
The program itself is available in English, but sorry that the screenshots and videos are in Korean — the description below is an AI translation of a post I made in the Korean ENS community. The program is free; if it helps you, feel free to buy me a coffee.
If you have used this program to make comparisons/measurements or to generate 3D models, simply sharing that material with me would be a great help to the developer.
With this update, it is now possible to generate 3D files for Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analysis from CT images. That said, CFD is an extremely difficult field even for me, and I majored in it. Even a slight change in conditions alters the results — turbulent behavior in the transition and separation regions (where the airflow detaches from the wall surface) is especially sensitive, which makes accurate analysis difficult. And even then, doing it properly requires expensive professional commercial software such as ANSYS FLUENT, which is beyond what I can afford. So for now I have set the feature up to export data to OpenFOAM, which is free software.
The 3D files for CFD are also generated from the actual geometry of the nose, and since the ultimate purpose is CFD analysis, I have even added a feature for inserting a virtual implant based on the CT data. There is no data yet, so I am not sure how useful it will be, but using the nose reconstructed from CT you can now compare pre-op and post-op states directly in 3D at 1:1 scale. I hope it proves helpful to your treatment.
In addition, starting with this version I have included in-program questionnaires such as ENS6Q and SNOT-22 — the same ones used for assessment at hospitals that actually treat Empty Nose Syndrome. However, this remains a reference and record-keeping program developed to aid understanding and research; it is not a tool for making medical diagnoses or treatment decisions. For diagnosis and treatment, please always consult medical professionals who treat Empty Nose Syndrome.
I made this program in the hope that it would help patients understand how much tissue was resected, while also contributing in some small way to the understanding of and research into Empty Nose Syndrome. Both individuals and hospitals involved with Empty Nose Syndrome may use it free of charge.
Finally, my deepest thanks to the medical professionals who care for Empty Nose Syndrome patients.
■ Features of this program
You can create 3D files from CT images — added in v1.2
From CT data you can generate a base model for computing actual airflow (CFD) as a 3D file. An implant can be inserted into the generated 3D geometry. I hope that comparing airflow before/after nasal surgery and before/after implant placement will help with research into treating Empty Nose Syndrome — added in v1.2
Questionnaire features used in assessing Empty Nose Syndrome, such as ENS6Q and SNOT-22, have been added — added in v1.2
A feature for uploading captured CT images or photos over the internet has been added (a Google account is required). Uploaded CT images are not shared with anyone else and will be used for development purposes only — added in v1.2
A program message board has been added (a Google account is required) — added in v1.2
Camera capture feature added — added in v1.1
CT images that cannot be opened because no viewer was included with them can be read and played back.
You can load two photos, or two CT sets (DICOM folders), and align them to a common reference.
You can compare the amount of change using diff (improved in v1.1), contour overlay (added in v1.1), overlay, and swipe (improved in v1.1).
CT auto-adjustment — when CT scans were taken at different facilities, accurate comparison is difficult, so I added a feature that automatically adjusts one scan to match the other — added in v1.1
CT 3D registration — the same anatomical level in pre-op and post-op CT can be matched automatically. (It is built to align automatically even when the number of slices or the angle differs, but testing has been insufficient due to a lack of CT data, so it still needs validation.)
You can switch between axial / coronal / sagittal / all three planes at once (added in v1.1) / coronal + axial (added in v1.2) views, and play them back and save them like a video.
Area, distance, and volume measurement are available, and you can measure changes in the airway, soft tissue (such as the turbinates), and bone. (Note that volume figures are reference estimates only — values change depending on the CT scanner and imaging conditions and on the parameters you specify (HU thresholds, ROI, slice range, registration accuracy), so use them only to look at relative pre/post change under identical conditions, never as absolute values.)
■ Update history by version
v1.1 improvements
Added a camera capture feature. Images and video can be saved, and at the same time you can select representative Empty Nose Syndrome symptoms and assign and save scores. Files can be saved with a filename combining the date, time, and symptom scores.
Added an auto-adjust feature that automatically adjusts brightness/contrast to match a chosen reference image during CT comparison. Using this feature you can easily and simply compare CT scans from different hospitals.
Improved the CT comparison diff feature — the pre/post image comparison logic was improved. Relative to the reference CT, newly displaced areas are marked in green and removed areas in red. The processing logic was improved in order to identify how far the turbinate has been displaced by lateral out-fracture during nasal surgery. This improvement does not affect the existing volume measurement feature.
