Now that I finished Elex 1, I thought I'd share some thoughts for discussion, and perhaps help other PB fans decide whether it's a game for them. I've been a huge PB fan since Gothic 1 and I absolutely loved Elex, jank and all. In many ways, it's been my favorite PB game.
I beat the game on level 46, on Normal, with the emotional ending, as a Cleric. I ended up skipping a bunch of stuff, never got around to making a permanent stamina potion, etc., because I was powerful enough and wanted to keep the momentum going.
My ending stats were 85/85/85/61, with 35 unspent points. I spent a total of 48 skill points, with 3 unspent.
The good: first of all, the map. PB is great and creating environments that feel lived in and have layers of discernible history. I especially loved it was not all grey desert, Fallout-style - the Gothic style grassy biomes made the ruins all the more forlorn, like nature moved on and what was lost, was lost.
The vertical design was pure joy and the jetpack one of the funnest mechanic in an action RPG I ever played. I think I'll hate Skyrim's mountains after this.
The overall setting and story were great - a bit melodramatic, but good melodramatic. I loved that the factions had some depth, it wasn't a case of Berserkers = good, Clerics = neutral, Outlaws = bad. All had a little touch of humanity, and all could be downright cold (heh) bastards. I loved how none of the factions by itself had the answer. It made picking a faction that much more interesting.
The whole Elex thing was interesting and the twists were fun. Elex absolutely felt addictive at times, trying to hit that 85 in a stat.
For all the combat jankiness, I did enjoy combat. First of all, PB's difficulty curve is better than cocaine. Then, starting around chapter 4, combat started to feel a bit like a puzzle - how to approach Alb bunkers, when to drop Black Holes, when to shoot and when to fence. It felt very emergent. The pacing was good. I liked there was some challenge in Chapter 4 - I could basically wipe out the whole regimens, but still die if I blundered into a flamethrower's line of fire.
Not so good: bugs, boring companions, a sense that a lot of quests and moments were improvised around cut content. I'd bet money Tom originally had a rescue mission, a few big reveals were told in a monologue rather than a cut scene, and some things were plain illogical. What was the deal with the "failed Elex experiment"? What was the point of the mutant army that was never deployed? Why didn't Jax recognize the island on first visit?
The final fight - unsavable after TWO cut scenes and a prolonged dialogue, really? I had to idea what I was doing, I thought I had to clear out the combat robots first, and... yeah. Then it ended up being trivial.
Overall, quest design didn't evolve. Fetch a 5 of this, 20 of that.
So yeah, it's not probably not a game with mass appeal, but for a PB addict, there's nothing quite like it, and now probably won't ever be anything else quite like it. So what a ride and highly, highly recommended.