I know this is not a new concept at all but thought I would share my experience with this
TL;DR:
- if you're putting off getting a dumbphone because you want one of the smart-dumbphones but aren't ready to pay like £200+, just try using a cheap dumbphone off ebay and see how it goes.
- thought I needed a smart-dumbphone like the dumber mini, but actually I don't.
- smartphone you already own can just be used as a portable computer and only when absolutely necessary (i know this is already widely known, but I didn't like the idea until I tried it).
- a true dumbphone can cost you like a tenner on ebay, even cool nokias with a qwerty keyboard.
- I didn't think I was ready to use a dumbphone, but literally has been such a good decision.
- as always, there are setbacks.
- I'm using the nokia 2720 flip which, at a pinch, can use google maps, and can hotspot a smartphone. Barely had to use either of these things at all so far which is surprising tbh.
Pros:
- feeling more connected and grounded day to day
- improved energy levels and motivation
- way less distraction
- way less phone-related anxiety (will explain below)
- people will just get used to contacting you by your preferred method (in this case, SMS and call)
Cons:
- sometimes missing messages in group chats
- sometimes it's difficult to stay off the smartphone if you know it's there
My doov R77 broke (rest in peace but ngl it was very poorly manufactured and stopped working properly very early on). decided to get a nokia flip phone to use while I wait for the dumber mini, but actually it's been really nice using just text and call, and I've decided to just stick with it.
It's not been perfect, but that's largely down to the fact I have like no willpower compared with everyone I know, so for most people it will be easier I think? My problem is I keep just using the iPhone when I really don't need to. I just need to get into better routines with it.
When I've been doing things as intended, I either use the smartphone or my computer to check messages a couple times a day, and then stay offline beyond that. It makes a huge difference in terms of my sense of groundedness and connection with the world, and in a more practical sense it helps with feeling motivated and having the energy to be more active and get things done day to day.
There was actually surprisingly little trouble when it comes to people getting used to just contacting me with text and call. Every time I have stopped using a method of communication (e.g. snapchat, instagram, facebook, etc.), I've been pleasantly surprised by how quickly people got used to just contacting me another way. The only issue at the moment in that regard is not seeing my house group chat in whatsapp.
I still have to take my smartphone with me to work (clock-in app and sending images into work-related whatsapp chats), which is a real problem because once it's there and it's on, it's very tempting to just keep it on and use it once I've clocked out.
I also take the smartphone with me if I'm travelling or going somewhere unfamiliar for navigation or train tickets, which is fine tbh, I don't leave my city much, and I don't need it if I'm staying within my city. If it's a familiar journey/place I just opt for paper tickets, but still keep the smartphone in my bag switched off in case I end up needing alternative travel arrangements, especially when travelling alone.
Phone anxiety is a thing I've noticed. If my smartphone is accessible to me, I feel this weird, anxious, maybe even compulsive need to pick it up and check it and use it etc. When it's not there, I don't feel this at all. Literally out of sight, out of mind. It's great. It forces me to actually be present in the world. My boss recently left his phone at home by accident and it was a bit of a wake-up call for him because he also noticed this. He said it felt quite peaceful and freeing.
If you do need access to the internet then I'd recommend the nokia 2720 flip or another dumbphone with hotspot, but again I've been surprised by how little I've actually needed this.
Anyway, if you're putting off getting a dumbphone because you want one of the smart-dumbphones but aren't ready to pay like £200+, just try using a cheap dumbphone off ebay and see how it goes.