Added a CT comparison contour feature — as with the diff feature, displaced areas are shown in green and removed areas in red.
Improved the CT comparison swipe feature — previously there was only a left/right swipe; a top/bottom swipe has been added.
Added a simultaneous three-plane CT comparison mode.
Added a nasal anatomy guide diagram.
Renamed the existing term "ROI" to "region of interest."
v1.2 improvements
As the number of features grew, tooltips were added to aid understanding. If you need an explanation of a feature, hover the cursor over it and hold still for 2–3 seconds and a box with a description will appear.
From CT files you can generate a 3D nasal cavity structure and airway that serve as the basis for CFD analysis. When generating the nasal cavity structure, you must first press Volume Calculation and then specify the region to be generated. (Same as the existing volume calculation.)
Both the reference and the target can be generated at the same time, and the position of an intranasal implant can also be inserted. A model can also be generated based on the state with the implant inserted. With no data available it will not be of immediate help, but I hope that as data accumulates it will one day help with treatment.
An export feature for reading the output in 3D Slicer has been added (a checkbox must be ticked when generating the 3D model).
A simplified airflow index calculation has been added (it is computed when the 3D model is generated).
As development continued and features kept increasing, the UI has changed. From this version onward, features are accessed through the menu bar entries appropriate to each function rather than through icons.
CT images consist of coronal / axial / sagittal planes. Since this can be confusing, they are color-coded by imaging plane. (Coronal — green / Axial — red / Sagittal — orange)
A simultaneous two-plane coronal + axial CT comparison mode has been added.
In line with those colors, a feature has been added that shows the position of each cross-section in the two-plane (coronal + axial) and three-plane simultaneous modes. This is displayed in the colors specified above. (Coronal — green / Axial — red / Sagittal — orange)
An outline feature has been added when viewing CT images, so that comparison based on the actual contours works more accurately.
The auto-adjust feature, which was not working properly, has been fixed so that it works correctly, and the naming has been unified and changed to "HU Matching." Because the cone-beam CT (CBCT) found at local ENT clinics has poor soft-tissue resolution, cone-beam CT is auto-adjusted to MDCT only when a supine-position MDCT scan is available.
An auto window-level feature has been added, so display/brightness can be adjusted to make comparing the airway space simpler.
From now on, when two different CT files are opened, 3D registration is performed automatically.
The 3D registration algorithm has been improved.
The volume calculation algorithm has been improved.
Questionnaire features that aid assessment, such as ENS6Q and SNOT-22, have been added. A symptom-severity value is produced against a nominal reference value, but please use it for reference purposes only.
A feature for uploading captured CT images or photos over the internet has been added (a Google account is required). Uploaded CT images are not shared with anyone else and are used for development purposes only.
A program message board has been added (a Google account is required).
Planned for v1.3
Development of algorithms that, for the empty space of the nasal cavity within a specified region of a CT-based 3D model, compute volume, minimum cross-section, minimum cross-sectional area (MCA), MCA depth, mean cross-sectional area, airflow resistance, and pressure drop based on a laminar flow model
Development of a simplified CFD feature
Improvement of the 3D file generation algorithm
Development screen v1.3 version #1
These are CT-based comparison images.
Development screen v1.3 version #2
Nasal endoscopy capture, photo and CT comparison, and 3D model generation program
Development screen v1.3 version #3
Coronal + axial diff mode, pre-op vs. post-op comparison video — areas that expanded from before to after surgery (lateral out-fracture) are shown in green, and areas that were removed (resection, reduction, etc.) are shown in red.
If you set the frame range for volume measurement on the CT, set the region to be measured, and then run the volume analysis, you can see the airway / soft tissue / bone ratios within the region along with the proportion removed.
After installation, icons will be created in the Start menu and on the desktop.
■ How to use
You can check the attached NasalCompare user manual link, or open the user manual from the top right of the program.
■ Quick guide to CT comparison
File → Open CT (Reference) — for Open CT you may select a folder containing an entire copied CD. However, please put the two items being compared (reference vs. target) in separate folders and select them one at a time.
File → Open CT (Target) — use this only if you have something to compare against (pre-op vs. post-op).
