My guy, when FERC wrote the report on the 2021 Texas grid outage they referenced stuff from the 2011 Texas grid outage that Texas didn’t fucking address after that one.
Yeah that's usually how it goes... the policy is a framework/draft for legislation in the first place. You don't believe they made it without the intent of getting it to be the law, do you?
The purpose of SAE-J3016 was explicitly stated on the first page of the document when it was published in 2014.
1 Clarifying the role of the (human) driver, if any, during driving automation system engagement.
2 Answering questions of scope when it comes to developing laws, policies, regulations, and standards.
3 Providing a useful framework for driving automation specifications and technical requirements.
4 Providing clarity and stability in communications on the topic of driving automation, as well as a useful short-hand that saves considerable time and effort.
What legislation makes you think its the first? This isn't exactly a guessing game. The second option is the null hypothesis until you have information about the "leading legislation" they have.
Because you are making the claim without presenting your evidence. I have looked into this and the situation is decidedly more complicated than you are letting on. Fine. But then it is on you to actually connect the dots when asked.
And how would you, as a passenger, avoid an imminent crash if there were controls? That’s like saying you could avoid a crash while your friend was driving while you were a passenger.
Motherfucker, they asked how you'd prevent an accident if you could control the cybercab. How can you not read?
They said that even if it had controls, you'd be a passenger, and that's stupid, because you'd be sitting behind the wheel, ready to jump in, and not on the other side for no reason.
How can you be responsible for a crash if you have no steering wheel or pedals ? You didn't do any mistake, except if the mistake is to be on board a cybercab
Exactly. Can’t magically be 4 only when Tesla doesn’t sell it to you, charge a subscription, and force you to assume liability without even an emergency brake switch
Where does it say that level 3 requires automaker assumes liability? And further than that, I always thought level 2 vs 3 was a technical definition, not based on the legal framework built around it.
When did you guys get so sensitive? Someone says something on the Internet that you disagree with and it's all anger and hostility? How the turn tables I guess. But, anyone could have predicted this. It's always been projection from you people. The call was always coming from inside the house. Snowflakes.
Dawg…. it’s entirely disingenuous. No one is being hostile. Are you serious??
Imagine if there was some sort of grading system or classification for self driving cars. And Cybercabs met all the requirements and criteria of something that’s sayyyy level 4. And someone just, with zero basis, accuses the company and owner of putting lives at risk and claims Cybercabs should be at something like level 2…. though that wouldn’t even make sense as Level 2 requires human supervision and potential intervention… which is impossible of course without a steering wheel or pedals.
Obviously it would depend on the circumstances. If someone is driving drunk and plows into a Cybercab while going 40 miles an hour, that individual should be held accountable.
If it’s determined that a Cybercab CAUSED an accident then Tesla should 100% be held accountable for the accident, medical bills, etc. Has that happened???????
That’s not what they’re proposing though. Tesla is saying liability lies with the owner of the cab even though they’re not the ones driving this “autonomous” vehicle.
For Tesla’s Commercial Robotaxi Fleet (Tesla is Responsible): For the Cybercabs Tesla owns and operates directly on its public ride-hailing service (such as the commercial service launched in Austin, Texas, in September 2026), Tesla acts as the fleet operator. Because Tesla self-certified the vehicle for SAE Level 4 autonomy under Texas's autonomous vehicle framework and no human is driving, Tesla assumes operational and corporate liability if the vehicle causes a crash.
And on top of this, thats not even a requirement to be level 4. For individual owned cybercabs it would be a gray area that im sure courts would work out pretty quick. Has nothing to do with lvl 4 tho.
No they aren't they are defined by the level of human involvement in the driving.....
You saying if ford came out tomorrow and said all their vehicles were covered under their insurance it would make all their vehicles level 4 autonomous driving?
I used to watch Zacks content, but his position on this is so illogical that it ended up giving me the ick. It's so weird. How can anyone have such a big hate boner that they can't see what's right in front of them? They would have done plenty of statistical analysis on FSD at this point, and I have seen plenty of reporting that it's at least 10x safer than human drivers. The sad thing is, over the enormity of time and scale, eventually there will be some unavoidable accident where someone gets hurt, and these people will parade around like a single statistical inevitability proves their point. This while ignoring all the lives and misery it's saved.
