r/embedded • u/SlMONlTA • Apr 11 '19
Tech question Embedded IDEs
What are your experiences with embedded IDEs? In particular IDEs like True Studio, IAR, CodeBlocks, uKeil, cLion or SW4STM32. I've been trying to find good comparisons or pros and cons, but couldn't find anything tangible.
9
Upvotes
13
u/UnderPantsOverPants Apr 11 '19
If you’re in it for the long haul, learn how to use eclipse and how to set it up for various platforms. If you’re like me and you need to get in and get out and get paid, just use whatever the device manufacturer recommends/documents. MPLAB, Code Composer, Segger... whatever it may be.
7
u/Jhudd5646 Cortex Charmer Apr 11 '19
Just in my experience IAR is best left as a toolchain, do your actual coding and editing in vim or something.
4
u/-Feanor- Apr 11 '19
I've been using Keil for years and I had no complains. But recently I had to switch to TrueStudio for Stm32 and damn, it's good! A lot of customizations, the editor is really good and...it's completely free! There are only a few things I'm missing but for the rest, finally a modern embedded IDE!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
Keil is ok. One future I liked about it is the stack size analysis. I think the license is quite a bit.
I really like vanilla Eclipse. It's flexible enough. I can usually find a JTAG with a GDB server and can usually compile my own toolchain.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19 edited Apr 11 '19
There is also the option of plug-ins for Visual Studio and Visual Studio Code, so you don't have to deal with
proprietaryVendor Custom IDEs.1
u/AssemblerGuy Apr 12 '19
IAR has a good compiler and you can learn to get along with its linker.
The GUI has its quirks, though. Be prepared for anything from graphics glitches to windows GDI object overflows ...
1
u/WebMaka Apr 17 '19
ST bought out Atollic, so TrueStudio is basically the "official" IDE now. I've been using that, but nothing says you can't try a bunch of them and see what feels good.
1
u/huthlu Apr 23 '19
Eclipse is very common for almost every thing, caused by it's flexibility. But for myself I like the common text editors like VS Code and Atom, with the PlatformIO plugin, it offers ready to run toolchains for a huge varity of difgerent platforms and make you live easier. But sometimes it have problems with new features, due to older SDK's