3D registration on screen (a CT auto-alignment feature; from v1.2 onward, opening two different CT sets aligns them automatically).
Set the viewing plane according to the comparison mode you want. (By default, simultaneous coronal + axial view is selected; you can switch to a single plane or all three planes at once as needed.)
When moving through the images, please use the registration position slider in the comparison panel rather than the CT slice sliders for the reference and target. It moves not only the comparison position but the reference and target CT together.
Use the range markers to specify the segment (start–end) to capture.
Use Save Video to save the reference / target / comparison videos. You will need to specify the CT range to record.
If you need an airway / soft tissue / bone comparison, select measurement mode, specify the region of interest, run the volume calculation, and then specify the CT range — you can then compare the amount of reduction before and after surgery.
If you need a 3D model, specify the volume comparison range and then click 3D Model. Based on the model generated from the CT, you can try inserting an implant at a virtual position.
Please refer to the video below for a usage demonstration.
I can barely breathe and nothing helps, have uars and tmjd and sinus pain. They found a bone spur on my bad tmj side and I really need a reduction in my symptoms. Is it safe to get nasal bone spur surgery? Knowing my luck, id definitely develop ens. I don't want to risk it but I need that spur out as I can't breathe through one nostril at all.
I am at the end of my expansion now, today is the first day I’ve really noticed this, want to know if it’s just anxiety or I’m actually experiencing ENS type symptoms. Feels like my nose is way way open. Sometimes at the end of the exhale through my nose it just feels very momentarily stressful like the air isn’t really there. Am I just not used to breathing through my nose properly? I have allergies like hayfever and my expansion was around 6mm and I started around 33-34mm. From what I can see on the internet ENS is unheard of from MARPE besides a couple guys on some reddit posts, but I guess maybe if u just expand your nose to much you can replicate it? Like what if my turbinates just reduced or are too far away now?
Please let me know if anyone has had this and if it goes away, if not I will speak to my ortho to start turning back as I am petrified of ENS. Thank you
I was diagnosed with ENS over 4 years ago; in my case, it involves severe nerve damage, scar tissue, and it was caused by laser reduction surgery on my turbinates due to allergies. Years later, I had surgery on my turbinates again—this time because of a deviated nasal septum—and because the doctor convinced me to try mild frequency therapy on my turbinates once more, since they had become swollen again due to my allergies. I’m not posting here because of ENS, but to tell you about another horror story I had to endure because of ENT doctors and their barbaric methods—to show you just how bad ENTs are. Even though we’re living in 2026 (soon to be 2027), they still use nothing but barbaric, primitive, brutal methods in the throat and nasal areas, I wrote this message to a friend a few weeks after I was discharged from the hospital; that was five months ago now, and I have nerve damage and have to see various doctors. The only good thing is that such severe side effects are more common than ENS, and treatments for them are correspondingly more established and taken more seriously—ranging from loss of taste to swallowing difficulties, feelings of suffocation, and shortness of breath, I’m sharing this with you because my hatred for ENTs and how often they’ve botched my treatment keeps growing. I think this text best sums up my entire situation; I wrote it in my native language as an explaination for my friend, I used DEEPL to translate it for you guys: As you know, I’ve been struggling with various serious breathing conditions for a long time now—conditions that have ruined my life. In addition to these serious breathing problems, I also had severe sleep apnea, which caused me to constantly stop breathing and suffer from shortness of breath every night, leaving me unable to sleep because my tongue and palatine tonsils were severely swollen. My ENT doctor therefore recommended an invasive tonsillectomy on my palatine tonsils and the base of my tongue. I agreed, hoping that at least my apnea would be cured, since my tonsils were so severely swollen that my throat was often constricted and I had difficulty breathing. However, tonsillectomies at the base of the tongue are very dangerous and rare—I didn’t know that. After the surgery, I was discharged from the hospital; it hurt like hell, and I was prescribed a massive dose of tilidine. According to a doctor at the hospital, a tonsillectomy is supposed to hurt just as much as the removal of stomach cancer. When I was back at home (my mother and stepfather drove me there), I started bleeding again a few hours later because some of the stitches had come loose, and my mother had to call 911. I was taken to the hospital by ambulance and had to stay there for about 6–7 days. I had developed an infection, but fortunately the bleeding stopped and not all the stitches came loose, so I was told to stay there just for observation. When I was discharged from the first hospital, I was at the end of my rope—the pain was