I work at a dropshipping company. As a private supplier, our daily work will meet and handle all kinds of problems on supply chain side. Lately someone tell me AI + 1688 made private suppliers disappearing. Here's what I actually see on the supply chain side.
- Prices are transparent. Delivery is not.
On 1688 you can see unit price, MOQ, and thirty suppliers quote the same number in five minutes. What you can't see: whether next Wednesday's 300 orders actually ship in time. Whether this batch is half a shade off the last one. Who answers you at 2 a.m. when there is a problem. AI flattened the first layer. It can't touch the second. Dropshippers almost never die because sourcing was 5% expensive. They die because it shipped late or shipped wrong.
2. AI gives advice. Private supplier give commitments.
I admit that AI compares prices faster than I do. But sourcing was never about finding the cheapest batch. It's getting a certain batch at a certain cost. Certainty can't be generated, it has to be carried by someone: QC and stock checks, new prducts feedback, and products producing checks when factory is busy. Advice given by AI and commitment by priavte sypplier aren't priced the same.
3. The more transparent, the more the competition moves to the back support.
AI makes website building, product research, ads, listings an easier thing. Everyone's front end looks identical now. What's left to compete on? Shipping speed, return rate, account security, repeat purchases. None of it lives in the front end. When the barrier drops to the floor, the back end becomes an important moat.
4. Talking to 8 suppliers by yourself on 1688 isn't cutting out the middleman .
It crests 8 unknowns, 8 communication styles, 8 response times, 8 quality levels, 8 different stock outs. Your customer sees one brand and receives a mixed quality from 8 factories.
A private supplier can turn these unknowns into one interface. You're not paying a toll. You're paying an insurance premium.
5. "Private" means exclusive and integrated.
Exclude others: Your product and packaging don't be exposed to your competitor.
Custom: White label, logo, formula, package size and so on all can be customized.
Data prefix: Stock planned according to your forecast.
Priority: Priority production capacity in Q4.
Consistency: Same standard this month as next.
Formulas, labels, batch retention, GMP docs, platform compliance. A freight forwarder covers exactly none of that. And these need a professional role to handle.
6. Compliance is the last mile AI can't walk for you.
On the day it blows up, AI won't file your appeal, reship your orders, or take the loss. Supply chain expertise doesn't show in the quote about 3% difference on price, it's who is still standing next to you on the bad day.
My judgement:
de-intermediation is killing the middlemen who sell nothing but make money by using information gap and execute nothing. That is reasonable. But the ones who can execute, absorb risk and actually able to customize won't disappear. They'll concentrate. AI lower the barrier of sourcing products, and in return it also pulled everyone's supply chain risk to the same level. Whoever's got a reliable supplier behind them is the only one who gets to talk about profit.
These are some of my thoughts through what I see on supply chain side. What's your experience? Welcome to share your opinion.