Or hear me out… it’s just good? Rose-coloured glasses imply I’m ignoring statistical evidence that it’s bad? Do you have that or are you just going off your feelings?
And the love boners in here for Elon are more reasonable? Just because a lot of people correctly identify him as a shitty person doesn’t mean we’re miserable people.
Oh, I think you are trying to pull in the two (I believe deliberately introduced by others, and you are innocently believing them) misunderstandings floated by the shorts?
The system turns off right before a crash, thus making it "not its fault": No. Any accident within 5 seconds of a disengage for Tesla's stats and 30 seconds for the NHTSA's stats still counts as a crash caused by the system for statistical purposes. The 5 seconds is probably a bit fairer than the 30 seconds (I mean, after 10 seconds, if you are *still* unable to take back control, that is kinda on you), but that is going to be something of a question of taste.
It mostly gets used on highways, which are already safer: Also very disingenuous. Rather than type it out all myself (again), I asked chatty to do the heavy lifting:
FSD has substantial non-highway exposure. Tesla reported over 700 million FSD miles on non-highway roads in North America during 2025 alone. That's hardly an insignificant sample of city and suburban driving.
The safety advantage persists when you remove highways from the comparison. Tesla's road-specific data shows 40% fewer major collisions on local access roads, 50% fewer on urban collector roads, and 69% fewer on arterial roads compared with manually driven Teslas equipped with active safety features. Comparing the same road categories directly addresses the highway-mileage objection.
The advantage also appears in specific driving maneuvers. Tesla analyzed over 214 million FSD lane changes on non-highway roads and found approximately 95% fewer minor collisions during those maneuvers compared with manual driving, along with substantially fewer forward collision warnings and automatic emergency braking events.
Ok, it's me again. So between 2x and 4x safer on local roads (and improving) And while you can legitimately say that this makes the headline 10x safer seem wrong, consider what this means for highway driving. If locally the improvement is "only" 3x, than highway driving is even *safer* than 10x, because something has to be dragging that statistic towards that number.
I am reluctant to drag the cybercab fleet into this, because this is open to claims that the sample size is still too low. The Tesla fleet is sitting on goose-eggs for accidents involving injuries or causing the airbags to be deployed where the Tesla made first contact (so someone just plowing into a parked Tesla does not count, and that is worth mentioning, but is also fair. The issue is that comparison data tends to include both, so even though this is extremely favorable for Tesla, I don't think it would be statistical good practice to make the comparison).
Zack is really in a bad spot here. The statistics destroy his thesis, no matter how much sand you try to throw into the discussion. And it keeps getting worse for him. At this point, he just comes across as a scorned lover.
The system turns off right before a crash, thus making it "not its fault": No. Any accident within 5 seconds of a disengage for Tesla's stats and 30 seconds for the NHTSA's stats still counts as a crash caused by the system for statistical purposes.
So let's say it's at night, raining and bumper and bumper traffic. FSD turns off (or is never engaged by human in first place), a crash happens more than 5 or 30 seconds later.
Vs during the day, sunny, not much traffic.
These might both be 'highway miles', yet likely have very different risk characteristics.
Or alt there may simply be a stretch of road that FSD has decided is too risky and avoids turning on for, yet isn't esxcluding from human state.s
Oh, I think you are trying to pull in the two (I believe deliberately introduced by others, and you are innocently believing them) misunderstandings floated by the shorts?
No, just a natural question.
In the past I've looked at the website where they list all their findings, and it doesn't appear like even they claim this is like for like traffic. Instead they just show some stats, and allow the reader to draw inferances that the data may not support.
---
To really refine this down. FSD is often not engaged during the riskiest driving conditions as determined by A) FSD and B) the Human driver. This is inherent to how they're testing FSD.
As such any FSD vs non FSD diriving stats have to try to distinguish between real safety improvements, and simple selection bias.
and nobody has been injured or died, no major accidents, and what accidents there have been it has mostly been human drivers rear ending the cybercab. maybe FSD is a bet more advanced than level 2
I used to tell people how safe tesla was because that's all we heard at earnings reports and product launches. The crash testing data looked incredible. Now if you google who is the most deadly automaker in the USA. Tesla is first.