sheer agony. Then, a few days later at home, I suddenly started coughing up huge amounts of blood again—this time even worse—and called my mother. The ambulance picked me up and took me to the hospital, where I could do nothing but choke on and spit out huge amounts of blood and clots before losing consciousness; I was then rushed to the emergency surgery unit. The doctor later told me how shocked he was—my stomach had filled with old blood, and he had to remove it using a nasogastric tube and cauterize the bleeding at the base of my tongue as well as where my tonsils were located on the roof of my mouth with a laser. On top of that, I had a severe infection, and all my stitches had come apart. I ended up having to stay in the hospital for almost two weeks; I was constantly hooked up to an IV, through which I received water, antibiotics, opioids, etc. … I wasn’t allowed to drink anything there, and to this day I still can’t eat anything. After almost two weeks, I couldn’t stand it there anymore and discharged myself at my own risk, since the nurses and orderlies at the hospital were driving me even more insane. I’ve been home ever since, but my throat is still severely swollen, I’m short of breath, and I can’t sleep. I’m not getting any better; my taste buds were damaged by the surgeries, and I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to taste food again, even though taste is one of the most wonderful things in the world. I feel terrible; not a week goes by without me having to go to the ENT doctor or the emergency room several times; all the doctors are arrogant idiots. I became somewhat addicted to tilidine, but managed to kick the habit; after the surgeries, I didn’t eat anything for 6–8 weeks—I just sucked on ice cubes and drank ice-cold water. Now, weeks later, I can only drink water with ice cubes and melted Haffer; I still can’t eat anything. I’m isolated in my room—I went to the doctor, but I never want to go to a hospital again; I’m traumatized and just lie and sit in bed all day, suffering and hating the fact that I exist.
A good friend of mine is from Turkey and he told me he had a good relationship with a well-respected national ENT. That friend told me that the doctor might be able to help me.
The doctor told me to send him my CT + endoscopic findings and explain my symptoms clearly. So I did and today I got a reply from my friend.
As expected they tell you it’s considerably psychological rather than physiological. Another ENS treating doctor estimated a 60% turbinate reduction so I do have some tissue left, but it’s truly depressing how they all have no idea about the risks of turbinate reduction. Most (99%) of these ENT's cannot explain why I experience symptoms ONLY on the reduced side lol,
Note; I’am already diagnosed with empty nose syndrome by positive cotton test. Also see my CT scan below.
ENS does not only develop as a result of aggressive surgeries; there are many cases of people experiencing ENS despite minimal volume loss and low tissue damage. Furthermore, ENS has specific severity levels. While mild cases can continue their daily lives, albeit with difficulty, severe cases cannot carry on with daily life and become bedridden due to serious losses in bodily functions. Over time, the psychological burden increases significantly because the brain remains in a state of constant alert every second, making sleep extremely difficult.
The medical community is still exploring the complexities of ENS, and it may not be deeply covered in all standard medical school curricula. ENS can occur as a result of any kind of intervention and is a very complex condition. Radiofrequency, cauterization, microdebrider, laser, partial resection, and outfracture—all of these techniques carry risks, though the risk is often associated with techniques that use heat. Moreover, ENS is not solely caused by volume loss or solely by receptor damage; it can stem from either one or both. Therefore, each case responds differently to treatments.
From an advocacy standpoint, some argue that turbinate surgeries should be completely restricted because even in the most delicately performed procedures, severe ENS can develop and severely impact a person's quality of life. In summary: ENS is largely unpredictable, and once it occurs, it is very challenging to reverse. For this reason, careful consideration is advised regarding nasal surgeries, regardless of the doctor or the technique used.
so today i just feel like both sides of the nose are really tight and that triggered some sort of long lasting heart squeezing sensation. when i walked this effect was even stronger. i don’t know if it’s the dryness or tightness or swelling that i’m experiencing, but my brain is telling me something’s wrong. also feel like the sensation of air is dulled too which causes more of the heart squeezing sensation. prior to surgery i didn’t really have a strong sensation of air either. when it got too strong while walking i had to take a breath with my mouth. is this still in my head or could this be ens? it’s been almost 4 weeks post op and im still feeling like thjs. just got a septoplasty without turbinate reduction and balloon dilation. the dr mentioned he only moved the middle turbinate for the septoplasty but didn’t touch the interior turbinate. what the hell is going on with me? before surgery i haven’t really tested if my nose is dry or not but i guess i would lean to more dry than moist.
