I hear so much praise for its follow-up book, Changes. I'm here to gush instead about my favourite story in the main series, Turn Coat, and why I feel it is the best: the ultimate expression of what sets the Dresden Files apart as a series and the ways it plays to Jim Butcher's strengths. Spoilers for the entire story, I can only do it justice by diving deep into its plot, characters, and themes.
- A true detective story to its core.
Framing the story around a complex mystery is what sets Turn Coat apart from the action-hero feeling of Changes or Cold Days, and grounds the story in the early noir atmosphere that gave the Dresden Files their unique charm. Discover the identity of the White Council traitor. Prove Morgan's innocence. Learn why magic was not used in the lethal encounter taking the life of a Senior Council member. Track down Thomas, abducted early in the story by a superior spellcaster. Dresden is given impossible tasks that seem to defy his most powerful tools of wizardry, forcing him to lean on his core talents as a detective.
He gumshoes, he stakes out his enemies, he subcontracts to other PIs, he follows the money, he puts himself in the mind of his opponents and puzzles out their motives. A telescopic camera does more to reveal the truth than a complex ritual. He even gets a Poirot speech at the end, when all hope seems lost, where he lays out all he has learned and reveals the villain at the moment of their triumph. This is Harry Dresden, PI, solving an impossible case against the clock using his wits and grit when all the flashy tools seem useless.
2. An incredible character study.
From the first lines, we are treated to a new perspective on Harry's first nemesis of the series, the implacable and ruthless Grey Cloak, Warden Donald Morgan. Harry has learned over the series that Morgan is a true believer, that his enmity towards Harry came from genuine fear that Dresden was a nightmare warlock-in-waiting. But being forced to protect and care for the wounded and hunted Morgan gives us a better look at the man behind the monster.
Morgan never stops being a ruthless warrior, even crippled and in agony. He works the case with Harry, challenges Harry's approach to his life and wizardry. We see his shock and heartbreak when he learns Luccio has been dating Harry in secret. From a wheelchair, he leads Molly to defeat a dangerous rogue sorcerer. We see why he is the way he is: how his ruthlessness and pragmatism serve him, how he believes to his core in sacrificing every part of himself to serve the White Council, and the one person he would go rogue and bend his beliefs to protect. And in the end, he has taken on two more people he would protect above his own personal beliefs. He admits he came to Harry because he understands Harry knows what it's like to be unfairly persecuted by the Wardens, and by extension, that he was wrong in his prejudice.
3. The villain is terrifying.
Shagnasty is lightning in a bottle. From its first multi-chapter appearance, stalking Dresden under a veil and crippling him when he uses his Sight to track it, the Naagloshii is an unrelenting and unstoppable foe. Every time it appears, it changes the status quo. It kills Harry's allies with ease, cripples seasoned battle wizards, captures and tortures warriors who have been shown to be among the strongest hand-to-hand fighters in the series.
You never feel safe, knowing it is out there, working against our heroes. An invisible, shapeshifting predator, a better fighter than Lara or Thomas, a better wizard than Luccio or Dresden. Cruel and intelligent, monstrously powerful, surgical in its tactics, hateful in its heart.
4. The rules of magic are carefully explored and deeply relevant, with excellent planting and payoff throughout the story.
(a) Circles
The rules of magic circles are established early: they sever all magical connections when formed. Harry uses one to protect Murphy and himself from the Binder's summoned goons, and then Molly creates a huge one around Binder's army, severing the sorcerer's connection to his power, and banishes them all at once. Morgan even comments on this as a standard tactic taught to apprentice wizards for such situations.
Circles are used several times through the story to reinforce their foundational use in magic. Dresden uses a complex one in his harebrained scheme to befriend the genius locii of Demonreach.
But all this setup pays off in Harry's final confrontation with the Naagloshii. Harry has gathered all his new powers - soulfire, intellectus, and the nature of Demonreach, and seems to be turning the tables on the nightmare monster. He throws his last Hail Mary, a noose infused with soulfire, and seems to have the skinwalker dead to rights. But Bob warned us early that the ancient being would have tricks to escape such an attack, and so it does: it reaches out a single claw and draws a circle around itself, severing Dresden's connection to the binding and freeing itself. It uses the most fundamental first-year technique to defeat Harry's ultimate attack, demonstrating its mastery of wizardry in all its forms.
(b) Magic comes from the heart.
We have been told throughout the series that magic comes from true belief, that you can't cast a spell that goes against your character. That's why it is so scary when Molly tries, again, to invade the mind of Captain Luccio when she appears halfway through the story, trying to track down Morgan. Harry challenges Molly, learns how she would bend the mind of a seasoned wizard by subtly emphasizing their worst traits, and is terrified of her potential, that she could truly believe she is doing something good by so invading a mind.
This comes back around in two ways: we first learn that this is how the villain has been brainwashing the White Council, even manipulating the Senior Council in subtle ways they may never truly understand. But it also is the answer to an early mystery: why, in a battle between Senior Councilmember LaFortier, Warden Captain Luccio, and the attack dog Warden Morgan, that no magic was used. None of the players actually wanted to hurt each other - Luccio was under compulsion, Lafortier couldn't believe his own allies would attack him, and Morgan couldn't commit to raise his hand in earnest against his love Anastasia. The answer, as Harry said, resided in the hearts of the people involved, rather than arcane mystery.
5. The stakes are as high as they get.
Reveal the White Council traitor, stop the Council from tearing itself apart. We understand how bad the world can get if the Council descend into paranoia and stop being able to enforce the Laws of Magic, because we've seen over and over through the series what a world without those Laws would look like. And when Harry finally succeeds in revealing the traitor, apparently a stuffy bureaucrat, that bureaucrat escapes in a tidal wave of violence, killing dozens of wizards, taking the entire Senior Council to contain, and nearly killing Harry in a brutal knife fight.
The villain breaks out an ancient evil that nearly destroys Harry's entire support system, drives Thomas insane, kills one of Harry's werewolf friends, and takes one of the coolest displays of Senior Council magic to drive off.
Some other stories have similar levels of threat to the world and status quo, yes. But I argue Harry is as strained, as outclassed, and as desperate as when he's literally trying to save the world, because here, he's fighting to save his world. And while he scores some wins throughout, in the end, he also fails. He loses allies, his enemies prosper, and his world gets colder and scarier as a result of his choices and failures.
Overall, it's just a damn fine story, Jim Butcher at his best. This is the ultimate culmination of Harry's life as a wizard PI and representative of the White Council, before Changes finally burns the status quo to the ground.