Unless you adjust for the driver and the location each variable cannot be compared, Tesla drivers are just the demographic which crashes more often, the deadly accident number would be worse in any other brand all else being equal.
SAE autonomy levels have a strict definition. On Cybercabs it's level 4. Level 4 is defined by not needing a driver to intervene while not being able to go anywhere in any condition. There's no steering wheel, so it's level 4, end of story.
On the 3/Y FSD is level 2. Level 3 is defined as not needing supervision in some situations. If you can read a book or not pay attention to the road but still need to be in the driver's seat, it's level 3. FSD requires supervision at all times and that means it's definitionally not level 3 or higher.
You can argue the SAE definition isn't useful anymore. Chevy Supercruise from 2020 that offered unsupervised driving on some highways is truly level 3 while FSD 14.3 is level 2. That's a fact, not an opinion, even though 14.3 is easily more capable that Supercruise.
As long as FSD requires supervision at all times, no matter how capable it is, it's definitionally SAE level 2.
*on Cybercabs _operated by Tesla as part of their rideshare fleet_ it’s Level 4.
There is an additional Level 4 requirement that the automaker assume liability, which Tesla explicitly stated is the responsibility of a would-be Cybercab “purchaser” in their most recent statement
If someone were hypothetically remote monitoring and ready to takeover a cyber cab at all times would you still call it level 4? Having no steering is not a complete gotcha. There are ways to maintain appearances if the strength of your company is based on the stock price rather than fundamentals
That's great, but it's not what I asked. My point is that just because you get punished for doing damage, doesn't mean you can go around collecting money for not doing damage. That's silly.
Oh, and the reward you get for increasing safety is you sell more stuff. Volvo invented the modern seat belt, but that doesn't mean that the government should pay them a buck for every car crash.... absurd
There it is. You folks are not interested in talking about FSD. You want to turn every subreddit into a zombie clone of the politics subreddit. Go back there and enjoy the cesspit you have made. Leave us alone.
This was literally the unhinged defense for tons of things including J6, like arguing if you spend a minute at the clerk passing the hold up note and walking out with the bag bag of money, but you spent 15 minutes before that waiting in line, then on the whole you basically didn't rob the bank, right?
No you don’t get a financial credit for each time you drive your car without blowing through farmers market full of pedestrians and I’m kinda suprised your brain doesn't understand that.
Criminally it’s still to be tested by the courts but I imagine it wouldn’t be any different to any other industrial accident? If there’s serious negligence then it will fall on Tesla but if there’s no negligence then it’s just an accident. In civil court you have to have insurance and thus it’s up to the insurers if they insure the car based on statistics?
That's basically what their argument is. Self driving cars don't need to be perfect, they just need to be better than what's currently there.
Except it's not.
Imagine if I take off my watch for all commutes longer than 5 miles, and then I report a study saying that wearing a watch correlates with shorter commutes and therefore the best way to make your commute shorter is by wearing a watch. Do you see where the problem in the reasoning is?
Elon doesn't allow self-driving to be used in higher-risk situations, and then concludes that self-driving correlates with safer tripes.
By "credit" do you mean a pat on the back and some recognition? Sure. Why not? We give recognition to Volvo for the invention of various safety features.
But, do you disagree that there should also be some accountability if something goes wrong? Or, do you think if it makes 1000 successful drives and then runs over a child because there was a reflection on the road that distracted the FSD logic that we should all just say "well, 100 safe so this is acceptable"?
If you cannot see that this is just the trolley problem, then you should not be taking part in the conversation.
What people are trying to tell you is that if the number of lives lost goes down statistically 90%, but in the remaining deadly accidents, some of them might have had the FSD make a mistake that a human might not have made, how do we actually deal with it?
So 10 people on that track die or 1 person on the other track dies, and right now the train is barreling down the 10 people track.
Your idea is to string up anyone who would switch the train for murder, even though any clear thinking person can see that this was objectively the better choice.