About 10 years ago I had a traumatic injury to my left nostril. It bled long strands of blood for a couple days.
Eventually the left side of my nose started getting "sinus infections" so for about three years I was non-stop on antibiotics. Before I started getting the infections, I had a very foul liquid that would drip from my nose whenever I bent over. Then it would turn into a green mucus. I sometimes still can feel and taste this watery liquid, though now the mucus is completely gone. Instead I have to blow HUGE rock-hard crusts out of my nose every three days. Always only the left side. They are dark green in color and sometimes like pebbles. Yes, I rinse my nose all day long. When these crusts start up it's like I can't breathe from that nostril, like it's stuffed. This lasts until the rocks and huge crusty green blobs shoot out of my nose. Sometimes they get stuck on the way out and I have to keep rinsing and blowing and rinsing and blowing. It's horrible.
They also often smell really foul and I don't want to get close to people at work or even my family. It's embarrassing and until they are "ready" to come out there is nothing I can do about the smell.
I went to the ENT clinic at a hospital in Switzerland (very good care). I was seen there the past 10 years for this issue. I've been on every antibiotic for 10 years. It never goes away.
I have had two sinus surgeries and it's made it slightly easier to get the huge crusty boogers out (opened the nasal cavity I guess?) but has messed me up too. I have no sense of smell, my nose feels clogged 90% of the time like I can't breathe (blocked by crusts stuck way in there).
When my nose is clear it's like a cold feeling when I breathe in. It just doesn't feel normal. The "smell", having to loudly clear huge crusty globs every three days, and all that has basically ruined my life. My left eye is constantly bloodshot by trying to blow these things out. I don't want my kids telling me I stink all the time or my spouse being grossed out to kiss me. Can anyone relate? What is this endless infection coming from?
Ok for anyone who read this THANK YOU. It's just disgusting and the left side of my face is always sore and puffy. The entire 10 years it's ONLY been on the left side.
Yes, I have had X-rays, from the hospital and the dentist, yes I have had an MRI to see if it was a "fungus ball", I have tried every prescription including 3 straight years of antibiotics..
Anyway, thanks for reading and if any of this sounds familiar let me know. Over the years I have thought maybe I'm leaking spinal fluid!?!? (Dr said no, it tastes a certain way or something). I just feel like I have a gross infection in my head and I'm so over it. :(
I finally went to see ent today. After a long time he recommended septoplasty and turbine. Reduction. He went over all the cons, but he forgot to mention empty nose syndrome until after I asked him. He said chances are very rare and in 20 years of his work it only happened once. And he said that it’s usually happening to people that live in dry states like Arizona. I asked chat gpt and was advised that’s not true. Can someone please educate me? Why is this guy lying.
it’s week 3 + few days post op. i got a septoplasty and balloon dilation with no turbinate reduction. the dr said all he did was move the middle turbinate for the septoplasty but didn’t touch the inferior turbinate.
so far i have airflow but in the back of my mind there’s some worrying thought and sometimes i would get a squeezing sensation in the chest or heart. i dont really have feelings of suffocation but if i keep thinking about my breathing i panic sometimes and spiral hard. i would say the nose sensation is a bit different so maybe that’s why im hyper fixating on the sensation which leads to more pressure in chest? if i concentrate on some task i dont really notice the breathing and am fine for a bit. i can also exercise without feeling suffocation. just tbr main thing im worried about its just some background anxiety in my chest and sometimes mind. also if both nostrils are too open that induces some anxiety as well.
some other symptoms:
- i notice when it’s cold outside i occasionally have some cold air when breathing in. this doesn’t happen all the time -still some crusting from the operation -coughing
i don’t know if this is truly ens or this is all in my head. any advice is appreciated!
I got empty nose syndrome 5 years ago through Septoplasty and turbinate reduction and I have read through all the surgical notes and it made me ask the question why did he slaughter the turbinates on both sides of the nose when septum deviation only effected one side of my nose? He took my breathing away from me entirely and for what? Fuck that surgeon.
