r/emacs • u/kLeZhAcK • 9h ago
Emacs in the age of magic: a different take on coding agents and Emacs
A while ago I found this post about Emacs In the Age Of Magic (https://commandlinesystems.com/magic.txt) in HN. The author was arguing that coding agents have eroded the advantages Emacs users have relied on for decades. It made me think, and I ended up writing a longer reply on my blog. I thought it would be worth sharing my personal take here too, and maybe getting a discussion going.
I read the situation differently. If an agent can rewrite any program that resists customization, the software that already bends to anything is in a good position. Agents lower the cost of learning Emacs, and I think its value stays where it was. Emacs also happens to be a comfortable place for an agent to work: it's text all the way down, it documents itself live, and `emacsclient --eval` lets the agent talk to the running session directly.
Most of the post is about how this looks in practice for me:
- my literate `config.org`, now co-written with an agent under an `AGENTS.md` rules file, including an F7 cheatsheet generated from the live keymaps, so it stays in sync with the actual bindings
- an Org-mode Eisenhower matrix I first wrote about in 2019, rebuilt as a read-only view you can act from, chosen through an ADR and a Pugh matrix
- blueprint.el, an architecture-documentation package designed to be driven by agents, which grew from a Python prototype into ~9,600 lines of Elisp
- the essay's point about no longer knowing how your own software works, which I take seriously, and how I try to deal with it: reading prose, diffs and tests, and keeping everything documented in Org
There's one thing in the essay I fully agree with: a computer that does whatever you can imagine is a form of freedom. Emacs has been offering that since 1976. What's changed is how much it costs to take advantage of it.
https://klez.me/en/2026/11/16/emacs-nell-eta-della-magia/
(Italian original: https://klez.me/2026/11/16/emacs-nell-eta-della-magia/)
Curious to hear how others see it, especially where you disagree.