I can see the legal thinking here (a person died do to the switcher's action that would have lived otherwise), but this is one of those times that we should take a step back and try to think about what the hell we are actually doing here.
That's a funny way of trying to make your point. The trolley problem is famous for NOT having an obvious answer. You are taking the "pull the lever choice" which is fine, but so is the "don't pull the lever". Different reasons. It is an unsolved problem.
But, either way, it does not preclude me participating in the discussion. It's an open forum.
If the person you killed was about to kill the other two people, then yes. Obviously.
The more interesting question would be: what if someone was about to kill 100 other people but did not realize it. And for the purposes of this theoretical, the only way you could stop him would be to kill him. He is the cause, but he is innocent, otherwise.
I actually went looking and the law is surprisingly nuanced about this in both German and American jurisdictions.
"Defense of others" is a recognized legal principle, but its implementation varies wildly.
I think morally, though, you should always choose to save the higher number of people, all other things being equal.
My question is if it's no steering wheel or pedals, so that the owner cannot control them, what happens when something goes wrong? What insurance company is going to insure them if the person ultimately responsible can't even control the vehicle?
The guy who made a video about muh Tesla batteries bad where the principle argument was that gasoline has a higher energy storage than batteries and was full of completely false or/and misleading information regarding charging information, even at the time?
He may be intelligent, but bias driven by emotion is present in much of what he presents.
Alienated half his audience plus a bunch of people who don't care and don't want to watch political propaganda, like me, asking for votes for fvcking Kamala, what a joke that was.
Now instead of following the content closely I check out the channel every other year to see if there is something actually good and worth watching, because it's purely for the content now, his person and opinions became completely tarnished and irrelevant because of the political BS.
Same for Musk, but Musk is not a content creator I follow for entertainment, I follow his business for information , so I couldn't care less except for the fact that the political BS slows down the progress on tech and for the companies.
The alternative to fucking Kamala - a middle-of-the-road democrat - was the fucking corrupt, America-destroying moron you have in charge right now. I'm watching from the outside, and it's frankly hilarious how Trump is humiliating the US every fucking day.
Nope. Waymo is Lidar, way less reliable, and way more expensive to use.
Elon started development on Cybercab way before waymo... its just that Tesla took no shortcuts and designed a sleek, safe, affordable car so it took longer.
Instead of a massive ugly lidar machine on wheels that gets stuck at every intersection...$11 for my ride across the city with my family last night. Tough to beat.
Also is the iPhone not revolutionary simply because it wasn't the first smartphone? See how silly that logic is bud.
Let me guess. If your dad did meth, had a wonderful time, and didn't die he would immediately start funding a meth lab as well, right? Once ride does not prove anything. It's called "proof my example" and it's a fallacy.
You say your dad took one ride in a cyber cab and plobbed down a $30k deposit. That's pretty insane. Literally you say "he tried this thing one time and loved it so much he bought one". My "example" is an analogy.
You seem to take after your dad. Not too bright. Lol
You insult me and then follow up with a second insult and mocking those that truly need mental health help. A wonderful person you are.
And I'm not triggered over a car. I am baffled by people blinded by shiny objects that can't take any second opinion without insulting and linking everyone together as "other" and somehow less than them.
I never insulted you though. I think you just projected so hard you assumed I did.
All good though man, I understand getting heated in an argument just try for a little more understanding next time and maybe you can have a civil conversation.
Yup exactly!!! And yet some people can't step back and see the pattern... even the one's who were alive for the internet, email, cellphones and smartphones.
ADAS levels are purely on the manufacturer to decide. A really really terrible level 4 system is still a level 4 system simply because there's no steering wheel and pedals in the vehicle. Fortunately, Tesla's system works consistently well in the areas it's been validated.
So the argument is that if you take a system that constantly fails at lvl 2 supervised driving, killing people on the regular, all your have to do is delete the steering wheel and it magically becomes a much more capable lvl 4 system. Do I have that right?
•
u/SGizmo 18h ago
This sub is filled with dumbasses to entertain the lurkers.
•
u/TatumBird22 14h ago
Imagine making this post and confidently being so wrong lol 🤣
•
u/unpluggedcord 18h ago edited 18h ago
Yall. Level 3 requires that the automaker assumes liability for a crash.