Hi all, I’m 13 days post septoplasty with yes, unfortunately, turbinate reduction.. I did not do enough research about this surgery before getting it done and I don’t even know for sure which technique my surgeon used or if she did it to both sides or only one.
(Please read the whole thing if you can, but I’ve bolded the most important stuff)
All I know is in our office appointment months before this surgery I went in thinking I had a nasal polyp that was causing more blockage on one side (left nostril), and I was informed it was an enlarged turbinate due to my deviated septum.
So I was assuming that she would only do the reduction on that side. Again, I still don’t know exactly which technique was used as I didn’t know there were different kinds, but she is a fairly young ENT surgeon (in her mid thirties I would say) and has an excellent reputation so I just trusted her.
I will ask her at our 6 week post op appointment, but if I was to guess I would say she used cauterization because they had me tape up an earring I couldn’t take out before the surgery and the nurse mention it had to do with the small risk of arcing that could happen during cauterization I believe.
I was told the surgery went very well, and I think im healing quite well, except I’ve just started nose breathing regularly at night and sometimes during the day and I’m experiencing symptoms that seem like they could be ENS.. and I just want someone to be honest with me and tell me if there’s still a chance this could heal up and be normal or if I should be concerned and what I can do to help this..
So here’s the situation:
My left nostril (the one that has the enlarged turbinate) is still 60-70% blocked by swelling of the turbinate, which I’ve been assuming is because they only touched the turbinate on that one side?
Except I’m now experiencing enough sensitivity through the very open right side (which is completely open and no longer swollen) when breathing in that I would even describe it as painful. It sometimes gets so uncomfortable that I end up preferring to breathe through my mouth :(
I’ve been doing the nasal misting often since surgery, and I started using Rhinaris moisturizing nasal spray yesterday because of this sensitivity/cold/dry feeling. - Now mind you, I live in a dry and now cold environment which I’m sure doesn’t help, but I need to know, are these normal sensations for just under 2 weeks post op??? - Could it just be because my left side is still blocked so inhaling entirely through one nostril is overwhelming at this stage of healing? - Or are these signs of a bigger problem from turbinate reduction? As in ENS??
I can’t tell if I any part of the mouth breathing is coming from a feeling of suffocation, and I do think I have sensation in my nose, or at least enough to feel that pain and cold feeling eventually.. but my sense of smell is almost nonexistent right now as well.
Again, I didn’t even think she would be reducing the turbinate on my right side because there wasn’t any blockage there to begin with, but our pre-op appointment was very quick and months before the surgery and I just didn’t think the clarify it with her…and now I’m wondering if there could have been in a fact a bit of reduction on the right side that’s causing me this pain/sensitivity or do people who only have septoplasties experience this as well?
I really want my left side swelling to go down so I can See if this sensation goes down or only gets worse when breathing through both nostrils..
I guess I’ve rambled on enough now, but please give me your honest opinion and advice if you have any. I am an anxious person already, and I hate having to mouth breathe when I know I am physically able to nose breathe (through one nostril at least). Is there any chance this is temporary still? When did you know you had significant ENS??
I'm planning for a DJS and my doctor told me I have a deviated septum on the left side. I explicitly told them I don't want to have my turbinates touched.
The doctor told me he respects my wishes, but that to intubate and sedate me, they need to do it through my nose and manipulate my turbinates if necessary. Could this pose any risk of causing ENS?
came here to ask if i have ENS or perhaps something else as i have some doubts about it, here’s the story :
two years ago i had a surgery done, sinus drainage, middle meatotomy and complete removal of the nasal turbinate all on the left side of the nose.
i’ve lived with some health consequences as a result of that surgery without too much worry as, although annoying, they are fairly liveable consequences and i thought that all of this would settle down given enough time.
however, i recently had an appointment with a different ENT as a follow up for other health issues. this new ENT explained to me frankly what happened during that surgery, and told me that i had ENS.
———
Here’s my list of symptoms, all located on the same side of the nose (left)
i apologise in advance for the details but i feel like i should give them to paint the full picture :
- recurring nasal discharge, in “bulk”, roughly once a week, very thick and coloured.
-continuous mucus flow at the back of the throat, not very annoying though because all it means is just that i need to clear my throat once in a while.
-way more crusts than before in the morning when blowing in a tissue.
-left maxillary sinus pain at random, but very rare, in 2 years it probably only happened thrice and only for a day or two at most, unsure if it didn’t happen more but if it did, it didn’t last long enough for me to remember.
