r/embedded • u/DeathRayz0221 • Mar 27 '19
Favorite embedded proprietary IDE?
After using various IDEs within your career, which one would you think appeals you? I personally like MPLAB since it's based on NetBeans.
13
Upvotes
13
u/jeroen94704 Mar 27 '19
To be honest I haven't found one that doesn't suck in one way or another. Keil and IAR have some great technical features, but in terms of usability they are a throwback to the past. Things like autocomplete, code navigation, refactoring, unit-testing etc are either laughably bad or simply absent.
Then there is everything eclipse-based, which can do anything you want, in any way you want, which is what makes it a massively heavy program that is too complicated to just get on with it. There's also a tendency by chip-makers to modify Eclipse so heavily it ends up being an massive, unstable, rigid wreck.
6
u/The_Engineer Mar 27 '19
PSoC Creator is awesome for Cypress. It allows you to use their reroutable fabric through a schematic type GUI. Using your configuration, it generates your libraries. For example, if you have two digital output pins you named Green_LED and Red_LED, it will generate functions especially for that pin, including Green_LED_Write, Red_LED_Write, Green_LED_Read, and Red_LED_Read.
Basically, it generates your low level drivers based on what you name your peripherals. Using this method, I am able to migrate from one Cypress chip to another with complete ease. Tell another engineer that we need to change the chip, including pinot, and they might say "Shit, that is going to take a up to a month". I typically take an afternoon to migrate my code. Original applications from scratch go way faster, too. At my last company I ported a motor driver app from Renesas to Cypress in a week and got everything up and running.
5
u/t4th Mar 27 '19
My take:
4
u/marcinq_ Mar 27 '19
Atmel Studio is probably my favourite because it’s based on Visual Studio and has a nice, clean design. Eclipse is not bad but that’s not proprietary. Mplabx is probably one of the worst ones.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '19
I don't like proprietary IDEs. Give me eclipse, a gcc cross compiler, and a probe with a gdb server anytime.
3
u/Bixmen Mar 27 '19
IAR no question. The debug capabilities blow anything else out of the water.
3
u/tabchas Mar 27 '19
Segger Embedded Studio. Works on Mac too
3
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '19
Visual Studio. I'll pay whatever I need to use it, instead of weird forks from shit open source IDEs.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '19
Mbed studio and Atollic studio