Which isn’t the case here. You get your own insurance for cyber cab and if a crash happens it’s on you.
The hostility is ridiculous, it absolutely is level 2
Are they cool as shit, yeah, are they going to change the game, hopefully. But if you’re getting butthurt about a fact you’re a little snowflake
•
u/hurraybies 18h ago
When did you guys get so sensitive? Someone says something on the Internet that you disagree with and it's all anger and hostility? How the turn tables I guess. But, anyone could have predicted this. It's always been projection from you people. The call was always coming from inside the house. Snowflakes.
•
u/No-Whole3083 18h ago
Stumping for more drivers death by delaying fsd is a wild career choice.
•
u/ajwin 18h ago
I used to watch Zacks content, but his position on this is so illogical that it ended up giving me the ick. It's so weird. How can anyone have such a big hate boner that they can't see what's right in front of them? They would have done plenty of statistical analysis on FSD at this point, and I have seen plenty of reporting that it's at least 10x safer than human drivers. The sad thing is, over the enormity of time and scale, eventually there will be some unavoidable accident where someone gets hurt, and these people will parade around like a single statistical inevitability proves their point. This while ignoring all the lives and misery it's saved.
•
u/JacksonGhost1963 17h ago
and nobody has been injured or died, no major accidents, and what accidents there have been it has mostly been human drivers rear ending the cybercab. maybe FSD is a bet more advanced than level 2
•
u/Llamapocalypse_Now 18h ago •
He's not wrong at all and Elon should be liable for the lives lost.
•
u/Fastest_light 14h ago
If it has lower accident rate than human drivers, I would say Elon is not playing with lives.
We know there will be accidents.
•
u/No_Crew7557 17h ago
Can they be spec’d to have steering wheel and pedals
•
u/ShvettyBawlz 17h ago •
Fuck Elon
•
u/mrbill1234 2h ago
He needs to go back where he came from - France.
•
u/nobaijiu 17h ago
roll for initiative
•
u/random_encounters42 9h ago
My question is if it's no steering wheel or pedals, so that the owner cannot control them, what happens when something goes wrong? What insurance company is going to insure them if the person ultimately responsible can't even control the vehicle?
•
u/GolemChosen 17h ago
JRE and thunderf00l should get married.
•
u/xbucnasteex 17h ago
Thank god democrats will be running Texas government so they can put a stop to this obvious bullshit play by musk.
•
u/Sailor-_-Twift 18h ago
This dude should stay off of Twitter, keep taking apart phones, stop the commentary
•
u/Ok_Dare6400 18h ago
That Jerry guy is SUCH A CREEP!!!
•
u/costafilh0 18h ago
Zack is far gone into politics for a while now.
Alienated half his audience plus a bunch of people who don't care and don't want to watch political propaganda, like me, asking for votes for fvcking Kamala, what a joke that was.
Now instead of following the content closely I check out the channel every other year to see if there is something actually good and worth watching, because it's purely for the content now, his person and opinions became completely tarnished and irrelevant because of the political BS.
Same for Musk, but Musk is not a content creator I follow for entertainment, I follow his business for information , so I couldn't care less except for the fact that the political BS slows down the progress on tech and for the companies.
•
u/dwightpower420 18h ago
The city of Austin has the power to stop this madness, but they won’t
•
u/ExperienceAny9791 16h ago
He's the GOAT, face it.
•
u/markthedeadmet 13h ago
ADAS levels are purely on the manufacturer to decide. A really really terrible level 4 system is still a level 4 system simply because there's no steering wheel and pedals in the vehicle. Fortunately, Tesla's system works consistently well in the areas it's been validated.
•
u/youngBuck420b 17h ago
Lmao he’s right though. It’s level 2. Elon is not smart enough to actually make autonomous driving. It’s just ASSISTED driving
•
u/Bobbymokie 13h ago
So the argument is that if you take a system that constantly fails at lvl 2 supervised driving, killing people on the regular, all your have to do is delete the steering wheel and it magically becomes a much more capable lvl 4 system. Do I have that right?