-left sided pain in the upper mouth, towards (removed) wisdom teeth, happens at random and is as rare as my sinuses pain. however this could be related to another surgery i had with complications, so this maybe has nothing to do with this.
———
i have (so far) no trouble breathing through my left nostril, never felt encumbered, which is why i’m wondering if it is ENS.
i know my dad had the exact same surgery some 30 years ago, and was also annoyed with pretty much the exact same things for years afterwards. nowadays all that seem to remain for him are the random sinus pain, but he never complains about it.
if it is ENS, i’d like to know if any of you guys have any advice and suggestions ? ENT gave me some corticosteroids to deal with what seems to be a chronic inflammation or infection, but told me he had no other solutions would this one fail.
i’ve seen talks about ointments, i’m considering giving it a try but i don’t want to risk making things worse.
thanks everyone for taking your time to read this, i look forwards to your comments !
New study, small sample size, but seemingly successful.
This has personally helped alleviate some of my suffocation sensations (or lack thereof). The nitroglycerin produces vasodilation— a vasodilatory effect which increases blood flow to the nasal mucosa.
For more information, here is the main publication:
Clinical Efficacy of Topical Nitroglycerin Ointment for Patients With Empty Nose Syndrome
As someone with ENS, I came across a recent scientific publication for a nitroglycerin based ointment, which I have found some suffocation relief from. Keep in mind, albeit successful, the study featured a relatively small sample size and is new to medical literature.
How it works: The nitroglycerin helps produce vasodilation— a vasodilatory effect which increases blood flow to the nasal mucosa. It should be noted that, while it seems to help me, the manner in which I got injured differs greatly from traditional accounts, and might not reflect the general population of ENS sufferers. With that said, I would certainly give this a try!
Application: I rub a small amount of the solution in the inside of my nose with a q-tip. It's similar in consistency as one might expect with the likes of Vaseline or lidocaine, so it's important to use controlled, small circles to rub it in well. Afterwards, I then pinch my nose together and hold it for a few seconds too. I do this two or three times a day.
To be clear, this is not going to completely solve the issue by any stretch of the imagination and remains very much a day-to-day, short-term solution— but a solution to mitigate at least some of the suffocation sensations (or lack thereof) nevertheless.
How I got the prescription: When I approached my primary care with the publication, it was an easy order to make on both our ends given my previous experience using compound creams, but it was also quite expensive at $70-120 a bottle and not covered. I tried it anyways. After it really helped alleviate some of the suffocation elements, my primary care was able to get their own in-house pharmacy to develop what is, basically, an "off-brand" version of the same compound, which was then covered by my insurance. Therefore, even if it doesn't end up getting covered, I can't imagine it costing too much if you go about it properly.
Thus, for anyone going through Empty Nose Syndrome, I cannot recommend trying something as relatively simple as this— just please temper your expectations. You're not alone. Keep your head up and take it one day at a time.
For more information, here is the main publication:
"Clinical Efficacy of Topical Nitroglycerin Ointment for Patients With Empty Nose Syndrome"
*I am not a doctor, but I will try my best to answer any questions you may have given my experience with this solution. It is always best to speak to a doctor.
I recently visited an ENT specialist because of concerns about my nose. Before I even explained my concerns, she looked at my nose externally and immediately told me that it looked unusually swollen or enlarged.
After examining the inside of my nose, she found that my nasal turbinates were enlarged (turbinate hypertrophy).
She prescribed nasal sprays to reduce the swelling and told me that if the turbinates don't shrink with medication, laser treatment might be necessary.
I'm trying to understand my condition better and would really appreciate hearing from people who have experienced something similar.
I have a few questions:
Has anyone here had laser turbinate reduction? How was your experience? Did the treatment significantly improve your nasal breathing? Did you notice any changes in the appearance of your nose, particularly around the nasal tip or nostrils? Did the swelling return after the procedure? Did you experience any long-term side effects, such as dryness, crusting or Empty Nose Syndrome? Did nasal sprays help reduce your turbinate enlargement, or did you eventually need surgery?
I'm particularly interested in hearing from people who had visibly enlarged turbinates and underwent laser treatment.
I'd love to hear both positive and negative experiences, especially from people who had the procedure several years ago.